본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Resistance to sliding in orthodontics: misconception or method error? A systematic review and a proposal of a test protocol

Domenico Dalessandri|Corrado Paganelli|Fabio Savoldi|Aggeliki Papoutsi|Simona Dianiskova|Stefano Bonetti|James K. H. Tsoi|Jukka P. Matinlinna
대한치과교정학회 (The Korean Association Of Orthodontists)|2018.07|대한치과교정학회지 (The Korean Journal of Orthodontics)|제48권 제4호|pp. 268-280

1

조회

0

다운로드

2

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

BracketWireBiomaterial science
주제분류치의학

초록

Resistance to sliding (RS) between the bracket, wire, and ligature has been largely debated in orthodontics. Despite the extensive number of published studies, the lack of discussion of the methods used has led to little understanding of this phenomenon. The aim of this study was to discuss variables affecting RS in orthodontics and to suggest an operative protocol. The search included PubMed©, Medline©, and the Cochrane Library©. References of full-text articles were manually analyzed. English-language articles published between January 2007 and January 2017 that performed an in vitro analysis of RS between the bracket, wire, and ligature were included. Study methods were analyzed based on the study design, description of materials, and experimental setup, and a protocol to standardize the testing methods was proposed. From 404 articles identified from the database search and 242 records selected from published references, 101 were eligible for the qualitative analysis, and six for the quantitative synthesis. One or more experimental parameters were incompatible and a meta-analysis was not performed. Major factors regarding the study design, materials, and experimental setup were not clearly described by most studies. The normal force, that is the force perpendicular to the sliding of the wire and one of the most relevant variable in RS, was not considered by most studies. Different variables were introduced, often acting as confounding factors. A protocol was suggested to standardize testing procedures and enhance the understanding of in vitro findings.[Korean J Orthod 2018;48(4):268-280]

Abstract

Resistance to sliding (RS) between the bracket, wire, and ligature has been largely debated in orthodontics. Despite the extensive number of published studies, the lack of discussion of the methods used has led to little understanding of this phenomenon. The aim of this study was to discuss variables affecting RS in orthodontics and to suggest an operative protocol. The search included PubMed©, Medline©, and the Cochrane Library©. References of full-text articles were manually analyzed. English-language articles published between January 2007 and January 2017 that performed an in vitro analysis of RS between the bracket, wire, and ligature were included. Study methods were analyzed based on the study design, description of materials, and experimental setup, and a protocol to standardize the testing methods was proposed. From 404 articles identified from the database search and 242 records selected from published references, 101 were eligible for the qualitative analysis, and six for the quantitative synthesis. One or more experimental parameters were incompatible and a meta-analysis was not performed. Major factors regarding the study design, materials, and experimental setup were not clearly described by most studies. The normal force, that is the force perpendicular to the sliding of the wire and one of the most relevant variable in RS, was not considered by most studies. Different variables were introduced, often acting as confounding factors. A protocol was suggested to standardize testing procedures and enhance the understanding of in vitro findings.[Korean J Orthod 2018;48(4):268-280]

참고문헌 (74)

