사사기 17-21장과 친왕권적 신학
Judges 19-21 and Pro-monarchical Theology
0
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
일반적으로 사사기 17-21장은 신명기사가의 편집 작업 이후에 왕국 탄생의 신학적 정당성을 제공하고 종교적으로, 윤리적으로 타락한 사사시대를 그려내기 위해 ‘부록’으로 들어온 친왕권적 신학의 결과물로 간주되고 있다. 본 논문은 이러한 전통적인 가설을 반박하고, 사사기 17-21장 안에서 신명기사가의 역사서 편집 작업의 흔적들을 찾아내는 것을 목적으로 하고 있다.
Abstract
Scholars believe that Jud 17-21 is an additional product of pro-monarchical theology which attempts to provide the theological foundation of the monarchy in the kingdoms of Israel and Judah as well as a theological judgment upon the religious and ethical corruption of the period of judges, and that it was written after the period of Deuteronomistic redactional work. In other words, scholars believe that there is no Deuteronomistic editorial work in Jud 17-21. However, is Jud 17-21 really an additional text and without any relation to Deuteronomistic edition? The traditional viewpoint of Jud 17-21 as an additional text added after the Deuteronomistic edition was finished is not conclusive. There are some Deuteronomistic editorial statements such as “all the people did what was right in their own eyes” (17:6b; 21:15b), “residing” (17:7) and “Gershom” in chs 17-18, “in those days the tribe of the Danites” (18:1b), “Micah’s idols” and “Shiloh” (17:5), and “Levite,” “Bethlehem in Judah,” and “residing” (19:1). Previously, Jud 17-21 was not considered to be part of the work of the Deuteronomist because this text does not express the so-called Deuteronomistic theological viewpoint. Of course, Jud 17-21 does not follow the theological literary formation of “Israel’s corruption-YHWH’s rage-enemy’s invasion-suffering of the people and cry-salvation by Judge’s activity” as there is no judge in the text. If we extend the outset of the Judges’ period to 1 Sam 7 when Saul’s dynasty was not yet born, the result is entirely different. In this context, 1 Sam 1-7 reports the transitional period from Judges to monarchy. Then, in the whole context of Deuteronomistic History, we need to connect 1 Sam 1-7 to Jud 17-21. 1 Sam 1-3 reports “Judge” Samuel’s young age and 1 Sam 4-6 (the first half of the Ark of God narrative) deals with the subjects of the Philistines’ invasion and the loss of the Ark of God, which is the symbol of YHWH’s presence. 1 Sam 1-7 is loosely connected with Judges’ theological formation. The Deuteronomistic understanding of history is to promote that the Israelites’ sin puts them into the hand of enemy, and judges sent by God save them, but the Israelites sin again. In that case, Jud 17-21 and 1 Sam 1-7 can be connected. At the end of the story of Samson (Jud 13-16), the text reports Samson’s death (Jud 16:31). 1 Sam 4-6 describes military devastation by the Philistines and the loss of the Ark of God. Based on Deuteronomistic History, Israel’s sinful behavior must appear between ‘judge’s death’ and ‘military failure’ because 1 Sam 4 does not mention any problem of religious corruption in Israel. Moreover, the subject of 1 Sam 1-4 is Samuel’s young age, suggesting that the religious corruption must occur before Samuel’s birth and early life. Israel’s religious and ethical corruption in Jud 17-21, working as a model of unfaith, provides the basis of what the Deuteronomistic History criticizes. The episodes after Samson died are recorded as “a thing ever happened since the day that the Israelites came up from the land of Egypt until this day?” (Jud 19:30). Jud 17-21 works well in the theological formation of the Deuteronomistic History. The crime story in relation to the Levite is not a local scandal but a severe guilt which decisively brings Israel’s defeat by the Philistines.
