자본주의 다양성 이론의 변화 양상과 함의
The Evolution and Implications of Capitalist Diversity Theory
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
본 연구는 자본주의 다양성 이론의 변화양상을 문헌고찰을 통해 진단하고자 한다. 국내·외 2001년부터 2020년까지 총 189개의 문헌을 선정하고 세부주제는 ‘국가유형 분류’, ‘제도적 상호보완성과 제도변화’, ‘노동시장과 숙련’, ‘경제성장과 혁신’으로 구분하였다. 분석 결과, 국가 유형화 연구들은 동유럽과 아시아 국가까지 확장되었으며 재정위기에 대한 국가별 대응, 정치적 역동성에 중점을 두었다. 제도적 상호보완성 관련 논의들은 제도적 균열과 변화에 집중하며 특정한 조건이나 지역에 따라 서로 다르게 변화하는 양상을 진단하였다. 노동시장과 숙련의 측면에서는 CME 국가들을 중심으로 조정(coordination)에 관한 다양한 해석과 숙련형성 매커니즘에 관한 비판이 제기되었다. 마지막으로 경제와 혁신 관련 논의에서는 다국적 기업의 출현과 사회적 책임 등 다양한 이슈를 포함하려는 움직임이 존재하였다. 이러한 연구 결과는 자본주의 다양성 이론에 대한 비판적 성찰을 통한 이론적·정책적 논의가 보다 성숙되어야 함을 시사하였다.
Abstract
This study aims to diagnose the evolving patterns of diversity in capitalist theories through a literature review. A total of 189 documents were selected from both domestic and international sources spanning from 2001 to 2020, with detailed topics categorized into 'national typology classification,' 'institutional complementarity and institutional change,' 'labor market and skill,' and 'economic growth and innovation.' The analysis results indicate that studies on national typology have expanded to include Eastern European and Asian countries, with a focus on how different nations respond to financial crises and political dynamics. Discussions related to institutional complementarity concentrate on institutional ruptures and changes, diagnosing patterns that vary according to specific conditions or regions. Regarding labor markets and skills, criticisms of and issues related to coordination, particularly focusing on CME countries, have been raised. Lastly, discussions on economics and innovation included movements to encompass various issues such as the emergence of multinational corporations and social responsibility. These findings suggest that theoretical and policy discussions on the diversity of capitalist theories should mature through critical reflection.
참고문헌 (76)
- 김영미, "자본주의 다양성 관점에서 본 젠더와 계급의 교차성", 한국여성학, 26(3), pp.65~89 (2010), 한국여성학회
- 남재욱, "한국에서 ‘좋은’ 시간제 일자리는 가능한가?", 한국사회정책, 27(1), pp.187~211 (2020), 한국사회정책학회[DOI]
- 안형식, "체계적 고찰 연구의 개요", 대한의사협회지, 57(1), pp.49~59 (2014), 대한의사협회[DOI]
- 정무권, "최근 비교정책연구의 동향과 쟁점-생산레짐 이론과 자본주의 체제의 다양성", 한국정책학회 추계학술발표논문집, pp.199~221 (2004)
- 조성훈, "자본주의 다양성 논의의 비판적 검증: 한국형 시장경제의 특질을 중심으로", 응용경제, 18(1), pp.79~108 (2016), 한국응용경제학회
- 하연섭, "신제도주의의 이론적 진화와 정책연구", 행정논총, 44(2), pp.217~246 (2006), 한국행정연구소
- Aguirre, J. L., "Argentinian Variety of Capitalism in Comparative Perspective", Ph. D, pp.2014
- Transitional institutions, institutional complementarities and economic performance in China: A'Varieties of Capitalism' approach, "Ahrens, J.", ~, pp.No. 2010-11 (2010)
- Akkermans, D., "Do ‘liberal market economies’ really innovate more radically than ‘coordinated market economies’?: Hall and Soskice reconsidered", Research Policy, 38(1), pp.181~191 (2009)
- Allen, M., "The varieties of capitalism paradigm: not enough variety?", Socio-Economic Review, 2(1), pp.87~108 (2004)
- Amable, B., "Institutional complementarities in the dynamic comparative analysis of capitalism", Journal of Institutional Economics, 12(1), pp.79~103 (2016)
- The Diversity of Social Systems of Innovation and Production during the 1990s, "Amable, B.", Cepremap, ~, pp.N 2001-15 (2001)
- Amberg, S., "Liberal market economy or composite regime? Institutional legacies and labor market policy in the United States", Polity, 40(2), pp.164~196 (2008)
- Anderson, K. M., "The political economy of the service transition", pp.171~194 (2013), Oxford Univ. Press
- Bell, D. A., "East Asian capitalism: Towards a normative framework", Global Economic Review, 30(3), pp.73~89 (2001)
- Benner, M., "The bio-economy and the competition state: transcending the dichotomy between coordinated and liberal market economies", New Political Science, 29(1), pp.77~95 (2007)
- Benney, T. M., "Varieties of capitalism and renewable energy in emerging and developing economies", Journal of Economic Policy Reform, pp.1~26 (2019)
- Boyer, R., "How and why capitalisms differ", Economy and society, 34(4), pp.509~557 (2005)
- Bruff, I., "European varieties of capitalism and the international", European Journal of International Relations, 16(4), pp.615~638 (2010)
