Technical and Clinical Aspects of Diagnostic Single-Balloon Enteroscopy in the First Decade of Use: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Background/Aims: Single-balloon enteroscopy (SBE) has been widely used in diagnosing small bowel disease. We conducted this study to systematically appraise its technical and clinical performance. Methods: Studies on SBE published by September 2018 were systematically searched. Technical and clinical performance data were collected and analyzed with descriptive or meta-analysis methods. Results: In total, 54 articles incorporating 4,592 patients (6,036 procedures) were included. Regarding technical parameters, the pooled insertion depths (IDs) for anterograde and retrograde SBE were 209.2 cm and 98.1 cm, respectively. The pooled retrograde ID in Asian countries was significantly greater than that in Western countries (129.0 cm vs 81.1 cm, p<0.001). The pooled anterograde and retrograde procedure times were 57.6 minutes and 65.1 minutes, respectively. The total enteroscopy rate was 21.9%, with no significant difference between Asian and Western countries. Clinically, the pooled diagnostic yield of SBE was 62.3%. Obscure gastrointestinal bleeding (OGIB) was the most common indication (50.0%), with a diagnostic yield of 59.5%. Vascular lesions were the most common findings in Western OGIB patients (76.9%) but not in Asian ones (31.0%). The rates of severe and mild adverse events were 0.5% and 2.5%, respectively. Conclusions: SBE is technically efficient and is clinically effective and safe, but total enteroscopy is relatively difficult to achieve with this technique. Etiologies of OGIB in Asian countries differ from those in Western countries.
Abstract
Background/Aims: Single-balloon enteroscopy (SBE) has been widely used in diagnosing small bowel disease. We conducted this study to systematically appraise its technical and clinical performance. Methods: Studies on SBE published by September 2018 were systematically searched. Technical and clinical performance data were collected and analyzed with descriptive or meta-analysis methods. Results: In total, 54 articles incorporating 4,592 patients (6,036 procedures) were included. Regarding technical parameters, the pooled insertion depths (IDs) for anterograde and retrograde SBE were 209.2 cm and 98.1 cm, respectively. The pooled retrograde ID in Asian countries was significantly greater than that in Western countries (129.0 cm vs 81.1 cm, p<0.001). The pooled anterograde and retrograde procedure times were 57.6 minutes and 65.1 minutes, respectively. The total enteroscopy rate was 21.9%, with no significant difference between Asian and Western countries. Clinically, the pooled diagnostic yield of SBE was 62.3%. Obscure gastrointestinal bleeding (OGIB) was the most common indication (50.0%), with a diagnostic yield of 59.5%. Vascular lesions were the most common findings in Western OGIB patients (76.9%) but not in Asian ones (31.0%). The rates of severe and mild adverse events were 0.5% and 2.5%, respectively. Conclusions: SBE is technically efficient and is clinically effective and safe, but total enteroscopy is relatively difficult to achieve with this technique. Etiologies of OGIB in Asian countries differ from those in Western countries.
참고문헌 (61)
- Manno M, "Single balloon enteroscopy : technical aspects and clinical applications", World J Gastrointest Endosc, 4, pp.28~32 (2012)
- Iddan G, "Wireless capsule endoscopy", Nature, 405, pp.417~ (2000)
- Yamamoto H, "Total enteroscopy with a nonsurgical steerable double-balloon method", Gastrointest Endosc, 53, pp.216~220 (2001)
- Xin L, "Indications, detectability, positive findings, total enteroscopy, and complications of diagnostic double-balloon endoscopy : a systematic review of data over the first decade of use", Gastrointest Endosc, 74, pp.563~570 (2011)
- Lenz P, "Single-balloon enteroscopy", Gastrointest Endosc Clin N Am, 27, pp.123~131 (2017)
- Yamamoto H, "Clinical practice guideline for enteroscopy", Dig Endosc, 29, pp.519~546 (2017)
- Liao Z, "Indications and detection, completion, and retention rates of small-bowel capsule endoscopy : a systematic review", Gastrointest Endosc, 71, pp.280~286 (2010)
- ASGE Standards of Practice Committee, "The role of endoscopy in the management of obscure GI bleeding", Gastrointest Endosc, 72, pp.471~479 (2010)