참고문헌 (63)
- 룻기. 대한기독교서회 창립 100주년 기념 성서주석 7, "사사기", pp.2007, 김의원
- 김재구, "사무엘, 하나님의 실패한 계획", 구약논단, 16(1), pp.74~97 (2010), 한국구약학회
- 소형근, "역대기 역사서에 나타난 이방인 이해", 구약논단, 18(2), pp.158~177 (2012), 한국구약학회[DOI]
- 소형근, "고대 이스라엘의 사법조직들과 재판관들", 구약논단, 21(2), pp.155~175 (2015), 한국구약학회[DOI]
- 장석정, "사사기 순환구조 재고: 가능성 있는 내용의 부재(不在)를 중심으로", 신학논단, 84, pp.137~162 (2016), 연세대학교 신과대학 연합신학대학원
- 정석규, "왕의 법(신 17: 14-20)의 이중적 기능", 구약논단, 15(4), pp.30~50 (2009), 한국구약학회
- 최종원, "후기 유대 공동체의 '다문화‘(Multiculture)에 관한 연구 - 에스라와 느헤미야에 나타난 이방인에 대한 수용성과 배타성을 중심으로", 구약논단, 21(2), pp.122~154 (2015), 한국구약학회[DOI]
- 버틀러, T. C., "사사기" (2011), 솔로몬
- 베이욜라, T., "신명기" (2010), 도서출판 동연
- 소긴, J. A., "판관기" (1992), 한국신학연구소
- Amit, Y., "Hidden Polemic in the Conquest of Dan: Judges XVIIXVIII", VT, 40, pp.4~20 (1990)
- Amit, Y, "Hidden Polemics in Biblical Narrative" (2000), Brill
- Bartelmus, R., "Forschung am Richterbuch seit Martin Noth", ThR, 56, pp.221~259 (1991)
- Bartusch, M. W., "2Understanding Dan: An Exegetical Study of a Biblical City, Tribe and Ancestor" (2003), Sheffield Academic
- Becker, U., "Richterzeit und Königtum. Redaktionsgeschichtliche Studien zum Richterbuch" (1990), Walter de Gruyter
- Block, D. I., "Echo Narrative Technique in Hebrew Literature: A Study of Judges 19", WTJ, 52, pp.325~341 (1990)
- Block, D. I, "Judges, Ruth" (1999), Broadman & Holman
- Boecker, H. -J., "Die Beurteilung der Anfänge des Königtums in den deuteronomistischen Abschnitten des 1. Samuelbuches. Ein Beitrag zum Problem des “Deuteronomistischen Geschichtswerk,”" (1969), Neukirchener Verlag
- Boling, R. G., "Judges. Anchor Bible Series 6A" (1975), Doubleday
- Bray, J. S., "Sacred Dan: Religious Tradition and Cultic Practice in Judges 17-18" (2006), T & T Clark
- Budde, K., "Das Buch der Richter. KHCAT" (1897), Verlag von J. C. B. Mohr
- Cody, A., "A History of Old Testament Priesthood. AnBib 35" (1969), Biblical Institute Press
- Cr semann, F., "Der Widerstand gegen das Königtum. Die antiköniglichen Texte des Alten Testamentes und der Kampf um den frühen israelitischen Staat" (1978), Neukirchener Verlag
- Dietrich, W., "Prophetie und Geschichte. Eine redaktionsgeschtliche Untersuchung zum deuteronomistischen Geschichtswerk" (1972), Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht
- Exum,J. C., "Judges and Method", pp.65~90
- Fuhs, H. F., "r[;n:", pp.474~485 (1998)
- Fuss, W., "Die deuteronomistische Pentateuchredaktion in Exodus 3-17" (1972), Walter de Gruyter
- Gray, J., "Joshua, Judges and Ruth. New Century Bible Commentary Series" (1967), Thomas Nelson and Sons
- Guillaume, P., "Waiting for Josiah: The Judges" (2004), Sheffield Academic
- Hadley, J. M., "Dictionary of Old Testament Theology & Exegesis. Volume 3", pp.644~646 (1997)
- Hadley, J. M, "Dictionary of Old Testament Theology & Exegesis. Volume 2", pp.1000~1001 (1997)
- Hertzberg, H. W., "Die Bücher Josua, Richter, Ruth" (1985), Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht
- Hudson, D. M., "Living in a Land of Epithets: Anonymity in Judges 19-21", JSOT, 62, pp.49~66 (1994)
