TES(Translation Evaluation System) 분석을 통해 살펴본 번역오류항목 가중치에 관한 연구 -한일 번역물 분석을 중심으로
A Study on the Weight of Translation Errors Based on the Translation Evaluation System(TES) Analysis
0
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Translation quality is a key to discussing translation, and it is essential to have the criteria that help determine a “good” target text in order to discuss translation quality. Despite endless debates on the issue, the academic community has yet to agree on explicit standards that a “good” target text needs to satisfy. Therefore,translations have been assessed according to subjectively-set criteria. This paper is a preliminary report on designation of different weights by translation error category. To devise a clear and consistent translation evaluation model, it is vital to first set adequate categories for evaluation according to directionality i.e. Japanese into Korean and vice versa. Therefore, the study attempts to establish evaluation criteria for Korean-Japanese technical translations by using Translation Evaluation System(TES), which a Japanese company, Hitachi Ltd. utilizes to evaluate Japanese-English technical translations. Once the criteria were determined, the target texts produced by the paper's subjects (students) were examined to sort identified errors by the categories. The errors were then sent to native speakers of Japanese for a five-step assessment based on naturalness of expressions and readability. By designating different weighted value to each error category, this study aims to contribute to a more systematic and quantitative evaluation of translated texts.
Abstract
Translation quality is a key to discussing translation, and it is essential to have the criteria that help determine a “good” target text in order to discuss translation quality. Despite endless debates on the issue, the academic community has yet to agree on explicit standards that a “good” target text needs to satisfy. Therefore,translations have been assessed according to subjectively-set criteria. This paper is a preliminary report on designation of different weights by translation error category. To devise a clear and consistent translation evaluation model, it is vital to first set adequate categories for evaluation according to directionality i.e. Japanese into Korean and vice versa. Therefore, the study attempts to establish evaluation criteria for Korean-Japanese technical translations by using Translation Evaluation System(TES), which a Japanese company, Hitachi Ltd. utilizes to evaluate Japanese-English technical translations. Once the criteria were determined, the target texts produced by the paper's subjects (students) were examined to sort identified errors by the categories. The errors were then sent to native speakers of Japanese for a five-step assessment based on naturalness of expressions and readability. By designating different weighted value to each error category, this study aims to contribute to a more systematic and quantitative evaluation of translated texts.
참고문헌 (16)
- 김진아, "번역 품질평가에 관한 小考", 외국문학연구, (11), pp.4~124 (2002), 외국문학연구소
- 한-일 번역에 있어서의 외래어의 오역 분석, "김한식", 한국외국어대학교 통역번역연구소, 2~ (1998)
- 한-일 번역에 있어서의 句讀點의 문제, "김한식", 한국외국어대학교 통역번역연구소, 4~ (2000)
- 김한식, "한일 통역과 번역" (2003), 한국문화사
- 성초림, "번역교육 현장에서의 번역물 품질 평가", 번역학연구, 2(2), pp.37~56 (2001)
- 신경애, "학습자의 니즈 중심의 통역교육 －대학의 통역교육 현황 분석을 토대로－", 일어일문학연구, 76(1), pp.241~260 (2011), 한국일어일문학회
- 오경순, "『The Catcher in the Rye』의 한.일 번역 비교-충실성과 가독성의 관점에서", 日本文化學報, 30(30), pp.131~147 (2006), 한국일본문화학회
- 이유진, "번역교수법과 번역능력의 상관관계 연구", 통번역학연구, 14(1), pp.123~144 (2010), 통번역연구소
- 이향, "번역능력이란 무엇인가", 통역과 번역, 8(1), pp.177~193 (2006), 한국통역번역학회
- Gouadec, D., "Présentationdu Système d'évaluation positive destraductions «SEPT»" (1989), Bureau des traductions, Secrétariat d'État du Canada
- Hönig, H. G., "Positions, power and practice: Functionalist approaches and translation quality assessment, In Translation and quality", pp.6~34 (1998), MultilingualMatters
- Larose, R., "Méthodologie de l'évaluation des traductions", Meta, 43(2), pp.163~186 (1998)
- Morrissey, Kevin, "技術翻訳のチェックポイント ー技術翻訳の作成と評価" (2005), (株)丸善
- PACTE GROUP, "Acquiring translation competence: Hypothesis and methodological problems in a research project, In Investigating translation", pp.99~106 (2000), John Benjamins
- Schaffner, Christina, "From 'good' to 'functionally appropriate': Assessing translation quality, In Translation and quality", pp.1~5 (1998), Multilingual Matters
- Williams, Malcolm, "Translation Quality Assessment : An Argumentation -Centred Approach", pp.188~ (2004), University of Ottawa Press