物의 槪念과 空間―格致와 科學, 그 사이의 言表와 談論을 중심으로
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
At the time when Chinese traditional Gezhi(格致) met western science, the statements of Bowu(博物) and Gewu(格物), which were commonly used along with Gezhi, appeared during the transition of thinking towards Wu(物). These statements were not merely synonyms of Gezhi. They were in the middle of the epistemological conversion that happened in the process of conceptual differentiation, such as Wu for a Ren(人) and Wu for Ziran(自然). One of the most distinctive contributions of Gezhi to modern China might be the differentiation of Xue(學). The passion for enlightenment made it possible - The enlightenment for national salvation continuously facilitated tensions between the old and the new. Despite of the positive effects of the differentiation, however, the severance caused by the differentiation might be inevitable. This was because science, also known as the study of differentiation(Kexue, 科学), then again, ironically, tried to integrate the whole knowledge system under another concept. Maybe, these two conflicting phenomena represent a modern-day desire that pursues individuality and, at the same time, totality. In this sense, Kexue itself in modern China was a symbol of differentiation and integration. In addition, interestingly enough, these concepts had made not only such chronological history, but also the space for discussions. Museums and exhibitions, the terms of which had been used without any difference, started to show their own features along with the transition of awareness towards Wu. Also, Shuyuan(书院) adopting Gezhi began to define knowledges of modern education. From this time when Kexue replaced Bowu, Gewu and Gezhi, Wu has been engraving its concept on the space, attempting to converse its concept from the natural philosophy into knowledge and property of things.
Abstract
At the time when Chinese traditional Gezhi(格致) met western science, the statements of Bowu(博物) and Gewu(格物), which were commonly used along with Gezhi, appeared during the transition of thinking towards Wu(物). These statements were not merely synonyms of Gezhi. They were in the middle of the epistemological conversion that happened in the process of conceptual differentiation, such as Wu for a Ren(人) and Wu for Ziran(自然). One of the most distinctive contributions of Gezhi to modern China might be the differentiation of Xue(學). The passion for enlightenment made it possible - The enlightenment for national salvation continuously facilitated tensions between the old and the new. Despite of the positive effects of the differentiation, however, the severance caused by the differentiation might be inevitable. This was because science, also known as the study of differentiation(Kexue, 科学), then again, ironically, tried to integrate the whole knowledge system under another concept. Maybe, these two conflicting phenomena represent a modern-day desire that pursues individuality and, at the same time, totality. In this sense, Kexue itself in modern China was a symbol of differentiation and integration. In addition, interestingly enough, these concepts had made not only such chronological history, but also the space for discussions. Museums and exhibitions, the terms of which had been used without any difference, started to show their own features along with the transition of awareness towards Wu. Also, Shuyuan(书院) adopting Gezhi began to define knowledges of modern education. From this time when Kexue replaced Bowu, Gewu and Gezhi, Wu has been engraving its concept on the space, attempting to converse its concept from the natural philosophy into knowledge and property of things.
참고문헌 (44)
- 권석환, "중국의 강남 예술가와 그 패트론들" (2009), 이담Books
- 박노자, "개념의 번역과 창조 개념사로 본 동아시아 근대" (2012), 돌베개
- 박희성, "원림, 경계 없는 자연" (2011), 서울대학교출판문화원
- 안대회, "西洋科學의 東傳과 동아시아 전통과학의 終焉", ‘근대 제국주의 침탈과 동아시아의 귀환’—고려대학교-中國海洋大學 공동 학술대회 (2011), 고려대학교 민족문화연구원 한국학관 회의실
- 이연희, "낯설음에 대한 유혹 -지괴의 타자성-", 도교문화연구, (34), pp.323~342 (2011), 한국도교문화학회
- 전진성, "박물관의 탄생" (2004), 살림
- 조숙경, "1876년 과학기구 특별 대여전시회 : 런던 과학 박물관의 출발과 물리과학의 대중화", 박사, 과학사및과학철학, pp.2001
- 차문성, "근대박물관 형성과정에 대한 연구 : 박물학과 박람회의 영향을 중심으로", 석사, 박물관교육, pp.2008
- 최재천, "지식의 통섭" (2007), 이음
- 한성구, "중국 근현대 “科學”에 대한 인식과 사상 변화", 중국인문과학, (31), pp.447~466 (2005), 중국인문학회
- 한성구, "중국 근대 “格致學”의 變遷과 中西 格致學 비교", 한국철학논집, (18), pp.425~456 (2006), 한국철학사연구회
- 홍성욱, "21세기 한국의 자연과학과 인문학", 이화여자대학교 통섭원(統攝苑) ‘지식의 통섭을 위하여’ 심포지엄 발표문 (2006)
- 홍성욱, "홍성욱의 과학 에세이 - 과학, 인간과 사회를 말하다" (2008), 동아시아
- 황기원, "경관의 해석" (2011), 서울대학교출판문화원
- 홍은영, "미셸 푸꼬의 과학적 이성의 고고학" (1999), 백의 출판사
- 구가 가쓰토시, "지식의 분류사" (2007), 한국출판마케팅연구소
- 로버트 헉슬리, "위대한 박물학자" (2009), 21세기북스
- 리디아 리우, "언어횡단적 실천" (2005), 소명출판
- 먼로 C. 비어슬리, "미학사" (1987), 이론과 실천
- 장화, "博物志" (2013), 지식을 만드는 지식
- 진관타오, "관념사란 무엇인가1" (2010), 푸른역사
- 토머스 핸킨스, "과학과 계몽주의" (2011), 글항아리
- 페데리코 마시니, "근대 중국의 언어와 역사" (2005), 소명출판
- 피터 보울러, "현대과학의 풍경2" (2008), 궁리
- 羅竹鳳, "漢語大詞典" (1994), 漢語大詞典出版社
- 巫仁恕, "從生産性到觀賞性? 明淸蘇州園林形態的再思考, In “江南與中外交流”國際學術硏討會論文集" (2008), 上海復旦大學歷史系主辦
- 심국위, "近代中日詞彙交流研究ーー漢字新詞的創製、容受與共享" (2010), 中華書局
- 楊麗君, "《格致彙編》的科技內容及意義", 遼寧工學院學報, 2 (2003)
- 梁啓超, "飮冰室合集⋅文集5" (1988), 中華書局
- 呂濟民, "中國博物館史論" (2004), 北京紫金省出版社
- 趙 冬, "近代科學與中國本土實踐" (2007), 社會科學文獻出版社
- 左玉河, "近代中國與世界" (2005), 社會科學文獻出版社
- 陳少明, "人, 物之間—理解《莊子》哲學的一個關鍵(2)", ~
- 侯迺慧, "宋代園林及其生活文化" (2010), 三民書局
- 侯迺慧, "宋代園林及其生活文化" (2010), 三民書局
- 熊月之, "西學東漸與晩淸社會" (1994), 上海人民出版社
- 熊月之, "論晚清上海文化管理: 從《點石齋畫報》案說起", 書窗, 2 (2000)
- "辭海" (1989), 上海辭書出版社
- "圖畵日報" (1999), 上海古籍出版社
- "中國近代科學的文化史" (2009)[URL]
- "漢語大字典"[URL]
- "中國文獻媒體資料中心"[URL]
- "NAVER 지식백과"[URL]
