Civil-Military Relations in Democratic South Asia: A Comparative Framework
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The aim of this paper is to conceptualize a comparative framework on civil-military relations (CMR), at both political and strategic levels, in the context of major South Asian states such as India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh. There are complexities involved in framing and explaining power relations between political/ bureaucratic and military elites in these countries. Methodology used in this paper is basically content analysis, interviews, and observations made, and inferences drawn by the author himself, given his professional experience. The paper concludes there are both similarities and dissimilarities in such relations between democratic and quasi-democratic or between liberal and illiberal polities.
Abstract
The aim of this paper is to conceptualize a comparative framework on civil-military relations (CMR), at both political and strategic levels, in the context of major South Asian states such as India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh. There are complexities involved in framing and explaining power relations between political/ bureaucratic and military elites in these countries. Methodology used in this paper is basically content analysis, interviews, and observations made, and inferences drawn by the author himself, given his professional experience. The paper concludes there are both similarities and dissimilarities in such relations between democratic and quasi-democratic or between liberal and illiberal polities.
참고문헌 (28)
- Sam C. Sarkesian, "The U.S. Military Must Find Its Voice", Orbis, 12(3), pp.426~ (1998)
- Siegfried O. Wolf, "Civil-Military Relations and Democracy in Bangladesh", Spotlight South Asia (Applied Political Science of South Asia (APSA)), 5~ (2013)
- Samuel P. Huntington, "The Soldier and the State: The Theory and Politics of Civil-Military Relations" (1985), Harvard University Press
- S. E. Finer, "The Man on Horseback—The Role of the Military in Politics" (1988), Westview Press
- Larry Diamond, "Civil-Military Relations and Democracy", pp.29~ (1996), Johns Hopkins University Press
- Andrew Cottey, "The Second Generation Problematic: Rethinking Democracy and Civil-Military Relations", Armed Forces and Society, 29(1) (2002)
- Paul Staniland, "Explaining Civil-Military Relations in Complex Political Environments: India and Pakistan in Comparative Perspective", Security Studies, 17(2), pp.324~ (2008)
- "An Essay on Civilian Control of the Military" (1997)[URL]
- Samuel P. Huntington, "Reforming Civil-Military Relations", Journal of Democracy, 6(4), pp.4~ (1995)
- Narli Nilufer, "Civil-military Relations in Turkey", Turkish Studies, 1(1), pp.109~ (2000)
- Zillur R. Khan, "Civil-Military Relations and Nuclearization of India and Pakistan", World Affairs, 166(1), pp.25~ (2003)
- Harsh V. Pant, "India’s Nuclear Doctrine and Command Structure—Implications for Civil- Military Relations in India", Armed Forces and Society, 33(2) (2007)
- Rajat Pandit, "India’s Civil-Military Ties Worsening?", The Times of India, ~ (2013)
- "Civil Military Relation in Crisis" (2012)[URL]
- Eliot A. Cohen, "Are U.S. Forces Overstretched? Civil-Military Relations", Orbis, 41(2), pp.181~ (1997)
- India’s national Security Council—A Critical Review, "Subash Kapila", South Asia Analysis Group, ~, pp.Paper No. 123 (2000)
- Shashank Joshi, "India’s Civil-Military Dysfunction", The Interpreter, ~ (2013)
- Anit Mukharjee, "Defense Reform Shouldn’t Wait for another Kargil", The Times of India, ~ (2011)
- Y. M. Bammi, "Restructuring India’s Military: Out of Box Options (Book Review)", Journal of Defense Studies, 7(2), pp.176~ (2013)
- Lawrence Ziring, "Pakistan in the Twentieth Century: A Political History", pp.5~ (2001), Oxford University Press
- Safdar Mahmood, "Pakistan: Political Roots and Development, 1947-1999", pp.47~ (2000), Oxford University Press
- Mariana Baabar, "Ufa and Civil-Military Relations in Pakistan", The Hindu, ~ (2005)
- "Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan", ~
- "Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh", ~
- Mahmudul Islam, "Constitutional Law of Bangladesh" (2002), Mullick Brothers
- Mohd Aminul Karim, "Civil-Military Relations in Bangladesh: A Perspective", NDC Journal, 1(1), pp.12~ (2002)
- Shahedul Anam Khan, "Civil-military Relations in Bangladesh", The Daily Star, ~ (2009)
- Christoph Bluth, "India and Pakistan: A Case of Asymmetric Nuclear Deterrence", The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis, 22(3), pp.387~406 (2010), 한국국방연구원