戦前、日本における漢字制限について-岡崎常太郎の「五〇〇字制限論」を中心に-
About Kanji restrictions in Japan before the Second World War -Focusing on Okazaki Tsunetaro’s “500 Kanji restriction theory”-
2
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Since the Meiji Restoration, there have been various debates over the characters used to describe Japanese. In 1935, Entomologist and member of Kanamojikai, Tsunetaro Okazaki embarked on a research project related to Kanji. In a Kanji writing test conducted on 1479 elementary school students in Tokyo, the average number of correct Kanji per person was only 631. As a result of having 424 ordinary people select 1929 Kanji including regular use Kanji, the number of Kanji selected by 50 or less is 809, accounting for 42% of the total. As a result of examining the 60-day Chinese words in five newspapers, the total number of Kanji was 3542, of which 100 characters had an appearance frequency of 38.7% and 500 characters had an appearance frequency of 77.3%. Based on these results, Okazaki created a proposal to limit 500 Kanji characters. The proposed restrictions based on Okazaki’s empirical research are quite convincing. However, as can be seen from the results of the newspaper survey, it seems that the 500 character limit proposal is somewhat impossible in the situation where about 79% of the Chinese words are read aloud. Currently, the number of common use Kanji in Japan is 2136. Compared to the number of common use Kanji in the 1930s, it increased by 278 characters. Through empirical surveys, Okazaki was trying to reduce the number of Kanji that would be a substantial burden on learning. Now that we can enter a lot of Kanji using machines, we should take a serious look at Okazaki’s proposal.
Abstract
Since the Meiji Restoration, there have been various debates over the characters used to describe Japanese. In 1935, Entomologist and member of Kanamojikai, Tsunetaro Okazaki embarked on a research project related to Kanji. In a Kanji writing test conducted on 1479 elementary school students in Tokyo, the average number of correct Kanji per person was only 631. As a result of having 424 ordinary people select 1929 Kanji including regular use Kanji, the number of Kanji selected by 50 or less is 809, accounting for 42% of the total. As a result of examining the 60-day Chinese words in five newspapers, the total number of Kanji was 3542, of which 100 characters had an appearance frequency of 38.7% and 500 characters had an appearance frequency of 77.3%. Based on these results, Okazaki created a proposal to limit 500 Kanji characters. The proposed restrictions based on Okazaki’s empirical research are quite convincing. However, as can be seen from the results of the newspaper survey, it seems that the 500 character limit proposal is somewhat impossible in the situation where about 79% of the Chinese words are read aloud. Currently, the number of common use Kanji in Japan is 2136. Compared to the number of common use Kanji in the 1930s, it increased by 278 characters. Through empirical surveys, Okazaki was trying to reduce the number of Kanji that would be a substantial burden on learning. Now that we can enter a lot of Kanji using machines, we should take a serious look at Okazaki’s proposal.
참고문헌 (24)
- 금영진, "우소지(嘘字)를 통해 본 일본근세 한자문자유희 - 시키테이 산바(式亭三馬)의 『우소지즈쿠시(嘘字尽くし)』를 중심으로 -", 일어일문학연구, 96(2), pp.21~38 (2016), 한국일어일문학회[DOI]
- 금영진, "우소지(嘘字)를 통해 보는 에도(江戸)의 언어문자 유희문화 -한자(漢字)와의 비교를 중심으로-", 한림일본학 (구 한림일본학연구), (31), pp.78~101 (2017), 일본학연구소[DOI]
- 성명진, "한자문화권에 대한 재검토 - 동아시아 3개 국어에 있어서의 한자의 표음성과 관련하여 -", 한국문화연구, 28, pp.213~247 (2015), 한국문화연구원[DOI]
- 신웅철, "일본에서 현대 중국의 인명과 지명을 표기하는 방식에 대한 고찰 ― 동아시아문명의 공통자산으로서 한자에 대한 인식을 중심으로", 중국학, (66), pp.43~59 (2019), 대한중국학회[DOI]
- 岡崎常太郎, "漢字制限の基本的研究", pp.1~186 (1938), 松邑三松堂
- 河路由佳, "戦前の非漢字圈留学生に対する漢字教育と国字問題", pp.139~ (2000), 凡人社
- 구명회, "「日本人の読み書き能力調査事業」について ― 1948年調査事業を中心に ―", 건지인문학, (28), pp.5~19 (2020), 인문학연구소[DOI]
- 형진의, "近代日本における正書法に関する考察 -国語国字問題を中心に-", 日本語文學, 1(37), pp.215~236 (2008), 한국일본어문학회
- 형진의, "近代日本の言語規範と言語認識", 비교일본학, 37, pp.333~344 (2016), 일본학국제비교연구소
- 子安宣邦, "漢字論ー不可避の他者ー", pp.1~234 (2003), 岩波書店
- "人民日報日本語版「中国の漢字はいくつある?」"[URL]
- "小学館大百科全書(ニッポニカ)"[URL]
- 高橋俊男, "漢字と日本人", pp.1~256 (2001), 文藝春秋
- 田中克彦, "漢字が日本を滅ぼす", pp.1~271 (2011), 角川書店
- 棚橋尚子, "『国語運動』創刊と漢字制限問題", 奈良教育大学国文, 24, pp.1~12 (2001), 奈良教育大学国文学会
- 橋本博孝, "日本語の音と文字の学習(Ⅱ)-小学校におけるローマ字学習の意義-", 奈良教育大学国文:教育と研究, 16, pp.62~63 (1994), 奈良教育大学国文学会
- 中村春作, "訓読論ー東アジア漢文世界と日本語", pp.1~338 (2008), 勉誠出版
- 平井昌夫, "国語国字問題の歴史", pp.1~628 (1998), 三元社
- 堀誠, "早稲田教育評論", pp.10~11 (2001)
- 文部省, "国民の読み書き能力", pp.1~634 (1961), 大蔵省印刷局
- 安田敏朗, "言語政策はどのように日常を支配するのか-村上広之の議論を中心に-", 일어일문학연구, 79(1), pp.47~68 (2011), 한국일어일문학회[DOI]
- 安田敏朗, "国語の近代史", pp.1~308 (2006), 中公新書
- 安田敏朗, "漢字廃止の思想史", pp.1~538 (2016), 平凡社
- 読み書き能力調査委員会, "日本人の読み書き能力", pp.1~808 (1951), 東京大学出版部
