니카라과와 콜롬비아의 영토 및 해양 경계 분쟁 연구: 역사적 전개와 시사점을 중심으로
A Study on Territorial and Maritime Boundary Dispute between Nicaragua and Colombia: Historical Development and Implications
1
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study analyzes the territorial and maritime dispute between Nicaragua and Colombia. The long dispute between two countries resulted in a trial at the International Court of Justice. The final verdict from the International Court of Justice created more tension between Colombia and Nicaragua due to the fact that Colombia did not accept the end result from the ICJ while Nicaragua welcomed it. By analyzing the case of territorial conflict between Nicaragua and Colombia, this study indicates that Latin American particularity of territorial conflicts, the small likelihood of full-scale war, derives not only from the fact that the conflict area contains natural resources or is of the strategical importance of the region but also from the fact that persistent historical dispute of boundaries provides incentives to the conflicts. In addition, this study offers a valuable lesson to Korean society regarding its on-going conflict over Dok-do with Japan.
Abstract
This study analyzes the territorial and maritime dispute between Nicaragua and Colombia. The long dispute between two countries resulted in a trial at the International Court of Justice. The final verdict from the International Court of Justice created more tension between Colombia and Nicaragua due to the fact that Colombia did not accept the end result from the ICJ while Nicaragua welcomed it. By analyzing the case of territorial conflict between Nicaragua and Colombia, this study indicates that Latin American particularity of territorial conflicts, the small likelihood of full-scale war, derives not only from the fact that the conflict area contains natural resources or is of the strategical importance of the region but also from the fact that persistent historical dispute of boundaries provides incentives to the conflicts. In addition, this study offers a valuable lesson to Korean society regarding its on-going conflict over Dok-do with Japan.
참고문헌 (26)
- 윤영민, "니카라과․콜롬비아 간 도서영유권 및 해양경계획정 분쟁에 관한 ICJ 판결의 분석 및 시사점", 해사법연구, 25(3), pp.43~82 (2013), 한국해사법학회
- 이용희, "국제판례상 실효적 지배의 개념과 독도에 관한 고찰", Ocean and Polar Research, 35(4), pp.313~322 (2013), 한국해양과학기술원[DOI]
- 이창열, "ICJ, 니카라과와 컬럼비아 간 영토 및 해양경계획정 분쟁 판결", KMI 독도·해양영토 브리핑, 12(210) (2012)
- 이창열, "니카라과, 콜롬비아 대상으로 대륙붕 경계획정 문제 ICJ에 제소", KMU 독도·해양영토 브리핑, 12(226) (2013)
- Abramson, Scott F., "The Historical Origins of Territorial Disputes", American Political Science Review, 110(4), pp.675~698 (2016)
- Alvarado B., "El conflicto fronterizo entre Colombia y Nicaragua: Recuento histórico de una lucha por el territorio", Historia Caribe, 9(25), pp.241~271 (2014)
- Bekker, Pieter, "The World Court Awards Sovereignty Over Several Islands in the Caribbean Sea to Colombia and Fixes a Single Maritime Boundary between Colombia and Nicaragua", Insights, 17(3) (2013)
- Diemer, Christian, "Territorial Questions and Maritime Delimitation with Regard to Nacaragua’s Claims to the San Andrés Archipelago", ZaőRV, 66, pp.167~185 (2006)
- Domínguez, Jorge, "Boundary Dispute in Latin America" (2003)
- Hensel, Paul R., "The Colonial Legacy and Border Stability: Uti Possidetis and Territorial Claims in the Americas", Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the International Studies Association (2004)
- ICJ, "Alleged Violations of Sovereign Rights and Maritime Spaces in the Caribbean Sea (Nicaragua v. Colombia) Fixing of time-limit for the filing by Nicaragua of a written statement of its observations and submissions on the preliminary objections raised by Colombia", ~ (2014)
- ICJ, "Nicaragua institutes proceedings against Colombia asking the Court to definitively determine the question of the delimitation of the continental shelf between Nicaragua and Colombia in the area beyond 200 nautical miles from the Nicaraguan coast", ~ (2013)
- Territorial and Maritime Dispute (Nicaragua v. Colombia), Judgement of 19 Novemebr 2012, "ICJ", ICJ, ~ (2012)
- Lee, Hoon, "Foreign Direct Investment and Territorial Disputes", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 56(4), pp.675~703 (2012)
- Mantilla, Silvia, "La Disputa: Colombo-Nicaragüense" (2009), San Andrés
- Monroy Cabra, "El diferendo entre Colombia y Nocaragua sobre el Archipiélago de San Andrés y Providencia" (2013), Academia Colombiana de Jurisprudencia
- Simmons, Beth A., "Rules over Real Estates: Trade, Territorial Conflict and International Borders as Institutions", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 49(6), pp.823~848 (2005)
- Uribe Vargas, Diego, "El meridiano 82: frontera marítima entre Colombia y Nicaragua" (1999), Universidad de Bogotá Jorge Tadeo Lozano
- "‘고지도에 독도는 우리 땅’ 국제재판선 힘 못쓴다", 한겨레신문[URL]
- BBC Mundo, "Nicaragua, Colombia y el fallo de la Corte de La Haya: ¿quién gana y quién pierde?", ~ (2012)
- Economist, "Colombia and Nicaragua: Hot Waters", ~ (2012)
- Grandes Medios, "El fallo que arrebató a Colombia el 43% de su territorio marítimo sobre el Caribe", ~ (2012)
- Latin Post, "Colombia, Nicaragua Continue Maritime Border Dispute", ~ (2014)
- Reuters, "Colombia leaves pact recognizing U.N. court rulings", ~ (2012)
- The City Paper, "ICJ Claims Jurisdiction in Colombia-Nicaragua Territory Dispute", ~ (2016)
- Vanguardia, "Colombia rechazó el fallo de La Haya", ~ (2012)