  1. Besancon RM, "The encyclopedia of physics" (1985), Van Nostrand Reinhold Company
  2. Jastrzebsky ZD, "The nature and properties of engineering materials" (1976), Wiley & Sons
  3. Kusy RP, "Influence of archwire and bracket dimensions on sliding mechanics: derivations and determinations of the critical contact angles for binding", Eur J Orthod, 21, pp.199~208 (1999)[DOI]
  4. Kusy RP, "Friction between different wire-bracket configurations and materials", Semin Orthod, 3, pp.166~177 (1997)[DOI]
  5. Burrow SJ, "Friction and resistance to sliding in orthodontics: a critical review", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 135, pp.442~447 (2009)[DOI]
  6. Kapur R, "Comparison of frictional resistance in titanium and stainless steel brackets", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 116, pp.271~274 (1999)[DOI]
  7. Southard TE, "Friction does not increase anchorage loading", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 131, pp.412~414 (2007)[DOI]
  8. Braun S, "Friction in perspective", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 115, pp.619~627 (1999)[DOI]
  9. Yeh CL, "In vitro evaluation of frictional resistance between brackets with passive-ligation designs", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 131, pp.704~ (2007)
  10. Muguruma T, "Effects of third-order torque on frictional force of self-ligating brackets", Angle Orthod, 84, pp.1054~1061 (2014)[DOI]
  11. Kusy RP, "Influence of force systems on archwire-bracket combinations", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 127, pp.333~342 (2005)[DOI]
  12. Edwards GD, "The ex vivo effect of ligation technique on the static frictional resistance of stainless steel brackets and archwires", Br J Orthod, 22, pp.145~153 (1995)[DOI]
  13. Suwa N, "Static-dynamic friction transition of FRP esthetic orthodontic wires on various brackets by suspension-type friction test", J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater, 67, pp.765~771 (2003)
  14. Kusy RP, "Comparison of the frictional coefficients for selected archwire-bracket slot combinations in the dry and wet states", Angle Orthod, 61, pp.293~302 (1991)
  15. Tageldin H, "Resistance to sliding in orthodontics: a systematic review", Jacobs J Dent Res, 3, pp.034~ (2016)
  16. Leite VV, "Comparison of frictional resistance between self-ligating and conventional brackets tied with elastomeric and metal ligature in orthodontic archwires", Dental Press J Orthod, 19, pp.114~119 (2014)
  17. Fleming PS, "Randomized clinical trial of orthodontic treatment efficiency with self-ligating and conventional fixed orthodontic appliances", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 137, pp.738~742 (2010)[DOI]
  18. Savoldi F, "Incisal apical root resorption evaluation after low-friction orthodontic treatment using two- dimensional radiographic imaging and trigonometric correction", J Clin Diagn Res, 9, pp.70~74 (2015)
  19. Saunders CR, "Surface topography and frictional characteristics of ceramic brackets", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 106, pp.76~87 (1994)[DOI]
  20. Peterson L, "A comparison of friction resistance for Nitinol and stainless steel wire in edgewise brackets", Quintessence Int Dent Dig, 13, pp.563~571 (1982)
  21. Husain N, "Frictional resistance between orthodontic brackets and archwire: an in vitro study", J Contemp Dent Pract, 12, pp.91~99 (2011)
  22. Kim TK, "Comparison of frictional forces during the initial leveling stage in various combinations of self-ligating brackets and archwires with a custom-designed typodont system", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 133, pp.187.e15~187.e24 (2008)
  23. Oz AA, "The clinical and laboratory effects of bracket type during canine distalization with sliding mechanics", Angle Orthod, 82, pp.326~332 (2012)[DOI]
  24. Huang TH, "An in vitro comparison of the frictional forces between archwires and self-ligating brackets of passive and active types", Eur J Orthod, 34, pp.625~632 (2012)[DOI]
  25. Lombardo L, "Frictional resistance exerted by different lingual and labial brackets: an in vitro study", Prog Orthod, 14, pp.37~ (2013)[DOI]
  26. Williams CL, "Frictional resistance of three types of ceramic brackets", J Oral Maxillofac Res, 4, pp.e3~ (2014)
  27. Amaral MR, "Evaluation in vitro of frictional resistance of self-ligating esthetic and conventional brackets", Int J Odontostomatol, 8, pp.261~266 (2014)[DOI]
  28. Pasha A, "Comparison of frictional forces generated by a new ceramic bracket with the conventional brackets using unconventional and conventional ligation system and the self-ligating brackets: an in vitro study", J Int Oral Health, 7, pp.108~113 (2015)
  29. Nursel Arici, "Comparison of the frictional characteristics of aesthetic orthodontic brackets measured using a modified in vitro technique", 대한치과교정학회지, 45(1), pp.29~37 (2015), 대한치과교정학회
  30. Gandini P, "In vitro frictional forces generated by three different ligation methods", Angle Orthod, 78, pp.917~921 (2008)[DOI]
  31. 김윤미, "Comparison of frictional forces between aesthetic orthodontic coated wires and self-ligation brackets", 대한치과교정학회지, 44(4), pp.157~167 (2014), 대한치과교정학회
  32. Reznikov N, "Measurement of friction forces between stainless steel wires and reduced-friction self- ligating brackets", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 138, pp.330~338 (2010)[DOI]
  33. Ozturk Ortan Y, "A comparative in vitro study of frictional resistance between lingual brackets and stainless steel archwires", Eur J Orthod, 34, pp.119~125 (2012)[DOI]
  34. Regis S Jr, "Biodegradation of orthodontic metallic brackets and associated implications for friction", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 140, pp.501~509 (2011)[DOI]
  35. Budd S, "A study of the frictional characteristics of four commercially available self-ligating bracket systems", Eur J Orthod, 30, pp.645~653 (2008)[DOI]
  36. Fourie Z, "Effect of dental arch convexity and type of archwire on frictional forces", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 136, pp.14.e1~14.e7 (2009)[DOI]
  37. Edwards IR, "The effect upon friction of the degradation of orthodontic elastomeric modules", Eur J Orthod, 34, pp.618~624 (2012)[DOI]
