The Issue of Credibility in Deterrence and Implications of the Israeli Experience for South Korea
1
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Israel’s military superiority and security strategies have attracted the interest of both academics and practitioners in South Korea. However, to date there have been no rigorous analyses comparing the two countries’ security environments or examining the adaptability of the Israeli experience to the case of South Korea. This paper attempts to investigate such possibilities by applying discussion of deterrence theories with a specific focus on the issue of threat credibility. The analysis reveals that Israel and South Korea are situated in different security settings which cause the two countries’ policies of deterrence to function differently. Despite conventional beliefs, the distinctive features of the Israeli security environment and security strategies make them inappropriate for application to the case of South Korea.
Abstract
Israel’s military superiority and security strategies have attracted the interest of both academics and practitioners in South Korea. However, to date there have been no rigorous analyses comparing the two countries’ security environments or examining the adaptability of the Israeli experience to the case of South Korea. This paper attempts to investigate such possibilities by applying discussion of deterrence theories with a specific focus on the issue of threat credibility. The analysis reveals that Israel and South Korea are situated in different security settings which cause the two countries’ policies of deterrence to function differently. Despite conventional beliefs, the distinctive features of the Israeli security environment and security strategies make them inappropriate for application to the case of South Korea.
참고문헌 (34)
- Adamsky, Dmitry, "From Israel with Deterrence: Strategic Culture, Intra-war Coercion and Brute Force", Security Studies, 26(10), pp.157~184 (2017)
- Bar-Joseph, Uri, "Variations on a Theme: The Conceptualization of Deterrence in Israeli Strategic Thinking", Security Studies, 7(3), pp.145~181 (1998)
- "Profile: Hamas Palestinian Movement" (2017)[URL]
- "Deterring Terror:How Israel Confronts the Next Generation of Threats. English Translation of the Official Strategy of the Israel Defense Forces" (2016)[URL]
- "Why Iran and Israel Are Clashing in Syria" (2018)[URL]
- Danilova, Vesna, "Conceptual and Selection Bias Issues in Deterrence", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 45(1), pp.97~125 (2001)
- George, Alexander L., "The Deterrence in American Foreign Policy: Theory and Practice" (1974), Columbia University Press
- Huth, Paul K., "Deterrence and International Conflict: Empirical Findings and Theoretical Debates", Annual Review of Political Science, 2, pp.25~48 (1999)
- Huth, Paul K., "Cases from 1900-1980", World Politics, 36(4), pp.496~526 (1984)
- Inbar, Efraim, "Israeli National Security, 1973-96", The Annuals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 555, pp.62~81
- "The 2014 Gaza Conflict: Factual and Legal Aspects"[URL]
- "A Countermeasure against North Korean Ballistic Missile, Israel Has the Key" (2017)[URL]
- "Iran Fires Rockets into Golan Heights from Syria, Israeli Say" (2018)[URL]
- A Proposal for Constructing More Effective Missile Defense System: Israeli Defense System, "Kim, Jong Woo", The Asan Institute for Policy Studies, ~ (2017)
- 김강녕, "이스라엘의 안보환경과 국방정책", 한국군사학논총, 3(1), pp.3~40 (2014), 미래군사학회[DOI]
- "The 2014 Gaza Conflict: Factual and Legal Aspects" (2015)[URL]
- Morgan, Patrick M., "Deterrence: A Conceptual Analysis" (1983), SAGE Publications, Inc
- 박휘락, "이스라엘, 일본, 한국의 탄도미사일 방어(BMD) 비교와 한국에 대한 함의", 국제지역연구, 20(1), pp.195~224 (2016), 국제지역연구센터[DOI]
- "World Now: A Report from a Military Officer. Why Israel Is Strong" (2018)[URL]
- Press, Darly G., "The Credibility of Power: Assessing Threats during the “Appeasement” Crises of the 1930s", International Security, 29(3), pp.136~169 (2005)
- Quchenbush, Stephen L., "Making Sense of IR Theory" (2006)
- Quchenbush, Stephen L., "Deterrence Theory: Where Do We Stand?", Review of International Studies, 37(2), pp.741~762 (2001)
- Roehrig, Terence, "From Deterrence to Engagement: The U.S. Defense Commitment to South Korea" (2006), Lexington Books
- Sagan, Scott D., "The Commitment Trap: Why the United States Should Not Use Nuclear Threats to Deter Biological and Chemical Weapons Attacks", International Security, 24(4), pp.85~115 (2000)
- Another Brick in the Wall: The Israeli Experience in Missile Defense, "Samaan, Jean-Loup", Army War College Strategic Studies Institute, ~ (2015)
- Satori, Anne E., "Deterrence by Diplomacy" (2013), Princeton University Press
- Schelling, Thomas C., "Arms and Influence" (1966), Yale University Press
- 성일광, "이스라엘의 안보 전략 변화와 그 함의: 대칭전에서 비대칭전으로", 한국중동학회논총, 36(2), pp.1~26 (2015), 한국중동학회[DOI]
- "Hamas and Fatah: How are the Two Groups Different?" (2017)[URL]
- "Chaim Choshen, Ambassador of Israel to Korea Says “Cooperating with South Korea on Missile Defense" (2017)[URL]
- "The New Triangle of Egypt, Israel, and Hamas"[URL]
- Zagare, Frank C., "Perfect Deterrence" (2000), Cambridge University Press
- Zagare, Frank C., "Reconciling Rationality with Deterrence: A Reexamination of Logical Foundations of Deterrence Theory", Journal of Theoretical Politics, 16(2), pp.107~141 (2004)
- The Palestinians: Background and US Relations, "Zanotti, Jim", Congressional Research Service, ~ (2014)