플라톤 정치사상에서 철인지배와 법치의 상보적 통합성: ‘좋은 법질서’(eunomia)를 향한 철학적 충동
Inter-supplementary Integration of the Rule of Wise Man and the Rule of Law in Plato’s Political Thought: Philosophical Impulse Toward ‘a Good Legal Order’(eunomia)
0
조회
0
다운로드
9
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The Purpose of this paper is to consider the legal aspect of Plato’s political thought with special attention to the characteristics of his political philosophy in the hope of offering an alternative interpretation of his political thought, and try to argue that seemingly conflicting elements of his legal thought, especially the rule of wise man and the rule of law, can be understood as inter-supplementary normative elements which are finally integrated into “a good legal order”(eunomia). In chapter II, it is argued that the structure of Plato’s political philosophy consists of two elements, one of which functions, at horizontal dimension, continuously to accomplish complete congruity among various elements of a specific political order(a model state), and the other of which functions, at vertical dimension, to formulate various model states respectively corresponding to specific human and historical conditions. In chapter III, on the basis of my argument in chapter II, it is argued that the rule of wise man and the rule of law should be understood as being inter-supplementary with each other, co-participating in sovereignty. In chapter IV, it is demonstrated that “a good legal order”(eunomia) Plato tried to achieve is a totally congruent normative order into which various normative elements of political community are finally integrated, continuously inter-playing with each other circularly and supportively. In chapter V, Plato’s political philosophy, with a proviso that it needs to be adopted to modern pluralism, might be expected to suggest an alternative direction for a viable normative practical philosophy to take, in response to today’s highly specialized ones.
Abstract
The Purpose of this paper is to consider the legal aspect of Plato’s political thought with special attention to the characteristics of his political philosophy in the hope of offering an alternative interpretation of his political thought, and try to argue that seemingly conflicting elements of his legal thought, especially the rule of wise man and the rule of law, can be understood as inter-supplementary normative elements which are finally integrated into “a good legal order”(eunomia). In chapter II, it is argued that the structure of Plato’s political philosophy consists of two elements, one of which functions, at horizontal dimension, continuously to accomplish complete congruity among various elements of a specific political order(a model state), and the other of which functions, at vertical dimension, to formulate various model states respectively corresponding to specific human and historical conditions. In chapter III, on the basis of my argument in chapter II, it is argued that the rule of wise man and the rule of law should be understood as being inter-supplementary with each other, co-participating in sovereignty. In chapter IV, it is demonstrated that “a good legal order”(eunomia) Plato tried to achieve is a totally congruent normative order into which various normative elements of political community are finally integrated, continuously inter-playing with each other circularly and supportively. In chapter V, Plato’s political philosophy, with a proviso that it needs to be adopted to modern pluralism, might be expected to suggest an alternative direction for a viable normative practical philosophy to take, in response to today’s highly specialized ones.
참고문헌 (32)
- 나정원, "플라톤의 政治思想" (1989), 법문사
- 플라톤, "국가" (1997), 서광사
- 플라톤, "법률" (2009), 서광사
- 플라톤, "정치가" (2000), 한길사
- 플라톤, "크라튈로스" (2007), 이제이북스
- 한상수, "플라톤의 법치국가론:『법률』을 중심으로", 법철학 연구, 2 (1999)
- Aristotle, "Politics" (1969), Oxford. University Press
- Barker, Ernest, "The Political Thought of Plato and Aristotle" (1959), Dover Publications, Inc
- Bobonich, Christopher, "Plato’s Utopia Recast" (2002), Oxford University Press
- Cairns, Huntington, "Plato‘s Theory of Law", Harvard Law Review, 56(3) (1942)
- Cohen, David, "Law, Autonomy, and Political Community in Plato’s Laws", Classical Theology, 88 (1993)
- Dworkin, Ronald, "Foundations of Liberal Equality", The Tanner Lectures on Human Values, 11 (1990), Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press
- Dworkin, Ronald, "Truth for Hedgehogs" (2001), Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
- Hansen, M. H., "The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes" (1991), Oxford University Press
- Harris, E. M., "Democracy and the Rule of Law in Classical Athens" (2006), Cambridge University Press
- Heinze, Eric, "Epinomia: Plato and the First Legal Theory", Ratio Juris, 20(1)
- Irwin, T. H., "Plato: The Intellectual Background, in The Cambridge Companion to Plato" (1992), Cambridge University Press
- Jones, J. W., "Law and Legal Theory of the Greeks" (1956), Clarendon Press
- Klosko, "The Nocturnal Council in Plato’s Laws"
- Klosko, George, "Knowledge and Law in Plato’s Laws", Political Studies, 56 (2008)
- Klosko, George, "The Nocturnal Council in Plato’s Laws", Political Studies, 36(1) (1988)
- Klosko, George, "The Development of Plato’s Political Theory" (2006), Oxford University Press
- Laks, André, "The Laws, in The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Political Thought" (2000), Cambridge University Press
- Morrow, Glenn R., "Plato and the Rule of Law", Philosophical Review, L(2) (1941)
- Murphy, R. O., "Introduction, Aristotle and Modern Law" (2003), Ashgate
- Tamanaha, B. Z., "On the Rule of Law: History, Politics, Theory" (2004), Cambridge University Press
- Ober, Joshia, "The Orators, in Greek and Roman Political Thought" (2000), Cambridge University Press
- Ostwald, M., "From Popular Sovereignty to the Sovereignty of Law" (1986)
- Saunders, Trevor J., "Plato on Women in the Laws, The Greek World" (1995), Routledge & Kegan Paul
- Stalley, R., "An Introduction to Plato's Laws" (1983), Hackett
- Stalley, R., "The Development of Plato's Political Theory" (2006), Oxford University Press
- Waldron, J., "Legal and Political Philosophy, in The Oxford Handbook of Jurisprudence and Philosophy of Law" (2002), Oxford University Press