Beyond the intangible/tangible binary: an analysis of historic built environments in Valencia, Spain.
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper is a theoretical reflection aiming to understandhow specific assets of intangible heritage are affectedby contemporary discourse. This approach focuses onunderstanding the protection, preservation and reenactmentof the intangible heritage found in Spanishrural landscapes. By an analysis of the global, nationaland regional laws, the paper addresses the need toapproach the intangible, understanding the peculiaritiesof places that shape the scenery. The places and ‘Assetsof Cultural Interest’ analysed in this paper are definedas geographic areas associated with a historic event,activity, or people, which exhibit cultural and aestheticvalues. Following this definition, these landscapes areexperiential cultural spaces, involving a complex set ofelements, fixed, semi-fixed and unfixed. The way in whichthese traditions are viewed and experienced by locals andforeigners plays a central role in many intangible heritagestudies, as does the way in which it reflects integrity,authenticity, attachment and a sense of identity, and howit anchors collective memory. It is the intention of this paperto emphasise the need to transfer the phenomenon ofintangible heritage from the realm of a lived experienceto the world of living places. In doing so some questionsarise: Is the intangible cultural heritage contained inrural landscapes authentic? Is it simply the materiality,the past act or the past cultural process, or is it the waythe intangible cultural heritage has been managed untiltoday? Are we applying critical considerations to inner andouter perceptions, appropriations and transmigrationswhen managing cultural heritage?
Abstract
This paper is a theoretical reflection aiming to understandhow specific assets of intangible heritage are affectedby contemporary discourse. This approach focuses onunderstanding the protection, preservation and reenactmentof the intangible heritage found in Spanishrural landscapes. By an analysis of the global, nationaland regional laws, the paper addresses the need toapproach the intangible, understanding the peculiaritiesof places that shape the scenery. The places and ‘Assetsof Cultural Interest’ analysed in this paper are definedas geographic areas associated with a historic event,activity, or people, which exhibit cultural and aestheticvalues. Following this definition, these landscapes areexperiential cultural spaces, involving a complex set ofelements, fixed, semi-fixed and unfixed. The way in whichthese traditions are viewed and experienced by locals andforeigners plays a central role in many intangible heritagestudies, as does the way in which it reflects integrity,authenticity, attachment and a sense of identity, and howit anchors collective memory. It is the intention of this paperto emphasise the need to transfer the phenomenon ofintangible heritage from the realm of a lived experienceto the world of living places. In doing so some questionsarise: Is the intangible cultural heritage contained inrural landscapes authentic? Is it simply the materiality,the past act or the past cultural process, or is it the waythe intangible cultural heritage has been managed untiltoday? Are we applying critical considerations to inner andouter perceptions, appropriations and transmigrationswhen managing cultural heritage?
참고문헌 (43)
- Basque Government, "Basque Cultural Heritage Law 7", 1990, July the 3rd, 1990
- Basque Government, "Basque Cultural Heritage Law Blueprint", ~ (2015)
- Bortoloto, Chiara, "UNESCO, cultural heritage, and outstanding universal value: value-based analyses of the World Heritage and Intangible Cultural Heritage Conventions", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 21(5), pp.528~530 (2015)
- Catalan Government, "Catalan Cultural Heritage Law 9", 1993, September the 30rd, 1993
- Classen, Constance, "Sensible objects: colonialism, museums and material culture", pp.199~222 (2006), Berg
- Council of Europe, "European landscape convention", Council of Europe, ~ (2000)
- Crookea, Elisabeth, "The politics of community heritage: motivations, authority and control", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 16(1), pp.16~29 (2010)
- Daly, Patrick, "Routledge Handbook of Heritage in Asia", pp.350~363 (2012), Routledge
- Daugbjerg, Mads, "Introduction: heritage gone global. Investigating the production and problematics of globalised pasts", History and Anthropology, 22, pp.135~147 (2011)