- Busemeyer, M. R., "Asset specificity, institutional complementarities and the variety of skill regimes in coordinated market economies", Socio-Economic Review, 7(3), pp.375~406 (2009)
- Campbell, J. L., "Institutional Competitiveness: A broad Perspective on the Danish Case", Social Cohesion and Competitiveness. Conference Presentation Paper (2006)
- Carney, R., "Varieties of capitalism in France: interests, institutions, and finance", French Politics, 4(1), pp.1~ (2006)
- Deducing Varieties of Capitalism, "Carney, R.", MPRA, ~, pp.MPRA Paper. No.5145 (2007)
- Casey, T., "Comparative Disadvantage: Models of Capitalism and Economic Performance in the Global Era", Political Studies Association Conference (2004)
- Casper, S., "Patterns of Innovation and Varieties of Capitalism: Explaining the Development of High-Technology Entrepreneurialism in Europe", Final Conference of ESSY (European Sectoral Systems of Innovation) research network (2001)
- Christopherson, S., "Why do national labor market practices continue to diverge in the global economy? The ‘missing link’ of investment rules", Economic Geography, 78(1), pp.1~20 (2002)
- Clifton, N., "Creative knowledge workers across ‘varieties of capitalism’: Evidence from Sweden and the UK", ~ (2010)
- Cognard, E., "Varieties of capitalism and financial cooperation between employers: The initial and continuous vocational training in comparison", European Journal of Industrial Relations, 17(1), pp.25~40 (2011)
- Content, J., "Does related variety foster regional entrepreneurship? Evidence from European regions", Regional Studies, 53(11), pp.1531~1543 (2019)
- Crouch, C., "The oxford handbook of comparative institutional analysis", pp.117~137 (2010), Oxford University Press
- Crowley, S., "East European Labour, the Varieties of Capitalism, and the Expansion of the EU", annual meeting of the American Political Science Association (2005)
- Culpepper, P. D., "Small states and skill specificity: Austria, Switzerland, and interemployer cleavages in coordinated capitalism", Comparative Political Studies, 40(6), pp.611~637 (2007)
- Deeg, R., "Complementarity and institutional change in capitalist systems", Journal of European Public Policy, 14(4), pp.611~630 (2007)
- Edlund, J., "Protection of mutual interests? Employment protection and skill formation in different labour market regimes", European Journal of Industrial Relations, 14(3), pp.245~264 (2008)
- Esken, B., "Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility in the Varieties of Capitalism Framework–A Need for Multinational Corporations to Adapt to Different National Institutional Contexts?", Ph. D, pp.2014
- Estévez-Abe, M., "Labor markets, public policies and gender equality: The varieties of capitalism perspective and beyond", Harvard University, ~ (2001)
- Estevez-Abe, M., "Gender, inequality, and capitalism: The ‘varieties of capitalism’ and women", Social Politics, 16(2), pp.182~191 (2009)
- Fast, T., "Varieties of Capitalism: A Critique", Relations Industrielles, 2016, pp.71(1), 133~155
- Folbre, N., "Varieties of patriarchal capitalism", Social Politics, 16(2), pp.204~209 (2009)
- Gould, A., "Varieties of capitalism revisited: current debates and possible directions", Les varietes du capitalisme revisitees: debats actuels et avenues possibles, Industrial Relations, pp.2015, 70(4)[DOI]
- Hall, P. A., "Varieties of capitalism and the Euro crisis", West European Politics, 37(6), pp.1223~1243 (2014)
- Varieties of capitalism and institutional complementarities in the macroeconomy: an empirical analysis, "Hall, P. A.", Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies, ~ (2004)
- Hall, P. A., "Varieties of capitalism and institutional change: A response to three critics", Comparative European Politics, 1(2), pp.241~250 (2003)
- Hall, P. A., "Varieties of capitalism: The institutional foundations of comparative advantage" (2001), OUP
- Hall, P. A., "Institutional change in varieties of capitalism", Socio-economic review, 7(1), pp.7~34 (2009)
- Herrigel, G., "Alternatives to varieties of capitalism", The Business History Review, 84(4), pp.667~674 (2010)
- Hiscox, M. J., "Birds of a different feather? Varieties of capitalism, factor specificity, and inter industry labor movements", Harvard University, ~ (2002)
