치료냐 예방이냐? 결핵 퇴치 운동의 우선권 논의: 20세기 전환기 프랑스를 중심으로
Treatment or Prevention? the matter of Priority in the Anti-tuberculosis Movement at the Turn of the 20th Century France
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The purpose of this paper is to analyze discussions on the matter of priority in treatment and prevention that took place in the medical community, the government and social hygiene associations to tuberculosis referred to as one of the national calamity in France at the turn of the 20th century. In other words, it is to show that treatment and prevention have complementary properties in France’s anti-tuberculosis movement, considering the discussions on which institutions should preferably be expanded - between the Sanatorium that values medical treatment and the anti-tuberculosis dispensary that values social prevention. Tuberculosis, which is known to have existed from the ancient times, spread to the era of industrialization and urbanization, resulting in a large loss of lives in the second half of the 19th century following cholera in the first half of the century. Starting in Germany in the middle of this century, Sanatorium established a treatment for tuberculosis patients with air therapy, proper exercise or rest, and diet. In France, a public Sanatorium was built for the lower class, not like a luxury resort style Sanatorium for the wealthy class, from the 1890s. The spread was slow, however, due to financial problems. In the 1900s, anti-tuberculosis dispensary as a health center were increasingly built in working class quarters. The debate over whether to support the sanatorium or the dispensary was ignited at first, but since the mid-to-late 1900s, the two institutions’ roles, namely, medical treatment and social prevention, have been recognized as complementary. The Anti-tuberculosis dispensary Act of 1916 and the Sanatorium Act of 1919 systematically supported the complementary relationship between treatment and prevention in fighting against tuberculosis.
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to analyze discussions on the matter of priority in treatment and prevention that took place in the medical community, the government and social hygiene associations to tuberculosis referred to as one of the national calamity in France at the turn of the 20th century. In other words, it is to show that treatment and prevention have complementary properties in France’s anti-tuberculosis movement, considering the discussions on which institutions should preferably be expanded - between the Sanatorium that values medical treatment and the anti-tuberculosis dispensary that values social prevention. Tuberculosis, which is known to have existed from the ancient times, spread to the era of industrialization and urbanization, resulting in a large loss of lives in the second half of the 19th century following cholera in the first half of the century. Starting in Germany in the middle of this century, Sanatorium established a treatment for tuberculosis patients with air therapy, proper exercise or rest, and diet. In France, a public Sanatorium was built for the lower class, not like a luxury resort style Sanatorium for the wealthy class, from the 1890s. The spread was slow, however, due to financial problems. In the 1900s, anti-tuberculosis dispensary as a health center were increasingly built in working class quarters. The debate over whether to support the sanatorium or the dispensary was ignited at first, but since the mid-to-late 1900s, the two institutions’ roles, namely, medical treatment and social prevention, have been recognized as complementary. The Anti-tuberculosis dispensary Act of 1916 and the Sanatorium Act of 1919 systematically supported the complementary relationship between treatment and prevention in fighting against tuberculosis.
참고문헌 (72)
- Administration générale de l’Assistance publique à Paris, "L’oeuvre de l’Assistance publique à Paris contre la tuberculose (1896-1905)", Congrés international de la tuberculose (1905), Berger-Levrault
- Alliance d’hygiène sociale, "Congrés de Lyon 13-16 mai 1907 (Bordeaux: Mutualité, 1907)", Alliance d’hygiène sociale, Congrés de Paris (1913), Mutualité
