본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Which Leadership Matters?: Comparison of the Effect of Transformational and Transactional Leadership and Relationship between Organizational Performance and Job Satisfaction

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류행정학

초록

(Purpose) Few studies have compared the effects of transformational and transactional leadership on the relationships between job satisfaction and organizational performance and between organizational performance and job satisfaction. This study compared the effect of transactional and transformational leadership on organizational performance and job satisfaction and explored the relationship between organizational performance and job satisfaction. (Design/methodology/approach) Using Korean government employee surveys adapted from the Organizational Assessment Survey Generic Form used by the Office of Personnel Management, we conducted a Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) and regression analysis. (Findings) The results supported the notion that transformational leadership has a stronger influence on job satisfaction and organizational performance than transactional leadership. Furthermore, the relationship between organizational performance and job satisfaction was inconclusive. (Research implications or Originality) This paper contributes to the organization theory on leadership and performance by comparing the effect of transformational and transactional leadership on organizational performance and job satisfaction, as well as by testing the relationship between organizational performance and job satisfaction.

Abstract

(Purpose) Few studies have compared the effects of transformational and transactional leadership on the relationships between job satisfaction and organizational performance and between organizational performance and job satisfaction. This study compared the effect of transactional and transformational leadership on organizational performance and job satisfaction and explored the relationship between organizational performance and job satisfaction. (Design/methodology/approach) Using Korean government employee surveys adapted from the Organizational Assessment Survey Generic Form used by the Office of Personnel Management, we conducted a Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) and regression analysis. (Findings) The results supported the notion that transformational leadership has a stronger influence on job satisfaction and organizational performance than transactional leadership. Furthermore, the relationship between organizational performance and job satisfaction was inconclusive. (Research implications or Originality) This paper contributes to the organization theory on leadership and performance by comparing the effect of transformational and transactional leadership on organizational performance and job satisfaction, as well as by testing the relationship between organizational performance and job satisfaction.

참고문헌 (109)

  1. Aarons, G., "Transformational and transactional leadership : Association with attitudes toward evidence-based practice", Psychiatric Services, 57(8), pp.1162~1169 (2006)
  2. Andrews, R., "Representative bureaucracy, organizational strategy, and public service performance", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 15, pp.489~504 (2005)
  3. Andrew, R., "Public Service Performance: Perspectives on Measurement and Management", pp.14~34 (2006), Cambridge University Press
  4. Al-Yahya, K, O., "Power-influence in decision making, competence utilization, and organizational culture in public organizations: The Arab world in comparative perspective", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 19(2), pp.385~407 (2008)
