EURATOM: Bridging ‘Rapprochement’ and ‘Radiance’of France in the Post-war
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article interrogates the question of how France was able to achieve their policy goals, ‘radiance of France’ (nuclear development), in respect to the relations with those in the post-war alliance, ‘rapprochement of France’ (European integration). It argues that France’s membership in EURATOM provided a venue for pursuance of its political autonomy via rhetorical actions which I labelled, ‘agree-and-deepen policy,’ was precisely one such mechanism through which this was done. In so doing, I open the discussion with critiques to the Rationalist Materialist account on the French motivation to become a member of EURATOM; namely that France joined EURATOM to accomplish its nuclear ambition through exploiting all the available sources of EURATOM and the false controversies contained within the EURATOM ‘defence clause’. Next, an alternative explanation is provided in regards to the influence of EURATOM over France by tracing the path in which the French foreign policy identity was reconstructed in the post-war period via EURATOM under the framework of ‘agree-and-deepen policy’. Finally, it concludes that EURATOM provided France leeway for legitimate nuclear development, which satisfied two policy goals demanded by Others and desired by the French Self, without negatively impacting on the French relations with Others.
Abstract
This article interrogates the question of how France was able to achieve their policy goals, ‘radiance of France’ (nuclear development), in respect to the relations with those in the post-war alliance, ‘rapprochement of France’ (European integration). It argues that France’s membership in EURATOM provided a venue for pursuance of its political autonomy via rhetorical actions which I labelled, ‘agree-and-deepen policy,’ was precisely one such mechanism through which this was done. In so doing, I open the discussion with critiques to the Rationalist Materialist account on the French motivation to become a member of EURATOM; namely that France joined EURATOM to accomplish its nuclear ambition through exploiting all the available sources of EURATOM and the false controversies contained within the EURATOM ‘defence clause’. Next, an alternative explanation is provided in regards to the influence of EURATOM over France by tracing the path in which the French foreign policy identity was reconstructed in the post-war period via EURATOM under the framework of ‘agree-and-deepen policy’. Finally, it concludes that EURATOM provided France leeway for legitimate nuclear development, which satisfied two policy goals demanded by Others and desired by the French Self, without negatively impacting on the French relations with Others.
참고문헌 (42)
- Ambassador of France, "Frances First Atomic Explosion, In French White Paper" (1960), Service de Presse et D’Informa.tion
- Andreini, Ginevra, "EURATOM: An Instrument to Achieve a Nuclear Deterrent? French Nuclear Independence and European Integration during the Mollet Government (1956)", Journal of European Integration History, 6(1), pp.109~128 (2000)
- Baylis, John, "Contemporary Strategy : Theories and Policies" (1975), Croom Helm Ltd
- Bell, Philip, "France and Britain 1940-1994 : The Long Separation" (1997), Longman
- Bryant, Janet., "French Foreign and Defence Policy, In The French Exception", pp.121~135 (2004), Berghahn Books
- Coicaud, Jean-Marc, "Conclusion: Making Sense of National Interest and International Solidarity, In National Interest and International Solidarity: Particular and Universal Ethics in International Life", pp.288~301 (2008), the United Nations University Press
- Deubner, Christian, "The Expansion of West German Capital and the Founding of Euratom", International Organization, 33(22), pp.203~228 (1979)
- Duroselle, J. B, "The Foreign Policy of France, In Foreign Policies in a World of Change" (1963), Harper & Row
- Errera, M. J, "EURATOM: Analyse et Commentaires du Traité" (1958), Librairie Encyclopédique, S.P.R.I
