買肖城 전투와 羅唐戰爭의 종결 ― 『三國史記』 신라본기 675년 2월 기사의 분석 ―
The Battle at the Macho-seong(買肖城) Fortress, and the End of the Shilla-Dang(羅唐) War — Analysis of the February 675 Entry of the Shilla Section in Samguk Sagi —
0
조회
0
다운로드
26
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Examined in this article are certain issues associated with the ending of the Shilla-Dang war. I tried to reevaluate the issues from a perspective different than before. The February 675 entry of Samguk Sagi(三國史記) portrays how the war ended. This is actually a reedited version of what was written in Shin-Dangseo(新唐書), which neglected to record the Maecho-seong(買肖城) fortress battle and described as if battles continued afterwards. But all the battles recorded here clearly took place before the Maecho-seong battle which broke out in September, and the war itself definitely ended when the status of Shilla king Munmu-wang was reinstated after this particular battle. This Maecho-seong fortress seems to have been the Sugok-seong(水谷城) fortress, which was located upon a strategically important traffic spot leading to the Pyeong’yang area. After Shilla lost region above the Daegok-seong(大谷城) fortress, it tried to secure Maecho-seong but unfortunately failed. As a result, Shilla’s northern borderline was established below the Daegok-seong fortress, and during the reign of King Hyoso-wang, fortresses were built in regions such as Gaeseong(開城) and Wujam(牛岑). Samguk Sagi described the events at the time as if Shilla was able to establish local units right up to “the Southern borderline of Goguryeo(高句麗 南境)” during the war. But such record should be understood as a description of Unified Shilla’s nine Ju units (“九州”) which were established after the war, reflecting the fact that Shilla’s territory under the Daedong-gang river line was authorized by Dang, during Shilla King Seongdeok-wang’s reign.
Abstract
Examined in this article are certain issues associated with the ending of the Shilla-Dang war. I tried to reevaluate the issues from a perspective different than before. The February 675 entry of Samguk Sagi(三國史記) portrays how the war ended. This is actually a reedited version of what was written in Shin-Dangseo(新唐書), which neglected to record the Maecho-seong(買肖城) fortress battle and described as if battles continued afterwards. But all the battles recorded here clearly took place before the Maecho-seong battle which broke out in September, and the war itself definitely ended when the status of Shilla king Munmu-wang was reinstated after this particular battle. This Maecho-seong fortress seems to have been the Sugok-seong(水谷城) fortress, which was located upon a strategically important traffic spot leading to the Pyeong’yang area. After Shilla lost region above the Daegok-seong(大谷城) fortress, it tried to secure Maecho-seong but unfortunately failed. As a result, Shilla’s northern borderline was established below the Daegok-seong fortress, and during the reign of King Hyoso-wang, fortresses were built in regions such as Gaeseong(開城) and Wujam(牛岑). Samguk Sagi described the events at the time as if Shilla was able to establish local units right up to “the Southern borderline of Goguryeo(高句麗 南境)” during the war. But such record should be understood as a description of Unified Shilla’s nine Ju units (“九州”) which were established after the war, reflecting the fact that Shilla’s territory under the Daedong-gang river line was authorized by Dang, during Shilla King Seongdeok-wang’s reign.
