한미 FTA 환경협정의 주요쟁점과 평가
Legal issues and Assessment of KORUS FTA Environmental Agreement
0
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In April second 2007, The government of the korea and the United states of america desiring to implement Free Trade Agreement(FTA) in a manner consistent with environmental protection and conservation have agreed an Environmental Agreement. The KORUS FTA Agreement Chapter 20(environment) is made up from article 20.1 to article 20.11 and ANNEX 20-A(covered agreements). The main issues from among these articles are Environmental Agreements(article 20.2), Application and Enforcement of Environmental Law(article 20.3), Opportunities for Public Participation(article 20.7), Environmental Cooperation(article 20.8), and Environmental Consultations and Panel Procedure(article 20.9). They were also disputed with the service and investment agreement in environment related projects and an automobile agreement in relation to air pollution. The environment chapter is the agreements to prescribe agendas can improve the standard of environmental protection with the exertion for environmental protection the independence of environmental policy, the enforcement of environmental cooperation work. The environmental agreements included the KORUS FTA Agreement have the expansive and strong environmental protection models. This is high estimated environmentally. In a this environmental agreements specially, it was frailly evaluated to be excluded an important agreements such as Kyoto protocol, Basel Convention and have the possibility of environmental controls and investment dispute by indirect expropriation. And radical measures of air pollution by the standard easing of discharge gas are demanded. We cannot predict situations after they validate the KORUS FTA. But we have to plan sustainable development and should not overlook possibility which environmental values will be threatened.
Abstract
In April second 2007, The government of the korea and the United states of america desiring to implement Free Trade Agreement(FTA) in a manner consistent with environmental protection and conservation have agreed an Environmental Agreement. The KORUS FTA Agreement Chapter 20(environment) is made up from article 20.1 to article 20.11 and ANNEX 20-A(covered agreements). The main issues from among these articles are Environmental Agreements(article 20.2), Application and Enforcement of Environmental Law(article 20.3), Opportunities for Public Participation(article 20.7), Environmental Cooperation(article 20.8), and Environmental Consultations and Panel Procedure(article 20.9). They were also disputed with the service and investment agreement in environment related projects and an automobile agreement in relation to air pollution. The environment chapter is the agreements to prescribe agendas can improve the standard of environmental protection with the exertion for environmental protection the independence of environmental policy, the enforcement of environmental cooperation work. The environmental agreements included the KORUS FTA Agreement have the expansive and strong environmental protection models. This is high estimated environmentally. In a this environmental agreements specially, it was frailly evaluated to be excluded an important agreements such as Kyoto protocol, Basel Convention and have the possibility of environmental controls and investment dispute by indirect expropriation. And radical measures of air pollution by the standard easing of discharge gas are demanded. We cannot predict situations after they validate the KORUS FTA. But we have to plan sustainable development and should not overlook possibility which environmental values will be threatened.
참고문헌 (25)
- 환경부, "보도자료", 환경부, ~ (2007)
- 환경부, "한미 FTA 환경분야 추가협의 결과, 자료2", 환경부, ~ (2007)
- 환경부, "한미FTA 환경협상결과 및 향후대책", 환경부, ~ (2007)
- "한미FTA 상세설명자료", 관계부처합동, ~ (2007)
- 한미 FTA 협정문 분석보고서4, 한미 FTA 환경분야평가보고, , 민주사회를 위한 변호사모임, ~ (2007)
- 강은주, "한미FTA와 환경, 한미FTA 환경쟁점 토론회 토론문", 한미FTA 환경대책위원회 (2007)
- 김관호, "한미 FTA와 간접수용: 국내 재산권 보호 제도에의 시사점", 규제연구, 16(1), pp.37~66 (2007), 한국규제학회
- 김영한, "한미FTA - 그 본질과 허상", 철학과 현실, 통권 : 71 (2006), 철학문화연구소
- 김진현, "국제환경협약의 국내적 수용과 규범적 통합 및 합치성", 비교법학연구, 5 (2005), 한국비교법학회
- 김철수, "環境權考", 헌법논총, 6 (1995), 헌법재판소
- 박근수, "신자유주의와 한미FTA", 지역사회地, 통권 : 54 (2006), 한국지역사회연구소
- 박태현, "한미FTA 투자협정과 간접수용문제(휘발류자동차 배출허용기준 및 투자자 국가소송을 중심으로)", 한미FTA 환경쟁점 토론회 발표문 (2007), 한미FTA 환경대책위원회
- 박현수, "한미 FTA 협상 타결과 한국경제의 미래" (2007), 삼성경제연구소
- 신부남, "FTA와 환경주권", 서울경제신문 기고문, ~ (2007)
- 전창환, "한미 FTA 협상 결정의 배경과 그 파장", 동향과 전망, 통권 : 67 (2006), 한국사회과학연구소
- 정서용, "한미FTA와 환경조항", 서울경제신문, 2007
- 조은래, "환경법" (2003), 세종출판사
- 여영학, "한미FTA가 환경제도 및 법률, 국제환경협약이행에 미치는 영향", 한미 FTA가 환경과 생명에 미치는 영향 발표문(한미FTA 환경대책위원회 토론회), 한국환경회의, ~ (2006)
- 이규용, "환경보전과 한ㆍ미 FTA 협상", 아시아 경제신문, ~ (2007)
- 한미 FTA와 환경, 무역협회제공 연구보고서, "이재형", FTA 국내대책위원회, ~ (2006)
- 이정우, "WTO 分爭解決節次의 問題點-이행절차를 중심으로-", 고시계, 통권 : 579 (2005), 고시계사
- 이종근, "미국헌법상의 규제적 수용의 법리", 토지공법연구, 37 (2007), 한국토지공법학회
- 이종탁, "자동차분야 협상타결과 환경정책의 후퇴", 한미FTA 환경쟁점 토론회 발표문, 한미FTA 환경대책위원회, ~ (2007)
- 이해영, "한미 FTA의 소위 ‘경제효과 비판", 문화과학, 통권 : 45 (2006), 문화과학사