- Rapport fait au nom de la commission d‟hygiène publique sur les mesures à prendre pour arrêter les progrès de la tuberculose, "Amodru, M.", ~, pp.Documents parlementaires, chambre, annexe n.2464 (1901)
- Armaingaud, A., "De la décroissance de la mortalité par tuberculose en Allemagne, ses causes réelles" (1904), Imp. G. Gounouilhou
- Artaud, G., "La lutte contre la tuberculose. Tuberculose et sanatoriums populaires" (1914), F. Alcan
- Baché, Y., "Le sanatorium: son utilité dans la lutte antituberculeuse" (1934)
- Bernard, L., "Le dispensaire Léon-Bourgeois", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 35 (1913)
- Bertillon, Jacques, "De la Frequence des principales causes de déces à Paris pendant la second moitié du XIXe siècle et notamment pendant la période 1886-1905" (1906), Imp. Municipale
- Blum, P., "Un Dispensaire d’ouvrière d’usines de guerre : la prophylaxie à l’usine", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 41 (1919)
- Brehmer, Goerbersdorf, "Etablissement thérapeutique pour les maladies de poitrine" (1887), Orell Füssli & Cie
- Brouardel, P., "Annales d’hygiène et de médecine légale" (1899)
- Brouardel, P., "La lutte internationale contre la tuberculose", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 23 (1901)
- Brunon, R., "Les sanatoriums de fortune pour les tuberculeux pauvres", Bulletin de l’Académie de médecine, 2 (1901)
- Calmette, A., "Le dispensaire antituberculeux Emile Roux à Lille", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 23 (1901)
- Calmette, A., "Les préventoriums ou dispensaires de prophylaxie sociale antituberculeuse, le préventorium Emile-Roux de Lille, 1901-1903" (1905), L. Danel
- Calmette, A., "Essai d’immunisation contre l’infection tuberculeuse", Bulletin de l’Académie nationale de médecine, 91 (1924)
- Clark, J., "The Influence of Climate in the Prevention and Cure of Chronic Diseases : More Particularly of the Chest and Digestive Organs" (1830), John Murray
- Commission de la tuberculose, "La Propagation de la tuberculose. Moyens pratiques de combattre" (1900), Masson
- Congrès international de la tuberculose, "Congrès international de la tuberculose", Rapports présentéau congrès (1905), Masson
- "Congrès pour l‟étude de la tuberculose humaine et animale", evue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 10 (1888)
- "Congrès pour l‟étude de la tuberculose humaine et animale", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 13 (1891)
- "Congrès de la tuberculose", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 15 (1893)
- Dehau, H., "La Lutte antituberculeuse en France" (1906), Masson
- Dettweiler, P., "Traitement hygiénique de la phtisie" (1888), Alcan
- Dislère, P., "Les dispensaires antituberculeux, Assemblée générale des Dames patronnesses du 9 janvier 1903, Œuvre de la tuberculose humaine" (1903), société philanthropique des dispensaires antituberculeux français
- Drouineau, G., "Congrès de la tuberculose", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 15 (1893)
- Dujat, Charles, "De la cachexie tuberculeuse; influence des climats sur la production et le traitement des affections tuberculeuses", pp.1937
- Foville, A., "Les dispensaires pour enfants malades", Annales d’hygiène publique et de médecine légale, 16(3) (1886)
- Frollo, J., "La lutte contre la Tuberculose", Le Petit Parisien, 28 (1898)
- Girard-Mangin, N., "Essai sur l’hygiène et la prophylaxie antituberculeuses au début du XXe siècle" (1913), Masson
- Grillot, H, "Lutte contre la tuberculose, le sanatorium français, sa possibilité, son organisation" (1901), C Naud
- Guinard, L., "La pratique des sanatoriums" (1925), Masson
- "Journal officiel de la République française", ~ (1916)
- Knopf, S.-A., "Les sanatoria. Traitement et prophylaxie de la phtisie pulmonaire" (1900), Carré et Naud
- Labarthe, P., "Dictionnaire populaire de médecine usuelle, tome 1" (1887), Marpon et Flammarion
- Laënnec, R., "De l’auscultation médiate ou Traité du diagnostic des maladies des poumons et du coeur, fondé principalement sur ce nouveau moyen d’exploration" (1819), J.A. Brosson et J.S. Chaudé
- Léon-Petit, E.-P., "Le phtisique et son traitement hygiénique : sanatoria, hôpitaux spéciaux, cure d’air" (1895), Alcan
