Monolithic zirconia crowns: effect of thickness reduction on fatigue behavior and failure load
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
PURPOSE. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of thickness reduction and fatigue on the failure load of monolithic zirconia crowns. MATERIALS AND METHODS. 140 CAD-CAM fabricated crowns (3Y-TZP, inCorisTZI, Dentsply-Sirona) with different ceramic thicknesses (2.0, 1.5, 1.0, 0.8, 0.5 mm, respectively, named G2, G1.5, G1, G0.8, and G0.5) were investigated. Dies of a mandibular first molar were made of composite resin. The zirconia crowns were luted with a resin composite cement (RelyX Unicem 2 Automix, 3M ESPE). Half of the specimens (n = 14 per group) were mouth-motion-fatigued (1.2 million cycles, 1.6 Hz, 200 N/ 5 - 55°C, groups named G2-F, G1.5-F, G1-F, G0.8-F, and G0.5-F). Single-load to failure was performed using a universal testing-machine. Fracture modes were analyzed. Data were statistically analyzed using a Weibull 2-parameter distribution (90% CI) to determine the characteristic strength and Weibull modulus differences among the groups. RESULTS. Three crowns (21%) of G0.8 and five crowns (36%) of G0.5 showed cracks after fatigue. Characteristic strength was the highest for G2, followed by G1.5. Intermediate values were observed for G1 and G1-F, followed by significantly lower values for G0.8, G0.8-F, and G0.5, and the lowest for G0.5-F. Weibull modulus was the lowest for G0.8, intermediate for G0.8-F and G0.5, and significantly higher for the remaining groups. Fatigue only affected G0.5-F. CONCLUSION. Reduced crown thickness lead to reduced characteristic strength, even under failure loads that exceed physiological chewing forces. Fatigue significantly reduced the failure load of 0.5 mm monolithic 3Y-TZP crowns.
Abstract
PURPOSE. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of thickness reduction and fatigue on the failure load of monolithic zirconia crowns. MATERIALS AND METHODS. 140 CAD-CAM fabricated crowns (3Y-TZP, inCorisTZI, Dentsply-Sirona) with different ceramic thicknesses (2.0, 1.5, 1.0, 0.8, 0.5 mm, respectively, named G2, G1.5, G1, G0.8, and G0.5) were investigated. Dies of a mandibular first molar were made of composite resin. The zirconia crowns were luted with a resin composite cement (RelyX Unicem 2 Automix, 3M ESPE). Half of the specimens (n = 14 per group) were mouth-motion-fatigued (1.2 million cycles, 1.6 Hz, 200 N/ 5 - 55°C, groups named G2-F, G1.5-F, G1-F, G0.8-F, and G0.5-F). Single-load to failure was performed using a universal testing-machine. Fracture modes were analyzed. Data were statistically analyzed using a Weibull 2-parameter distribution (90% CI) to determine the characteristic strength and Weibull modulus differences among the groups. RESULTS. Three crowns (21%) of G0.8 and five crowns (36%) of G0.5 showed cracks after fatigue. Characteristic strength was the highest for G2, followed by G1.5. Intermediate values were observed for G1 and G1-F, followed by significantly lower values for G0.8, G0.8-F, and G0.5, and the lowest for G0.5-F. Weibull modulus was the lowest for G0.8, intermediate for G0.8-F and G0.5, and significantly higher for the remaining groups. Fatigue only affected G0.5-F. CONCLUSION. Reduced crown thickness lead to reduced characteristic strength, even under failure loads that exceed physiological chewing forces. Fatigue significantly reduced the failure load of 0.5 mm monolithic 3Y-TZP crowns.
