본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

연구개발팀에서 팀내 갈등과 팀 혁신성과간의 관계에서 팀 학습행동의 매개역할

A Study on the Relationship between Intra-team Conflict and Team Innovative Performance and the Mediating Role of Team Learning Behaviors in R&D Teams

0

조회

0

다운로드

11

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류경영학

초록

In this era of cut-throat competition, innovation is a source of competitive advantage, and securing core competency through innovation plays a pivotal role in ensuring the survival and growth of an organization. In an organization, R&D team is a core division driving innovation, and creative tension and conflict among researchers fuels innovative performance. Despite heated debate over the positive and negative effects of conflict, insufficiently-identified process factors have left sophisticated mechanisms between conflicts and effects unaddressed. This study assumes that team learning behaviors can be an important process factor given that conflict propels learning, and that learning is a decisive factor in creating competitive advantage. This study conducted an empirical analysis of the relationship between relationship/task conflict and team innovative performance, and the mediating role of team learning behaviors using data collected from a questionnaire sent out to the heads of 262 R&D teams and second highest-ranking officials thereof. The analysis conducted based on structural equation model indicates that relationship conflict has negatively affected team learning behaviors, whereas task conflict has positively influenced team learning behaviors (full mediation effect), team learning behaviors has positively influenced team innovative performance. Based on these results, the study has suggested implications of intra-team conflict and team learning behaviors for team innovative performance.

Abstract

In this era of cut-throat competition, innovation is a source of competitive advantage, and securing core competency through innovation plays a pivotal role in ensuring the survival and growth of an organization. In an organization, R&D team is a core division driving innovation, and creative tension and conflict among researchers fuels innovative performance. Despite heated debate over the positive and negative effects of conflict, insufficiently-identified process factors have left sophisticated mechanisms between conflicts and effects unaddressed. This study assumes that team learning behaviors can be an important process factor given that conflict propels learning, and that learning is a decisive factor in creating competitive advantage. This study conducted an empirical analysis of the relationship between relationship/task conflict and team innovative performance, and the mediating role of team learning behaviors using data collected from a questionnaire sent out to the heads of 262 R&D teams and second highest-ranking officials thereof. The analysis conducted based on structural equation model indicates that relationship conflict has negatively affected team learning behaviors, whereas task conflict has positively influenced team learning behaviors (full mediation effect), team learning behaviors has positively influenced team innovative performance. Based on these results, the study has suggested implications of intra-team conflict and team learning behaviors for team innovative performance.

참고문헌 (107)

