기계번역의 한계와 번역사의 전략 - 유엔 총회 한·일 정상 연설문을 중심으로 -
Limitations of Machine Translation and Human Translation Strategies : A Comparative Study of Korean and Japanese Speeches at the UN General Assembly
0
조회
0
다운로드
13
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
本研究の目的は、機械翻訳が急成長している今日、機械翻訳と人間による翻訳の品質を比較することで、機械翻訳の現水準を把握し、人間の翻訳者であるからこそ可能な翻訳戦略にはどのようなものがあるかを考察することにある。具体的にはグーグル翻訳とネイバーのパパゴで代表されるニューラル機械翻訳の品質がどれほど向上したかを察するために機械翻訳のエラータイプを分析した。分析の結果、機械翻訳の精度が高くなったというものの、人間の翻訳者より多くのエラーを起こしていることが分かった。機械翻訳の間の比較では、グーグル翻訳がネイバーのパパゴよりエラー数が多かった。 次に、人間の翻訳者が翻訳に介入する形と戦略を調べてみた結果、依然として機械翻訳は人間による翻訳の品質に比べて劣っていた。一方で、翻訳のスピード面では、機械翻訳が圧倒的に優れていた。ところが、いくら機械翻訳が発達するとしても異文化を理解し、時代の流れと社会的な現象を把握したうえで、読者層の好みを反映するような積極的な翻訳行為においては、機械翻訳では限界があるはずだ。これから相互補完的な関係作りのためのさらなる取り組みが求められる。
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to examine the current level of machine translation by comparing it with the accuracy of human translators and hence to figure out the translation strategies that only human translators is are able to pursue. Specifically, error types of machine translation are analyzed in order to see the quality of artificial neural network-based machine translation, which is represented by Google Translation and Naver Papago. The analysis shows although the accuracy of machine translation has been considerably improved, it still generates many more errors than human translators. While comparing the two machine translations, Google Translation had more errors than Naver Papago Translation. When examining the form and strategy of human translators’ involvement in translation, machine translation still failed to follow the accuracy and precision of the translation of the strategic human translators. However, when it comes to the speed factor, machine translation was unparalleled. It was excellent. But no matter how advanced machine translation is, it most certainly has some limitations. For instance, it will fail to understand the culture, social trends, and current social phenomena, which reflect the tastes of readers. As a result, the mutual complementary efforts between machine translation and human translation will consistently be needed.
참고문헌 (11)
- 김종희, "포털사이트(portal site) 번역기의 오역에 관한 연구 - 정보 및 설명 텍스트를 중심으로 -", 일어일문학, (69), pp.141~158 (2016), 대한일어일문학회[DOI]
- 김한식, "한-일 번역에 있어서의 句讀點의 문제", 통번역학연구, 4, pp.47~68 (2000), 한국외국어대학교 통역번역연구소
- 서보현, "기계번역 결과물의 오류유형 고찰", 번역학연구, 19(1), pp.99~117 (2018), 한국번역학회[DOI]
- 이근희, "번역의 이론과 실제", pp.80~ (2005), 한국문화사
- 이주리애, "인공신경망 기계 번역의 한일", 일한 번역 품질에 대한 예비연구-품질향상 검토와 교열코드 적용-, 2018, pp.20(1), 43~71[DOI]
- 이하자, "한·일 기계번역시스템의 문제점 고찰 ― 번역가 번역문과의 대조분석을 통해 ―", 日本語敎育, (58), pp.151~166 (2011), 한국일본어교육학회
- 오미형, "번역투 인지가능성과 가독성에 대한 소고", 통역과 번역, 17(1), pp.65~88 (2015), 한국통역번역학회
- 松尾豊, "人工知能は人間を越えるかディープラーニングの先にあるもの", pp.221~ (2015), 角川選書
- "기계번역어디까지진화했나?"[URL]
- "第74回国連総会における安倍総理大臣一般討論演説"[URL]
- "제74차 유엔 총회 기조연설"[URL]