  5. Bass, B. M., "Leadership and Performance beyond Expectations" (1985), Free Press
  6. Bass, B. M., "Two decades of research and development in transformational leadership", European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 8(1), pp.9~32 (1999)
  7. Bass, B., "Predicting unit performance by assessing transformational and transactional leadership", Journal of Applied Psychology, 88(2), pp.207~218 (2003)
  8. Bennis, W., "Organization of the Future", Personnel Administration, 24 (1967)
  9. Bennis, W., "Leaders: Strategies for Taking Change" (1985), Harper & Row
  10. Bloom, M., "Relationships among risk, incentive pay, and organizational performance", Academy of Management Journal, 41(3), pp.283~297 (1998)
  11. Bowditch, J. L., "A Primer on Organizational Behavior" (2008), John Wiley and Sons
  12. Bowling, N. A, "Is the job satisfaction–job performance relationship spurious? A meta-analytic examination", Journal of Vocational Behavior, 71(2), pp.167~185 (2007)
  13. Boyne, G. A., "What is public service improvement?", Public Administration, 81(2), pp.211~227 (2003)
  14. Boyne, G. A., "Sources of public service improvement : A critical review and research agenda", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 13(3), pp.367~394 (2003)
  15. Brayfield, A. H., "Employee attitudes and employee performance", Psychological Bulletin, 52(5), pp.396~424 (1955)
  16. Brewer, G. A., "Why elephants gallop : Assessing and predicting organizational performance in federal agencies", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 10(4), pp.685~712 (2000)
  17. Brewer, G. A., "Public Service Performance:Perspectives on Measurement and Management", pp.35~54 (2006), Cambridge University Press
  18. Bryman, A., "Charisma and Leadership in Organizations" (1992), Sage
  19. Bryman, A., "Handbook of Organization Studies", pp.276~292 (1996), Sage
  20. Burns, J. M., "Leadership" (1978), Harper & Row
  21. Butler Jr, J. K., "Effects of perceived leadership behaviors on job satisfaction and productivity", Psychological Reports, 80(3), pp.976~978 (1997)
  22. Carter, N., "How Organisations Measure Success:The Use of Performance Indicators in Government" (1992), Routledge
  23. Costanza, D. P., "Leadership and Organizational Decline: The Relationship Between Personality Characteristics and Organizational Performance", Ph.D., pp.1996
  24. 조기웅, "Does Blake and Mouton’s managerial grid work?: the relationship between leadership type and organization performance in South Korea", International Review of Public Administration, 23(2), pp.103~118 (2018), 한국행정학회[DOI]
  25. Chun, Y. H., "Goal ambiguity and organizational performance in US federal agencies", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 15(4), pp.529~557 (2005)
  26. Cunningham, W., "Needham Height" (2000), Allyn and Bacon
  27. Denis, J. L., "The Oxford Handbook of Public Management", pp.446~467 (2005), Oxford University Press
  28. Denhardt, R. B., "Managing Human Behavior in Public and Nonprofit Organizations" (2013), Sage Publications
  29. Epitropaki, O., "The moderating role of individual differences in the relation between transformational", transactional leadership perceptions and organizational identification, 2005, pp.16(4), 569~589
  30. Fernandez, S., "Developing and Testing an Integrative Framework of Public Sector Leadership : Evidence from the Public Education Arena", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 15(2), pp.197~217 (2005)
  31. Fielder. F. E., "The contribution of cognitive resources and leader behavior to organizational performance", Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 16(6), pp.532~548 (1986)
