본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Deciding Together: Citizen Participation in planning the Neighbourhood Improvement in Seoul and Singapore

조임식|김수|Blaz Kriznik
아시아연구소|2019.02|아시아리뷰 (Asia Review)|제8권 제2호|pp. 65-102|DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.24987/SNUACAR.2019.02.8.2.65

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

urban planningcitizen participationcommunity engagementliving environmentneighbourhood improvement
주제분류사회과학일반

초록

Cities in East Asia are faced with growing social, economic and environmental risks. National and local governments are, hence, looking for novel policies that could improve the long-term capacity of cities to address these risks more comprehensively and effectively. Citizen participation and neighbourhood improvement are both considered playing a key role in building more inclusive and sustainable cities. This article compares the transformation of Samdeok Maeul in Seoul and Tampines in Singapore to better understand the importance of citizen participation in planning the neighbourhood improvement, and its consequences on urban development in general. Both cases represent a similar shift from previous state-led towards participatory planning. The research follows a case-oriented qualitative approach. The authors conducted in-depth interviews with major stakeholders, participant observation, expert workshops, and review of secondary resources. The research findings suggest that in both cases the residents were able to affect neighbourhood improvement through community engagement in the planning process. At the same time, the research findings imply that the state remains largely in control over the process, which indicates the challenges that need to be considered in order to empower communities in Seoul and Singapore in the long run.

Abstract

Cities in East Asia are faced with growing social, economic and environmental risks. National and local governments are, hence, looking for novel policies that could improve the long-term capacity of cities to address these risks more comprehensively and effectively. Citizen participation and neighbourhood improvement are both considered playing a key role in building more inclusive and sustainable cities. This article compares the transformation of Samdeok Maeul in Seoul and Tampines in Singapore to better understand the importance of citizen participation in planning the neighbourhood improvement, and its consequences on urban development in general. Both cases represent a similar shift from previous state-led towards participatory planning. The research follows a case-oriented qualitative approach. The authors conducted in-depth interviews with major stakeholders, participant observation, expert workshops, and review of secondary resources. The research findings suggest that in both cases the residents were able to affect neighbourhood improvement through community engagement in the planning process. At the same time, the research findings imply that the state remains largely in control over the process, which indicates the challenges that need to be considered in order to empower communities in Seoul and Singapore in the long run.

참고문헌 (85)