- Jüngling, H.-W., "Propaganda für das Königtum. Die Tendenzgeschichte in Ri. 19", BiKi, 38, pp.63~65 (1983)
- Kellermann, D., "rWG", pp.439~449 (1999)
- Lapsley, J. E., "Whispering the Word:Hearing Women’s Stories in the Old Testament", pp.39~67 (2005), Westminster John Knox
- Martin-Achard, R., "rWG", pp.409~412 (1984)
- Mattews V. H., "Social World of Ancient Israel 1260-587" (1993), Hendrickson
- Mayes, A. D. H., "Studies in Deuteronomy" (1994), Brill
- Mayes, A. D. H, "Deuteronomistic Royal Ideology in Judges 17-21", BibInt, 9, pp.241~258 (2001)
- Miller, P. D., "The Religion of Ancient Israel. Library of Ancient Israel" (2000), Westminster John Knox
- Mueller, E. A., "The Micah Story: A Morality Tale in the Book o f Judges", Studies in Biblical Literature, 34 (2001), Lang
- Nelson, R., "Raising Up a Faithful Priest: Community and Priesthood in Biblical Theology" (1993), Westminster John Knox
- Niehr, H., "Herrschen und Richten. Die Wurzel p im Alten Orient und im Alten Testament" (1986), Echter Verlag
- Niemann, H. M., "Die Daniten: Studien zur Geschichte eines Altisraelitischen Stämmes" (1985), Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht
- Noth, M., "Überlieferungsgeschichtliche Studien. Die sammelnden und bearbeitenden Geschichtswerke im Alten Testament" (1967), Max Niemeyer Verlag
- Noth, M, "Aufsätze zur biblischen Landes- und Altertumskunde I Neukirchen-Vluyn", pp.133~147 (1971), Neukirchener Verlag
- O’Connell, R. H., "The Rhetoric of the Book of Judges" (1996), Brill
- Otto, E., "Das Deuteronomium. Politische Theologie und Rechtsreform in Juda und Assyrien" (1999), Walter de Gruyter
- Rad, G. von, "Theologie des Alten Testaments I. Die Theologie der geschichtlichen überlieferungen Israels" (1987), Chr. Kaiser Verlag
- Reuter, E., "Kultzentralisation. Entstehung und Theologie von Dtn 12" (1993), Peter Hanstein Verlag
- Richter, W., "Die Bearbeitungen des “Retterbuches” in der deuteronomischen Epoche" (1964), Peter Hanstein Verlag GMBH
- Smend, R., "Probleme biblischer Theologie", pp.494~509 (1971), Chr. Kaiser Verlag
- Strauss, H., "Untersuchungen zu den Überlieferungen der vorexilischen Leviten", ev.-theol, pp.1960
- Sweeney, M. A., "Davidic Polemics in the Book of Judges", VT, 47, pp.517~529 (1997)
- Talmon, S., "Proceedings of the 5th World Congress of Jewish Studies", pp.242~243 (1969), Hacohen
- Täubler, E., "Biblische Studien: Die Epoche der Richter" (1998), Mohr Siebeck
- Thiel, W., "Die deuteronomistische Redaktion von Jeremia 26-45" (1981), Neukirchener Verlag
- Veijola, T., "Das Königtum in der Beurteilung der deuteronomistischen Historiographie. Eine redaktionsgeschichtliche Untersuchung" (1977), Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia
- Wong, G. T. K., "Compositional Strategy of the Book of Judges:An Inductive, Rhetorical Study" (2006), Brill
- Wood, B. G., "Giving the Sense" (2003), Kregel
- Yee, G, "Judges and Method", pp.146~170
- Zobel, H.-J., "hx'P'v.mi", pp.79~85 (1998)