  1. 김창호, "팀 조직의 활동이 지식경영 활동 및 성과에 미치는 영향에 대한 실증적인 분석", 지식경영연구, 6(2), pp.91~107 (2005), 한국지식경영학회
  2. 박헌준, "프로젝트 팀의 학습이 팀 성과에 미치는 영향", 인사조직연구, 12(특호), pp.41~66 (2004), 한국인사조직학회
  3. 박희진, "팀 구성원들의 교류기억과 팀 멘탈모델의 관계 - 팀 학습 행동의 매개를 중심으로 -", 한국심리학회지: 산업 및 조직, 22(4), pp.597~623 (2009), 한국산업및조직심리학회
  4. 박희진, "팀 학습 행동과 팀 수행의 관계: 메타분석", 한국심리학회지: 산업 및 조직, 24(3), pp.651~672 (2011), 한국산업및조직심리학회
  5. 박희진, "팀 학습 및 교류활성기억과 팀 수행의 관계: 팀 맥락을 선행요인으로", 한국심리학회지: 산업 및 조직, 20(4), pp.475~496 (2007), 한국산업및조직심리학회
  6. 손영우, "임파워링 리더행동과 팀원들의 학습행동 및 교류기억의 관계: 팀 효능감, 혁신성향 및 리더에 대한 신뢰의 매개효과", 한국심리학회지: 산업 및 조직, 22(1), pp.1~25 (2009), 한국산업및조직심리학회[DOI]
  7. 이준호, "연구개발팀에서 팀 효능감과 팀 혁신성과간의 관계에서 팀 학습행동의 매개역할", 지식경영연구, 13(3), pp.105~126 (2012), 한국지식경영학회
  8. 이준호, "집단 내 갈등과 이직의도의 관계에서 직무만족의 매개효과: 한국과 중국 종업원들의 공통점과 차이점", 한국심리학회지: 산업 및 조직, 24(1), pp.75~102 (2011), 한국산업및조직심리학회
  9. 이준호, "연구개발 집단에서의 갈등과 혁신성과간 관계에서 집단효능감의 조절역할", 조직과 인사관리연구, 35(1), pp.75~102 (2011), 한국인사관리학회
  10. 임희정, "지식근로자의 공유인지와 팀 효과성의 관계", 지식경영연구, 6(2), pp.67~89 (2005), 한국지식경영학회
  11. 전영욱, "팀 학습에 영향을 미치는 요인에 관한 구조분석", Andragogy Today: Interdisciplinary Journal of Adult & Continuing Education (IJACE), 12(4), pp.115~146 (2009), 한국성인교육학회
  12. Akgu, A. E., "Multi-dimensionalityofLearninginNew ProductDevelopmentTeams", EuropeanJournalofInnovationManagement, 5(2), pp.57~72 (2002)
  13. Akkerman, S., "Reconsidering GroupCognition: From Conceptual Confusion to aBoundary Area between Cognitive andSocio-cultural Perspectives", Educational ResearchReview, 2(1), pp.39~63 (2007)
  14. Amabile, T. M., "Assessing the WorkEnvironment for Creativity", Academy ofManagementJournal, 39(5), pp.1154~1184 (1996)
  15. Amason, A. C., "DistinguishingtheEffectsofFunctionalandDysfunctionalConflictonStrategicDecision Making:Resolving a Paradox forTopManagement Teams", Academy of ManagementJournal, 39(1), pp.123~148 (1996)
  16. Amason,A.C, "TheEffects of Top Management Team Size andInteraction Norms on Cognitive and AffectiveConflict", JournalofManagement, 23(4), pp.495~516 (1997)
  17. Anderson, J.C., "Structural Equation Modeling in Practice: AReview and Recommended Two-step Approach", PsychologicalBulletin, 103(3), pp.411~423 (1988)
  18. Anderson,N., "TheTeam ClimateInventory:DevelopmentoftheTCIand its Applications in Teambuilding forInnovativeness", European Journal of Work andOrganizationalPsychology, 5(1), pp.53~66 (1996)
  19. Argyris, C., "OnOrganizationalLearning" (1999), Blackwell
  20. Argyris,C, "OrganizationalLearning:A Theory of Action Perspective" (1978), Addison-Wesley
  21. Bagozzi,R.P., "OntheEvaluationof Structural Equation Models", Journal of theAcademyofMarketingScience, 16(1), pp.74~94 (1988)
  22. Bain, A., "Social Defenses againstOrganizationalLearning", Human Relations, 51(3), pp.413~429 (1998)
  23. Banker, R. D., "ImpactofWork TeamsonManufacturingPerformance:A LongitudinalFieldStudy", Academy of Management Journal, 39(4), pp.867~890 (1996)
  24. Baron, R.M., "TheModerator-mediatorVariableDistinctioninSocialPsychologicalResearch:Conceptual,Strategic,andStatisticalConsiderations", JournalofPersonalityandSocialPsychology, 51(6), pp.1173~1182 (1986)
  25. Bourgeois, L.J., "Strategy Decision Processesin a High VelocityEnvironment:FourCasesin theMicro-computerIndustry", ManagementScience, 34, pp.816~835 (1988)
  26. Brehmer, B., "SocialJudgmentTheoryandtheAnalysisofInterpersonalConflict", PsychologicalBulletin, 83(6), pp.985~1003 (1976)
  27. Brockhoff, K., "Customers'PerspectivesofInvolvement in New Product Development", International Journal of Technology Management, 26(5), pp.464~481 (2003)
  28. Brodbeck, F. C., "TheDissemination ofCritical,Unshared Informationin Decision-making Groups: The Effects ofPre-discussion Dissent", European JournalofSocialPsychology, 32(1), pp.35~56 (2002)