  1. Arnstein, Sherry R., "A Ladder of Citizen Participation", Journal of the American Planning Association, 35(4), pp.216~224 (1969)
  2. Botes, Lucius, "Community participation in development: nine plagues and twelve commandments", Community Development Journal, 36, pp.41~58 (2000)
  3. Callahan, Kathe, "Citizen Participation: Models and Methods", International Journal of Public Administration, 30(11), pp.1179~1196 (2007)
  4. Castells, Manuel, "States and Developmentin the Asia Pacific Rim", pp.33~70 (1992), Sage
  5. CLC and SI, "Planning for Communities, Lessons from Seoul and Singapore" (2017), Centre for Liveable Cities
  6. Cho, Im Sik, "HDB-NUS Study on the Social Aspects of the Built Environment", Innovation Magazine, The Magazine of Research & Technology, 15(1), pp.47~54 (2016)
  7. Cho, Im Sik, "Sustainable Cities in Asia", pp.226~235 (2017), Routledge
  8. Cho, Im Sik, "Community-Based Urban Development. Evolving Urban Paradigms in Singapore and Seoul" (2017), Springer
  9. Cho, Im Sik, "Mechanisms to facilitate community participation in Singapore’s neighborhood planning framework", Journal of Architectural and Planning Research, 34(4), pp.320~335 (2017)
  10. Chua, Beng-Huat, "Political Legitimacy and Housing: Stakeholding in Singapore" (1997), Routledge
  11. Chua, Beng-Huat, "Worlding cities: Asian experiments and the art of being global", pp.29~54 (2011), Wiley-Blackwell
  12. Chua, Beng-Huat, "Navigating Between Limits: the Future of Public Housing in Singapore", Housing Studies, 29(4), pp.520~533 (2014)
  13. Colantonio, Andrea, "Urban regeneration & social sustainability: Best practice from European cities" (2011), Wiley-Blackwell
  14. Study on the Application of Design Recommendations to Foster Community Bonding, CSAC, "HDB, final report", CSAC, 2015
  15. Daniere, Amrita, "The Politics of Civic Space in Asia: Building Urban Communities" (2008), Routledge
  16. Davidoff, Paul, "Advocacy and Pluralism in Planning", Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 31(4), pp.331~338 (1965)
  17. Day, Graham, "Community and Everyday Life" (2006), Routledge
  18. Dempsey, Nicola, "The social dimension of sustainable development: Defining urban social sustainability", Sustainable Development, 19(5), pp.289~300 (2011)
  19. Department of Statistics Singapore, "Yearbook of statistics Singapore 2015" (2015), Department of Statistics Singapore
  20. Doucette, Jamie, "Urban Developmentalism in East Asia: Geopolitical Economies, Spaces of Exception, and Networks of Expertise", Critical Sociology, 44(3), pp.395~403 (2018)
  21. Douglass, Mike, "After the revolution: from insurgencies to social projects to recover the public city in East and Southeast Asia", International Development Planning Review, 36(1), pp.15~23 (2014)
  22. Douglass, Mike, "Cities for Citizens: Planning and the Rise of Civil Society in a Global Age" (1998), John Wiley and Sons
  23. Fernandez, Warren, "Our homes: 50 years of housing a nation" (2011), Straits Times Press
  24. Ganesan, Narayanan, "Singapore in the new millennium: challenges facing the city-state edited by Derek da Cunha", pp.50~68 (2002), Institute of Southeast Asian Studies
  25. Gilchrist, Alison, "The Short Guide to Community Development" (2016), Policy Press
  26. Goh, Daniel P. S., "Recentering Southeast Asian Cities", International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 37(3), pp.825~833 (2013)
  27. Hantrais, Linda, "Method and Management of Cross-National Social Research" (1996), Pinter
  28. Ha, Seong-Kyu, "Housing Regeneration and Building Sustainable Low-Income Communities in Korea", Habitat International, 31(1), pp.116~129 (2007)
  29. 하성규, "Housing markets and government intervention in East Asian countries", 도시과학국제저널, 17(1), pp.32~45 (2013), 도시과학연구원[DOI]
  30. Hee, Limin, "Dissent and Cultural Resistance in Asia’s Cities", pp.72~91 (2009), Routledge
  31. Hee, Limin, "Suburban form: an international perspective", pp.127~147 (2004), Routledge
  32. Ho, Kong Chong, "The Politics of Civic Space in Asia: Building Urban Communities", pp.19~32 (2009), Routledge
  33. Hollnsteiner, Mary R., "People power: community participation in the planning and implementation of human settlements", Philippine Studies, 24(1), pp.5~36 (1976)
  34. Hou, Jeff, "Greening Cities: Forms and Functions", pp.113~130 (2017), Springer
  35. "HDB Friendly Faces, Lively Places Fund" (2016)[URL]
  36. "Creating Vibrant Places" (2018)[URL]
  37. "Hello Neighbour! @ Tampines Central" (2018)[URL]
  38. Innes, Judith E., "Reframing public participation: strategies for the 21st century", Planning Theory & Practice, 5(4), pp.419~436 (2004)
  39. Irvin, Renée A., "Citizen participation in decision making: Is it worth the effort?", Public Administration Review, 64(1), pp.55~64 (2004)
  40. 정규호, "한국 도시공동체운동의 전개과정과 협력형 모델의 의미", 한국학, 35(2), pp.7~34 (2012), 한국학중앙연구원[DOI]
  41. Kim, Jiyoun, "Creating a sewing village in Seoul: towards participatory village-making or post-political urban regeneration?", Community Development Journal, pp.1~21 (2017)
  42. Kim, Joochul, "Seoul: The Making of A Metropolis" (1997), John Wiley and Sons
  43. Kim, Kwang-Joong, "Seoul, Twentieth Century: Growth & Change of the Last 100 Years", pp.543~596 (2003), Seoul Development Institute
  44. Kim, Seong-Gyun, "함께 만드는 마을, 함께 누리는 삶" (2015), Korea National Open University Press
  45. Kim, Sangmin, "From Protest to Collaboration: The Evolution of the Community Movements amid Sociopolitical Transformation in South Korea", Urban Studies, 54(16), pp.3806~3825 (2017)