- Holleran G, "The use of single balloon enteroscopy in Crohn’s disease and its impact on clinical outcome", Scand J Gastroenterol, 53, pp.925~929 (2018)
- Kav T, "Enteroscopic findings of celiac disease and their correlation with mucosal histopathologic changes", Comput Biol Med, 65, pp.315~319 (2015)
- Waterman M, "Capsule enteroscopy of the small intestine", Abdom Imaging, 34, pp.452~458 (2009)
- Zhong J, "A retrospective study of the application on double-balloon enteroscopy in 378 patients with suspected small-bowel diseases", Endoscopy, 39, pp.208~215 (2007)
- Munn Z, "The development of a critical appraisal tool for use in systematic reviews addressing questions of prevalence", Int J Health Policy Manag, 3, pp.123~128 (2014)
- Meng Q, "Diagnosis and treatment of autoimmune pancreatitis in China : a systematic review", PLoS One, 10, pp.e0130466~ (2015)
- Inamdar S, "Systematic review and meta-analysis of single-balloon enteroscopy-assisted ERCP in patients with surgically altered GI anatomy", Gastrointest Endosc, 82, pp.9~19 (2015)
- May A, "Prospective multicenter trial comparing push-and-pull enteroscopy with the single-and double-balloon techniques in patients with small-bowel disorders", Am J Gastroenterol, 105, pp.575~581 (2010)
- Lenz P, "Double-vs. single-balloon vs. spiral enteroscopy", Best Pract Res Clin Gastroenterol, 26, pp.303~313 (2012)
- Hartmann D, "Balloonassisted enteroscopy using a single-balloon technique", Endoscopy, 39(Suppl 1), pp.E276~ (2007)
- Efthymiou M, "SINGLE-01 : a randomized, controlled trial comparing the efficacy and depth of insertion of single-and double-balloon enteroscopy by using a novel method to determine insertion depth", Gastrointest Endosc, 76, pp.972~980 (2012)
- Gong W, "Single-balloon enteroscopy for small bowel diseases : results from an initial experience at a single Chinese center", J Dig Dis, 13, pp.609~613 (2012)
- Li X, "Carbon dioxide insufflation improves the intubation depth and total enteroscopy rate in single-balloon enteroscopy : a randomised, controlled, double-blind trial", Gut, 63, pp.1560~1565 (2014)
- Xu N, "Characteristics of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs(NSAIDs)-induced small bowel injury identified by single-balloon endoscopy or capsule endoscopy", Med Sci Monit, 23, pp.5237~5245 (2017)
- Aktas H, "Complications of single-balloon enteroscopy : a prospective evaluation of 166 procedures", Endoscopy, 42, pp.365~368 (2010)
- Sethi S, "Prior capsule endoscopy improves the diagnostic and therapeutic yield of singleballoon enteroscopy", Dig Dis Sci, 59, pp.2497~2502 (2014)
- Lenz P, "CO2 insufflation during single-balloon enteroscopy : a multicenter randomized controlled trial", Endoscopy, 46, pp.53~58 (2014)
- Pinho R, "Multicenter survey on the use of device-assisted enteroscopy in Portugal", United European Gastroenterol J, 4, pp.264~274 (2016)
- Murino A, "Factors associated with reduced insertion depth at double balloon enteroscopy : a retrospective, multivariate analysis", Dig Liver Dis, 46, pp.956~958 (2014)
- Decker GA, "Predictors of insertion depth at double balloon enteroscopy (DBE)", Gastrointest Endosc, 69, pp.AB309~AB310 (2009)
- Wadhwa V, "A meta-analysis on efficacy and safety: single-balloon vs. double-balloon enteroscopy", Gastroenterol Rep(Oxf), 3, pp.148~155 (2015)
- 김태준, "Comparison of the Efficacy and Safety of Single- versus Double-Balloon Enteroscopy Performed by Endoscopist Experts in Single-Balloon Enteroscopy: A Single-Center Experience and Meta-Analysis", Gut and Liver, 11(4), pp.520~527 (2017), 거트앤리버 소화기연관학회협의회
- Domagk D, "Single-vs. doubleballoon enteroscopy in small-bowel diagnostics : a randomized multicenter trial", Endoscopy, 43, pp.472~476 (2011)
- Takano N, "Single-balloon versus double-balloon endoscopy for achieving total enteroscopy : a randomized, controlled trial", Gastrointest Endosc, 73, pp.734~739 (2011)
- Lipka S, "Single versus double balloon enteroscopy for small bowel diagnostics : a systematic review and meta-analysis", J Clin Gastroenterol, 49, pp.177~184 (2015)
- Tanaka S, "Diagnostic yield of double-balloon endoscopy in patients with obscure GI bleeding", Gastrointest Endosc, 68, pp.683~691 (2008)