  32. Forbes, M., "Public Service Performance: Perspectives on Measurement and Management", pp.35~54 (2006), Cambridge University Press
  33. Fry, B, R., "Mastering Public Administration: From Max Weber to Dwight Waldo" (2008), CQ Press
  34. Harms, P. D., "Emotional intelligence and transformational and transactional leadership : A meta-analysis", Journal of Leadership &Organizational Studies, 17(1), pp.5~17 (2010)
  35. Hartog, D, "Transactional versus transformational leadership : An analysis of the MLQ", Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 70, pp.19~34 (1997)
  36. Hater, J. J., "Superiors' evaluations and subordinates'perceptions of transformational and transactional leadership", Journal of Applied Psychology, 73(4), pp.695~ (1988)
  37. Hennessey Jr, J. T., ""Reinventing" Government: Does Leadership Make the Difference?", Public Administration Review, 58(6), pp.522~532 (1998)
  38. Higgins, C. C., "Transactional and Transformational Leadership: An Examination of the Relationship between Leadership Orientation and Perceptions of Organizational Effectiveness", Ph.D, pp.1998
  39. Hochwarter, W. A., "Job satisfaction and performance : The moderating effects of value attainment and affective disposition", Journal of Vocational Behavior, 54(2), pp.296~313 (1999)
  40. 홍한국, "CEO의 리더십 유형에 따른 기업의 위기관리 차이에 관한 연구", 한국콘텐츠학회 논문지, 13(9), pp.382~391 (2013), 한국콘텐츠학회[DOI]
  41. 홍승희, "변혁적・거래적 리더십이 직무만족과 조직몰입에 미치는 영향: 강원도 지방교육행정공무원을 중심으로", 한국조직학회보, 11(3), pp.25~54 (2014), 한국조직학회[DOI]
  42. 홍성화, "한국호텔기업에 있어서 변혁적 리더십과 거래적 리더십간의 비교", 호텔경영학연구, 9(2), pp.123~138 (2000), 한국호텔외식관광경영학회
  43. House, R. J., "Charismatic Leadership: The Elusive Farm in Organizational Effectiveness" (1988), Jossey-Bass
  44. Howell, J. M., "Transformational leadership, transactional leadership, locus of control, and support for innovation : Key predictors of consolidated-business-unit performance", Journal of Applied Psychology, 78(6), pp.891~902 (1993)
  45. Hrebiniak, L. G., "Top management agreement and organizational performance", Human Relations, 35(12), pp.1139~1157 (1982)
  46. 허성욱, "Organizational Culture and Public Service Motivation in Executive Agencies: Mediating Role of Adhocracy Culture", 한국비교정부학보, 26(1), pp.41~64 (2022), 한국비교정부학회[DOI]
  47. Huselid, M. A., "The impact of human resource management practices on turnover, productivity, and corporate financial performance", Academy of Management Journal, 38(3), pp.635~672 (1995)
  48. 황성철, "사회복지기관 리더십 유형이 조직 효과성에 미치는 영향: 변혁적 거래적 리더십을 중심으로Ⅰ. 서론 : 연구의 필요성 및 목적", 한국사회복지행정학, 5(1), pp.135~157 (2003), 한국사회복지행정학회
  49. 황기순, "경찰지구대장의 변혁적 리더십이 직무성과에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구: 서울지방경찰청 경찰지구대를 중심으로", 한국정책과학학회보, 9(2), pp.65~90 (2005), 한국정책과학학회
  50. 황지현, "스포츠센터 경영자의 변혁적 리더십과 거래적 리더십, 임파워먼트, 직무만족, 조직몰입의 구조적 관계", 한국체육과학회지, 21(1), pp.441~452 (2012), 한국체육과학회
  51. Iaffaldano, M. T., "Job satisfaction and job performance : A meta-analysis", Psychological Bulletin, 97(2), pp.251~273 (1985)
  52. Im, T., "Fixed the spinning-wheel public administration study. Korean", The Korean Association for Policy Studies. Summer Seminar (2008)
  53. Jacobs, D., "Leadership and organizational performance : Isolating links between managers and collective success", Social Science Research, 22(2), pp.165~189 (1993)
  54. Jacobsen, C. B., "Is leadership in the eye of the beholder? A study of intended and perceived leadership practices and organizational performance", Public Administration Review, 75(6), pp.829~841 (2015)
  55. 장명, "태권도 지도자의 변혁적 · 거래적 리더십과 선수만족, 운동몰입 및 운동지속의도의 관계", 한국사회체육학회지, (46), pp.807~818 (2011), 한국사회체육학회