  29. Brown,J.S, "OrganizationalLearning and Communities-of-practice:Toward aUnified View of Working, Learning, andInnovation", OrganizationScience, 2(1), pp.40~57 (1991)
  30. Bunderson, J.S, "Management Team Learning Orientation andBusiness Unit Performance", Journal of AppliedPsychology, 88(3), pp.552~560 (2003)
  31. Caldwell,D.F, "TheDeterminants of Team-based Innovation inOrganizations:TheRoleofSocialInfluence", SmallGroupResearch, 34(4), pp.497~517 (2003)
  32. Carnevale,P.J., "SocialValuesand SocialConflictin CreativeProblemSolving and Categorization", JournalofPersonalityandSocialPsychology, 74(5), pp.1300~1309 (1998)
  33. Cohen, W.M, "Absorptive Capacity: A New Perspective onLearning and Innovation", Administrative ScienceQuarterly, 35(1), pp.128~152 (1990)
  34. Combs, K. L., "The Role of InformationSharing in Cooperative Research andDevelopment", International Journal of IndustrialOrganization, 11(4), pp.535~551 (1993)
  35. Coser, L. A., "TheFunctionsofSocialConflict" (1956), FreePress
  36. Crossan, M. M., "An OrganizationalLearning Framework:From Intuition to Institution", Academy ofManagementReview, 24(3), pp.522~537 (1999)
  37. Daft, R. L., "Organization TheoryandDesign" (2004), ThomsonSouthwestern
  38. Day, D., "Leadership Capacity in Teams", The LeadershipQuarterly, 15, pp.857~880 (2004)
  39. DeDreu, C. K. W., "WhenTooLittleorTooMuch Hurts: Evidence for a CurvilinearRelationship between Task Conflict andInnovationinTeams", JournalofManagement, 32(1), pp.83~107 (2006)
  40. DeDreu,C.K.W, "UsingConflictinOrganizations" (1997), Sage
  41. DeDreu,C.K.W, "Responses to Relationship Conflict and TeamEffectiveness", JournalofOrganizationalBehavior, 22, pp.309~328 (2001)
  42. DeDreu,C.K.W, "TaskversusRelationship Conflict,Team Performance,and Team MemberSatisfaction:A Meta-analysis", JournalofAppliedPsychology, 88(4), pp.741~749 (2003)
  43. DeDreu,C.K.W, "MinorityDissentandTeam Innovation:TheImportanceofParticipation in Decision Making", Journal ofAppliedPsychology, 86(6), pp.1191~1201 (2001)
  44. deWit, F. R. C., "The Paradox of Intragroup Conflict: AMeta-analysis", JournalofAppliedPsychology, 97(2), pp.360~390 (2012)
  45. Dechant,K, "InSearchoftheLearningOrganization:Toward aConceptualModelofCollectiveLearning, In ProceedingsoftheEasternAcademyofManagement", pp.225~228 (1991), Eastern Academy ofManagement
  46. Decuyper, S., "Grasping the Dynamic Complexity ofTeam Learning: An Integrative Model forEffective Team Learning in Organizations", EducationalResearchReview, 5(2), pp.111~133 (2010)
  47. Drach-Zahavy, A., "The Proficiency Trap:How to BalanceEnriched Job Designsand theTeam'sNeedforSupport", JournalofOrganizationalBehavior, 25(8), pp.979~996 (2004)
  48. Dunphy, D, "Teams:Panaceas or Prescription for ImprovedPerformance", HumanRelations, 49(5), pp.677~698 (1996)
  49. Dyer, B, "InnovationStrategyandSanctionedConflict:A New EdgeinInnovation", Journal of Product InnovationManagement, 15(6), pp.505~519 (1998)
  50. Earley,P.C, "MultinationalTeams:A New Perspective" (2002), LawrenceErlbaum Associates
  51. Edmondson, A., "PsychologicalSafety andLearningBehaviorinWorkTeams", AdministrativeScienceQuarterly, 44(2), pp.350~383 (1999)
  52. Edmondson, A. C., "Disrupted Routines:Team Learning andNew Technology Implementation in Hospitals", AdministrativeScienceQuarterly, 46(4), pp.685~716 (2001)
  53. Ellis, A. P. J., "TeamLearning:CollectivelyConnectingtheDots", JournalofAppliedPsychology, 88(5), pp.821~835 (2003)
  54. Farh, J. L., "TaskConflict and Team Creativity:A Question ofHow Much and When", Journal of AppliedPsychology, 95(6), pp.1173~1180 (2010)
  55. Fornell,C, "EvaluatingStructural Models with Unobservable Variableand Measurement Error", Journal of MarketingResearch, 18(1), pp.39~50 (1981)
