본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

한탄강 댐건설에 따른 갈등흐름 분석과 합의형성의 의미

An Analysis of Conflict Flow relative to Consensus Buildingon Hantan-river's Dam Projects

0

조회

0

다운로드

7

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

Recently, large public works are faced the conflict over the construction of dam project between local residents and the central government. This resistance imply a failure of decision making through difference of economical benefit and cost that while political decisions are taken in urban areas namely, the downstream in this case, however it taken farm areas with a shrinking population and a decline of land value in many unpopular facilities are located, where local residents feel that these facilities are being unfairly imposed on them. In this article, for the case of the construction of dam projects which has been in conflict between residents and government as regional conflict in HANTAN-river case, most of all I will analyze the conflict flow in macro scale. And then, this research clarifies the intensity of conflict between the conflict’s countermove and process, based on time-series from 2001 to 2007, using RDI (Relative Deviation Index) method. Therefore, this research objective leads to consensus building on public works locating the damaged district. I focus on conflict between the resistance areas caused by ‘the opposition processes’of neighborhood. The study can be of help to develop the rational negotiation process concerning the fair compensation of local residents.

Abstract

Recently, large public works are faced the conflict over the construction of dam project between local residents and the central government. This resistance imply a failure of decision making through difference of economical benefit and cost that while political decisions are taken in urban areas namely, the downstream in this case, however it taken farm areas with a shrinking population and a decline of land value in many unpopular facilities are located, where local residents feel that these facilities are being unfairly imposed on them. In this article, for the case of the construction of dam projects which has been in conflict between residents and government as regional conflict in HANTAN-river case, most of all I will analyze the conflict flow in macro scale. And then, this research clarifies the intensity of conflict between the conflict’s countermove and process, based on time-series from 2001 to 2007, using RDI (Relative Deviation Index) method. Therefore, this research objective leads to consensus building on public works locating the damaged district. I focus on conflict between the resistance areas caused by ‘the opposition processes’of neighborhood. The study can be of help to develop the rational negotiation process concerning the fair compensation of local residents.

참고문헌 (47)

