미국 의료시스템과학 교육의 한국 도입과 그 비판
Introduction of America’s Health Systems Science Education and Its Criticism
1
조회
0
다운로드
7
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Recently, Korean medical education circles have proposed a full- scale introduction of America’s health systems science to replace the existing medical humanities education in Korea. The so-called Flexner education system, formed in the early 20th century, was centered on basic and clinical sciences. America’s health systems science education was introduced to supplement the system. The full-scale introduction of health systems science has been promoted, mainly by the Korean Association of Medical Colleges. However, it does not fit into the current circumstance of Korean medical education circles. It is deemed that there are political reasons behind the push – the alignment of interests between the medical education circles and the government. This study first examined the social and cultural circumstances behind the emergence of health systems science in America, focusing on pragmatism, a native American ideology, to critique the background of the introduction of the American system. It also discussed the negative aspects of pragmatism in American medical education in the cases of American educators Ralph Tyler and Abraham Flexner. Then, it specifically examined the background and reasons for introducing America’s health systems science to Korea and discussed the problems of directly introducing the health systems science to Korea without any adaptation process through a comparative analysis with existing medical humanities. Finally, it suggested a more desirable adaptation form of health systems science that can be considered for its implementation in Korea.
Abstract
Recently, Korean medical education circles have proposed a full- scale introduction of America’s health systems science to replace the existing medical humanities education in Korea. The so-called Flexner education system, formed in the early 20th century, was centered on basic and clinical sciences. America’s health systems science education was introduced to supplement the system. The full-scale introduction of health systems science has been promoted, mainly by the Korean Association of Medical Colleges. However, it does not fit into the current circumstance of Korean medical education circles. It is deemed that there are political reasons behind the push – the alignment of interests between the medical education circles and the government. This study first examined the social and cultural circumstances behind the emergence of health systems science in America, focusing on pragmatism, a native American ideology, to critique the background of the introduction of the American system. It also discussed the negative aspects of pragmatism in American medical education in the cases of American educators Ralph Tyler and Abraham Flexner. Then, it specifically examined the background and reasons for introducing America’s health systems science to Korea and discussed the problems of directly introducing the health systems science to Korea without any adaptation process through a comparative analysis with existing medical humanities. Finally, it suggested a more desirable adaptation form of health systems science that can be considered for its implementation in Korea.
참고문헌 (41)
- "의사신문", ~
- 김보규, "거리로 나오게 된 의대생" (2020), 조윤커뮤니케이션
- 인제대학교 의과대학, "인제대학교 의과대학 교육요람", ~ (2019)
- 한국의과대학ㆍ의학전문대학원협회, "기본의학교육 학습성과: 사람과 사회 중심", ~ (2017)
- 한국의과대학ㆍ의학전문대학원협회, "의료와 사회의 통합적 이해와 실천을 위한 보건의료시스템과학 교육체제 구축 사업", ~ (2021)
- 한국의학교육평가원, "의학교육 평가인증 기준 및 규정", ~ (2010)
- 한국의학교육평가원, "ASK2019 의학교육 평가인증 기준", ~ (2018)
- 한국의학교육학회, "의학교육백서 제3집: 해운대 보고서" (2014)
- World Federation for Medical Education, "Basic medical education WFME global standards for quality improvement : The 2015 revision", WFME office, ~ (2015)
- 기창덕, "한국근대의학교육사" (1995), 아카데미아
- 김동식, "프래그머티즘" (2002), 아카넷
- 김성근, "근대 일본의 서양학문 수용과 ‘학역(學域)’의 형성-자연과학과 인문･사회과학의 분리를 중심으로", 동서철학연구, (99), pp.191~216 (2021), 한국동서철학회[DOI]
- 김은정, "타일러 모형의 학습자 중심 관점에 대한 고찰", 학습전략중재연구, 9(2), pp.13~32 (2018)
- 김장한, "의사외전 : 대한민국에서 의사로 산다는 것" (2021), 허원미디어
- 김학준, "타일러 논리의 재음미: ‘교사배제 교육과정’의 맥락에서", 교육과정연구, 31(3), pp.1~26 (2013), 한국교육과정학회[DOI]
- 듀이, 존, "민주주의와 교육" (2007), 교육과학사
- 듀이, 존, "인간 본성과 행위 Ⅰ" (2020), 봄
- 듀이, 존, "인간 본성과 행위 Ⅱ" (2020), 봄
- 린드버그, 데이비드 C., "서양과학의 기원들" (2009), 나남출판사
- 박채형, "타일러의 교육과정 모형 : 매력과 함정", 도덕교육연구, 20(1), pp.27~48 (2008), 한국도덕교육학회
- 반덕진, "히포크라테스 선서" (2006), 사이언스 북스
- 서재복, "교육의 역사와 철학" (2018), 공동체
- 스타, 폴, "미국 의료의 사회사" (2012), 대한의사협회 의료정책연구소
- 신일철, "현대철학사상의 새 흐름" (1987), 집문당
- 엄정식, "프래그머티즘과 미국문화의 수용", 서강인문논총, 5, pp.75~100 (1996)
- 우튼, 데이비드, "의학의 진실" (2007), 마티
- 이영환, "우리나라 의학교육의 역사 : 의학교육이 걸어온 길과 나아갈 길" (2022), 대한민국의학한림원
- 이홍우, "미국 교육학의 정체" (2018), 교육과학사
- 전우택, "보건의료 시스템과학", 의학교육논단, 20(1), pp.60~61 (2018)
- 전우택, "인문사회의학" (2010), 청년의사
- 전우택, "인문사회의학과 의학교육의 미래" (2003), 연세대학교 출판부
- 토버, 알프레드, "어느 의사의 고백" (2003), 지호
- 플렉스너, 에이브러햄, "플렉스너 보고서 : 미국과 캐나다의 의학교육" (2005), 한길사
- 한기철, "교육철학 방법으로서의 프래그머티즘 재음미: 프랙티스의 교육적 의미를 중심으로", 교육사상연구, 24(1), pp.177~203 (2010), 한국교육사상학회[DOI]
- Cooke, Molly, "Educating physicians : a call for reform of medical school and residency" (2010), Jossey-Bass
- Duffy, Thomas P., "The Flexner Report ― 100 Years Later", Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine, 84(3), pp.269~276 (2011)
- Medical Professionalism Project, "Medical professionalism in the new millennium : a physicians’ charter", Lancet, 359, pp.520~522 (2002)
- Morcke, Anne M., "Outcome(competency)based education : an exploration of its origins, theoretical basis, and empirical evidence", Advances in Health Sciences Education, 18(4), pp.851~863 (2013)
- Skochelak, Susan E., "Health Systems Science" (2017), Elsevier
- Skochelak, Susan E., "Health Systems Science" (2021), Elsevier
- Tyler, Ralph W., "Basic principles of curriculum and instruction" (1949), The University of Chicago Press