유전자정보수집의 입법목적의 정당성
The Legislative Justness of Law for DNA Database
0
조회
0
다운로드
37
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The high technology like bio-technology requires more and more in the field of criminal procedure, especially forensic science. And DNA databases would provide the criminal justice systems with not only an efficient way of crime solving but also prevent of crime. So recently the Korean government enforced a law for collection and administration of DNA databases. As that law, the use of DNA databases in the criminal justice system would be possible to offer the investigation information to compare the specimen from the crime scene with and to identify convicted offenders and suspects for recordable offenders. Particularly, DNA databases would be operated to arrest of hard core criminals, for example murder, robbery, arson, burglary, rape that have the high repetition rate. Law for DNA databases aims to criminal investigation, crime prevention and protection of human right. The three legislative Justness of law for DNA database are very different in function. the criminal investigation fulfills a function of criminal procedure, crime prevention performs a function of the police law that should eliminate potential risk factors in society. and protection of human right deals with the constitution. especially Law for DNA databases has been embroiled in controversy from a constitutional perspective through past fifteen years. But the use of individual genetic information provided DNA databases would have potentially dangerousness to violate the human rights-the right of the self-determination of personal information. so in this article several issues are pointed out in regard to three legislative Justness of law for DNA database and their solutions are suggested. Ultimately, the normative criterions for reasonable operation of DNA database should be set up and fair operation should be regulated by that law to accomplish legislative Justness of law for DNA database.
Abstract
The high technology like bio-technology requires more and more in the field of criminal procedure, especially forensic science. And DNA databases would provide the criminal justice systems with not only an efficient way of crime solving but also prevent of crime. So recently the Korean government enforced a law for collection and administration of DNA databases. As that law, the use of DNA databases in the criminal justice system would be possible to offer the investigation information to compare the specimen from the crime scene with and to identify convicted offenders and suspects for recordable offenders. Particularly, DNA databases would be operated to arrest of hard core criminals, for example murder, robbery, arson, burglary, rape that have the high repetition rate. Law for DNA databases aims to criminal investigation, crime prevention and protection of human right. The three legislative Justness of law for DNA database are very different in function. the criminal investigation fulfills a function of criminal procedure, crime prevention performs a function of the police law that should eliminate potential risk factors in society. and protection of human right deals with the constitution. especially Law for DNA databases has been embroiled in controversy from a constitutional perspective through past fifteen years. But the use of individual genetic information provided DNA databases would have potentially dangerousness to violate the human rights-the right of the self-determination of personal information. so in this article several issues are pointed out in regard to three legislative Justness of law for DNA database and their solutions are suggested. Ultimately, the normative criterions for reasonable operation of DNA database should be set up and fair operation should be regulated by that law to accomplish legislative Justness of law for DNA database.
참고문헌 (33)
- 권오걸, "형사소송법" (2010), 형설출판사
- 김택수, "프랑스 유전자은행 체계의 변화", 경찰학연구, (6) (2004), 경찰대학
- 박동균, "범죄자 유전자정보은행의 운영방안에 관한 연구", 한국경찰학회보, 10(2), pp.83~116 (2008), 한국경찰학회
- 박용철, "피의자의 유전자정보 채취의 제문제", 형사정책, 18(2), pp.9~32 (2006), 한국형사정책학회
- 배종대, "형사소송법" (2009), 홍문사
- 서정범, "경찰법연구" (2009), 세창출판사
- 송호림, "강력범 유전자은행 설립 목적 및 필요성", 수사연구, (9) (2008), 수사연구사
- 신동운, "형사소송법" (2009), 법문사
- 신양균, "유전자정보은행제도와 인권-「디엔에이신원확인정보의 이용 및 보호에 관한 법률」을 중심으로-. in: 한국형사법학회 2010년 하계학술회의 자료집"
- 신양균, "형사소송법" (2009), 화산미디어
- 심희기, "유전자정보은행과 프라이버시 이슈들", 형사정책, 18(2), pp.85~108 (2006), 한국형사정책학회
- 심희기, "형사소송법" (2009), 삼영사
- 유영찬, "과학 수사의 발전방안에 관한 연구-유전자은행이 설립과 활용을 중심으로-", 치안논총, 14 (1998), 치안정책연구소
- 윤영철, "개인 유전정보의 형사사법적 이용의 문제점과 이에 대한 해결방안", 형사정책, 18(2), pp.33~66 (2006), 한국형사정책학회
- 이승환, "범죄자 DNA 데이터베이스의 이론과 국제 현황", 형사법의 신동향, 통권 : 18 (2009), 대검찰청
- 이승환, "합리적인 범죄자 DNA 데이터베이스구축. in: 한국형사정책학회 추계학술대회 자료집" (2006)
- 이은모, "대물적 강제처분에 있어서의 영장주의의 예외", 법학논총, 24(3), pp.129~146 (2007), 법학연구소
- 이재상, "형사소송법" (2010), 박영사
- 이헌석, "인간유전자정보보호에 관한 연구-유전자정보은행을 중심으로-", 아태공법연구, 11 (2003), 아세아태평양공법학회
- 조성용, "독일 형사소송법상의 유전자정보은행에 관한 법적 고찰-보의 수집 및 관리에 관한 법률안과의 비교를 중심으로", 형사정책, 19(1), pp.155~182 (2007), 한국형사정책학회
- 조성용, "범죄자 유전자정보은행의 설립에 관한 법적 고찰 - '유전자감식정보의 수집 및 관리에 관한 법률안'을 중심으로 -", 고려법학, (49), pp.987~1034 (2007), 법학연구원
- 한면수, "경찰 초동수사 목적의 유전자감식정보 검사 및 관리", 형사정책, 18(2), pp.109~126 (2006), 한국형사정책학회
- 한면수, "과학수사와 증거재판에서 DNA프로필의 역할 (2)", 경찰학연구, (4), pp.253~286 (2003), 경찰대학
- 한희중, "유전자자료은행 운영을 위한 유전자감식정보 수집 및 관리 법률의 필요성", 한국법과학회지, 6(2) (2005)
- 홍정선, "경찰행정법" (2007), 박영사
- 황만성, "과학적 증거의 증거능력과 증명력", 형사정책연구, 18(3), pp.779~810 (2007), 한국형사정책연구원
- A.C. Bernasconi, "Beyond Fingerprinting: Indicting DNA Threatens Criminal Defendants' Constitutional and Statutory Rights", AM. U. L. REV., 50 (2001)
- Bramley R., "The National DNA Database, Forensic Science Service in U.K. in: 제3회 한국법과학회 춘계학술대회, 한·영 법과학심포지엄 자료집" (2002)
- Gill. P., "Forensic Application of DNA fingerprints", Nature, 318 (1985)
- Leonard Saxe, "Admissiblity of Polygraph Tests: The Application of Scientific Standards Post-Daubert", Psychology, Public Policy and Law, 5 (1999), American Psychological Association
- M. J. Markett, "Genetic Diaries: An Analysis of Privacy Protection in DNA Databanks", SUFFOLK U. L. REV., 30 (1996)
- Annual Report 2007-09, "National DNA Database", ~
- Wickenheiser. R., "The Business case for using forensic DNA technology to solve and prevent crime", J. of Biolow and Business, 7 (2004)