참고문헌 (42)
- "三國史記", ~
- "舊唐書", ~
- "新唐書", ~
- "資治通鑑", ~
- "冊府元龜", ~
- "日本書紀", ~
- 權悳永, "古代韓中外交史" (1997), 一潮閣
- 徐榮敎, "羅唐戰爭史 硏究" (2006), 아세아문화사
- 이상훈, "나당전쟁 연구" (2012), 주류성 출판사
- 李昊榮, "新羅三國統合과 麗ㆍ濟 敗亡原因硏究" (1997), 서경문화사
- 金瑛河, "新羅의 百濟統合戰爭과 體制變化", 韓國古代史硏究, 16 (1999)
- 김병희, "매소성 전투의 위치와 실상에 대한 고찰", 군사, (91), pp.195~228 (2014), 국방부군사편찬연구소
- 김영하, "신라의 ‘통일’영역 문제-교과서 내용의 시정을 위한 제언-", 韓國史學報, (56), pp.7~32 (2014), 고려사학회
- 김종복, "특집 : 백제와 고구려 고지에 대한 당의 지배 양상", 역사와 현실, (78), pp.73~103 (2010), 한국역사연구회
- 노태돈, "7세기 전쟁의 성격을 둘러싼 논의", 한국사연구, (154), pp.329~345 (2011), 한국사연구회
- 노태돈, "對唐戰爭期(669-676) 新羅의 對外關係와 軍事活動", 軍史, 34 (1997)
- 閔德植, "羅唐戰爭에 관한 考察 : 買肖城 전투를 중심으로", 史學硏究, 40 (1989)
- 拜根興, "‘羅唐戰爭’ 硏究 中의 몇 가지 問題", 中國學報, 16 (2002)
- 拜根興, "7世紀東亞細亞의 新羅" (2010), 新羅文化遺産硏究院
- 徐榮敎, "羅唐戰爭과 吐蕃", 동양사학연구, 79, pp.1~30 (2002), 동양사학회
- 서영일, "고구려의 백제 공격로 고찰", 史學志, 38 (2006)
- 徐榮一, "漢城時代의 百濟 北方交通路", 문화사학, (21), pp.219~238 (2004), 한국문화사학회
- 신형식, "삼국통일전후 신라의 대외관계", 新羅文化, 2 (1985)
- 沈正輔, "羅唐戰爭期 新羅의 北境意識", 新羅史學報, 4 (2005)
- 安國承, "買肖城 硏究", 경기향토사학, 2 (1997)
- 윤경진, "고려 태조대 鎭 설치에 대한 재검토 －禮山鎭･神光鎭을 중심으로－", 韓國史學報, (40), pp.7~42 (2010), 고려사학회
- 윤경진, "新羅 太宗(武烈王) 諡號 논변에 대한 자료적 검토 - 原典에 대한 이해를 중심으로 -", 역사와 실학, (51), pp.5~41 (2013), 역사실학회
- 윤경진, "671년 「答薛仁貴書」의 ‘平壤已南 百濟土地’에 대한 재해석 : 백제의 영토의식과 浿河의 새로운 이해", 역사문화연구, (60), pp.3~54 (2016), 역사문화연구소[DOI]
- 윤경진, "고구려 ‘南平壤’의 실체와 출현 배경", 서울과 역사, (95), pp.7~53 (2017), 서울역사편찬원
- 윤선태, "‘통일신라’의 발명과 근대역사학의 성립", 신라문화, (29), pp.5~5 (2007), 신라문화연구소
- 이상훈, "唐의 軍事戰略을 통해 본 羅唐戰爭期의 買肖城 戰鬪", 신라문화, (29), pp.4~4 (2007), 신라문화연구소
- 이상훈, "羅唐戰爭期 伎伐浦 戰鬪와 薛仁貴", 대구사학, 90, pp.39~69 (2008), 대구사학회
- 이상훈, "羅唐戰爭의 종전배경과 新羅의 역할", 동북아역사논총, (32), pp.333~373 (2011), 동북아역사재단
- 이상훈, "662년 김유신의 군량 수송작전", 국방연구, 55(3), pp.97~122 (2012), 국가안전보장문제연구소
- 이상훈, "나당전쟁 연구동향과 전망", 군사, (100), pp.11~38 (2016), 국방부군사편찬연구소
- 李鍾學, "新羅三國統一의 軍事史的 考察", 軍史, 8 (1982)
- 張學根, "新羅의 征服地 支配防禦戰略 : 對唐戰爭을 中心으로", 軍史, 41 (2001)
- 전덕재, "신라의 北進과 서북 경계의 변화", 한국사연구, (173), pp.85~126 (2016), 한국사연구회
- 정요근, "7～11세기 경기도 북부지역에서의 간선교통로 변천과 ‘長湍渡路’", 한국사연구, (131), pp.191~222 (2005), 한국사연구회
- 존ㆍ씨ㆍ재미슨, "羅唐同盟의 瓦解 : 韓中記事 取捨의 比較", 歷史學報, 44 (1969)
- 河日植, "三國統一後 新羅 支配體制의 推移", 韓國古代史硏究, 23 (2001)
- 池內宏, "滿鮮史硏究 上世" (1951), 吉川弘文館