  56. Judge, T. A., "The job satisfaction-job performance relationship : A qualitative and quantitative review", American Psychological Association, 127(3), pp.376~407 (2001)
  57. Judge, T. A., "Transformational and transactional leadership : A meta-analytic test of their relative validity", Journal of Applied Psychology, 89(5), pp.755~768 (2004)
  58. 정병을, "공공의료기관장의 리더십이 조직유효성에 미치는 형향 : 변혁적-거래적 리더십을 중심으로", 병원경영학회지, 15(3), pp.97~122 (2010), 한국병원경영학회
  59. 정연성, "무도관장의 거래적․변혁적 리더십이 신뢰와 조직성과에 미치는 영향", 한국체육과학회지, 19(1), pp.71~82 (2010), 한국체육과학회
  60. 강수돌, "변혁적 리더십, 거래적 리더십과 직무만족: 내재적 동기부여의 매개효과", 인적자원개발연구, 13(2), pp.21~40 (2010), 한국인적자원개발학회
  61. Kim, P. S., "Civil service reform in Japan and Korea : toward competitiveness and competency", International Review of Administrative Sciences, 68(3), pp.389~403 (2002)
  62. Kim, S., "Individual-level factors and organizational performance in government organizations", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 15(2), pp.245~261 (2005)
  63. 김용수, "태권도 코치의 거래적·변혁적 리더십이 선수만족에 미치는 영향", 한국사회체육학회지, (35), pp.387~401 (2009), 한국사회체육학회
  64. 김태우, "일과 삶의 균형, 경력개발지원, 연고(緣故)가 공무원 조직몰입에 미치는 영향 연구: 기초지방자치단체 신규 하위직 공무원을 중심으로", 한국지방자치연구, 22(4), pp.169~201 (2021), 대한지방자치학회
  65. 김병기, "기관장(부서장)의 변혁적·거래적 리더십이 조직구성원의 창의성 발휘 및 연구성과물에 미치는 영향 - 지방자치단체 산하 연구기관을 중심으로 -", 한국지방자치학회보, 23(3), pp.157~184 (2011), 한국지방자치학회
  66. Kim, J., "Wring Thesis with Structural Equation Modeling" (2009), Communication Books
  67. 김경희, "노인재가센터 리더십과 팔로어십이 조직효과성에 미치는 영향", 한국조직학회보, 7(3), pp.129~149 (2010), 한국조직학회[DOI]
  68. Kirkman, B. L., "Beyond self-management : Antecedents and consequences of team empowerment", Academy of Management Journal, 42(1), pp.58~74 (1999)
  69. Klay, W. E., "Encyclopedia of Public Administration and Public Policy" (2015), Taylor & Francis
  70. Kline, R. B., "Principles and Practice of Structural Equation Modeling" (2010), The Guilford Press
  71. 권혁기, "변혁적 리더십과 거래적 리더십이 조직성과에 미치는 영향 : 자기효능감과 직무만족의 매개효과를 중심으로", 경영과 정보연구, 31(2), pp.1~20 (2012), 대한경영정보학회[DOI]
  72. Lawler, E, E, ., "The effect of performance on job satisfaction", Industrial relations : A journal of Economy and Society, 7(1), pp.20~28 (1967)
  73. Leatt, P., "Where are the healthcare leaders? The need for investment in leadership development", Healthcare Papers, 4(1), pp.14~31 (2003)
  74. 이창신, "변혁적", 거래적 리더십이 집단자아존중감과 무사안일행태에 미치는 영향, 2006, pp.17(2), 25~52[DOI]
  75. Lee, C. W., "Mediate role of collective efficacy for the type of leadership to influence organizational effectiveness", The Journal of Korean Association for Policy Sciences, 9(4), pp.25~45 (2005)
  76. 이동준, "검도 지도자의 거래적-변혁적 리더십과 지도자 신뢰, 수련만족 및 수련지속의도의 관계", 한국체육과학회지, 23(2), pp.561~572 (2014), 한국체육과학회
  77. 이재헌, "야구코치의 변혁적·거래적 리더십이 선수만족에 미치는 영향", 한국사회체육학회지, (53), pp.31~44 (2013), 한국사회체육학회[DOI]
  78. 이성철, "거래적·변혁적 리더십이 팀 임파워먼트 및 성과에 미치는 영향", 한국의류산업학회지, 10(6), pp.936~946 (2008), 한국의류산업학회
  79. 이영균, "변혁적 리더십과 조직몰입의 관계에 관한 연구", 한국정책과학학회보, 8(2), pp.179~204 (2004), 한국정책과학학회
  80. Leithwood, K., "A review of transformational school leadership research 1996–2005", Leadership and Policy in Schools, 4(3), pp.177~199 (2005)
  81. Locke, E., "Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology", pp.1297~1349 (1976), Rand– McNally
  82. Lundberg C., "Foundations for Inquiry: Choices and Trade-Offs in the Organizational Sciences" (2005), Stanford University Press
  83. Medsker, G. J., "A review of current practices for evaluating causal models in organizational behavior and human resources management research", Journal of Management, 20(2), pp.439~464 (1994)