- Daugbjerg, Mads, "Re-enacting the past: vivifying heritage ‘again’", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 20(7-8), pp.681~687 (2014)
- DeSilvey, Caitlin, "Curated decay. Heritage beyond saving" (2017), Minnesota University Press
- de Groot, Rudolf, "Function-analysis and valuation as a tool to assess land use conflicts in planning for sustainable, multi-functional landscapes", Landscape and Urban Planning, 75, pp.175~186 (2006)
- García-Esparza, Juan A., "Epistemological paradigms in the perception and assessment of vernacular architecture", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 21(9), pp.869~888 (2015)
- García-Esparza, Juan A., "Are World Heritage concepts of integrity and authenticity lacking in dynamism? A critical approach to Mediterranean autotopic landscapes", Landscape Research, 43(6), pp.817~830 (2018)
- García-Esparza, Juan A., "Clarifying dynamic authenticity in cultural heritage. A look at vernacular built environments", ICOMOS. ICOMOS University Forum Workshop on Authenticity and Reconstructions, 1 (2018)
- Gilmore, James. H., "Authenticity: What consumers really want?" (2007), Harvard Business School Press
- Harrison, Rodney, "Heritage: Critical Approaches" (2012), Routledge
- Harvey, David C., "Heritage Pasts and Heritage Presents: Temporality, Meaning and the Scope of Heritage Studies", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 7(4), pp.319~338 (2001)
- Harvey, David C., "Heritage and scale: settings, boundaries and relations", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 21(6), pp.577~593 (2015)
- Holtorf, Cornelius, "Heritage erasure: rethinking ‘protection’ and ‘preservation’", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 21(4), pp.313~317 (2015)
- ICOMOS, "Charter on the Conservation of Historic Towns and Urban Areas: ‘The Washington Charter’", ICOMOS, ~ (1987)
- ICOMOS, "Charter for the protection and management of the archaeological heritage", ICOMOS, ~ (1990)
- ICOMOS, "The Nara Document on Authenticity", ICOMOS, ~ (1994)
- ICOMOS, "Charter for Places of Cultural Significance: ‘The Burra Charter’", ICOMOS, ~ (1999)
- ICOMOS, "Charter for the Interpretation and Presentation of Cultural Heritage Sites", ICOMOS, ~ (2008)
- Kenway, Jane, "Globalising the Research Imagination" (2009), Routledge
- Kristensen, Troels M., "Pilgrimage, devotional practices and the consumption of sacred places in ancient Egypt and contemporary Syria", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 21(4), pp.354~368 (2015)
- Lennon, Jane L., "Managing Cultural Landscapes", pp.45~69 (2012), Routledge
- Lennon, Jane L., "Managing Cultural Landscapes", pp.345~364 (2012), Routledge
- Lixinski, Lucas, "Between orthodoxy and heterodoxy: the troubled relationships between heritage studies and heritage law", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 21(3), pp.203~214 (2015)
- Ministry of Culture, Education and Sports, "National Plan for the safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage", Secretaría General Técnica. Centro de Publicaciones. Ministerio de Educación, Cultura y Deporte, ~ (2011)
- Nagaoka, Masanori, "‘European’ and ‘Asian’ approaches to cultural landscapes management at Borobudur, Indonesia in the 1970s", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 21(3), pp.232~249 (2015)
- Schorch, Philipp, "Cultural feelings and the making of meaning", International Journal of Heritage Studies, 20(1), pp.22~35 (2014)
- Science and Heritage: an Update, "Science and Technology Committee", HMSO, ~, pp.HL Paper 168 (2007)
- Spanish Government, "Spanish Historical Heritage Law 16", 1985, June 25th, 1985
- Spanish Government, "Law 10", 2015 for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage, May 26th, 2015
- Stephenson, Janet, "The Cultural Values Model: An integrated approach to values in landscapes", Landscape and Urban Planning, 84, pp.127~139 (2008)
- UNESCO, "Convention concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage", UNESCO, ~ (1972)
- UNESCO, "Recommendation Concerning the Safeguarding and Contemporary Role of Historic Areas", UNESCO, ~ (1976)
- UNESCO, "Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage", UNESCO, ~ (2003)
- Valencian Government, "Valencian Cultural Heritage Law 4", 1998, June 11th, 1998
- Valencian Government, "Valencian Cultural Heritage Law 5", 2007, February 9th, 2007
- Waitt, Gordon, "Consuming heritage: Perceived historical authenticity", Annals of Tourism Research, 27, pp.835~862 (2000)