본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

역사 시뮬레이션 구축의 제 문제와 그 방법에 대한 연구

A Study on the Problems of Building a Historical Simulation and Its Method

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류역사학

초록

The aim of this study is examine of various difficulties of computational history. Computational history is a history that uses calculation as its main research method. Here, calculation refers to simulation. There are a lot of difficulties of introduction of computational history in historical research. This study examine three problems. That are simulation and historical coincidence, simulation and historical representation and method of the simulation. First, history handles coincidence. simulation can either. Coincidence is a key concept in simulation. This can be seen from Buffon's thought experiment. The only difference simulation has is that simulation coincidence is subject to purpose. This is due to the fact that simulation is basically an algorithm for solving problems. Historians can use this nature of simulation to approach historical problems. Second, the issue of representation. History is a representation of the facts of the past, and simulation is an imaginary representation. However, in essence, representation is a representation of an idea. This can be seen by looking at the example in the photograph. Photograph that we consider to be representations of reality are actually only mechanical representations of ideas(moment). However, we derive the usefulness of reality from the representation of ideas. Likewise, we explore historical facts from historical representations, that is, representations of ideas. This is not much different from simulation, which is a representation of an idea. Therefore, we do not need to have any doubts in using simulation in our historical exploration. Finally, there are two main methods of simulation. System dynamics and agnet-based simulation modeling(ABM). In this study I proposed an agent-based simulation modeling as a method for historical simulation. ABM is a computational model that seeks to understand the entire system based on autonomous agents. At this time, it is assumed that the agents communicate with other agents and act in order to achieve a specific goal within limited autonomy with their own attributes and their own rationality. This ABM has the advantage of not only being able to build a model that encompasses the system and its members, but also analyzes both the interrelationships between members and the interrelationships between members and systems. Simulation platforms to build ABM include Refast, Mason, Netlogo, and Mesa. In particular, Mesa has the advantage of being able to design a large number of agents and considering spatial factors. And there is a trend of gradually appearing historical researches using the ABM platform. Based on this research, I expect more studies on the history of simulation to emerge.

Abstract

The aim of this study is examine of various difficulties of computational history. Computational history is a history that uses calculation as its main research method. Here, calculation refers to simulation. There are a lot of difficulties of introduction of computational history in historical research. This study examine three problems. That are simulation and historical coincidence, simulation and historical representation and method of the simulation. First, history handles coincidence. simulation can either. Coincidence is a key concept in simulation. This can be seen from Buffon's thought experiment. The only difference simulation has is that simulation coincidence is subject to purpose. This is due to the fact that simulation is basically an algorithm for solving problems. Historians can use this nature of simulation to approach historical problems. Second, the issue of representation. History is a representation of the facts of the past, and simulation is an imaginary representation. However, in essence, representation is a representation of an idea. This can be seen by looking at the example in the photograph. Photograph that we consider to be representations of reality are actually only mechanical representations of ideas(moment). However, we derive the usefulness of reality from the representation of ideas. Likewise, we explore historical facts from historical representations, that is, representations of ideas. This is not much different from simulation, which is a representation of an idea. Therefore, we do not need to have any doubts in using simulation in our historical exploration. Finally, there are two main methods of simulation. System dynamics and agnet-based simulation modeling(ABM). In this study I proposed an agent-based simulation modeling as a method for historical simulation. ABM is a computational model that seeks to understand the entire system based on autonomous agents. At this time, it is assumed that the agents communicate with other agents and act in order to achieve a specific goal within limited autonomy with their own attributes and their own rationality. This ABM has the advantage of not only being able to build a model that encompasses the system and its members, but also analyzes both the interrelationships between members and the interrelationships between members and systems. Simulation platforms to build ABM include Refast, Mason, Netlogo, and Mesa. In particular, Mesa has the advantage of being able to design a large number of agents and considering spatial factors. And there is a trend of gradually appearing historical researches using the ABM platform. Based on this research, I expect more studies on the history of simulation to emerge.

참고문헌 (23)

  1. 박충식, "빅 히스토리와 인공지능: 정보적 관점에서", 인간.환경.미래, (22), pp.31~59 (2019), 인간환경미래연구원[DOI]
  2. 최제영, "행위자 기반 미시-거시 연계 경제 시뮬레이션과 루만의 사회체계이론 구현", 한국지능정보 시스템학회 학술대회논문집 (2014), 한국지능정보시스템학회
  3. 이상동, "From Data to Agents: 한국 디지털 역사학의 현주소와 AI 시대의 역사학", 호모미그란스-이주, 식민주의, 인종주의, 22, pp.178~202 (2020), 이주사학회[DOI]
  4. 박치완, "디지털인문학, 인문학의 창발적 변화인가?", 현대유럽철학연구, (38), pp.185~219 (2015), 한국하이데거학회
  5. 정일영, "빅데이터를 ‘다루는’ 역사학을 위하여: 임태훈, 『검색되지 않을 자유』)", 역사연구, (31), pp.343~355 (2016), 역사학연구소
  6. 양재혁, "과거의 재현에서 시뮬레이션으로: 계산 역사학(Computational History)의 가능성에 관한 소고", 호모미그란스-이주, 식민주의, 인종주의, 22, pp.148~177 (2020), 이주사학회[DOI]
  7. 김기봉, "시뮬라크르 시대에서 역사란 무엇인가", 한국언어문화, (25), pp.95~117 (2004), 한국언어문화학회
  8. 이상엽, "행위자기반모형(Agent-Based Modeling)을 이용한 신기술과 지식 확산 연구", 조사연구 (2015), 과학시술정책연구원
  9. 아우구스티누스, "고백" (1985), 범조사
  10. 안창원, "인구동태 마이크로 시뮬레이션 기술동향", 전자통신동향분석, 29(4) (2014)
  11. 폴 리쾨르, "시간과 이야기 1" (1999), 문학과 지성사
  12. 발터 벤야민, "아케이드 프로젝트 II" (2006), 새물결
  13. 발터 벤야민, "발터 벤야민, 사진에 대하여" (2018), 위즈덤 하우스
  14. 보먼트 뉴홀, "사진의 역사" (2013), 열화당
  15. David Goldsman, "A Brief History of Simulation", Proceedings of the 2009 Winter Simulation Conference (2009)
  16. Project Mesa Team, "Mesa Documentation Release", ~ (2020)
  17. Arianna Betti, "Towards a Computational History of Ideas", CEUR Workshop Proceedings (2016)
  18. Juan A. Barceló, "Simulating Prehistoric and Ancient Worlds" (2016), Springer
  19. Michael Gavin, "Agent-Based Modeling and Historical Simulation", Digital Humanities, ~ (2013)
  20. Ulf Christian Ewert, "Modelling Maritime Trade Systems: Agent-Based Simulation and Medieval History", Historical Social Research, 43 (2018)
  21. David Ortega, "Towards a Multi-Agent-Based Modelling of Obsidian Exchange in the Neolithic Near East", J Archaeol Method Theory, 21 (2014)
  22. Michael Gavin, "An Agent-based Computational Approach to the ‘Adam Smith Problem", Historical Social Research, 41(1) (2018)
  23. Davoud Taghawi-Nejad, "ABCE: A Python Library for Economic Agent-based Modeling", International Conference on Social Informatic (2017)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (11건)