  84. The influence of job satisfaction and organizational commitment on executive withdrawal and performance, "Moynihan, L. M.", CAHRS, ~, pp.CAHRS Working Paper Series. Paper 94 (2000)
  85. Nahavandi, A., "Leader Style in Strategy and Organizational Performance : An Integrative Framework", Journal of Management Studies, 30(3), pp.405~425 (1993)
  86. Noe, R. A., "Human Resource Management: Gaining a Competitive Advantage" (2010), Irwin McGraw-Hill
  87. Orazi, D. C., "Public sector leadership : new perspectives for research and practice", International Review of Administrative Sciences, 79(3), pp.486~504 (2013)
  88. Park, H. T., "Transformational and transactional leadership styles of the nurse administrators and job satisfaction, organizational commitment in nursing service", Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing, 27(1), pp.228~241 (1997)
  89. 류병곤, "변혁적", 거래적 리더십이 조직몰입에 미치는 영향: 조직문화의 조절효과를 중심으로, 2013, pp.15(3), 239~262[DOI]
  90. Petty, M. M., "A meta-analysis of the relationships between individual job satisfaction and individual performance", Academy of Management Review, 9(4), pp.712~721 (1984)
  91. Popovich, M. G., "Creating High-performance Government Organizations: A Practical Guide for Public Managers" (1998), Jossey-Bass
  92. Quinn, R. E., "A spatial model of effectiveness criteria : towards a competing values approach to organizational analysis", Management Science, 29(3), pp.363~377 (1983)
  93. Rainey, H. G., "Understanding and Managing Public Organizations" (1991), Jossey-Bass
  94. Ritz, A., "Public service motivation and organizational performance in Swiss federal government", International Review of Administrative Sciences, 75(1), pp.53~78 (2009)
  95. 노시범, "지방자치단체 리더십이 조직효과성에 미치는 영향요인 연구 :경기북부지역을 중심으로", GRI연구논총, 11(3), pp.5~30 (2009), 재단법인 경기연구원
  96. Shafritz, J, M., "Classics of Public Administration", pp.2009, Wadsworth
  97. Shibru, B., "Effects of transformational leadership on subordinate job satisfaction in leather companies in Ethiopia", International Journal of Business Management & Economic Research, 2(5), pp.334~344 (2011)
  98. Simon, C. A., "Organizational Performance in the Public Sector: A Comparison of 77 Federal Bureaus Receiving Or Not Receiving the President's Quality Award 1992-1997", Doctor, pp.1998
  99. Smith, P., "The Measurement of Satisfaction in Work and Retirement" (1969), Rand–McNally
  100. 송상우, "대학축구지도자의 변혁적․거래적 리더십이 조직유효성에 미치는 영향", 한국체육과학회지, 20(5), pp.197~209 (2011), 한국체육과학회
  101. Stogdill, R. M., "Personal factors associated with leadership : A survey of the literature", The Journal of Psychology, 25(1), pp.35~71 (1948)
  102. Thomas, A. B., "Does leadership make a difference to organizational performance", Administrative Science Quarterly, 33(3), pp.388~400 (1988)
  103. Tichy, N. M., "The Transformational Leader" (1986), John Wiley
  104. Tichy, N. M., "The Transformational Leader" (1990), John Wiley
  105. Van Wart, M., "Leadership in Public Organization, Armonk" (2008), M.E. Sharpe
  106. Venkatraman, N., "Measurement of business performance in strategy research : a comparison of approaches", Academy of Management Review, 11(4), pp.801~814 (1986)
  107. Wanous, J. P., "A causal-correlational analysis of the job satisfaction and performance relationship", Journal of Applied Psychology, 59(2), pp.139~144 (1974)
  108. Westphal, J. D., "Collaboration in the boardroom : Behavioral and performance consequences of CEO-board social ties", Academy of Management Journal, 42(1), pp.7~24 (1999)
  109. 양승범, "LINKING EMPOWERMENT AND JOB ENRICHMENT TO TURNOVER INTENTION: THE INFLUENCE OF JOB SATISFACTION", International Review of Public Administration, 14(2), pp.13~24 (2009), 한국행정학회

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (10건)