An Eye for an Eye: Signaling Before and During the Korean War of 1950-53
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Although signaling is the essence of diplomacy, it has often been overlooked in previous studies on international crises. In fact, whether states in a dyad escalate disputes to the brink of war or seek conflict resolution, both sides of a crisis use these forms of signaling to convey their intended messages and possible responses. However, in most of these dyadic international conflicts, the patterns of signaling motives are not identified. In this article, it is argued that signaling decisions depend on the interaction of contextual dimensions, perceived threats, and the status disparity facing the states in a dyad. By analyzing both the signaling and the counter-signaling of nations in dyadic interactions, an alternative insight is offered into why the Korean War turned out to be inevitable.
Abstract
Although signaling is the essence of diplomacy, it has often been overlooked in previous studies on international crises. In fact, whether states in a dyad escalate disputes to the brink of war or seek conflict resolution, both sides of a crisis use these forms of signaling to convey their intended messages and possible responses. However, in most of these dyadic international conflicts, the patterns of signaling motives are not identified. In this article, it is argued that signaling decisions depend on the interaction of contextual dimensions, perceived threats, and the status disparity facing the states in a dyad. By analyzing both the signaling and the counter-signaling of nations in dyadic interactions, an alternative insight is offered into why the Korean War turned out to be inevitable.
참고문헌 (72)
- Raymond Cohen, "Theatre of Power: The Art of Diplomatic Signaling", pp.20~ (1987), Longman Inc
- Robert Jervis, "The Logic of Images in International Relations", pp.20~25 (1970), Princeton UP
- Thomas L. Brewer, "Issue and Context Variations in Foreign Policy: Effects on American Elite Behavior", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 17(1), pp.96~97 (1973)
- James D. Fearon, "Signaling versus the Balance of Power and Interests: An Empirical Test of a Crisis Bargaining Model", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 38(2), pp.249~259 (1994)
- "Koreas in Border Artillery Clash"[URL]
- Robert Jervis, "Perception and Misperception in International Politics", pp.239~248 (1976), Princeton UP
- Robert M. Blum, "Drawing the Line: The Origin of the American Containment Policy in East Asia", pp.179~193 (1982), W.W. Norton
- "A History of the War of Resistance to the U.S. and Assistance to Korea 1, In History Research Department of the Academy of Military Sciences", pp.90~113 (2000), Military Science Press
- Bevin Alexander, "The Strange Connection: U.S. Intervention in China, 1944–-1972", pp.59~66 (1992), Greenwood Press
- Hao Yufan, "China’'s Decision to Enter the Korean War: History Revisited", China Quarterly, (121), pp.100~102 (1990)
- Thomas J. Christensen, "Threats, Assurances, and the Last Chance for Peace: The Lessons of Mao’'s Korean War Telegrams", International Security, 17(1), pp.122~154 (1992)
- Allen S. Whiting, "China Crosses the Yalu: The Decision to Enter the Korean War", pp.115~116 (1960), MacMillan
- Richard N. Lebow, "Between Peace and War: The Nature of International Crisis", pp.148~228 (1981), The Johns Hopkins UP
- John Orme, "Deterrence Failures: A Second Look", International Security, 11(4), pp.96~124 (1987)
- Zhou Enlai, "Statement on the U.S. Armed Invasion of Chinese Territory on Taiwan, June 28, 1950, In Selected Works on Diplomacy of Zhou Enlai", pp.18~19 (1990), Central Archives and Manuscripts Press
- Hew Strachan, "The Lost Meaning of Strategy", Survival, 47(3), pp.43~ (2005)
- Sun Tzu, "The Art of War", pp.8~ (2009), EL Paso Norte Press
- Thomas Schelling, "The Strategy of Conflict", pp.117~ (1960), Harvard UP
- Paul K. Huth, "Extended Deterrence and the Outbreak of War", The American Political Science Review, 82(2), pp.423~443 (1988)
- Stephen M. Walt, "Alliance Formation and the Balance of World Power", International Security, 9(4), pp.3~43 (1985)
- Alexander L. George, "Deterrence in American Foreign Policy: Theory and Practice" (1974), Columbia UP
- Lawrence Freedman, "Deterrence: A Reply", Journal of Strategic Studies, 28(5), pp.789~801 (2005)
- Fearon, "Signaling versus the Balance of Power and Interests", 249~269
- Cohen, "Theatre of Power", 20~
- Schelling, "The Strategy of Conflict", 117~
- Martin Hollis, "Explaining and Understanding International Relations", pp.68~71 (1991), Oxford UP
- James D. Morrow, "Capabilities, Uncertainty and Resolve", American Journal of Political Science, 33(4), pp.941~972 (1989)
- Patrick M. Morgan, "Taking the Long View of Deterrence", Journal of Strategic Studies, 28(5), pp.751~752 (2005)