  46. 김선혁, "Historical Development of Civil Society in Korea since 1987", Journal of International and Area Studies, 24(2), pp.1~14 (2017), 국제학연구소[DOI]
  47. Kim, Su, "확장된 계획행동이론을 통해 본 마을공동체 참여 행위에 대한 연구: 서울 성북구 삼덕마을의 사례", master, pp.2018
  48. Designing for Social Impact, "Emerging Civic Urbanisms", pp.2018, Kim, Su
  49. Koh, Gillian, "Civil Society in Southeast Asia", pp.167~197 (2004), ISEAS
  50. Križnik, Blaž, "Transformation of Deprived Urban Areas and Social Sustainability: A Comparative Study of Urban Regeneration and Urban Redevelopment in Barcelona and Seoul", Urbani izziv, 29(1), pp.83~95 (2018)
  51. Križnik, Blaž, "Streets as a Space of Community Building: The Case Study of Urban Regeneration in Samdeok Maeul, Seoul", Asian Studies, 6(2), pp.231~251 (2018)
  52. Lee, So Young, "커뮤니티 워크와 사회적 자본과의 순환적 관계에 관한 연구, 서울시 삼덕마을 사례를 중심으로", doctor, pp.2016
  53. Ledwith, Margaret, "Community development, A critical approach" (2011), Policy Press
  54. Maeng, Da Mi, "서울시 주거환경관리사업, 앞으로 나아갈 방향은? (Seoul REMP, the Path Ahead)", 지속가능한 발전방향 모색을 위한 전문가토론회 (Expert Discussion to Seek for Sustainable Development) (2015), Seoul Institute
  55. 서울시 주거환경관리사업의 추진실태와 정책제언 (Implementation Status and Policy Implications of Seoul REMP), "Maeng, Da Mi", Seoul Institute, ~ (2016)
  56. Manzi, Tony, "Social Sustainability in Urban Areas: Communities, Connectivity, and the Urban Fabric" (2010), Earthscan
  57. Margerum, Richard D., "Collaborative Planning: Building Consensus and Building a Distinct Model for Practice", Journal of Planning Education and Research, 21(3), pp.237~253 (2002)
  58. Miller, Michelle Ann, "Disaster Governance in Urbanising Asia" (2016), Springer
  59. Mobrand, Erik, "Struggles Over Unlicensed Housing in Seoul 1960-80", Urban Studies, 45(2), pp.367~389 (2008)
  60. Nanumgwamirae, "생생한 주거환경관리사업의 현장기록. 다같이 돌자 동네 한바퀴 (Vivid On-site Documentation of the Residential Environment Management Project. Let’s Have a Stroll through the Neighbourhood together)", Nanumgwamirae, ~ (2015)
  61. Nanumgwamirae, "2016년 서울시 주거환경관리사업 마을재생 이야기: 삼덕마을에 넘치는 인정 좀 보소 (Maeul Regeneration Story of the 2016 Seoul Residential Envi ronment Management Project – Look How Warm-Hearted is Samdeok Maeul)", SMG, ~ (2016)
  62. Ng, Mee Kam, "Enclosure and recommoning in Wanchai, Hong Kong: The struggle of local community development in Asia’s World City", Local Economy, 32(7), pp.640~655 (2017)
  63. Noh, Abdillah, "Remaking public participation: The case of Singapore", Asian Social Science, 4(7), pp.19~32 (2008)
  64. Ooi, Giok Ling, "Local Organizations and Urban Governance in East and Southeast Asia: Straddling State and Society", pp.174~190 (2009), Routledge
  65. Ooi, Giok Ling, "Local Organizations and Urban Governance in East and Southeast Asia: Straddling State and Society", pp.174~190 (2009), Routledge
  66. Ooi, Giok Ling, "Beyond the port city: development and identity in 21st century Singapore" (2004), Prentice Hall
  67. Park, Bae-Gyoon, "Where Do Tigers Sleep at Night? The State’s Role in Housing Policy in South Korea and Singapore", Economic Geography, 74(3), pp.272~288 (1998)
  68. Perry Martin, "Singapore: a Developmental City State" (1997), John Wiley and Sons
  69. Read, Benjamin L., "Roots of the State: Neighborhood Organization and Social Networks in Beijing and Taipei" (2012), Stanford University Press
  70. Sanoff, Henry, "Community Participation Methods in Design and Planning" (2000), John Wiley and Sons
  71. Seongbuk-gu, "성북구 정릉동 삼덕마을 주거환경관리구역 지정 및 계획 결정 (Designation and Planning Decision of Samdeok Maeul, Jeongneung - dong, Seongbuk- gu as a Residential Environment Management Area)", Seongbuk-gu, ~ (2015)
  72. Seongbuk-gu, "삼덕마을 운영을 위한 10가지 방법 (10 Ways to Operate Sam deok Maeul)", Seongbuk-gu, ~ (2015)
  73. Shin, Hyun Bang, "Urban Movements and the Genealogy of Urban Rights Discourses: The Case of Urban Protesters against Redevelopment and Displacement in Seoul, South Korea", Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 108(2), pp.356~369 (2018)
  74. Shin, Hyun Bang, "The Developmental State, Speculative Urbanisation and the Politics of Displacement in Gentrifying Seoul", Urban Studies, 53(3), pp.540~559 (2016)
  75. SMG, "함께 만들고 함께 누리는 서울시, 주민참여형 재생사업 매뉴얼 (Seoul Built and Enjoyed Together, Manual for Residents’ Participatory Regeneration Project)", SMG, ~ (2013)
  76. White Paper on Neighborhood Communities of Seoul: Seoul, Life and People, "SMG", SMG, ~ (2015)
  77. SMG, "Seoul Statistics Yearbook 2017" (2017), SMG
  78. Somerville, Peter, "Understanding Community: Politics, Policy and Practice" (2016), Policy Press
  79. Teo, Siew Eng, "Public housing in Singapore: Interpreting ‘Quality’ in the 1990s", Urban Studies, 34(3), pp.441~452 (1997)
  80. The State of Asian and Pacific Cities 2015, Urban Transformations: Shifting from Quantity to Quality, "UN-HABITAT", UN-HABITAT, ~ (2015)
  81. "Our Favourite Place" (2016)[URL]
  82. Walliman, Nicholas, "Social Research Methods" (2006), Sage
  83. Watson, Jini Kim, "Seoul and Singapore as “New Asian Cities”: Literature, Urban Transformation, and the Concentricity of Power", Positions, 19(1), pp.193~215 (2011)
  84. Wilson, Japhy, "The Post-Political and Its Discontents: Spaces of Depoliticisation, Spectres of Radical Politics" (2014), Edinburgh University Press
  85. Wolfram, Marc, "Cities Shaping Grassroots Niches for Sustainability Transitions: Conceptual Reflections and an Exploratory Case Study", Journal of Cleaner Production, 173, pp.11~23 (2018)

