볼리비아와 칠레의 영토분쟁과 차라냐(Charaña) 협상
Territorial Dispute between Bolivia and Chile: The Negotiation of Charaña
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study analyzes the territorial dispute between Bolivia and Chile. It aims to enhance our understanding of Bolivia-Chile relations and to explore the possible solutions for their territorial dispute. Special attention is paid to the negotiation of Charaña, which is considered to be the most important negotiation between the two countries in the 20th century regarding Bolivia’s access to the Pacific Ocean. After careful examination of the case, the authors argue the followings: 1) The ideological similarities between the governments in the two countries turned out to be a significant variable to determine the outcome of dispute resolution process. Historically, the probability of dispute resolution augmented when the governments of both sides shared similar ideology. i. e. the socialist government of Torres in Bolivia with the socialist government of Allende in Chile, the military government of Banzer in Bolivia with the military government of Pinochet in Chile, and the leftist government in Morales in Bolivia with the leftist government in Bachelet in Chile. 2) Peru plays an important role in the dispute resolution. As a participant in the War of the Pacific, Peru reaffirmed during the negotiation process of Charaña its rights written in the 1929 Treaty. 3) The negotiation of Charaña illustrates us the importance of neighboring countries and regional institutions on the territorial dispute resolution. In sum, this research sheds lights on political conditions for the possible resolution of the territorial dispute between Bolivia and Chile.
Abstract
This study analyzes the territorial dispute between Bolivia and Chile. It aims to enhance our understanding of Bolivia-Chile relations and to explore the possible solutions for their territorial dispute. Special attention is paid to the negotiation of Charaña, which is considered to be the most important negotiation between the two countries in the 20th century regarding Bolivia’s access to the Pacific Ocean. After careful examination of the case, the authors argue the followings: 1) The ideological similarities between the governments in the two countries turned out to be a significant variable to determine the outcome of dispute resolution process. Historically, the probability of dispute resolution augmented when the governments of both sides shared similar ideology. i. e. the socialist government of Torres in Bolivia with the socialist government of Allende in Chile, the military government of Banzer in Bolivia with the military government of Pinochet in Chile, and the leftist government in Morales in Bolivia with the leftist government in Bachelet in Chile. 2) Peru plays an important role in the dispute resolution. As a participant in the War of the Pacific, Peru reaffirmed during the negotiation process of Charaña its rights written in the 1929 Treaty. 3) The negotiation of Charaña illustrates us the importance of neighboring countries and regional institutions on the territorial dispute resolution. In sum, this research sheds lights on political conditions for the possible resolution of the territorial dispute between Bolivia and Chile.
참고문헌 (28)
- 곽재성, "대외정책의 결정요인을 중심으로 칠레의 대외정책:아옌데 정부와 피노체트 정부의 경험", 이베로아메리카, 7(1), pp.1~33 (2005), 중남미지역원
- Bitar, Sergio, "Un Futuro Común: Chile, Bolivia, Perú: El Norte de Chile en el siglo XX" (2011), Aguilar Chilena de Ediciones S.A
- Bulnes, Gonzalo, "Chile and Peru : the Causes of the War of 1879" (1920), Imprenta Universitaria
- Carvajal Prado, Patricio, "Charaña: un acuerdo entre Chile y Bolivia y el tercero en discordia" (1994), Empresa Editora Arquén
- Correa, Loreto, "Política Exterior de Chile, 1990-2009: Del aislamiento a la integración global" (2012), Ril editores
- Crespo Rodas, Alfonso, "Banzer, el destino de un soldado" (1999), Editorial Gráfica s.r.l
- Dennis, William J., "Tacna and Arica" (1967), Yale University Press
- Fellmann Velarde, J., "Memorandum sobre política exterior boliviana" (1967), Librería Editorial Juventud
- Fernando Guachalla, L., "La cuestión portuaria y las negociaciones de 1950" (1976), Editorial Los Amigos del Libro
- García Argañarás, Fernando, "Memory, History and Identity in Bolivia’s Foreign Policy Toward Chile Under Morales", Symposium Conflict, and Reconciliation: Bridging Past, Present, and Future, January 10-13, 2012, Kigali, Rwanda (2012)
- Gordon, Dennis R., "The Question of the Pacific: Current Perspectives on a Long-Standing Dispute", World Affairs, 141(4), pp.321~335 (1979)
- Gumucio Granier, J., "Estados Unidos y el Mar Boliviano: Testimonios para la historia" (1985), n.p
- "“How Bolivia Lost Its Hat”, The New York Times, June 19, 2012" (2012)[URL]
- Mesa Gisbert, Carlos D., "Historia de Bolivia" (2012), Editorial Gisbert
- Milet, P., "Chile–Bolivia: cien años después", Revista Fuerzas Armadas y Sociedad, 18(2), pp.37~49 (2004)
- Mora, F., "Latin American and Caribbean Foreign Policy" (2003), Lanham, MD
- Morales, Waltraud Q., "A Brief History of Bolivia" (2010), Fact on File, Inc
- Pinochet de la Barra, O., "Chile y Bolivia : ¡hasta cuándo!" (2004), LOM
- Prudencio Lizón, Ramiro, "Historia de la negociación de Charaña" (2011), Plural Editores
- Rodríguez Elizondo, José, "De Charaña a la Haya: Chile, entre la aspiración marítima de Bolivia y la demanda marítima de Perú", Estudios Internacionales, 42(163), pp.151~161 (2009)
- Quitral Rojas, Máximo, "Chile y Bolivia: entre el abrazo de Charaña y sus relaciones económicas, 1975-1990", Revista Universum, 2(25) (2010)
- Sicotte, Richard, "The Fiscal Impact of the War of the Pacific", Cliometrica, (3), pp.97~121 (2009)
- St. John, Ronald Bruce, "Boundaries, Trade, and Seaports: Power Politics in the Atacama Desert" (1992), University of Massachusetts at Amherst
- St John, Ronald Bruce, "Chile, Peru and the Treaty of 1929: The Final Settlement", IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin, ~ (2000)
- Approaches to Solving Territorial Conflicts: Sources, Situations, Scenarios, and Suggestions, "The Carter Center", The Carter Center, ~ (2010)
- Van Der Ree, G., "Chile’s (Inter) National Identities: Framing the Relations with Bolivia and Peru", Bulletin of Latin American Research, 29(2), pp.208~223 (2010)
- From Rivalry to Mutual Trust: The Othering Process between Bolivia and Chile, "Wehner, Leslie", GIGA, ~ (2010)
- Zalles, A., "Bolivia y Chile: los imperativos de una nueva época", Nueva Sociedad, 207(1), pp.34~43 (2007)