- Alexandra Guisinger, "Honest Threats: The Interaction of Reputation and Political Institutions in International Crises", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 46(2), pp.179~181 (2002)
- Robert Jervis, "Perceiving and Coping with Threat, In Psychology and Deterrence", pp.24~27 (1986), Johns Hopkins UP
- Richard N. Lebow, "Deterrence and Cold War", Political Science Quarterly, 110(2), pp.157~181 (1995)
- Gerhard Lenski, "Power and Privilege: A Theory of Social Stratification", pp.73~93 (1966), McGraw-Hill
- Michael D. Wallace, "Status, Formal Organization, and Arms Levels as Factors Leading to the Onset of War, 1820–-1964, In Peace, War, and Numbers", pp.49~69 (1972), Sage
- Robert Powell, "In the Shadow of Power: States and Strategies in International Politics", pp.82~114 (1999), Princeton UP
- Suzanne Werner, "Choosing Demands Strategically: The Distribution of Power, the Distribution of Benefits, and the Risk of Conflict", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 43(6), pp.713~ (1999)
- Mark Hewitson, "Images of the Enemy: German Depictions of the French Military, 1890–-1994", War in History, 11(1), pp.4~33 (2004)
- Chinese People’'s Institute of Foreign Affairs, "Oppose U.S. Occupation of Taiwan and “"Two Chinas”" Plot", pp.3~ (1958), Foreign Languages Press
- Mao Zedong, "Mao Zedong’'s Letter to Nie Rongzhen, July 7, 1950, In Collection of Mao Zedong’'s Writings after the Establishment of the People’'s Republic of China 1", pp.428~ (1989), Central Literature Publishing House
- Zhou Enlai, "The PRC’'s Foreign Policy, In Selected Works on Diplomacy of Zhou Enlai", pp.24~ (1990), Central Archives and Manuscript Press
- Dean Acheson, "Present at the Creation : My Years in the State Department", pp.453~ (1969), W. W. Norton & Company
- "Memorandum by the Central Intelligence Agency", The Foreign Relations of United States (FRUS), 933~934 (1950)
- Kavalam M. Panikkar, "In Two Chinas: Memoirs of a Diplomat", pp.108~ (1955), G. Allen & Unwin
- Zhou, "The PRC’'s Foreign Policy,”", 24~
- Pei Jianzhang, "An Epic of New China’'s Diplomacy", pp.97~ (1990), The World Knowledge Press
- Harry S. Truman, "Memoirs 2, Years of Trial and Hope", pp.356~366 (1956), Doubleday
- John M. Allison, "The Foreign Relations of United States, 7", 868~869 (1950)
- Clay Blair, "The Forgotten War: America in Korea, 1950–-1953", pp.340~ (1987), Times Books
- Spencer C. Tucker, "Special Issue in Commemoration of the 60th Anniversay of the Korean War The Korean War, 1950-1953: From Maneuver to Stalemate", The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis, 22(4), pp.421~433 (2010), 한국국방연구원
- Peng-Dehuai, "The Autobiography of Peng Dehuai", pp.257~258 (1981), People’'s Publishing House
- "Chinese Communist Plans: Korean Intervention"[URL]
- Peng Dehuai, "Peng Dehuai’'s Biography Writing Group", pp.423~ (1993), Contemporary China Publishing House
- Shen Zhihua, "Stalin, and the Korean War", pp.246~251 (2003), Guangdong People’'s Press
- Simei Qing, "From Allies to Enemies: Vision of Modernity, Identity, and U.S.-China Diplomacy, 1945–-1960", pp.162~163 (2007), Harvard University Press
- Paul Nitze, "The Foreign Relations of United States, 1", 146~147 (1950)
- Intelligence Estimate Prepared by the Estimates Group, "The Foreign Relations of United States, 7", 148~154 (1950)
- John Foster Dulles, "Consultant to the Secretary of State, to the Director of the Policy Planning Staff (Nitze)", The Foreign Relations of United States, 386~387 (1950)
- Thomas Preston, "Following the Leader: the Impact of U.S. Presidential Style upon Advisory Group Dynamics, Structures, and Decision, In Beyond Groupthink: Political Group Dynamics and Foreign Policy-making", pp.236~ (2000), Michigan UP
- Lebow, "Between Peace and War", 246~247
- "Truman, Memoirs 2", 362~
- "The Foreign Relations of the United States", Substance of Statements Made at Wake Island Conference, 7, pp.953~
- Jonathan D. Pollack, "The Korean War and Sino-American Relations, In Sino-American Relations, 1945–-1955: A Joint Assessment of a Critical Decade", pp.224~ (1989), Scholarly Resources
- Christensen, "Threats, Assurances, and the Last Chance for Peace", 130~
- Orme, "Deterrence Failures", 121~
- Yang Kuisong, "Moscow: Gratitude and Resentment", pp.365~388 (2005), Jiangxi People’'s Publishing House
- Rosemary Foot, "The Wrong War: American Policy and the Dimensions of the Korean Conflict, 1950–-1953", pp.78~79 (1985), Cornell U
- Christensen, "Threats, Assurances, and the Last Chance for Peace", 131~
- Blum, "Drawing the Line", 61~63
- Sartori, "Deterrence by Diplomacy", 19~36
- Xiao Jinguang, "Xiao Jinguang’'s Memoir", pp.2~8 (1988), People’'s Liberation Army Press
- Jervis, "The Logic of Images", 18~25
- Lebow, "Between Peace and War", 82~95
- Powell, "In the Shadow of Power", 85~106
