對아프리카 ODA의 방향성 및 원조 효과성의 질적 개선에 관한 연구
Study on Improving the Quality of Direction and Aid Effectiveness of ODA to Africa
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Purpose - Despite the fact that economic cooperation and exchange with Africa is a global trend and the need of the hour, the region is still plagued by chronic ills such as regional conflicts, political corruption, hunger, poverty, and disease that deny people the basic human dignity, despite the increase in ODA sources, FDI, and high economic growth rates. This study examines the effectiveness and direction of ODA by donor countries. This study will discuss and suggest ways to improve the quality of ODA to Africa so that the systemic problems of poverty and disparity in Africa can be improved. Design/methodology/approach - This study defines the 'growth without development trap' as a situation in which the African continent, which has been a large ODA recipient for a long period of time and has been showing high economic growth rates, still does not have the necessary conditions to maintain a dignified life, such as chronic hunger, poverty, disparity between the rich and poor, disease, and civil war. It calls for a shift in the direction of ODA as a way to resolve this growth trap, and identifies a strategy that can be implemented as a combination of improving the effectiveness of external aid and improving the quality of Africa's internal governance, raising the need for social policy assistance as a means of doing so and proposing concrete action plans. Findings - This paper proposes the implementation of four aid strategies to eliminate the vicious cycle of corruption by achieving sustainable development through education ODA policies that can pursue the realization of human security, preventing the occurrence of dependency syndrome, improving the low effectiveness of existing aid, through social policy ODA that can overcome the trap of growth without development. Research implications or Originality - The choices and consequences of aid are also the responsibility of African countries themselves, and self-help must be fostered to enable them to make and focus their own choices. This study reiterates that the fundamental remedy for the low effectiveness of decades of aid to Africa lies in a qualitative transformation of Africa's own internal governance and the social policy orientation of aid that can guide it to ultimately realize human security.
Abstract
Purpose - Despite the fact that economic cooperation and exchange with Africa is a global trend and the need of the hour, the region is still plagued by chronic ills such as regional conflicts, political corruption, hunger, poverty, and disease that deny people the basic human dignity, despite the increase in ODA sources, FDI, and high economic growth rates. This study examines the effectiveness and direction of ODA by donor countries. This study will discuss and suggest ways to improve the quality of ODA to Africa so that the systemic problems of poverty and disparity in Africa can be improved. Design/methodology/approach - This study defines the 'growth without development trap' as a situation in which the African continent, which has been a large ODA recipient for a long period of time and has been showing high economic growth rates, still does not have the necessary conditions to maintain a dignified life, such as chronic hunger, poverty, disparity between the rich and poor, disease, and civil war. It calls for a shift in the direction of ODA as a way to resolve this growth trap, and identifies a strategy that can be implemented as a combination of improving the effectiveness of external aid and improving the quality of Africa's internal governance, raising the need for social policy assistance as a means of doing so and proposing concrete action plans. Findings - This paper proposes the implementation of four aid strategies to eliminate the vicious cycle of corruption by achieving sustainable development through education ODA policies that can pursue the realization of human security, preventing the occurrence of dependency syndrome, improving the low effectiveness of existing aid, through social policy ODA that can overcome the trap of growth without development. Research implications or Originality - The choices and consequences of aid are also the responsibility of African countries themselves, and self-help must be fostered to enable them to make and focus their own choices. This study reiterates that the fundamental remedy for the low effectiveness of decades of aid to Africa lies in a qualitative transformation of Africa's own internal governance and the social policy orientation of aid that can guide it to ultimately realize human security.