- Fischer, David, "History of the International Atomic Energy Agency : The First Forty Years Vienna" (1997), The Agency
- Foreign Relations of the United States, "France, In The Foreign Relations of the United States", pp.592~717 (1948), Government Printing Office
- Furniss, Edgar S. Jr, "France, Troubled Ally : De Gaulle's Heritage and Prospects" (1960), Harper & Brothers
- Gardner, Lloyd C, "The Atomic Temptation, 1945-54, In Redefining the Past: Essays in Diplomatic History in Honor of William Appleman Williams", pp.169~194 (1986), Oregon State University Press
- Godin, Emmanuel, "The Front National as a French Exception?, In The French Exception", pp.61~75 (2004), Berghahn Books
- Godin, Emmanuel, "Introduction, In The French Exception", pp.xiii~xxiv (2004), Berghahn Books
- Goffman, Erving, "On Face-work: An Analysis of Ritual Elements in Social Interaction, In Interaction Ritual: Essays in Face-to-Face Behavior", pp.5~46 (2005), Transaction Publishers
- Goffman, Erving, "The Presentation of Self, In Life as Theater: A Dramaturgical Sourcebook", pp.129~140 (2005), Transaction Publishers
- Goldschmidt, Bertrand, "The Atomic Complex: A Worldwide Political History of Nuclear Energy" (1982), American Nuclear Society
- Gordon, Philip H, "A Certain Idea of France: French Security Policy and the Gaullist Legacy" (1993), Princeton University Press
- Hecht, Gabrielle, "Technologiy, Politics, and National Identity in France, In Technologies of Power", pp.253~294 (2001), The MIT Press
- Howlett, Darryl A, "EURATOM and Nuclear Safeguards" (1990), MacMillan
- Hunebelle, Danielle, "Une Epopée de l'Après-Guerre: l'Epanouissement de Notre Industrie Atomique", Réalitiés, 155, pp.108~112 (1958)
- Kelly, Michael, "Modernization and Avant-Gardes, In French Cultural Studies: An Introduction", pp.140~182 (1995), Oxford University Press
- Kelly, Michael, "Crises of Modernization, In French Cultural Studies: An Introduction", pp.99~139 (1995), Oxford University Press
- Kohl, Wilfrid L, "French Nuclear Diplomacy" (1971), Princeton University Press
- Krige, John, "American Hegemony and the Postwar Reconstruction of Science in Europe" (2006), The MIT Press
- Macridis, Roy, "French Foreign Policy, In Foreign Policy in World Politics" (1962), Prentice-Hall Inc
- McSweeney, Bill, "Security, Identity, and Interests: A Sociology of International Relations" (1999), Cambridge University Press
- Mongin, Dominique, "La Bombe Atomique Française 1945-1958" (1958), Bruylant and L.G.D.J
- Nuclear France Aboard: History, Status and Prospects of French Nuclear Activities in Foreign Countries, "Mycle, Schneider", Mycle Schneide Consulting Independent Analysis on Energy and Nuclear Policy, ~ (2009)
- Nuenlist, Christian, "Into the 1960s: NATO's Role in East-West Relations, 1958-63, In Transforming NATO in the Cold War: Challenges beyond Deterrence in the 1960s", pp.67~88 (2007), Routledge
- O'Driscoll, Mervyn, "The Origins and Early History of Euratom, 1955-1958, In The European Parliament and the Euratom Treaty: Past, Present and Future" (1958), European Parliament
- Parker, Noel, "A Theoretical Introduction, In The Geopolitics of Europe’s Identity: Centers, Boundaries, and Margins" (2008), Palgrave MacMillan
- Robert Schuman: Homme d'État, "Poidevin, Raymond", Impr. Nationale, 1886~1963 (1963)
- Polach, Jaroslav G, "Euratom: Its Background, Issues and Economic Implications" (1964), Oceana Publications
- Scheinman, Lawrence, "Atomic Energy Policy in France under the Fourth Republic" (1965), Princeton University Press
- Scheinman, Lawrence, "Euratom: Nuclear Integration in Europe", Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, ~ (1967)
- Scheinman, Lawrence, "The Politics of Nationalism in Contemporary France", International Organization, 23(4), pp.834~858 (1969)
- "The Schuman Declaration 9 May 1950" (1950)[URL]
- Skogmar, Gunnar, "The United States and the Nuclear Dimension of European Integration" (2004), Palgrave MacMillan
- "The Treaty Establishing the European Atomic Energy Community" (1957)[URL]
- Wall, Irwin W, "The United States and the Making of Postwar France 1945-1954" (1991), Cambridge University Press