基于修辞学理论对章太炎演讲的分析
An Analysis of Zhang Taiyan’s Speech Based on Rhetoric Theory
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
本文是以亚里斯多德的修辞学理论和西塞罗的演讲术为理论基础,以章太炎的《东京留学生欢迎会上的演讲辞》为考察对象,分析章太炎的演讲内容和修辞特点,探究他如何运用演讲宣传革命思想。西塞罗认为演讲者应该具有五种能力,对应着演讲的五个阶段,即开题、布局、文体、记忆和发表,因章太炎的演讲没有影像资料留存,因此本文只就开题、布局和文体三个阶段进行考察。在联想阶段,本文分别对修辞学的情况、本次演讲的背景、演讲的类型、演讲者和听众进行了分析。在排列阶段,本文依据亚里斯多德的人格诉诸(Ethos)、逻辑诉诸(Logos)和情感诉诸(Pathos)三种说服因素对本次演讲的布局进行了分析,章太炎以其谦和、坚韧不屈等美好的品质获得了听众的好感,演讲时多次使用三段论法论证自己的观点,激发了听众的友爱、愤慨和自豪三种情感,使得听众信服。在表现阶段,章太炎以浅显的白话文进行演讲,杂以部分文言词汇,形成了简约而又正式的风格。同时,演讲者使用了引用、仿拟、示现、设问、排比等修辞手法,本文只对使用次数较多的设问和示现两种修辞手法进行了具体的分析。设问具有引起注意、启发思考的作用;示现使得演讲者可以超绝时空的限制而充分列举过去的事情作为论据。
Abstract
This study is based on Aristotle’s rhetoric theory and Cicero’s oratory, taking Zhang Taiyan’s speech 《东京留学生欢迎会上的演讲辞 Speech at the welcome meeting for international students in Tokyo》 as the research object, analyzing the content and rhetorical characteristics, and exploring How he used speech to propagate revolutionary ideas. According to Cicero’s oratory, speech is divided into five stages: association, arrangement, expression, memory, and presentation. Since there is no video for Zhang Taiyan’s speech, this paper analyzed only three stages. In the association stage, this paper analyzes the situation of rhetoric, the background of the speech, the type of the speech, the speaker and the audience. In the arrangement stage, this paper analyzes the layout of this speech based on Aristotle’s appeals: ethos,logos, and pathos. Good qualities such as humility and tenacity have won the favor of the audience. During the speech, he used syllogism many times to prove his point of view, which inspired the audience’s three emotions of friendship, indignation and pride, and convinced the audience. In the expression stage, Zhang Taiyan gave speeches in vernacular mixed with some classical Chinese forming a simple and formal style. At the same time, the speaker used rhetorical such as ‘引用 quote’、‘仿拟 imitate’、‘示现 show’、‘设问 question’、‘排比 parallel’. This paper only makes a specific analysis of the two rhetorical of ‘设问’ and ‘示现’. ‘设问’ has the function of attracting attention and inspiring thinking; ‘示现’ enables the speaker to transcend the limitations of time and space and list past events as arguments.
참고문헌 (21)
- 陈平原, "中国现代学术之建立:以章太炎、胡适之为中心" (1998), 北京大学出版社
- 陈望道, "修辞学发凡" (2008), 复旦大学出版社
- 何九盈, "辞源" (2015), 商务印书馆
- 나민구, "중국어레토릭" (2017), 한국외국어대학교 지식출판원
- 罗竹风, "汉语大词典 第5卷" (1986), 上海辞书出版社
- 章太炎, "章太炎政论选集" (1977), 中华书局
- 王希杰, "汉语修辞学" (2004), 商务印书馆
- 西塞罗, "论演说家" (2003), 中国政法大学出版社
- 西塞罗, "西塞罗全集·修辞学" (2007), 人民出版社
- 亚理斯多德, "修辞学" (1991), 三联书店
- 中国社会科学院语言研究多词典编辑室, "现代汉语词典" (2016), 商务印书馆
- 卞孝萱, "章太炎各次演讲之比较研究", 传统文化与现代化, (6) (1998)
- 陈平原, "有声的中国—“演说”与近现代中国文章变革", 文学评论, (3) (2007)
- 傅杰, "章太炎与汉语修辞学", 天津师范大学学报(社会科学版), (4) (2003)
- 华云刚, "章太炎晚年的民族关怀与“士”之理想", 南京师范大学文学院学报, (2) (2015)
- 刘桂秋, "章太炎无锡讲学活动考述", 江南大学学报(人文社会科学版), 7(3) (2008)
- 许德发, "国粹教育与域外流寓者—论章太炎在马来亚的演说", 汉语言文学研究, (4) (2015)
- 周励恒, "国学大义与个人志业_苏州章氏国学讲习会创办缘起新探", 河南师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版), (5) (2018)
- 周生杰, "学精功伟:章太炎国学演讲会与国魂塑造", 中国矿业大学学报(社会科学版), (1) (2019)
- 朱磊, "尚质轻文——从《文学七篇》看章太炎的修辞思想", 阜阳师范学院学报(社会科学版), (4) (2010)
- 宗廷虎, "中西古典修辞学说异同论", 古汉语研究, (1) (1994)