  1. Bruce Williams, "Democracy, Dialog, and Environmental Disputes: The Contested Languages of Social Regulations" (1995), Yale U. Press
  2. 조성배, "공공사업의 합리적의사결정을 위한 PFI의 도입방안에 관한 연구", 석사, 동산학과, pp.2003
  3. 최홍석, "사회기반시설 설치의 절차적 합리성 제고방안: 댐건설과정사례" (2004), 한국행정학회
  4. 최홍석, "공유재와 갈등관리:수자원을 둘러싼 갈등과 협력" (2004), 박영사
  5. 최흥섭, "사회적갈등의 이론적 이해-댐건설을 중심으로", 한국행정학보, 37(4) (2003)
  6. 조현석, "사회갈등 예방을 위한 시민참여, 왜 필요한가?: 시민참여의 필요성 및 전통적 참여모델과 숙의적 참여모델 비교, 사회갈등 예방을 위한 시민참여제도 소개 강좌", ~ (2005)
  7. 주경일, "프레임분석을 통한 수자원 갈등 각 이해집단의 의미구성 이해" (2003), 한국행정학회
  8. Ducsik, Dennis W., "Electricity planning and the environment: Toward a new role for government in the decision process", 박사, pp.1978
  9. Dear,M., "Understanding and Overcoming the NIMBY Syndrome", Journal of the American Planning Association, 58(3) (1992)
  10. Frank E. A. Sander, "The Future of ADR", J. Disp. Resol, 3 (2000)
  11. Glaser, Barney G., "The Discovery of Grounded Theory : Strategies for qualitative Research" (1967), Aldine De Gruyter
  12. Gray, B., "An interactive Theory of Reframing on Negotiation" (1989), Pennsylvania University Press
  13. 萩原よしみ, "コンフリクトマネジメント?水資源の社?的リスク" (2006), 勁草書房
  14. ?橋晴俊, "新幹線公害―高速文明の社?問題" (1985), 有斐閣
  15. 정대연, "사회과학방법론사전", pp.375~376 (1997), 백의출판사
  16. 정호원, "갈등관리 및 갈등해결-사회갈등, 어떻게 해결할 것인가 in PCSD세미나자료집" (2004)
  17. 한탄강댐타당성검토보고서, "강원도·철원군", ~ (2004)
  18. 권해수, "공공부문과 민간부문의 대체적 분쟁해결제도 비교 연구", 한국행정학회 동계학술대회 논문집(Ⅱ), pp.287~312 (1996)
  19. 김선희, "국책사업의 효과적 추진을 위한 사회합의형성시스템 구축방안 연구" (2005), 국토연구원
  20. 김일중, "지역간 환경갈등의 국내사례 및 해결방안 in 환경분쟁의 경제적 해결방안 모색", pp.1~18 (1996), 한국환경경제학회
  21. 김환석, "참여적 의사결정의 의의와 활용방안 in 공공갈등과 참여적 의사결정 포럼" (2005), PSCD 포럼
  22. 김유환, "참여적 의사결정의 설계와 성공요인 검토 in 공공갈등과 참여적 의사결정", pp.147~150 (2005)
  23. Kraft, Michael E., "Citizen Participation and the NIMBY Syndrome: Public Response to Radioactive Waste Disposal", Western Political Quarterly, 44, pp.299~328 (1991)
  24. 이종엽, "입지정책의 결정과 집행과정에서의 정책수용성에 관한 연구: 혐오시설입지선정사례를 중심으로", 박사, pp.1997
  25. 문미경, "사회갈등해소를 위한 갈등관리제도의 구축 및 효율적 운영방안연구", pp.16~ (2005), 한국여성개발원
  26. Maznmanian, Diniel A., "The ‘NIMBY’ Syndrom: Facility Siting and the Failure of Democratic Discourse in Environmental Policy in the 1990s" (1994), congressional Quarterly
  27. McKearnan, Sarah, "Producing Consensus in Consensus Building Handbook", pp.325~373 (1999), SAGE
  28. 나태준, "갈등해결의 제도적 접근: 현행 갈등관련 제도분석 및 대안", pp.16~ (2004), 한국행정연구원
  29. 나태준, "공공사업 갈등사례분석을 통한 해결기제의 모색", 추계학술대회, pp.3~7 (2005), 한국행정학회
  30. 나성린, "환경분쟁과 그 해결방안 : 외국사례 in 환경분쟁의 경제적 해결방안 모색", pp.19~28 (1996), 한국환경경제학회
  31. ?谷博明, "ダム建設をめぐる環境運動と地域再生" (2004), 昭和堂
  32. ?田道大, "地域政策と地域社?―“都市と水資源”問題を手がかりとして", 季刊地域, 3, pp.10~14 (1980)
  33. 박길준, "한국 법문화에서의 분쟁해결제도(1)", 법학연구, 8 (1998), 연세대법학연구소
  34. 박인용, "수자원개발과 정책불응" (2006), 한국학술정보(주)
  35. 박찬우, "소송에 의하지 않는 분쟁해결제도’", 연세법학연구, 6(2) (1998), 연세법학회
  36. PCSD, "공공갈등 관리의 이론과 기법 in PCSD자료집", pp.27~28 (2005)
  37. Plitkin, Sidney, "Keep Out: The Struggle for Land Use Control" (1987), University of California Press
  38. Richad Savage, "A Statistical Model of the Gross Analysis of Transaction Flows", Econometrica, 28(3), pp.551~572 (1960)
  39. 사득환, "지방시대 환경갈등의 해결기제: 제3자 조정을 중심으로", 한국행정학보, 31(3) (1997)
  40. 사득환, "환경갈등과 ‘대체적’ 분쟁해결장치: 인식과 대안", 환경정책, 6(2), pp.109~130 (1998)
  41. 송상현, "재판에 의하지 아니한 분쟁해결방법의 이념과 전망", 인권과 정의, (215) (1994)
  42. Simon, Hebert A., "From Substantive to Procedural Rationality in Method and Appraisal in Economics" (1976), Cambridge University Press
  43. Susskind, L., "The Consensus Building Handbook:A Comprehensve to Reaching Agreement" (1999), SAGE Publication
  44. 鈴村小興?, "世代間衡平性の厚生??? in 世代間衡平性の理論と倫理" (2006), 東洋??新聞社
  45. 양병회, "재판외 분쟁해결제도의 현황과 과제", 仲裁, (300) (2001)
  46. Vilhelm Aubert, "Competition and Disssensus: Two Types of Conflict and of Conflict Resolution in The Hidden Society" (1965), Transaction Books
  47. Weisberg, Barbara, "One City's Approach to NIMBY: How New York City Developed a Fair Share Siting Process", Journal of the American Planning Association, 59(1) (1993)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)