관련 논문AI추천

Local Administrative System Transformation and Neighborhood Governance in South Korea곽현근한국지방자치학회 · 한국지방자치학회보2012 · 제24권 제4호우리나라 참여형 도시계획의 추세 및 특성에 대한 연구: 청주, 수원, 서울의 2030년 도시기본계획을 중심으로이희정, 전철민서울연구원 · 서울도시연구2016 · 제17권 제4호도시재생사업에서 주민참여 만족도 결정요인 연구: 서울시 주거지재생형 도시재생사업 참여 주민 중심으로김지훈, 최창규(사) 한국도시재생학회 · 도시재생2024 · 제10권 제3호Community Empowerment through Participatory Planning:Experiences of a Mining Town in Korea심재만한국농촌경제연구원 · 농촌경제2006 · 제29권 제4호도시재생 시민참여과정 비교분석 연구: 서울시 ‘서울로7017’과 ‘문화비축기지’사업 사례강지선, 김광구, 조은영한국비교정부학회 · 한국비교정부학보2018 · 제22권 제2호지역 어메니티 촉진을 위한 마을만들기 운영사례 비교연구김근호, 이영창한국농촌계획학회 · 농촌계획2013 · 제19권 제2호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (10건)

한국화교의 인터-아시아 정체성에 대한 고찰: 중국, 대만, 그리고 한국에 대한 인식을 중심으로팽의훤, 조영한pp. 3-34태국의 국경경제특구와 메콩지역의 경제통합엄은희pp. 35-63문명 교류의 허브 ‘교역항’에서의 수공업 생산: 사천 늑도 유적의 수공업 공방지 재조명고일홍pp. 105-137신라 북요통(北傜通) 복원 서설도도로키히로시pp. 139-161일본문명의 형성과 외래문명의 수용 양상: 쇼소인과 견당사, 그리고 헤이안 시대 모노가타리이미숙pp. 163-191
원문 보기