Spectrophotometric evaluation of restorative composite shades and their match with a classical shade guide
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives: The aim of this study was to verify the match between 5 shades of composites from different manufacturers with a shade guide and among the systems using a portable spectrophotometer. Materials and Methods: Shade measurements were performed on specimens of Z350 XT (3M ESPE), Charisma Diamond (Heraeus Kulzer GmbH), Esthet X-HD (Dentsply Caulk), and Empress Direct (Ivoclar-Vivadent) for shades A1, A2, A3, B1, and C3 using a Vita Easyshade spectrophotometer (Vita Zahnfabrik) against a white background. Corresponding shades of Vitapan Classical (Vita Zahnfabrik) guide were measured likewise and shade variation (ΔE) was calculated based on International Commission on Illumination L*a*b* parameters. The ΔE of the composites in each shade was compared by one-way analysis of variance and Tukey's post hoc test (α = 0.05). Results: All composites presented ΔE > 3.7 compared with the shade guide. Variation in shades A3, B1, and C3 was significantly different for all composites. ΔE of Z350 XT was significantly lower for A1 than for the other shades, whereas ΔE of Z350 XT and Charisma Diamond were significantly lower for A2 than for the other shades. Conclusions: No composite shade matched with the shade guide. Equivalent shades of the restorative composite from different manufacturers may show clinically noticeable ΔE.
Abstract
Objectives: The aim of this study was to verify the match between 5 shades of composites from different manufacturers with a shade guide and among the systems using a portable spectrophotometer. Materials and Methods: Shade measurements were performed on specimens of Z350 XT (3M ESPE), Charisma Diamond (Heraeus Kulzer GmbH), Esthet X-HD (Dentsply Caulk), and Empress Direct (Ivoclar-Vivadent) for shades A1, A2, A3, B1, and C3 using a Vita Easyshade spectrophotometer (Vita Zahnfabrik) against a white background. Corresponding shades of Vitapan Classical (Vita Zahnfabrik) guide were measured likewise and shade variation (ΔE) was calculated based on International Commission on Illumination L*a*b* parameters. The ΔE of the composites in each shade was compared by one-way analysis of variance and Tukey's post hoc test (α = 0.05). Results: All composites presented ΔE > 3.7 compared with the shade guide. Variation in shades A3, B1, and C3 was significantly different for all composites. ΔE of Z350 XT was significantly lower for A1 than for the other shades, whereas ΔE of Z350 XT and Charisma Diamond were significantly lower for A2 than for the other shades. Conclusions: No composite shade matched with the shade guide. Equivalent shades of the restorative composite from different manufacturers may show clinically noticeable ΔE.
참고문헌 (27)
- Glockner K, "Visual vs. spectrophotometric methods for shade selection", Coll Antropol, 39, pp.801~802 (2015)
- Miyajiwala JS, "Comparison of photographic and conventional methods for tooth shade selection: a clinical evaluation", J Indian Prosthodont Soc, 17, pp.273~281 (2017)
- Bergen SF, "Dental operatory lighting and tooth color discrimination", J Am Dent Assoc, 94, pp.130~134 (1977)
- Kim BJ, "Influence of the shade designation on the color difference between the same shade-designated resin composites by the brand", Dent Mater, 25, pp.1148~1154 (2009)
- Lee YK, "Shade compatibility of esthetic restorative materials--A review", Dent Mater, 26, pp.1119~1126 (2010)
- Browning WD, "Color differences: polymerized composite and corresponding Vitapan Classical shade tab", J Dent, 37(Supplement 1), pp.e34~e39 (2009)
- Lehmann KM, "Four color-measuring devices compared with a spectrophotometric reference system", J Dent, 38(Supplement 2), pp.e65~e70 (2010)
- Oh WS, "Estimation of visual shade matching errors with 2 shade guides", Quintessence Int, 40, pp.833~836 (2009)
- Paolone G, "Composite shade guides and color matching", Int J Esthet Dent, 9, pp.164~182 (2014)
- Swift EJ Jr, "Colorimetric evaluation of vita shade resin composites", Int J Prosthodont, 7, pp.356~361 (1994)
- Igiel C, "Reliability of visual and instrumental color matching", J Esthet Restor Dent, 29, pp.303~308 (2017)
- Yılmaz B, "Outcomes of visual tooth shade selection performed by operators with different experience", J Esthet Restor Dent, 31, pp.500~507 (2019)
- Barutcigil C, "The color differences of direct esthetic restorative materials after setting and compared with a shade guide", J Am Dent Assoc, 142, pp.658~665 (2011)
- Hassel AJ, "Comparing L*a*b* color coordinates for natural teeth shades and corresponding shade tabs using a spectrophotometer", Int J Prosthodont, 22, pp.72~74 (2009)
- Kim HS, "Color differences between resin composites and shade guides", Quintessence Int, 27, pp.559~567 (1996)
- Paravina RD, "Color compatibility of resin composites of identical shade designation", Quintessence Int, 37, pp.713~719 (2006)
- Sampaio CS, "Dental shade guide variability for hues B, C, and D using cross-polarized photography", Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent, 38, pp.s113~s118 (2018)
- Nakhaei M, "The influence of dental shade guides and experience on the accuracy of shade matching", J Contemp Dent Pract, 17, pp.22~26 (2016)
- Alvim HH, "Analysis of camphorquinone in composite resins as a function of shade", Dent Mater, 23, pp.1245~1249 (2007)
- Rodrigo Rocha Maia, "Comparison of light-transmittance in dental tissues and dental composite restorations using incremental layering build-up with varying enamel resin layer thickness", Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics, 43(2), pp.1~9 (2018), 대한치과보존학회
- Salgado VE, "Influence of photoinitiator system and nanofiller size on the optical properties and cure efficiency of model composites", Dent Mater, 30, pp.e264~e271 (2014)
- Azzopardi N, "Effect of resin matrix composition on the translucency of experimental dental composite resins", Dent Mater, 25, pp.1564~1568 (2009)
- Chu SJ, "Dental color matching instruments and systems. Review of clinical and research aspects", J Dent, 38(Supplement 2), pp.e2~e16 (2010)
- Elgendy H, "Comparison of light propagation in dental tissues and nano-filled resin-based composite", Clin Oral Investig, 23, pp.423~433 (2019)
- Gulamali AB, "Survival analysis of composite Dahl restorations provided to manage localised anterior tooth wear (ten year follow-up)", Br Dent J, 211, pp.E9~ (2011)
- Moura FR, "Three-year clinical performance of composite restorations placed by undergraduate dental students", Braz Dent J, 22, pp.111~116 (2011)
- Wolff D, "Recontouring teeth and closing diastemas with direct composite buildups: a clinical evaluation of survival and quality parameters", J Dent, 38, pp.1001~1009 (2010)