참고문헌 (59)
- "Facts & Figures 2021"[URL]
- "Dental crowns & bridges market size worth $3.8 Billion By 2026 June 2019"[URL]
- Zhao K, "Influence of veneer application on fracture behavior of lithium-disilicate-based ceramic crowns", Dent Mater, 28, pp.653~660 (2012)
- Sailer I, "All-ceramic or metal-ceramic tooth-supported fixed dental prostheses (FDPs)? A systematic review of the survival and complication rates. Part I: Single crowns (SCs)", Dent Mater, 31, pp.603~623 (2015)
- Makhija SK, "Dentist material selection for single-unit crowns : Findings from the National Dental Practice-Based Research Network", J Dent, 55, pp.40~47 (2016)
- Ma L, "Load-bearing properties of minimal-invasive monolithic lithium disilicate and zirconia occlusal onlays : finite element and theoretical analyses", Dent Mater, 29, pp.742~751 (2013)
- Zhang Y, "Novel zirconia materials in dentistry", J Dent Res, 97, pp.140~147 (2018)
- Al-Amleh B, "Clinical trials in zirconia : a systematic review", J Oral Rehabil, 37, pp.641~652 (2010)
- Johansson C, "Fracture strength of monolithic all-ceramic crowns made of high translucent yttrium oxide-stabilized zirconium dioxide compared to porcelain-veneered crowns and lithium disilicate crowns", Acta Odontol Scand, 72, pp.145~153 (2014)
- Lameira DP, "Fracture strength of aged monolithic and bilayer zirconia-based crowns", Biomed Res Int, 2015, pp.418641~ (2015)
- Sun T, "Load-bearing capacity and the recommended thickness of dental monolithic zirconia single crowns", J Mech Behav Biomed Mater, 35, pp.93~101 (2014)
- Miura S, "Clinical evaluation of monolithic zirconia crowns: a failure analysis of clinically obtained cases from a 3.5-year study", J Prosthodont Res, 65, pp.148~154 (2021)
- Kontonasaki E, "Monolithic zirconia: an update to current knowledge. optical properties, wear, and clinical performance", Dent J(Basel), 7, pp.90~ (2019)
- Miyazaki T, "Current status of zirconia restoration", J Prosthodont Res, 57, pp.236~261 (2013)
- Guess PC, "Monolithic CAD", CAM lithium disilicate versus veneered Y-TZP crowns : comparison of failure modes and reliability after fatigue, 2010, pp.23, 434~442
- Swain MV, "Thermal induced deflection of a porcelain-zirconia bilayer : Influence of cooling rate", Dent Mater, 35, pp.574~584 (2019)
- Vigolo P, "Evaluation of zirconium-oxide-based ceramic single-unit posterior fixed dental prostheses(FDPs)generated with two CAD", CAM systems compared to porcelain-fused-to-metal single-unit posterior FDPs : a 5-year clinical prospective study, 2012, pp.21, 265~269
- Beuer F, "In vitro performance of full-contour zirconia single crowns", Dent Mater, 28, pp.449~456 (2012)
- Nakamura K, "Fracture resistance of monolithic zirconia molar crowns with reduced thickness", Acta Odontol Scand, 73, pp.602~608 (2015)
- Bömicke W, "Short-term prospective clinical evaluation of monolithic and partially veneered zirconia single crowns", J Esthet Restor Dent, 29, pp.22~30 (2017)
- Gunge H, "Retrospective clinical evaluation of posterior monolithic zirconia restorations after 1 to 3.5 years of clinical service", J Oral Sci, 60, pp.154~158 (2018)
- Solá-Ruiz MF, "Prospective study of monolithic zirconia crowns : clinical behavior and survival rate at a 5-year follow-up", J Prosthodont Res, 65, pp.284~290 (2021)
- Yadel Hazır Tekin, "Fracture resistance and marginal fit of the zirconia crowns with varied occlusal thickness", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 12(5), pp.283~290 (2020), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- Paul Weigl, "In-vitro performance and fracture strength of thin monolithic zirconia crowns", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 10(2), pp.79~84 (2018), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- Sorrentino R, "In vitro analysis of the fracture resistance of CAD-CAM monolithic zirconia molar crowns with different occlusal thickness", J Mech Behav Biomed Mater, 61, pp.328~333 (2016)
- Nordahl N, "Fracture strength of ceramic monolithic crown systems of different thickness", J Oral Sci, 57, pp.255~261 (2015)
- Gierthmuehlen P, "Effect of reduced material thickness on fatigue behavior and failure load of monolithic CAD", CAM PICN molar crowns, 2019, pp.32, 71~74
- "Dentsply Sirona GmbH. inCoris TZI 2021"[URL]
- Kern M, "Wear of composite resin vehttpsneering materials in a dual-axis chewing simulator", J Oral Rehabil, 26, pp.372~378 (1999)