  56. Gibson,C, "A HealthyDivide: Subgroup as a Stimulus for TeamLearningBehavior", AdministrativeScienceQuarterly, 48, pp.202~239 (2003)
  57. Greenberg,J, "ProceduralJustice,Participation,and theFairProcessEffectin Groups and Organizations, In Basic Group Processes", pp.235~256 (1983), Springer-Verlag
  58. Gruenfeld, D. H., "CognitiveFlexibility,CommunicationStrategy,and IntegrativeComplexity in Groups:PublicversusPrivateReactionsto Majority andMinority Status", Journal of Experimental SocialPsychology, 34(2), pp.202~226 (1998)
  59. Guetzkow,H, "AnAnalysisofConflict in Decision-making Group", HumanRelations, 7, pp.367~381 (1954)
  60. Guth,W.D, "StrategyImplementation versus Middle ManagementSelf-interest", Strategic Management Journal, 7, pp.313~327 (1986)
  61. Hair, J. F., "MultivariateDataAnalysis" (2006), PrenticeHall
  62. Hedberg, B., "How OrganizationsLearnandUnlearn, In HandbookofOrganizationalDesign", pp.3~27 (1981), OxfordUniversityPress
  63. Hirst, G., "A Cross-levelPerspective on EmployeeCreativity: Goal Orientation, Team LearningBehavior,and IndividualCreativity", Academy ofManagementJournal, 52(2), pp.280~293 (2009)
  64. Huber, G. P., "OrganizationalLearning:TheContributing Processes and the Literatures", OrganizationalScience, 2, pp.88~115 (1991)
  65. Ickes, W, "SocialCognition and Social Cognition from theSubjective to the Intersubjective", Small GroupResearch, 25(2), pp.294~315 (1994)
  66. Jehn, K. A., "A MultimethodExaminationofthe Benefits and Detriments of IntragroupConflict", Administrative Science Quarterly, 40, pp.256~282 (1995)
  67. Jehn,K.A, "IntragroupConflict in Organizations: A ContingencyPerspectiveon theConflict-outcomeRelationship", ResearchinOrganizationalBehavior, 25, pp.187~242 (2003)
  68. Jehn,K.A., "TheDynamicNature of Conflict:A Longitudinal Study ofIntragroup Conflict and Group Performance", AcademyofManagementJournal, 44(2), pp.238~251 (2001)
  69. Kelloway, E. K., "UsingLisrelforStructuralEquationModeling" (1998), Sage
  70. Kim, Y., "TheRolesofR&D Team Leaders in Korea: A ContingentApproach", R&D Management, 29(2), pp.153~165 (1999)
  71. Kirkman, B. L., "TheImpactofTeam Empowermenton VirtualTeam Performance:The ModeratingRole of Face to Face Interaction", Academy ofManagementJournal, 46(2), pp.1~15 (2004)
  72. Kozlowski, S.W.J, "WorkgroupsandTeamsinOrganization, In Comprehensive Handbook of Psychology,IndustrialandOrganizationalPsychology", pp.333~375 (2003), Wiley
  73. Kremer-Bennett,J, "TheTwelve Building Blocks of the LearningOrganization", Training, pp.41~49 (1994)
  74. Lizeo, E., "A Dynamic Model of GroupLearning and Effectiveness", System DynamicsSocietyConference2005 (2005)
  75. Lovelace, K., "MaximizingCross-functionalNew ProductTeams'InnovativenessandConstraintAdherence:A ConflictCommunicationsPerspective", AcademyofManagementJournal, 44(4), pp.779~793 (2001)
  76. Marsick, V. J., "Team Learning, In SculptingtheLearningOrganization:LessonsintheArtandScienceofSystemicChange", pp.96~117 (1993), Jossey-Bass
  77. Matsuo, M., "CustomerOrientation,Conflict,and Innovativeness in Japanese SalesDepartments", JournalofBusiness Research, 59(2), pp.242~250 (2006)
  78. McDermott, R., "LearningacrossTeams:TheRole of Communities of Practice in TeamOrganization", KnowledgeManagementReview, 3(8), pp.32~36 (1999)
  79. Moorman, C., "Organizational MarketInformation Processes:CulturalAntecedentsandNew Product Outcomes", Journal of MarketingResearch, 32, pp.318~335 (1995)
  80. Mumford, M. D., "SocialInnovation:TenCasesfrom BenjaminFranklin", CreativityResearchJournal, 14, pp.253~266 (2002)
  81. Ortega, A., "Team Learning and Effectiveness inVirtualProjectTeams:TheRoleofBeliefsaboutInterpersonal Context", Spanish Journal ofPsychology, 13(1), pp.267~276 (2010)
  82. Panteli,N, "TrustandConflict within Virtual Inter-organizationalAlliances: A Framework for FacilitatingKnowledge Sharing", Decision Support Systems, 39(4), pp.599~617 (2005)