  38. Martins MM, "Friction generated by elastomeric ligature with and without polymer coating", Braz Dent Sci, 14, pp.9~12 (2011)
  39. Queiroz GV, "Comparative study of frictional forces generated by NiTi archwire deformation in different orthodontic brackets in vitro evaluation", Dental Press J Orthod, 17, pp.45~50 (2012)[DOI]
  40. Abbassy MA, "The effect of fluoride on beta titanium orthodontics wires' surface texture and friction resistance", Int J Dent Oral Sci, 2, pp.47~52 (2015)
  41. Uribe MN, "Comparison of resistance to sliding produced by self-ligating brackets and conventional brackets ligated with conventional elastomeric ligature and low-friction ligatures", Rev Fac Odontol Univ Antioq, 23, pp.192~206 (2012)
  42. Pillai AR, "Comparison of the frictional resistance between archwire and different bracket system: an in vitro study", J Pharm Bioallied Sci, 6(Suppl 1), pp.S150~S155 (2014)[DOI]
  43. Kumar S, "Evaluation of friction in orthodontics using various brackets and archwire combinations-an in vitro study", J Clin Diagn Res, 8, pp.ZC33~ZC36 (2014)[DOI]
  44. Fathimani M, "Development of a standardized testing system for orthodontic sliding mechanics", Prog Orthod, 16, pp.14~ (2015)[DOI]
  45. Voudouris JC, "Self-ligation esthetic brackets with low frictional resistance", Angle Orthod, 80, pp.188~194 (2010)[DOI]
  46. Nucera R, "Analysis of the characteristics of slot design affecting resistance to sliding during active archwire configurations", Prog Orthod, 14, pp.35~ (2013)[DOI]
  47. Farronato G, "The effect of Teflon coating on the resistance to sliding of orthodontic archwires", Eur J Orthod, 34, pp.410~417 (2012)[DOI]
  48. Alio-Sanz JJ, "In vitro com- parative study on the friction of stainless steel wires with and without <TEX>$Orthospeed^{(R)}$<", TEX> (JAL 90458) on an inclined plane, 2016, pp.8, e141~e145
  49. Whitley JQ, "Influence of interbracket distances on the resistance to sliding of orthodontic appliances", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 132, pp.360~372 (2007)[DOI]
  50. Tecco S, "An in vitro investigation of the influence of self- ligating brackets, low friction ligatures, and archwire on frictional resistance", Eur J Orthod, 29, pp.390~397 (2007)[DOI]
  51. Pliska BT, "A comparison of resistance to sliding of self-ligating brackets under an increasing applied moment", Angle Orthod, 81, pp.794~799 (2011)[DOI]
  52. Tecco S, "Evaluation of the friction of self- ligating and conventional bracket systems", Eur J Dent, 5, pp.310~317 (2011)
  53. Crincoli V, "Friction forces dur- ing sliding of various brackets for malaligned teeth: an in vitro study", ScientificWorldJournal, 2013, pp.871423~ (2013)
  54. de Lima Mendonca S, "Comparison of friction produced by two types of orthodontic bracket protectors", Dental Press J Orthod, 19, pp.86~91 (2014)
  55. Chang CJ, "Effect of bracket bevel design and oral environmental factors on frictional resistance", Angle Orthod, 83, pp.956~965 (2013)[DOI]
  56. Galvao MB, "Frictional resistance in monocrystalline ceramic brackets with conventional and nonconventional elastomeric ligatures", Prog Orthod, 14, pp.9~ (2013)[DOI]
  57. Inami T, "Surface topography, hardness, and frictional properties of GFRP for esthetic orthodontic wires", J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater, 104, pp.88~95 (2016)[DOI]
  58. Ioi H, "Frictional resistance in plastic preadjusted brackets ligated with low-friction and conventional elastomeric ligatures", J Orthod, 36, pp.17~22 (2009)[DOI]
  59. Matarese G, "Evaluation of frictional forces during dental alignment: an experimental model with 3 nonleveled brackets", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 133, pp.708~715 (2008)[DOI]
  60. Giancarlo Cordasco, "In vitro evaluation of resistance to sliding in self-ligating and conventional bracket systems during dental alignment", 대한치과교정학회지, 42(4), pp.218~224 (2012), 대한치과교정학회[DOI]
  61. 2.0.CO;2,
  62. Heo W, "Friction properties according to vertical and horizontal tooth displacement and bracket type during initial leveling and alignment", Angle Orthod, 81, pp.653~661 (2011)[DOI]
  63. Meier MJ, "Friction behavior and other material properties of nickel-titanium and titanium-molybdenum archwires following electrochemical surface refinement", J Orofac Orthop, 75, pp.308~318 (2014)[DOI]
  64. Murayama M, "Relationship between friction force and orthodontic force at the leveling stage using a coa- ted wire", J Appl Oral Sci, 21, pp.554~559 (2013)[DOI]
  65. Seo YJ, "Effect of tooth displacement and vibration on frictional force and stick-slip phenomenon in conventional brackets: a preliminary in vitro mechanical analysis", Eur J Orthod, 37, pp.158~163 (2015)[DOI]
  66. Obaisi NA, "Comparison of the transformation temperatures of heat-activated nickel-titanium orthodontic archwires by two diffe- rent techniques", Dent Mater, 32, pp.879~888 (2016)[DOI]
  67. Savoldi F, "In vitro evaluation of the influence of velocity on sliding resistance of stainless steel arch wires in a self-ligating orthodontic bracket", Orthod Craniofac Res, 20, pp.119~125 (2017)
  68. Natt AS, "A comparative evaluation of static frictional resistance using various methods of ligation at different time intervals: an in vitro study", Int J Dent, 2015, pp.407361~ (2015)
  69. Venancio FR, "Effect of elastomeric ligatures on frictional forces between the archwire and orthodontic bracket", Braz J Oral Sci, 12, pp.41~5 (2013)
  70. Pacheco MR, "Evaluation of friction in self-ligating brackets sub- jected to sliding mechanics: an in vitro study", Dental Press J Orthod, 16, pp.107~115 (2011)[DOI]
  71. Cordasco G, "In vitro evaluation of the fric- tional forces between brackets and archwire with three passive self-ligating brackets", Eur J Orthod, 31, pp.643~646 (2009)[DOI]
  72. Doshi UH, "Static frictional force and surface roughness of various bracket and wire combinations", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 139, pp.74~79 (2011)[DOI]
  73. Sirisaowaluk N, "The influence of ligation on frictional resistance to sliding during repeated displacement", Aust Orthod J, 22, pp.141~146 (2006)
  74. Keith O, "The influence of bracket material, ligation force and wear on frictional resistance of orthodontic brackets", Br J Orthod, 20, pp.109~115 (1993)[DOI]

