“属国”意识与晚清对朝政策之转型研究
The Consciousness of “Vassal” and The Transformation of the Late Qing Dynasty’s Policies for Korea
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
19世纪中后期,以中国为中心的传统朝贡体系因受外部冲击而逐渐呈现动摇之势,中朝之间的宗藩关系也随之进入到一个关键的转型期。1879年以前,清总理各国事务衙门在致欧美各国的照覆中,一直坚持中朝宗藩关系是“属国自主”关系。这种关系是清政府在面对内外压力时采取的一种外交策略,总理衙门试图通过对外强调属国的自主性来维持在朝鲜的宗主国地位,同时以此避免与西方列强产生直接冲突。然而,这种“属国自主”的宗藩观念自1879年日本吞并琉球后,开始发生转变。晚清官员们围绕当时的东亚时局和中朝之间的宗属关系进行过多次讨论,并孕育出“属国≠自主”的论调,他们对朝鲜的定位开始带上了西方公法的色彩。此后,清政府的对朝政策逐渐从传统的宗藩关系转变为以近代条约体系为导向,宗藩概念中的“属国”意识也开始具有日益浓厚的公法色彩。
Abstract
In the middle to late 19th century, the traditional tributary system centered around China began to show signs of instability due to external pressures, and the suzerain vassal relationship between China and Korea also entered a crucial transitional period. Prior to 1879, the Zongli Yamen always consistently maintained in its correspondence with foreign countries that the suzerain-vassal relations between Modern China and Korea was “vassal but autonomous” relationship. However, this concept of “vassal autonomous” began to change after Japan annexed Ryukyu in 1879. Officials of the late Qing Dynasty represented by He Ruzhang, engaged in multiple discussions about the East Asian situation and the suzerain-vassal relationship between Qing and Korea, and gave birth to the argument that “vassal≠autonomy”, and their positioning of the Korea began to take on the color of Elements International Law. Subsequently, the Qing government’s policy towards Korea gradually shifted from the traditional suzerain-vassal relationship to the modern treaty system, and public law in the “vassal state” is increasingly strong.
참고문헌 (19)
- 陈铮, "黄遵宪全集(上)" (2005), 中华书局
- 顾廷龙, "李鸿章全集" (2008), 安徽教育出版社
- 郭廷以, "清季中日韩关系史料" (1972), 中央研究院近代史研究所
- 王彥威, "清季外交史料(卷二十三)" (2015), 湖南师范大学出版社
- 中国历史研究社, "东行三录" (1982), 上海书店
- "清光绪朝中日交涉史料", 故宫博物院, ~ (1932)
- "筹办夷务始末,第五册(同治朝)" (2008), 中华书局
- "日本外交文书,第二册(韩国篇)" (1980), 泰东文化社
- 冈本隆司, "属国与自主之间:近代中朝关系与东亚的命运" (2012), 生活·读书·新知三联书店
- 费正清, "中国的世界秩序" (2010), 中国社会科学出版社
- 惠顿, "万国公法" (2003), 中国政法大学出版社
- 김재선, "李鸿章의 对外政策硏究 - 朝鲜属国名分论을 중심으로", 동국사학, 53 (2012), 동국역사문화연구소
- 신승하, "조선의 문호개방과 마건충의 역할", 아세아연구, 32 (1989), 고려대학교 아세아문제연구원
- 유바다, "1882년 조약・장정의 체결과 속국(属国)·반주지국(半主之国) 조선의 국제법적 지위", 역사와 현실, 99 (2016), 한국역사연구회
- 高磊, "马建忠与近代早期朝鲜地缘政治争端", 外国问题研究 (2020), 东北师范大学
- 金凤珍, "「朝鲜=属国」论考", 社会システム研究, 5 (2007), 北九州市立大学大学院社会システム研究科
- 权赫秀, "晚清对外关系中的‘一个外交两种体制’现象刍议", 中国边疆史地研究 (2009), 中国社会科学院中国边疆研究所
- 赵立新, "民族主义与东亚的‘分裂’", 中国学, 43 (2021), 大韩中国学会
- 张礼恒, "近代中朝关系的现代性转换——论李鸿章的‘不沾不脱’原则", 清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版) (2017), 清华大学
