본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

한국과 일본 초등학교 국어교과서의 갈등 서사 비교

Comparison of National Language Textbook of Korea and Japan Elementary School - Focus on Narrative of Conflict in Literary Text -

0

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류일본어와문학

초록

The prose writings centering the fiction writings in the National Language textbook of the sixth grade in Korea and Japan have been analyzed for the description of the conflict in terms of the literature and the education. In terms of the literature, the intention of the description is separated as the lesson and the empathy, and there was no discrimination in giving internal information for two conflicting characters when the mental attitude of the narrator for them is evasion-evasion in case of the lesson. However, it was found that there is a formula of discrimination as the approaching character>evading character in giving internal information when the mental attitude of the narrator for two characters is approach-evasion whether the intention of the writing is lesson or empathy. The empathy for the character is composed by the discriminative information. However, there is remarkable difference between two nations in the comparison of the conflict material which is the analysis in terms of the education. Japan regulates the attitude to the nature in the education standard law different with Korea, and the veneration for the nature and ecological ethics are treated as most important thing in the description of the conflict in the textbook. However, there was no fiction writings treating international conflict. There is no writings foregrounding the conflict of the ecosystem whereas the personal, against the personal and international conflict are treated individually or multi layered equally. It is able to mention that the textbook of Korea borrows the realization of the ethical goodness in the personal relation, society and international society as the main material of the description of the conflict.

Abstract

The prose writings centering the fiction writings in the National Language textbook of the sixth grade in Korea and Japan have been analyzed for the description of the conflict in terms of the literature and the education. In terms of the literature, the intention of the description is separated as the lesson and the empathy, and there was no discrimination in giving internal information for two conflicting characters when the mental attitude of the narrator for them is evasion-evasion in case of the lesson. However, it was found that there is a formula of discrimination as the approaching character>evading character in giving internal information when the mental attitude of the narrator for two characters is approach-evasion whether the intention of the writing is lesson or empathy. The empathy for the character is composed by the discriminative information. However, there is remarkable difference between two nations in the comparison of the conflict material which is the analysis in terms of the education. Japan regulates the attitude to the nature in the education standard law different with Korea, and the veneration for the nature and ecological ethics are treated as most important thing in the description of the conflict in the textbook. However, there was no fiction writings treating international conflict. There is no writings foregrounding the conflict of the ecosystem whereas the personal, against the personal and international conflict are treated individually or multi layered equally. It is able to mention that the textbook of Korea borrows the realization of the ethical goodness in the personal relation, society and international society as the main material of the description of the conflict.

참고문헌 (22)

  1. 서울교육대학교, "초등학교 국어 6-1가』『초등학교 국어 6-1나』", pp.1~322 (2015), 미래엔
  2. 서울교육대학교, "『초등학교 국어 6-2가』『초등학교 국어 6-2나』", pp.1~289 (2015), 미래엔
  3. 甲斐睦朗 ほか, "国語六 創造", pp.1~284 (2016), 光村図書出版
  4. 강경완, "단어의 의미에 반영된 사회적 가치관에 관한 대조연구: 한일국어교과서를 예로", 한림일본학 (구 한림일본학연구), (28), pp.205~235 (2016), 일본학연구소[DOI]
  5. 고영복, "사회학사전", pp.17~ (2000), 사회문화연구소
  6. 사희영, "1940년대 ‘皇軍’ 養成을 위한 한일 「國語」교과서 -조선총독부 편찬 제Ⅴ기 『よみかた』, 『初等國語』와 文部省 편찬 제Ⅴ기 『よみかた』, 『初等科國語』를 중심으로-", 일본연구, (16), pp.223~250 (2011), 글로벌일본연구원
  7. 사희영, "한일 교과서를 통해 본 <國語>교육 비교 考察 -1940년대 조선총독부 『よみかた』, 『初等國語』와 文部省 『よみかた』, 『初等科國語』를 중심으로-", 일어일문학, (52), pp.315~335 (2011), 대한일어일문학회[DOI]
  8. 신원기, "한·일(韓日) 초등학교 『국어』교과서의 설화(說話) 교재 고찰 - <삼년고개>와 <三年とうげ>를 중심으로", 한국초등국어교육, (41), pp.89~131 (2009), 한국초등국어교육학회[DOI]
  9. 신지숙, "일본초등학교 5학년 국어교과서 문학교재의 특징 - 테마를 중심으로 -", 일어일문학연구, 96(2), pp.227~257 (2016), 한국일어일문학회[DOI]
  10. 신지숙, "애니미즘의 상상력 일본 초등 국어교과서 연구", pp.217~279 (2017), 제이앤씨
  11. 심은정, "한일 국어교과서의 전래동화 교재 연구", 동일어문연구, 13, pp.97~114 (1998)
  12. 이미숙, "한․일 초등학교 국어교과서의 삽화에 나타난 사회․문화적 가치관 연구― 저․중․고학년의 변화에 주목하여 ―", 일본학보, (95), pp.31~45 (2013), 한국일본학회
  13. 제라르 주네트, "서사 담론", pp.218~220 (1992), 교보문고
  14. 時事通信社, "2011年度小学校教科書採択状況文科省まとめ", 内外教育, 6045, pp.10~11 (2010)
  15. 鈴木愛理, "国語教育における文学の居場所ー言葉の芸術として文学を捉える教育の可能性", pp.348~ (2016), ひつじ書房
  16. 15年度小学校教科書採択状況-文科省まとめ, "内外教育編集部", ~ (2015)
  17. "データで読む 2014~2015調査・統計解説集", pp.37~, 時事通信社
  18. 府川源一郎, "国語教育総合事典", pp.6~ (2011), 朝倉書店
  19. "교육기본법" (2019)[URL]
  20. "‘갈등’『표준국어대사전』" (2019)[URL]
  21. "‘葛藤’『日本大百科全書(ニッポニカ)』" (2019)[URL]
  22. "教育基本法" (2019)[URL]

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (15건)