본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

독일 성년후견제도의 개정과정과 한국법에의 시사

Revisions of ‘Betreuungsrecht’ in Germany and Its Impact on Korean Adult Guardianship System

1

조회

0

다운로드

6

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

Betreuungsrecht(Adult Guardianship Law) in Germany has been revised four times since 1992. There are many reasons in revising the incompetency system in German Civil Law, such as disaccordance with the basic ideology of the modern law, the advent of aged society, etc. However, in the 21st century, Betreuungsrecht is being revised continuously for the purpose of converging on the idea of the social welfare state. At first, the German legislature focused on taking off their old clothes(Entmündigungsrecht) and wore a new dress(Betreuungsrecht). Recently, they are trying to make a perfect fit, that is, they are revising Betreuungsrecht in detail for putting teeth in the effectiveness on practicing the adult guardianship system. The Korean legislature revised the incompetency system for keeping pace with the times, and the new adult guardianship system was enforced on July 1st of this year. It is time to scrutinize the Korean adult guardianship system, because many countries adopted the adult guardianship system have noticed that there are many problems in practicing the adult guardianship system in these days, and solved the problems of the system in itself. This paper insisted that the systems between Korea and Germany are much similar. Therefore, it requires further checkup on what/how different/similar it is. And then, we need to check causes of the revision of the German system. It may be useful for us to practice our adult guardianship system. Thus we can solve and take measures.

Abstract

Betreuungsrecht(Adult Guardianship Law) in Germany has been revised four times since 1992. There are many reasons in revising the incompetency system in German Civil Law, such as disaccordance with the basic ideology of the modern law, the advent of aged society, etc. However, in the 21st century, Betreuungsrecht is being revised continuously for the purpose of converging on the idea of the social welfare state. At first, the German legislature focused on taking off their old clothes(Entmündigungsrecht) and wore a new dress(Betreuungsrecht). Recently, they are trying to make a perfect fit, that is, they are revising Betreuungsrecht in detail for putting teeth in the effectiveness on practicing the adult guardianship system. The Korean legislature revised the incompetency system for keeping pace with the times, and the new adult guardianship system was enforced on July 1st of this year. It is time to scrutinize the Korean adult guardianship system, because many countries adopted the adult guardianship system have noticed that there are many problems in practicing the adult guardianship system in these days, and solved the problems of the system in itself. This paper insisted that the systems between Korea and Germany are much similar. Therefore, it requires further checkup on what/how different/similar it is. And then, we need to check causes of the revision of the German system. It may be useful for us to practice our adult guardianship system. Thus we can solve and take measures.

참고문헌 (21)

  1. 김형석, "민법개정안 해설", 성년후견제 도입을 위한 민법개정안 공청회 자료집 (2009)
  2. 김형석, "민법 개정안에 따른 성년후견법제", 가족법연구, 24(2), pp.111~166 (2010), 한국가족법학회
  3. 박인환, "새로운 성년후견제 도입을 위한 민법개정안의 검토", 가족법연구, 24(1), pp.31~74 (2010), 한국가족법학회
  4. 백승흠, "민법개정안의 성년후견법제가 갖는 특징", 성년후견제 도입을 위한 민법개정안 공청회 자료집 (2009)
  5. 岡孝, "韓國における成年後見制度(民法改正案)についてのコメント", 보다 나은 민법전을 위하여―양국 민법총칙편의 검토(民法改正韓日共同심포지움 자료집) (2009)
  6. Bundesminister der Justiz, "Vormundschaft und Pflegschaft für Volljährige, Eine Untersuchung zur Praxis und Kritik des geltenden Rechts", pp.26~ (1987), Köln
  7. Deinert, "Neue Zahlen zur Praxis des Betreuungsrechts", FamRZ (1998)
  8. Jürgens, "Das neue Betreuungsrecht" (1999)
  9. Gregersen, "Die Vergütung des Betreuers" (1999), Bundesanzeiger Verlag
  10. Dodegge, "Das Betreuungsrechtsänderungsgesetz", NJW (1998)
  11. Biderbost, "Der neue Erwachsenenschutz im Überblick", SJZ (2010)
  12. Frantzen, "Neues Gesetz über Vormundschaft in Norwegen", FamRZ (2010)
  13. Aoki, "Das japanische Vormundschaftsrecht – Seinennkoukennhou", BtPrax (2009)
  14. Bienwald, "Ist das geltende Betreuungsrecht wirklich nicht mehr zeitgemäß?-Brauchen wir einen neuen Betreuungsbegriff?", BtPrax (2010)
  15. Volker Lipp, "Betreuungsrecht und UN-Behindertenrechtskonvention", FamRZ (2012)
  16. "BT-Drucksache 11", 6949
  17. "BT-Drucksache 11", 5628
  18. "BT-Drucksache 13", 7158
  19. "BT-Drucksache 16", 8442
  20. "BT-Drucksache 17", 2617
  21. "BT-Drucksache 11", 4528

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (13건)