본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

문학작품의 요약번역에 대한 연구 - 알렉상드르 뒤마의 <삼총사>를 중심으로

A Study on the Abridgement and Adaptation in Literary Translation - Analysis of Translations of Duma's The Three Musketeers

0

조회

0

다운로드

4

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류통역번역학

초록

This study aims to examine the practice of abridged translation in the field of literary translation. As the object of analysis, two different translations of Duma's The Three Musketeers are used, one being a complete translation and the other being an abridged translation. This paper begins with suggesting the reasons of abridgements, based on information found from the publishers' comments and book descriptions, and pointing out the possible problems that the abridgements of a literary text may produce. Then it shows that the act of translation is closely connected with the establishment of certain cultural values in a society and therefore always includes value judgements. In the analysis that follows, it is revealed that in the abridged version of The Three Musketeers the narrative structure is simplified, the personalities of characters are transformed and even distorted, and the motives of the characters are represented quite different from the original text. In a word, the whole structure of Dumas's original text undergoes radical changes and therefore even the nature of the work is transformed. In conclusion, this study points out that abridged translation of a work of literature, despite its good intentions, cannot render the unique flavor and subtle texture of the original to its readers properly, and a careful consideration should be given before the translation/publishing project.

Abstract

This study aims to examine the practice of abridged translation in the field of literary translation. As the object of analysis, two different translations of Duma's The Three Musketeers are used, one being a complete translation and the other being an abridged translation. This paper begins with suggesting the reasons of abridgements, based on information found from the publishers' comments and book descriptions, and pointing out the possible problems that the abridgements of a literary text may produce. Then it shows that the act of translation is closely connected with the establishment of certain cultural values in a society and therefore always includes value judgements. In the analysis that follows, it is revealed that in the abridged version of The Three Musketeers the narrative structure is simplified, the personalities of characters are transformed and even distorted, and the motives of the characters are represented quite different from the original text. In a word, the whole structure of Dumas's original text undergoes radical changes and therefore even the nature of the work is transformed. In conclusion, this study points out that abridged translation of a work of literature, despite its good intentions, cannot render the unique flavor and subtle texture of the original to its readers properly, and a careful consideration should be given before the translation/publishing project.

참고문헌 (21)

  1. 성승은, "대상독자의 차이에 따른 번역전략 연구 -<이상한 나라의 앨리스>를 중심으로-", 통역과 번역, 7(1) (2005), 한국통역번역학회
  2. 안미라, "대상 독자층에 따른 번역전략의 차이 ―그림형제 동화 번역 비교분석", 통번역학연구, 13(1), pp.107~125 (2009), 통번역연구소
  3. 이홍, "알렉상드르 뒤마의 소설 『삼총사』속의리슐리외의 이미지", 프랑스 문화 연구, 1(15), pp.519~540 (2007), 한국프랑스문화학회
  4. 조재룡, "번역 정글 잔혹사, 혹은 세계문학전집 번역 유감", 한국번역비평학회 2010년 동계 심포지움 발표집, pp.87~109 (2010)
  5. Carroll, L, "이상한 나라의 앨리스" (2007), 웅진주니어
  6. Dumas, A, "삼총사" (2001), 계림닷컴
  7. Dumas, A, "삼총사" (2002), 민음사
  8. Dumas, A, "삼총사" (2003), 대교출판
  9. Dumas, A, "삼총사" (2007), 효리원
  10. Dumas, A, "삼총사" (2008), 아이세움
  11. Dumas, A, "Les trois mousquetaires" (2001), Flammarion
  12. Dumas, A, "Les Trois mousquetaires" (2003), Fernand Nathan
  13. Dumas, A, "Les Trois mousquetaires" (2008), de Poche Jeunesse
  14. Dumas, A, "Les Trois mousquetaires" (2011), Larousse
  15. 김운찬, "번역한다는 것" (2010), 열린책들
  16. 유재홍, "문학의 정치" (2009), 인간사랑
  17. Milton, J, "Translation Studies and Adaptation Studies", Translation Research Projects, 2, pp.51~58 (2009)
  18. Sanders, J, "Adaptation and appropriation" (2006), Routledge
  19. Shavit, Z, "Poetics of children's literature" (1986), The University of Georgia Press
  20. Venuti, L, "번역의 윤리" (2006), 열린책들
  21. Van Hoof, H, "Histoire de la traduction en occident" (1991), Duculot

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (13건)