- Kawamura T, "Clinical evaluation of a newly developed single-balloon enteroscope", Gastrointest Endosc, 68, pp.1112~1116 (2008)
- Ohtsuka K, "Diagnosis and treatment of small bowel diseases with a newly developed single balloon endoscope", Dig Endosc, 20, pp.134~137 (2008)
- Tsujikawa T, "Novel single-balloon enteroscopy for diagnosis and treatment of the small intestine : preliminary experiences", Endoscopy, 40, pp.11~15 (2008)
- Ramchandani M, "Diagnostic yield and therapeutic impact of single-balloon enteroscopy : series of 106 cases", J Gastroenterol Hepatol, 24, pp.1631~1638 (2009)
- Barth BA, "Single-balloon enteroscopy in children : initial experience at a pediatric center", J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr, 51, pp.680~684 (2010)
- Dutta AK, "Learning curve, diagnostic yield and safety of single balloon enteroscopy", Trop Gastroenterol, 33, pp.179~184 (2012)
- Prachayakul V, "The utility of single-balloon enteroscopy for the diagnosis and management of small bowel disorders according to their clinical manifestations : a retrospective review", BMC Gastroenterol, 13, pp.103~ (2013)
- Oliva S, "Capsule endoscopy followed by single balloon enteroscopy in children with obscure gastrointestinal bleeding : a combined approach", Digest Liver Dis, 47, pp.125~130 (2015)
- Marques M, "Single-balloon enteroscopy efficacy and degree of concordance with noninvasive evaluation of small bowel", Endosc Int Open, 5, pp.E96~ (2017)
- Vargo J, "Clinical utility of the Olympus single balloon enteroscope: the initial U.S. experience", Gastrointest Endosc, 65, pp.AB90~ (2007)
- Vere CC, "Videocapsule endoscopy and single balloon enteroscopy : novel diagnostic techniques in small bowel pathology", Rom J Morphol Embryol, 50, pp.467~474 (2009)
- Frantz DJ, "Single-balloon enteroscopy : results from an initial experience at a U. S. tertiary-care center", Gastrointest Endosc, 72, pp.422~426 (2010)
- Trifan A, "Single-balloon enteroscopy following videocapsule endoscopy for diagnosis of the small bowel tumors:preliminary experiences", Chirurgia(Bucur), 105, pp.211~217 (2010)
- Riccioni ME, "Single-balloon push-and-pull enteroscopy system : does it work? A single-center, 3-year experience", Surg Endosc, 25, pp.3050~3056 (2011)
- Alderlieste YA, "Prospective enteroscopic evaluation of jejunal polyposis in patients with familial adenomatous polyposis and advanced duodenal polyposis", Fam Cancer, 12, pp.51~56 (2012)
- Di Nardo G, "Usefulness of single-balloon enteroscopy in pediatric Crohn’s disease", Gastrointest Endosc, 75, pp.80~86 (2012)
- Kushnir VM, "Long-term outcomes after single-balloon enteroscopy in patients with obscure gastrointestinal bleeding", Dig Dis Sci, 58, pp.2572~2579 (2013)
- Baijal R, "Single-balloon enteroscopy : a single-center experience of 48procedures", Indian J Gastroenterol, 33, pp.55~58 (2014)
- Davis-Yadley AH, "The safety and efficacy of single balloon enteroscopy in the elderly", Therap Adv Gastroenterol, 9, pp.169~179 (2015)
- Holman N, "Open-access single balloon enteroscopy : a tertiary care experience", South Med J, 108, pp.739~743 (2015)
- Minamino H, "Rectal biopsy, rather than ileal, is appropriate to confirm the diagnosis of early gastrointestinal graft-versus-host disease", Scand J Gastroenterol, 50, pp.1428~1434 (2015)
- Christian KE, "Performance characteristics of retrograde single-balloon endoscopy : a single center experience", World J Gastrointest Endosc, 8, pp.501~507 (2016)
- Ma J, "Capsule endoscopy and singleballoon enteroscopy in small bowel diseases: competing or complementary?", World J Gastroenterol, 22, pp.10625~10630 (2016)
- Shohei Ooka, "Roles of Capsule Endoscopy and Single-Balloon Enteroscopy in Diagnosing Unexplained Gastrointestinal Bleeding", Clinical Endoscopy, 49(1), pp.56~60 (2016), 대한소화기내시경학회
- Haanstra JF, "Incidence of small bowel neoplasia in Lynch syndrome assessed by video capsule endoscopy", Endosc Int Open, 5, pp.E622~ (2017)
- Lu Z, "Efficacy and safety of single-balloon versus double-balloon enteroscopy : a single-center retrospective analysis", Med Sci Monit, 23, pp.1933~1939 (2017)
- Moran RA, "A randomized controlled trial comparing the depth of maximal insertion between anterograde single-balloon versus spiral enteroscopy", Clin Med Insights Gastroenterol, 11, pp.419549375~ (2018)