‘합리적 행위자 이론’의 북한 적용을 위한 대안적 접근법
Alternative Approach of ‘The Rational Actor Theory’ in North Korea Leader’s Behavior
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Until now, `The rational actor theory` has been recognized as a very useful tool for interpreting international politics. At the same time, however, it has also been a subject of numerous academic controversies. The heart of debates is whether the actor's behavior can be objectified amid a lack of information about the actor's `rational reference point`. This raises questions about whether it is appropriate to use 'The rational actor theory' as a tool to interpret North Korea's political decisions. This is because there is very little information on the `reference point` of North Korean policy-makers. Whether it is right to adopt the `The rational actor theory` as a tool to interpret North Korean policies with the little information, and how to supplement the problem of lack of information, if adopted, is an important task for researchers. After considering the problems pointed out above, it comes to the conclusion that it is reasonable to interpret their actions from the perspective of North Korean(internal actors) if they can have an objective explanation of the North's reference point. In this study, the views of both the inside and the outside are tried to be applied step by step in order to overcome the limits of the `The rational actor theory`. When finding out the key policy-makers, the final objectives and goals, and the process of achieving goals, which are the main factors in forming 'The rational actor theory', internal actors' perspectives will be applied, and restrictions in the process of achieving the goal will be analyzed from the perspective of an external analyst. When the above analysis method is applied to the North Korean case, it can be inferred that Kim Jong-Un will set goals and act between the best and the lesser worst cases because he is a rational actor concentrated on interested in `Regime interest`. and His best goal is to secure regime interest without internal and external security threats, and the lesser worst is to secure only short-term regime stability with security threats. therefore, he will set a goal somewhere between these two options, and aim for the best.
Abstract
Until now, `The rational actor theory` has been recognized as a very useful tool for interpreting international politics. At the same time, however, it has also been a subject of numerous academic controversies. The heart of debates is whether the actor's behavior can be objectified amid a lack of information about the actor's `rational reference point`. This raises questions about whether it is appropriate to use 'The rational actor theory' as a tool to interpret North Korea's political decisions. This is because there is very little information on the `reference point` of North Korean policy-makers. Whether it is right to adopt the `The rational actor theory` as a tool to interpret North Korean policies with the little information, and how to supplement the problem of lack of information, if adopted, is an important task for researchers. After considering the problems pointed out above, it comes to the conclusion that it is reasonable to interpret their actions from the perspective of North Korean(internal actors) if they can have an objective explanation of the North's reference point. In this study, the views of both the inside and the outside are tried to be applied step by step in order to overcome the limits of the `The rational actor theory`. When finding out the key policy-makers, the final objectives and goals, and the process of achieving goals, which are the main factors in forming 'The rational actor theory', internal actors' perspectives will be applied, and restrictions in the process of achieving the goal will be analyzed from the perspective of an external analyst. When the above analysis method is applied to the North Korean case, it can be inferred that Kim Jong-Un will set goals and act between the best and the lesser worst cases because he is a rational actor concentrated on interested in `Regime interest`. and His best goal is to secure regime interest without internal and external security threats, and the lesser worst is to secure only short-term regime stability with security threats. therefore, he will set a goal somewhere between these two options, and aim for the best.
참고문헌 (38)
- 리 소테츠, "김정은 체제 왜 붕괴되지 않는가" (2017), 레드우드
- 박상현, "북한 대외정책의 합리성에 관한 고찰:약소국의 전략적 상호작용과 인지심리학적 함의를 중심으로", 통일정책연구, 18(1), pp.33~61 (2009), 통일연구원
- 박휘락, "정책의 합리성과 북한 이해의 함정", 전략논단 (2007)
- 박지연, "경제제재에 대한 북한의 의사결정 요인 분석: 전망이론 모델의 구축과 적용", 북한연구학회보, 17(1), pp.57~92 (2013), 북한연구학회
- 유동열, "북한 정보기구의 변천과 현황", 국가정보연구, 11(1), pp.153~187 (2018), 한국국가정보학회
- 이종석, "김정일 정권의 위기관리 방식: 대내적 측면", 경남대 극동문제 연구소, 19 (2000), 북한연구시리즈
- 정준표, "합리적 선택이론에 있어서 합리성의 개념", 대한정치학회보, 11(2), pp.415~439 (2003), 대한정치학회
- 최진, "대통령리더십과 국정운영스타일의 심리학적 상관관계-한국의역대 대통령 비교분석", 한국정책연구, 5(1) (2005)
- 태영호, "외교안보정책관료조직", 한반도 미래포럼 제54차 월례토론회 (2018)
- 태영호, "3층 서기실의 암호" (2018), 기파랑
- 현상진, "조선 변혁기 주요 인물의 리더십 연구 : 에니어그램 이론을중심으로", 석사, pp.2017
- 북한의 핵·미사일 대응책 연구, "홍우택", 통일연구원, ~ (2013)
- Allison, G., "결정의 본질: 누가 어떻게 국가의 운명을 결정짓는가?" (2018), 모던아카이브
- Solow, R., "A Contribution to the Theory of Economic Growth", The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 70(1) (1956)
- "北 인민반장 다 모아놓고 총리가 화폐개혁 사과" (2010)[URL]
- "북한이 NK경제 북한 블록체인 기사를 보고 갔다" (2019)[URL]
- "북한이 NK경제 북한 블록체인 기사를 보고 갔다" (2019)[URL]
- "북한 2019년 6월 어떤 키워드로 검색했을까?" (2019)[URL]
- "지난 7월 '메인프레임', '스타트업' 검색한 북한" (2019)[URL]
- "북한 8월 '빗썸', '양자컴퓨터', '강진규' 등으로 검색" (2019)[URL]
- "북한 2019년 9월 '가상현실', '빅데이터', '교육용로봇'으로 검색" (2019)[URL]
- "북한 10월 '북한 경제', '경제특구' 등으로 검색" (2019)[URL]
- "2019년 11월 북한 '북한해커'로 검색" (2019)[URL]
- "“NYT ‘北 인터넷 사용량 3년새 300% 증가, 사용목적은…’" (2020)[URL]
- 김정은, "당 중앙위 책임 일군들과의 담화", ~ (2012)
- 김정은, "김일성 탄생 100주년 대중연설", ~ (2012)
- 김정은, "당 중앙위 전원회의 연설", ~ (2013)
- 김정은, "당 창건 70주년 열병식 및 평양시 군중시위 연설", ~ (2015)
- 김정은, "7차 당대회 중앙위 사업총화 연설", ~ (2016)
- 김정은, "전국 초급당위원장 대회 연설", ~ (2016)
- 김정은, "조선소년단 8차대회 연설", ~ (2016)
- 김정은, "2017년 신년사 발표", ~ (2017)
- 김정은, "당 7기 3차 전원회의 시 연설" (2018)
- 김정은, "당 중앙위 7기 4차 전원회의 시 연설", ~ (2019)
- 김정은, "최고인민회의 14기 1차 회의 시정 연설", ~ (2019)
- 김정은, "2019년 신년사 발표", ~ (2019)
- 백남룡, "야전열차" (2017), 북한 문학예술출판사
- 재일본조선사회과학자협회, "21세기의 태양 김정은 원수님", ~ (2018)