관련 논문AI추천

In vitro evaluation of resistance to sliding in self-ligating and conventional bracket systems during dental alignmentAngela Militi, Antonino Lo Giudice, Giancarlo Cordasco, Giovanni Matarese, Giuseppe Triolo, Riccardo Nucera대한치과교정학회 · 대한치과교정학회지2012 · 제42권 제4호Effect of different combinations of bracket, archwire and ligature on resistance to sliding and axial rotational control during the first stage of orthodontic treatment: An in-vitro studyBing Han, Huizhong Chen, Tianmin Xu대한치과교정학회 · 대한치과교정학회지2019 · 제49권 제1호Effect of passive self-ligating bracket placement on the posterior teeth on reduction of frictional force in sliding mechanicsKyu-Ry Kim, Seung-Hak Baek대한치과교정학회 · 대한치과교정학회지2016 · 제46권 제2호A comparative study of frictional force in self-ligating brackets according to the bracket-archwire angulation, bracket material, and wire type황충주, Souk Min Lee대한치과교정학회 · 대한치과교정학회지2015 · 제45권 제1호Comparison of frictional forces between aesthetic orthodontic coated wires and self-ligation brackets김윤미, 유형석, 차정열, 황충주, Seon Gun Tahk대한치과교정학회 · 대한치과교정학회지2014 · 제44권 제4호Frictional property comparisons of conventional and self-ligating lingual brackets according to tooth displacement during initial leveling and alignment: an in vitro mechanical studyBum-Soon Lim, Do-Yoon Kim, Seung-Hak Baek대한치과교정학회 · 대한치과교정학회지2016 · 제46권 제2호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (7건)

READER’S FORUM이미영, 김경호pp. 213-215Trend of health care utilization of cleft lip and/or palate in Korea during 2007–2016홍미희, 백승학pp. 216-223Comparison of treatment effects between four premolar extraction and total arch distalization using the modified C-palatal plateMohamed Bayome, 조성윤, Justyn Park, 임희진, 한성호, 국윤아pp. 224-235The effect of occlusogingival placement of clinical bracket points on the adaptation of a straight wire to the lingual arch formAmir Hossein Abdi, Mahtab Nouri, Ehsan Balaghi, Saeed Reza Motamedianpp. 236-244Effects of different primers on indirect orthodontic bonding: Shear bond strength, color change, and enamel roughnessLincoln Issamu Nojima, Carlos Nelson Elias, Mirella Lemos Queiróz Tavarespp. 245-252
원문 보기