  83. Pearsall, M. J., "Coping with Challengeand HindranceStressorsin Teams:Behavioral,Cognitive,and AffectiveOutcomes", Organizational Behavior and HumanDecisionProcesses, 109(1), pp.18~28 (2009)
  84. Peter,M, "TheCentralityofTeams in the OrganizationalLearning Process", ManagementDecision, 43(9), pp.1186~1202 (2005)
  85. Pirola-Merlo, A., "TheRelationship between IndividualCreativity andTeam Creativity:Aggregating acrossPeopleandTime", Journal of Organizational Behavior, 25(2), pp.235~257 (2004)
  86. Priem,R., "Process andOutcomeExpectationsfortheDialecticalInquiry,Devil'sAdvocacy,and ConsensusTechniquesofStrategicDecisionMaking", GroupandOrganizationStudies, 16, pp.206~225 (1991)
  87. Quinn, J. B., "Strategies forChange:LogicalIncrementalism" (1980), HomewoodIL
  88. Scarpello, V, "AnExploration ofCriticalPersonalitiesin Researchand DevelopmentOrganizations", JournalofHighTechnologyManagementResearch, 2(2), pp.151~158 (1991)
  89. Schwab, D. P., "Research Methods forOrganizationalStudies" (2005), Erlbaum
  90. Schweiger,D.M, "Experiential Effects of DialecticalInquiry, Devil's Advocacy, and ConsensusApproaches to Strategic Decision Making", AcademyofManagementJournal, 32(4), pp.745~772 (1989)
  91. Schwenk, C. R., "Conflictin OrganizationalDecision Making:An Exploratory Study ofitsEffects in For-profit and Not-for-profitOrganizations", ManagementScience, 36(4), pp.436~448 (1990)
  92. Senge, R., "The Fifth Discipline" (1990), Doubleday
  93. Shrivastava, P., "A Typology ofOrganizational Learning Systems", Journal ofManagementStudies, 20(1), pp.7~28 (1983)
  94. Simon, H., "AdministrativeBehavior" (1976), FreePress
  95. Somech, A., "TheEffectsofLeadershipStyleand Team Process on Performance andInnovationinFunctionallyHeterogeneousTeams", JournalofManagement, 31(1), pp.132~157 (2006)
  96. Tjepkema, S., "TheLearningInfrastructureofSelf-managingWorkTeams" (2003), TwenteUniversityPress
  97. Van den Bossche, P., "Socialand CognitiveFactors Driving Teamwork in CollaborativeLearning Environments:Team Learning BeliefsandBehaviors", SmallGroupResearch, 37, pp.490~521 (2006)
  98. Van derVegt,G.S, "Learning and Performance in MultidisciplinaryTeams: The Importance of Collective TeamIdentification", AcademyofManagementJournal, 48, pp.532~547 (2005)
  99. van Woerkom,M, "Learning from Conflicts?TheRelationsbetweenTask and Relationship Conflicts,Team Learningand Team Performance", EuropeanJournalofWorkandOrganizationalPsychology, 18(4), pp.381~404 (2009)
  100. Wall,J.A, "Conflictandits Management", Journal of Management, 21(3), pp.515~558 (1995)
  101. Wall,V.D, "PerceptionsofInequity, Satisfaction, and Conflict inTask-oriented Groups", Human Relations, 39(11), pp.1033~1052 (1986)
  102. Walsh, J. P., "Negotiated BeliefStructuresand DecisionPerformance: An Empirical Investigation", OrganizationalBehaviorandHumanDecisionProcess, 42, pp.194~216 (1988)
  103. West, M. A., "Sparkling Fountains orStagnant Ponds: An Integrative Model ofCreativity and Innovation Implementation inWorkGroups", AppliedPsychology:AnInternationalReview, 51(3), pp.355~424 (2002)
  104. West, M. A., "InternationalHandbook ofOrganizationalTeamworkand Cooperative Working" (2003), Wiley
  105. Wildemeersch, D., "Social LearningRevisited: Lessons Learned from North andSouth, In SocialLearning:Towardsa Sustainable World", pp.99~116 (2007), WageningenAcademyPublishers
  106. Wong, S., "Distal and Local GroupLearning:Performance Trade-offs and Tensions", OrganizationScience, 15, pp.645~656 (2004)
  107. Zellmer-Bruhn, M., "MultinationalOrganization Context:ImplicationsforTeam Learningand Performance", AcademyofManagementJournal, 49(3), pp.501~518 (2006)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (8건)