참고문헌 (36)
- 김민재, "기업의 사회적 책임이 ODA무역에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구", 무역상무연구, 78, pp.145~174 (2018)
- 김수진, "ICT 분야에 대한 ODA가 아프리카 경제성장에 미치는 효과", 한국아프리카학회지, 37, pp.189~217 (2012)
- 김지영, "국익과 ODA : 아프리카에 대한 미 · 중 원조 동기 분석", 국제지역연구, 25(3), pp.99~127 (2021)
- 김지영, "한 · 중 · 일의 대 아프리카 ODA 분석을 통한 아시아 원조 모델 모색", 사회과학연구, 22(1), pp.146~181 (2014)
- 박영호, "한국의 對아프리카 ODA 중점분야 도출 방법론에 관한 소고", 한국아프리카학회지, 47, pp.3~38 (2016)
- 박환보, "아프리카 교육 ODA를 위한 ADEA와의 협력방안", 한국아프리카학회지, 56, pp.91~126 (2019)
- 서상현, "정치적 부패가 공적개발원조(ODA)및 외국인직접투자(FDI)의 유입에 미치는 영향 : 아프리카사례 분석", 한국아프리카학회지, 49, pp.97~130 (2016)
- 임형록, "우리나라 ODA의 지속가능성과 지역 효과에 관한 연구 : 아프리카 vs 비(非)아프리카", 국제지역연구, 27(1), pp.103~119 (2023)
- 한국개발연구원, "신산업정책연구-신산업정책 총론" (2024), 경제 · 인문사회연구회
- Robert Calderisi, "왜 아프리카 원조는 작동하지 않는가: 아프리카 개발협력의 혁신적 전략 10가지" (2023), 초록비책공방
- Bhargava, V., "Global Issues of Global Citizens" (2006), The World Bank
- Brazys, S., "Aid and Governance: Negative Returns?", The European Journal of Development Research, 28, pp.294~313 (2016)
- Busse, M., "Does foreign aid improve governance?", Economics Letters, 104(2), pp.76~78 (2009)
- Das, S., "Political economy of third party interventions", Journal of Public Economics, 195, pp.104331~ (2021)
- Dzhumashev, R., "Foreign aid and the quality of economic institutions", European Journal of Political Economy, (68), pp.102001~ (2021)
- Fofack, H., "the AfCFTA and African Trade-An Introduction to the Special Issue-", Journal of African Trade, 8(Suppl 2), pp.1~11 (2021)
- Matthews, S., "Post-Development Theory and the Question of Alternatives : A View from Africa", Third World Quarterly, 25(2), pp.373~384 (2001)
- Mohamoud, A., "Reversing the Brain Drain in Africa: Feasibility Study for Nuffic" (2005), Nuffic
- Nye, J. S., "Corruption and Political Development : A Cost-Benefit Analysis", The American Political Science Review, 61(2), pp.417~427 (1967)
- UN Millennium Project, "Investing in Development: A Practical Plan to Achieve the Millennium Development Goals" (2005), Sterling
- 池永伊奈生, "アフリカ諸国における腐敗の特質: アジア諸国との比較より", 六甲台論集. 国際協力研究編, (14), pp.29~39 (2013)
- 政府開発援助に『ビジネスと人権』の視点を～民間企業と連携する小規模農家支援の事例から, "井上直美", ~, pp.アジ研ポリシー・ブリーフ, 180 (2023)
- 小田英郎, "アフリカ研究の50年-政治· 国際関係· 現代史-", アフリカ研究, (86), pp.3~9 (2015)
- 加藤宏, "アフリカ開発の課題と日本の貢献", 国際問題, (621), pp.43~54 (2013)
- 2023年版開発協力白書, "外務省", ~ (2024)
- 北良行, "経済協力での資源確保における探査の貢献マダガスカルにおける世銀のPGRMプロジェクトにふれて", 資源地質, 58(3), pp.237~248 (2008)
- 金珉在, "自国実益型ODAモデル導入を通じた鉄鋼産業活性化方案に関する研究-日本のODA事例を中心に-", 貿易経営研究, (15), pp.1~22 (2018)
- 斎藤文彦, "アフリカ支援問題と生計アプローチ", アフリカレポート, (41), pp.3~8 (2005)
- 中島邦公, "ガーナ農家の営農実践と農業開発 : アフリカ農業の低生産性は農家が原因なのか？", アゴラ: 天理大学地域文化研究センター紀要, 6, pp.79~89 (2015)
- 花谷厚, "政府開発援助における『人間の安全保障』の実践から見たアフリカの国家と開発", アフリカ研究, (71), pp.63~71 (2007)
- 平野克己, "ディベート力のある援助論とは？", アフリカレポート, 50(0), pp.52~57 (2010)
- 松隈俊佑, "開発途上国の小規模道路整備に向けた草の根無償支援の活用法", 土木学会論文集F5（土木技術者実践）, 76(1), pp.124~136 (2020)
- 山崎健介, "ODA事業の再構築とアフリカ支援の位置づけ", 日本評価学会春季第3回全国大会発表要旨収録: 地域市民社会における評価の役割, pp.165~168 (2006)
- "Africa’s Development Dynamics(AfDD) Table 20 – External Financial Inflows", ~ (2024)
- "우리가 몰랐던 아프리카, 기회의 땅을 잡아라" (2024)[URL]
- "검은대륙? ICT 신대륙?" (2024), 이진상[URL]