- Letulle, M., "Le sanatorium populaire antituberculeux, œuvre de solidarité et de préservation sociale", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 23 (1901)
- Masson, G., "IVe Congrès pour l‟étude de la tuberculose", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 20 (1898)
- "Congrès antituberculeux de Berlin", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 21 (1899)
- Mesureur, A, "L’œuvre de l’Assistance Publique à Paris contre la tuberculose, Congrès international de la tuberculose" (1905), Berger-Levrault
- Mosny, E., "La lutte contre la tuberculose, maladie populaire, par le sanatorium, établissement de cure d’air et école de prophylaxie", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 23 (1901)
- Vallin, E., "Congrès britannique pour la préservation de la tuberculose", Revue d’hygiène et de police sanitaire, 23 (1901)
- Villemin, J. -A., "Etudes sur la tuberculose : preuves rationnelles et expérimentales de sa spécificité et de son inoculabilité" (1868), J. B. Baillière et fils
- Waldeck-Rousseau, P., "Action Républicaine et sociale" (1903), Charpentier
- 민유기, "파리의 공중보건 활동과 결핵 퇴치 운동(1889~1919)", 도시연구: 역사·사회·문화, (28), pp.35~66 (2021), 도시사학회[DOI]
- 민유기, "감염병 예방을 위한 도시위생 및 건축 규정 변화 : 20세기 초 파리를 중심으로", 서울학연구, (88), pp.37~66 (2022), 서울학연구소[DOI]
- 손은정, "한국의 결핵 현황 및 국가결핵관리사업", 대한의사협회지, 64(4), pp.316~323 (2021), 대한의사협회
- Barnes, David S., "The Making of a Social Disease : tuberculosis in nineteenth-century France" (1995), University of California Press
- Berche, P., "Une histoire des microbes" (2007), Editions John Libbey Eurotexte
- Burke, D., "Of postulates and peccadilloes : Robert Koch and vaccine(tuberculin)therapy for tuberculosis", Vaccine, 11, pp.795~804 (1993)
- Cremnitzer, J.-B., "Architecture et santé. Le temps du sanatorium en France et en Europe" (2005), Picard
- Daniel, Thomas M., "The history of tuberculosis", Respiratory Medicine, 100 (2006)
- Démier, F., "Les maux & les soins : Médecins et malades dans les hôpitaux parisiens au XIXe siècle", pp.1862~1870 (2007), Action artistique de la Ville de Paris
- Dessertine, D., "Combattre la tuberculose, 1900-1940" (1988), Presses universitaires de Lyon
- Faure, O., "La médecine gratuite au XIXe siècle : de la charité à l’assistance", Histoire, économie et société, 4, pp.593~608 (1984)
- Girond, J., "Aperçu d’ensemble sur la législation antituberculeuse", pp.1948
- Grandvoinnet, Ph, "Architecture thérapeutique. Histoire des sanatoriums en France(1900-1945)" (2014), Métis Presses
- Guillaume, P., "Du désespoir au salut : les tuberculeux aux XIXe et XXe siècles" (1986), Aubier
- Hayman, J., "Mycobacterium ulcerans : an infection from Jurassic time?", Lancet, 324(8410), pp.1015~1016 (1984)
- Jadot, C., "Réflexions sur le sanatorium pour tuberculeux pulmonaires(sanatorium de Boscamnant)", pp.1944
- Jankowski, L., "Le patrimoine des communes. Seine-Saint-Denis" (1994), Editions Flohic
- Lamoureux, David, "Le combat des cheminots contre la tuberculose(1919-1939)", Revue d’Histote de la Protection sociale, 1, pp.59~77 (2008)
- Murard, L., "L’hygiène dans la République: la santé publique en France, ou l’utopie contrariée 1870-1918" (1996), Fayard
- Murray, John F., "Treatment of Tuberculosis. A Historical Perspective", Annals of the American Thoracic Society, 12(12), pp.1749~1759 (2015)
- Poncelet, Sylvie, "Le dispensaire antituberculeux ou la difficile émergence d’un établissement prophylactique (1901-1943)", pp.2020
- Salomon-bayet, Claire, "Pasteur et la revolution pastorienne" (1986), Payot
- Seignan, Gérard, "L’hygiène sociale au XIXe siècle : une physiologie morale", Revue d’histoire du XIXe siècle, 40, pp.113~130 (2010)
- Simonet, M., "Albert Calmette, le père de la sérothérapie antivenimeuse et de la vaccination antituberculeuse", Revue de Biologie Médicale, 349, pp.43~54 (2019)
- Toulier, B., "Histoire et réhabilitation des sanatoriums en Europe" (2008), DoCoMoMo
- Viet, V., "La santé en guerre 1914-1918: Une politique pionnière en univers incertain" (2015), Presses de Sciences Po
- Wilson, Leonard G., "The historical decline of tuberculosis in Europe and America : its causes and significance", Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 45(3), pp.366~396 (1990)