- DeLong R, "The wear of dental amalgam in an artificial mouth : a clinical correlation", Dent Mater, 1, pp.238~242 (1985)
- Abernethy R, "The New Weibull Handbook. Reliability and statistical analysis for predicting life, safety, survivability, risk, cost and warranty claims" (2006)
- Ferrario VF, "Maximal bite forces in healthy young adults as predicted by surface electromyography", J Dent, 32, pp.451~457 (2004)
- Ivoclar Vivadent GmbH, "IPS e.max ZirCAD Labside -Gebrauchsinformation 2019. Provided by manufacturer", ~ (2019)
- "VITA YZ Solutions - Working Instructions 2019"[URL]
- Baladhandayutham B, "Fracture load of ceramic restorations after fatigue loading", J Prosthet Dent, 114, pp.266~271 (2015)
- Skjold A, "Effect of artificial aging on high translucent dental zirconia : simulation of early failure", Eur J Oral Sci, 128, pp.526~534 (2020)
- Cotes C, "Effects of aging procedures on the topographic surface, structural stability, and mechanical strength of a ZrO2-based dental ceramic", Dent Mater, 30, pp.e396~e404 (2014)
- Rosentritt M, "Influence of stress simulation parameters on the fracture strength of all-ceramic fixed-partial dentures", Dent Mater, 22, pp.176~182 (2006)
- Elsayed A, "Influence of the yttrium content on the fracture strength of monolithic zirconia crowns after artificial aging", Quintessence Int, 50, pp.344~348 (2019)
- Blatz MB, "The effect of resin bonding on long-term success of high-strength ceramics", J Dent Res, 97, pp.132~139 (2018)
- Lawson NC, "Bonding crowns and bridges with resin cement : An American Dental Association Clinical Evaluators Panel survey", J Am Dent Assoc, 151, pp.796~797. e2 (2020)
- Guess PC, "Damage and reliability of Y-TZP after cementation surface treatment", J Dent Res, 89, pp.592~596 (2010)
- Fernández-Estevan L, "Methodology in specimen fabrication for in vitro dental studies : Standardization of extracted tooth preparation", J Clin Exp Dent, 9, pp.e897~e900 (2017)
- Lawson NC, "Effect of surface treatment and cement on fracture load of traditional zirconia (3y), translucent zirconia (5y), and lithium disilicate crowns", J Prosthodont, 28, pp.659~665 (2019)
- Coelho PG, "Fatigue testing of two porcelain-zirconia all-ceramic crown systems", Dent Mater, 25, pp.1122~1127 (2009)
- Guess PC, "Influence of preparation design and ceramic thicknesses on fracture resistance and failure modes of premolar partial coverage restorations", J Prosthet Dent, 110, pp.264~273 (2013)
- Zhang Y, "Fatigue of dental ceramics", J Dent, 41, pp.1135~1147 (2013)
- Zhang Y, "Long-term strength of ceramics for biomedical applications", J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater, 69, pp.166~172 (2004)
- Zhang Y, "Competition of fracture mechanisms in monolithic dental ceramics : flat model systems", J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater, 88, pp.402~411 (2009)
- Koenig V, "Intraoral low-temperature degradation of monolithic zirconia dental prostheses : results of a prospective clinical study with ex vivo monitoring", Dent Mater, 37, pp.1134~1149 (2021)
- Guilardi LF, "Effect of zirconia surface treatment, resin cement and aging on the load-bearing capacity under fatigue of thin simplified full-contour Y-TZP restorations", J Mech Behav Biomed Mater, 97, pp.21~29 (2019)
- Rues S, "Effect of impact velocity and specimen stiffness on contact forces in a weight-controlled chewing simulator", Dent Mater, 27, pp.1267~1272 (2011)
- Øilo M, "Clinically relevant fracture testing of all-ceramic crowns", Dent Mater, 29, pp.815~823 (2013)
- Nakamura K, "Critical considerations on load-to-failure test for monolithic zirconia molar crowns", J Mech Behav Biomed Mater, 87, pp.180~189 (2018)
- Santana T, "Off-axis sliding contact reliability and failure modes of veneered alumina and zirconia", Dent Mater, 25, pp.892~898 (2009)
- Bonfante EA, "Fatigue and damage accumulation of veneer porcelain pressed on Y-TZP", J Dent, 38, pp.318~324 (2010)
- Kontonasaki E, "Strength and aging resistance of monolithic zirconia : an update to current knowledge", Jpn Dent Sci Rev, 56, pp.1~23 (2020)
- Zhang F, "Strength, toughness and aging stability of highly-translucent Y-TZP ceramics for dental restorations", Dent Mater, 32, pp.e327~e337 (2016)
- Rosentritt M, "Fatigue and wear behaviour of zirconia materials", J Mech Behav Biomed Mater, 110, pp.103970~ (2020)
