Comparative study of two CAD software programs on consistency between custom abutment design and the output
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Purpose: This study was aimed to compare the consistency between the custom abutment design and the output in two CAD software programs. Materials and Methods: Customized abutments were designed by using 3Shape Dental System CAD software and Delta9 CAD software on a plaster model with implants (CRM STL file). After milling of the designed abutments, the abutments were scanned with a contact method scanner (Test STL file). We overlaid the Test STL file with each CRM STL file by using inspection software, and then compared the milling reproducibility by measuring the output error of the specimens from each CAD software program. Results: The Delta9 showed better milling reproducibility than 3Shape when comparing the milling errors obtained with a full scan of all specimens (P < .05) and also when comparing the axial wall region specifically according to the axial angle. With 0.9 mm marginal radius, the Delta9 showed better consistency between the design and the output than 3Shape (P < .05). While, antirotation form had no significant difference in error between the two systems. When cumulative errors were compared, the Delta9 showed better milling reproducibility in almost cases (P < .05). Conclusion: Delta9 showed a significantly smaller error for most of the abutment design options. This means that it is possible to facilitate generation of printouts with reliable reproducibility and high precision with respect to the planned design.
Abstract
Purpose: This study was aimed to compare the consistency between the custom abutment design and the output in two CAD software programs. Materials and Methods: Customized abutments were designed by using 3Shape Dental System CAD software and Delta9 CAD software on a plaster model with implants (CRM STL file). After milling of the designed abutments, the abutments were scanned with a contact method scanner (Test STL file). We overlaid the Test STL file with each CRM STL file by using inspection software, and then compared the milling reproducibility by measuring the output error of the specimens from each CAD software program. Results: The Delta9 showed better milling reproducibility than 3Shape when comparing the milling errors obtained with a full scan of all specimens (P < .05) and also when comparing the axial wall region specifically according to the axial angle. With 0.9 mm marginal radius, the Delta9 showed better consistency between the design and the output than 3Shape (P < .05). While, antirotation form had no significant difference in error between the two systems. When cumulative errors were compared, the Delta9 showed better milling reproducibility in almost cases (P < .05). Conclusion: Delta9 showed a significantly smaller error for most of the abutment design options. This means that it is possible to facilitate generation of printouts with reliable reproducibility and high precision with respect to the planned design.
참고문헌 (21)
- 김종욱, "기성 지대주와 맞춤형 CAD-CAM 지대주의 적합 및 나사 안정성 비교", 대한치과보철학회지, 51(4), pp.276~283 (2013), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- Priest G, "Virtual-designed and computer-milled implant abutments", J Oral Maxillofac Surg, 63, pp.22~32 (2005)
- Alshhrani WM, "Customized CADCAM healing abutment for delayed loaded implants", J Prosthet Dent, 116, pp.176~179 (2016)[DOI]
- Thulasidas S, "Influence of implant angulation on the fracture resistance of zirconia abutments", J Prosthodont, 24, pp.127~135 (2015)[DOI]
- Vinnakota DN, "Effect of preparation convergence on retention of multiple unit restorations-An in vitro study", Contemp Clin Dent, 6, pp.409~413 (2015)[DOI]
- Corazza PH, "Influence of convergence angle of tooth preparation on the fracture resistance of Y-TZP-based allceramic restorations", Dent Mater, 29, pp.339~347 (2013)[DOI]
- Tiu J, "Reporting numeric values of complete crowns. Part 2: Retention and resistance theories", J Prosthet Dent, 114, pp.75~80 (2015)[DOI]
- Shillingburg HT, "Fundamentals of fixed prosthodontics", pp.132~133 (2012), Quintessence
- Alghazzawi TF, "Advancements in CAD", CAM technology: options for practical implementation, 2016, pp.60, 72~84
- Yamanishi Y, "Effects of the implant design on periimplant bone stress and abutment micromovement: three-dimensional finite element analysis of original computer-aided design models", J Periodontol, 85, pp.e333~e338 (2014)[DOI]
- Komine F, "Marginal and internal adaptation of zirconium dioxide ceramic copings and crowns with different finish line designs", Dent Mater J, 26, pp.659~664 (2007)[DOI]
- Beuer F, "Effect of preparation design on the fracture resistance of zirconia crown copings", Dent Mater J, 27, pp.362~367 (2008)[DOI]
- May KB, "Precision of fit: the Procera AllCeram crown", J Prosthet Dent, 80, pp.394~404 (1998)[DOI]
- 김총명, "2종류의 버와 3종류의 버를 이용해 제작된 크라운 보철물의 정밀도 평가", 대한치과기공학회지, 38(2), pp.57~62 (2016), 대한치과기공학회[DOI]
- Schaefer O, "Marginal and internal fit of pressed lithium disilicate partial crowns in vitro: a three-dimensional analysis of accuracy and reproducibility", Dent Mater, 28, pp.320~326 (2012)[DOI]
- International Organization for Standardization, "ISO-12836:2015. Dentistry - digitizing devices for CAD", CAM systems for indirect dental restorations - Test methods for assessing accuracy
- 이경탁, "치과용 스캐너로 채득한 디지털 모형의 반복성 및 재현성에 관한 3차원적 평가", 대한치과기공학회지, 34(3), pp.213~220 (2012), 대한치과기공학회
- Persson A, "A three-dimensional evaluation of a laser scanner and a touch-probe scanner", J Prosthet Dent, 95, pp.194~200 (2006)[DOI]
- Sahu N, "Comparison of the effect of implant abutment surface modifications on retention of implant-supported restoration with a polymer based cement", J Clin Diagn Res, 8, pp.239~242 (2014)
- Enkling N, "Precision of fit and retention force of cast non-precious-crowns on standard titanium implant-abutment with different design and height", Clin Oral Implants Res, 25, pp.451~457 (2014)
- 허중보, "CAD", CAM 보철물의 제작 과정에서 오류가 발생할 수 있는 요소들에 대한 경험적 고찰, 2014, pp.52(6), 332~345[DOI]