이미지와 실재에 대한 문제 고찰 -'성상논쟁'을 중심으로-
Examination of the issues of the Image and the Real - Focusing on Major 'Icon Controversy -
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The aim of this study is to re-examine discussions of image and the real in the process of restructuring the history of icon controversy, which can be called a root that stimulated changes in Western culture and arts history. The history of Western ideas from the birth of Greek philosophy until today, in short, is a history of battle between what is tangible (image) and intangible (the real). Examination of the two different views that are for the impossibility of the image of God, and the possibility of the image of God, cannot remain in a religious dimension embryology, but inevitably produces ideological discussions on the mage and the real. The discussion includes the subjective value judgments of the group that establishes the public opinion, and homogeneous meanings that are reached in the repetition of public opinion. Through the process of examining problems of the idea of image and the real derived from icon controversy, from iconoclasm under Leo III who brought about a great change to the East Roman Empire and Europe as a whole, to the religious reform of the sixteenth century which was the peak of icon controversy, and examining overlapping discussions, the results of this study discovered basics of new metaphysics from the perspective of Luther. His statements of ‘freedom’and ‘transcendence’ which appear to be his cohesive direction present a discussion of tolerance and combination that newly interprets reality, and a discussion of reconciliation.
Abstract
The aim of this study is to re-examine discussions of image and the real in the process of restructuring the history of icon controversy, which can be called a root that stimulated changes in Western culture and arts history. The history of Western ideas from the birth of Greek philosophy until today, in short, is a history of battle between what is tangible (image) and intangible (the real). Examination of the two different views that are for the impossibility of the image of God, and the possibility of the image of God, cannot remain in a religious dimension embryology, but inevitably produces ideological discussions on the mage and the real. The discussion includes the subjective value judgments of the group that establishes the public opinion, and homogeneous meanings that are reached in the repetition of public opinion. Through the process of examining problems of the idea of image and the real derived from icon controversy, from iconoclasm under Leo III who brought about a great change to the East Roman Empire and Europe as a whole, to the religious reform of the sixteenth century which was the peak of icon controversy, and examining overlapping discussions, the results of this study discovered basics of new metaphysics from the perspective of Luther. His statements of ‘freedom’and ‘transcendence’ which appear to be his cohesive direction present a discussion of tolerance and combination that newly interprets reality, and a discussion of reconciliation.
참고문헌 (40)
- 강내희, "재현체계와 근대성: 재현의 탈근대적 배치를 위하여", 문화과학, (겨울) (2000)
- 김수강, "동방교회 성상의 역사적 의미와 현대적 유용성", 석사, pp.2006
- 김정현, "이미지의 현상학 ―「실재와 그림자」를 중심으로 본레비나스의 예술론―", 철학과 현상학 연구, (22), pp.181~194 (2004), 한국현상학회
- 김차규, "레오3세의 성상파괴 논쟁", pp.109~138 (1999), 명지사론
- 김차규, "콘스탄티누스 5세와 성상파괴논쟁", 서양중세사연구, 1999, pp.6~8 (1999)
- 노병균, "칼뱅의 성찬신학에서 본 프로테스탄트 이미지 신학의 가능성", 석사, pp.2008
- 박건택, "기독교 이미지 신학의 역사적 고찰Ⅰ", 신학지남, 74(1) (2007)
- 박찬부, "실재의 상징적 재현과 해석의 문제", 영미어문학, (84), pp.123~142 (2007), 한국영미어문학회
- 박치완, "재현(-파괴) 논쟁과 실재물음", 해석학연구, (18), pp.55~104 (2006), 한국해석학회
- 박평종, "재현의 역설과 한계 -클레망 로세의 현실 개념을 중심으로-", 프랑스학연구, (36), pp.41~60 (2006), 프랑스학회
- 서명수, "기호와 재현: 탈근대주의 기호론을 위한 정초", 기호학 연구, pp.404~431 (1997)
- 손호현, "미학신학을 찾아서: 화이트헤드의 과정신학과 미학" (2007), 연세대학교출판부
- 양승학, "이미지: 성상숭배논쟁과 전자영상매체의 고리", 석사, pp.2000
- 유선호, "칼빈의 성찬론" (1996), 하늘기획
- 윤대선, "예술의 대상 이미지와 실재에 관한 철학적 해석", 해석학연구, (19), pp.241~266 (2007), 한국해석학회
- 윤성우, "들뢰즈: 재현의 문제와 다른 철학자들" (2004), 철학과 현실사
- 이도흠, "현실 개념의 변화와 예술의 재현 문제", 미학예술학연구, 20, pp.241~263 (2004), 한국미학예술학회
- 이도흠, "이미지와 실재의 문제에 대한 고찰: 서구사상의 이미지, 상상, 상상계 개념을 중심으로", 인문연구, pp.249~ (2004)
- 이주영, "시각적 재현에 있어서 유사성과 실재의 관계", 미학예술학연구, 24, pp.259~289 (2006), 한국미학예술학회
- 이창익, "16세기 종교개혁과 성상파괴론", 종교학연구, pp.107~123 (1999)
- 이형기, "종교개혁신학사상: 루터와 칼빈을 중심으로" (1984), 장신대출판부
- 임영방, "중세 미술과 도상" (2008), 서울대대학교출판부
- 주형일, "이미지로서의 육체, 기호로서의 이미지 : 살과 틀의 육체 담론", 인문연구, (47), pp.111~139 (2004), 인문과학연구소
- 진형준, "성상파괴주의와 성상옹호주의" (2003), 살림
- 최용호, "소쉬르와 라캉 : 실재 개념을 중심으로", 불어불문학연구, (47), pp.601~623 (2001), 한국불어불문학회
- 최재호, "비텐베르크 운동과 성상파괴주의", 역사교육, (94), pp.117~150 (2005), 역사교육연구회
- 한철, "이미지, 문자, 권력 - 성상파괴운동에 대한 매체학적 연구", 뷔히너와 현대문학, 34, pp.301~321 (2010), 한국뷔히너학회
- Eire, Calos M. N, "War against the Idol: The Reformation of Worship from Erasmus to Calvin", Cambridge Univ, 26~59 (1986)
- Fink Bruce, "The Lacanian Subject: Between Language and Jouissance" (1995), Princeton UP
- Foucault Michel, "The order of Things: An Archaeology of the Human Sciences" (1970), A Division of Random House Inc
- Gregory Bateson, "Vers une écologie de l’esprit tome 2", pp.208~210 (1980), Seuil
- Jaque Derrida, "La voix et le phénomène", pp.71~72 (1967), Seuil
- Jaroslav Pelikan, "예수의 역사 2000년", pp.157~158 (1999), 동연
- Jean Calvin, "기독교강요" (2008), 크리스챤다이제스트
- John of Damascus, "On holy Images" (1898), Thomas Baker
- Maurice Merleau-Ponty, "Le visible et l’invisible" (1964), Editions Gallimard
- H. T. Lehmann, "Luther’s Work. 55 vol", pp.79~80 (1955), Fortress
- Mitchell, W. J. T, "Iconology: Image, Text" (1987), Chicago UP
- Samuels Robert, "Between Philosophy and Psychoanalysis: Freud’s Reconstruction of Lacan" (1993), Routledge