Verification of a computer-aided replica technique for evaluating prosthesis adaptation using statistical agreement analysis
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
PURPOSE. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the reliability of computer-aided replica technique (CART) by calculating its agreement with the replica technique (RT), using statistical agreement analysis. MATERIALS AND METHODS. A prepared metal die and a metal crown were fabricated. The gap between the restoration and abutment was replicated using silicone indicator paste (n = 25). Gap measurements differed in the control (RT) and experimental (CART) groups. In the RT group, the silicone replica was manually sectioned, and the marginal and occlusal gaps were measured using a microscope. In the CART group, the gap was digitized using optical scanning and image superimposition, and the gaps were measured using a software program. The agreement between the measurement techniques was evaluated by using the 95% Bland-Altman limits of agreement and concordance correlation coefficients (CCC). The least acceptable CCC was 0.90. RESULTS. The RT and CART groups showed linear association, with a strong positive correlation in gap measurements, but without significant differences. The 95% limits of agreement between the paired gap measurements were 3.84% and 7.08% of the mean. The lower 95% confidence limits of CCC were 0.9676 and 0.9188 for the marginal and occlusal gap measurements, respectively, and the values were greater than the allowed limit. CONCLUSION. The CART is a reliable digital approach for evaluating the fit accuracy of fixed dental prostheses.
Abstract
PURPOSE. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the reliability of computer-aided replica technique (CART) by calculating its agreement with the replica technique (RT), using statistical agreement analysis. MATERIALS AND METHODS. A prepared metal die and a metal crown were fabricated. The gap between the restoration and abutment was replicated using silicone indicator paste (n = 25). Gap measurements differed in the control (RT) and experimental (CART) groups. In the RT group, the silicone replica was manually sectioned, and the marginal and occlusal gaps were measured using a microscope. In the CART group, the gap was digitized using optical scanning and image superimposition, and the gaps were measured using a software program. The agreement between the measurement techniques was evaluated by using the 95% Bland-Altman limits of agreement and concordance correlation coefficients (CCC). The least acceptable CCC was 0.90. RESULTS. The RT and CART groups showed linear association, with a strong positive correlation in gap measurements, but without significant differences. The 95% limits of agreement between the paired gap measurements were 3.84% and 7.08% of the mean. The lower 95% confidence limits of CCC were 0.9676 and 0.9188 for the marginal and occlusal gap measurements, respectively, and the values were greater than the allowed limit. CONCLUSION. The CART is a reliable digital approach for evaluating the fit accuracy of fixed dental prostheses.
참고문헌 (28)
- Holmes JR, "Considerations in measurement of marginal fit", J Prosthet Dent, 62, pp.405~408 (1989)
- Pimenta MA, "Evaluation of marginal and internal fit of ceramic and metallic crown copings using x-ray microtomography (micro-CT) technology", J Prosthet Dent, 114, pp.223~228 (2015)
- Contrepois M, "Marginal adaptation of ceramic crowns: a systematic review", J Prosthet Dent, 110, pp.447~454 (2013)
- Boitelle P, "A systematic review of CAD", CAM fit restoration evaluations, 2014, pp.41, 853~874
- Kianoosh Torabi, "The effect of various veneering techniques on the marginal fit of zirconia copings", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 7(3), pp.233~239 (2015), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- 지민경, "Evaluation of marginal fit of 2 CAD-CAM anatomic contour zirconia crown systems and lithium disilicate glass-ceramic crown", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 7(4), pp.271~277 (2015), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- Bugurman Burcu Bugurman, "Clinical gap changes after porcelain firing cycles of zirconia fixed dentures", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 6(3), pp.177~184 (2014), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- 이완선, "Evaluation of different approaches for using a laser scanner in digitization of dental impressions", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 6(1), pp.22~29 (2014), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- Falk A, "Reliability of the impression replica technique", Int J Prosthodont, 28, pp.179~180 (2015)
- Laurent M, "Clinical evaluation of the marginal fit of cast crowns-validation of the silicone replica method", J Oral Rehabil, 35, pp.116~122 (2008)
- Rahme HY, "In vitro evaluation of the "replica technique" in the measurement of the fit of Procera crowns", J Contemp Dent Pract, 9, pp.25~32 (2008)
- Coli P, "Fit of a new pressure-sintered zirconium dioxide coping", Int J Prosthodont, 17, pp.59~64 (2004)
- Chan DC, "The effect of sprue design on the marginal accuracy of titanium castings", J Oral Rehabil, 25, pp.424~429 (1998)
- Kim KB, "Three-dimensional evaluation of gaps associated with fixed dental prostheses fabricated with new technologies", J Prosthet Dent, 112, pp.1432~1436 (2014)
- Lee DH, "Digital approach to assessing the 3-dimensional misfit of fixed dental prostheses", J Prosthet Dent, 116, pp.836~839 (2016)
- Lin L, "Statistical methods in assessing agreement: Models, issues, and tools", J Am Stat Assoc, 97, pp.257~270 (2002)
- Barnhart HX, "Overall concordance correlation coefficient for evaluating agreement among multiple observers", Biometrics, 58, pp.1020~1027 (2002)
- Watson PF, "Method agreement analysis: a review of correct methodology", Theriogenology, 73, pp.1167~1179 (2010)
- Lin LI, "A concordance correlation coefficient to evaluate reproducibility", Biometrics, 45, pp.255~268 (1989)
- King TS, "A class of repeated measures concordance correlation coefficients", J Biopharm Stat, 17, pp.653~672 (2007)
- Lawrence I, "Assay validation using the concordance correlation coefficient", Biometrics, 48, pp.599~604 (1992)
- Cerna M, "Validity and reliability of the T-Scan(®) III for measuring force under laboratory conditions", J Oral Rehabil, 42, pp.544~551 (2015)
- King TS, "Robust estimators of the concordance correlation coefficient", J Biopharm Stat, 11, pp.83~105 (2001)
- Vonesh EF, "Goodness-of-fit in generalized nonlinear mixed-effects models", Biometrics, 52, pp.572~587 (1996)
- Lopez-Suarez C, "Marginal vertical discrepancies of monolithic and veneered zirconia and metal-ceramic three-unit posterior fixed dental prostheses", Int J Prosthodont, 29, pp.256~258 (2016)
- Kokubo Y, "Clinical marginal and internal gaps of In-Ceram crowns fabricated using the GN-I system", J Oral Rehabil, 32, pp.753~758 (2005)
- Giavarina D, "Understanding bland altman analysis", Biochem Med (Zagreb), 25, pp.141~151 (2015)
- 이예규, "Comparison of intraoral scanning and conventional impression techniques using 3-dimensional superimposition", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 7(6), pp.460~467 (2015), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]