- Howell, C., "Varieties of capitalism: and then there was one?", Comparative politics, pp.103~124 (2003)
- Analysing ‘system change’: The role of institutional complementarity in corporate governance, "Kang, N.", Global Development Institute. The University of Manchester, ~ (2006)
- Kannankulam, J., "Varieties of capitalism or varieties of relationships of forces? Outlines of a historical materialist policy analysis", Capital & Class, 38(1), pp.59~71 (2014)
- Challenging varieties of capitalism's account of business interests: The new social market initiative and German employers' quest for liberalization, "Kinderman, D.", Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies, ~ (2014)
- Klimplová, L., "The Czech Republic from the perspective of the varieties of capitalism approach", Contemporary European Studies, (02), pp.49~74 (2007)
- Knell, M., "Emerging varieties of capitalism in Central and Eastern Europe", Proceedings from the Varieties of Capitalism Conference (2005)
- Kohl, S., "Varieties of agrarian capitalism: Towards a comparative analysis of rural economies", Economic Sociology: The European Electronic Newsletter, 18(3), pp.19~31 (2017)
- Varieties of liberalism: Anglo-Saxon capitalism incrisis?, "Konzelmann, S. J.", Centre for Business Research, University of Cambridge, ~ (2010)
- Lam, A., "Alternative societal models of learning and innovation in the knowledge economy", International Social Science Journal, 54(171), pp.67~82 (2002)
- Lauder, H., "Globalisation, skill formation and the varieties of capitalism approach", New Political Economy, 13(1), pp.19~35 (2008)
- The motherhood wage penalty: A varieties of capitalism approach, "Lundquist, E.", Luxembourg Income Study, ~ (2017)
- Mahoney, James, "Explaining Institutional Change: Ambiguity, Agency and Power" (2010), Cambridge University Press
- Mandel, H., "Gender, class, and varieties of capitalism", Social Politics, 16(2), pp.161~181 (2009)
- Nelson, M., "Labor Mobility and the Varieties of Capitalism", ESPAnet Conference, pp.20~22 (2007)
- Nolke, A., "Enlarging the varieties of capitalism: The emergence of dependent market economies in East Central Europe", World Pol, 61, pp.670~ (2009)
- Novikova, J., "How Institutional Framework Affects the Formation of Capitalism in Countries in Transition: Following the Path or Finding New Ways?", Master, pp.2003
- Varieties of capitalism, quality of government, and policy conditionality in Southern Europe: Greece and Portugal in comparative perspective, "Paraskevopoulos, C. J.", Hellenic Observatory, ~ (2017)
- Pennings, P., "The diversity of welfare state reforms explored with fuzzy sets", ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshops, pp.22~27 (2002)
- Schmidt, V., "French capitalism transformed, yet still a third variety of capitalism", Economy and society, 32(4), pp.526~554 (2003)
- Streeck, Wolfgang, "Beyond Continuity" (2005), Oxford University Press
- Streek, Wolfgang, "Reforming Capitalism: Institutional Change in the German Political Economy" (2009), Oxford University Press
- Taylor, M. Z., "Empirical evidence against varieties of capitalism's theory of technological innovation", International Organization, 58(3), pp.601~631 (2004)
- Thelen, K., "The paradox of globalization: Labor relations in Germany and beyond", Comparative political studies, 36(8), pp.859~880 (2003)
- Thelen, K., "Varieties of capitalism: Trajectories of liberalization and the new politics of social solidarity", Annual Review of Political Science, 15, pp.137~159 (2012)
- Wilkins, M., "Multinational enterprises and the varieties of capitalism", The Business History Review, 84(4), pp.638~645 (2010)
- China: what variety of capitalism?, "Witt, M. A.", INSEAD, ~ (2010)
- Wöhl, S., "The state and gender relations in international political economy: A state-theoretical approach to varieties of capitalism in crisis", Capital & Class, 38(1), pp.87~99 (2014)
- Wueest, B., "Varieties of capitalist debates: How institutions shape public conflicts on economic liberalization in the United Kingdom", Germany and France. Comparative European Politics, 11(6), pp.752~772 (2013)
- Yoo, T., "In search of social capital in state-activist capitalism: Elite networks in France and Korea", Organization Studies, 30(5), pp.529~547 (2009)
