Accuracy of Bolton analysis measured in laser scanned digital models compared with plaster models (gold standard) and cone-beam computer tomography images
1
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objective: The aim of this study was to compare the accuracy of Bolton analysis obtained from digital models scanned with the Ortho Insight three-dimensional (3D) laser scanner system to those obtained from cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) images and traditional plaster models. Methods: CBCT scans and plaster models were obtained from 50 patients. Plaster models were scanned using the Ortho Insight 3D laser scanner; Bolton ratios were calculated with its software. CBCT scans were imported and analyzed using AVIZO software. Plaster models were measured with a digital caliper. Data were analyzed with descriptive statistics and the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). Results: Anterior and overall Bolton ratios obtained by the three different modalities exhibited excellent agreement (> 0.970). The mean differences between the scanned digital models and physical models and between the CBCT images and scanned digital models for overall Bolton ratios were 0.41 ± 0.305% and 0.45 ± 0.456%, respectively; for anterior Bolton ratios, 0.59 ± 0.520% and 1.01 ± 0.780%, respectively. ICC results showed that intraexaminer error reliability was generally excellent (> 0.858 for all three diagnostic modalities), with < 1.45% discrepancy in the Bolton analysis. Conclusions: Laser scanned digital models are highly accurate compared to physical models and CBCT scans for assessing the spatial relationships of dental arches for orthodontic diagnosis.[Korean J Orthod 2016;46(1):13-19]
Abstract
Objective: The aim of this study was to compare the accuracy of Bolton analysis obtained from digital models scanned with the Ortho Insight three-dimensional (3D) laser scanner system to those obtained from cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) images and traditional plaster models. Methods: CBCT scans and plaster models were obtained from 50 patients. Plaster models were scanned using the Ortho Insight 3D laser scanner; Bolton ratios were calculated with its software. CBCT scans were imported and analyzed using AVIZO software. Plaster models were measured with a digital caliper. Data were analyzed with descriptive statistics and the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). Results: Anterior and overall Bolton ratios obtained by the three different modalities exhibited excellent agreement (> 0.970). The mean differences between the scanned digital models and physical models and between the CBCT images and scanned digital models for overall Bolton ratios were 0.41 ± 0.305% and 0.45 ± 0.456%, respectively; for anterior Bolton ratios, 0.59 ± 0.520% and 1.01 ± 0.780%, respectively. ICC results showed that intraexaminer error reliability was generally excellent (> 0.858 for all three diagnostic modalities), with < 1.45% discrepancy in the Bolton analysis. Conclusions: Laser scanned digital models are highly accurate compared to physical models and CBCT scans for assessing the spatial relationships of dental arches for orthodontic diagnosis.[Korean J Orthod 2016;46(1):13-19]
참고문헌 (22)
- Wedrychowska-Szulc B, "Overall and anterior Bolton ratio in Class I, II, and III orthodontic patients", Eur J Orthod, 32, pp.313~318 (2010)
- Bolton WA, "Disharmony in tooth size and its relation to the analysis and treatment of malocclusion", Angle Orthod, 28, pp.113~130 (1958)
- Bolton WA, "The clinical use of a tooth size analysis", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 48, pp.504~529 (1962)
- Othman SA, "Tooth-size discrepancy and Bolton's ratios: a literature review", J Orthod, 33, pp.45~51 (2006)
- Sousa MV, "Accuracy and reproducibility of 3-dimensional digital model measurements", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 142, pp.269~273 (2012)
- Quimby ML, "The accuracy and reliability of measurements made on computer-based digital models", Angle Orthod, 74, pp.298~303 (2004)
- Mah JK, "Practical applications of cone-beam computed tomography in orthodontics", J Am Dent Assoc, 141(Suppl 3), pp.7S~13S (2010)
- Lagravère MO, "Three-dimensional accuracy of measurements made with software on cone-beam computed tomography images", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 134, pp.112~116 (2008)
- Akyalcin S, "Comparison of 3-dimensional dental models from different sources: diagnostic accuracy and surface registration analysis", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 144, pp.831~837 (2013)
- Flügge TV, "Precision of intraoral digital dental impressions with iTero and extraoral digitization with the iTero and a model scanner", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 144, pp.471~478 (2013)
- El-Zanaty HM, "Three-dimensional dental measurements: An alternative to plaster models", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 137, pp.259~265 (2010)
- Kim J, "Accuracy of laserscanned models compared to plaster models and cone-beam computed tomography", Angle Orthod, 84, pp.443~450 (2014)
- Whetten JL, "Variations in orthodontic treatment planning decisions of Class II patients between virtual 3-dimensional models and traditional plaster study models", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 130, pp.485~491 (2006)
- Fleming PS, "Orthodontic measurements on digital study models compared with plaster models: a systematic review", Orthod Craniofac Res, 14, pp.1~16 (2011)
- Naidu D, "Validity, reliability, and reproducibility of the iOC intraoral scanner: a comparison of tooth widths and Bolton ratios", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 144, pp.304~310 (2013)
- Wiranto MG, "Validity, reliability, and reproducibility of linear measurements on digital models obtained from intraoral and cone-beam computed tomography scans of alginate impressions", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 143, pp.140~147 (2013)
- Proffit WR, "Contemporary orthodontics", pp.170~ (2000), Mosby
- Roberts CT, "The design and analysis of reliability studies for the use of epidemiological and audit indices in orthodontics", Br J Orthod, 24, pp.139~147 (1997)
- Shellhart WC, "Reliability of the Bolton tooth-size analysis when applied to crowded dentitions", Angle Orthod, 65, pp.327~334 (1995)
- Zilberman O, "Evaluation of the validity of tooth size and arch width measurements using conventional and three-dimensional virtual orthodontic models", Angle Orthod, 73, pp.301~306 (2003)
- Nalcaci R, "Comparison of Bolton analysis and tooth size measurements obtained using conventional and three-dimensional orthodontic models", Eur J Dent, 7(Suppl 1), pp.S66~S70 (2013)
- Kau CH, "Evaluation of CBCT digital models and traditional models using the Little's Index", Angle Orthod, 80, pp.435~439 (2010)