Interference with Personal / Family Laws in British India and the Impact on Women
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper will show how colonization's effects on women contributed to women's subordination in British India. The British influence in family law is taken into consideration in certain specifics, which, in contrast to prior assurances of non-interference, powerfully illustrates the creeping meddling in the indigenous religious-personal laws. In British India, the encroachment of the colonial government on Muslim family law occurred more through cases, especially in restitution of conjugal rights while for the Hindu family law it was mainly through specific statutes. The statutes enacted under the Muslim family law, although seen as a significant step to ameliorate the legal status of women, were more concerned with Islamic debates than whether the reforms were beneficial to women. The remedy of restitution of conjugal rights was a prominent example of the introduction of English notions/principles to family law in British India that affected women. The idea itself is founded on Christian ecclesiastical law. It has recently been claimed that South Asia did not adequately implement this idea. It made life extremely difficult for women as well. In the past, women who declined to live with their spouses could do so and continue living with their parents, free from obligation. According to case law, whenever a wife files an action for dissolution or for maintenance pursuant to section 2(ii) of the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act of 1939, the husband responds by bringing a suit for restitution of conjugal rights. In this paper, I evaluate the widespread belief that this period's legislation liberated women by analysing the pertinent legal framework of the time. It is demonstrated that although claiming responsibility for many of the laws, the colonial rulers did not always completely support them. The tireless efforts of Indian reformers and, increasingly, women's organizations led to the enactment of the new legislation on numerous occasions. Furthermore, it has been demonstrated in numerous instances that the British government had no real interest in putting the new legislation into effect. First it was researched about the inequalities of gender in British India than about the historical backdrop of KLRI Journal of Law and Legislation Volume 13 Number 1, 2023 205 legislations than the legislations were dealt in detail. Finally, the English notions like restitution of conjugal rights and equity, justice and good conscience were imposed by the colonist were analysed. It is true for lack of time I could not deal with the second notion but highlighted the first with case laws even going into courts for decisions which are not reported in the different law reports.
Abstract
This paper will show how colonization's effects on women contributed to women's subordination in British India. The British influence in family law is taken into consideration in certain specifics, which, in contrast to prior assurances of non-interference, powerfully illustrates the creeping meddling in the indigenous religious-personal laws. In British India, the encroachment of the colonial government on Muslim family law occurred more through cases, especially in restitution of conjugal rights while for the Hindu family law it was mainly through specific statutes. The statutes enacted under the Muslim family law, although seen as a significant step to ameliorate the legal status of women, were more concerned with Islamic debates than whether the reforms were beneficial to women. The remedy of restitution of conjugal rights was a prominent example of the introduction of English notions/principles to family law in British India that affected women. The idea itself is founded on Christian ecclesiastical law. It has recently been claimed that South Asia did not adequately implement this idea. It made life extremely difficult for women as well. In the past, women who declined to live with their spouses could do so and continue living with their parents, free from obligation. According to case law, whenever a wife files an action for dissolution or for maintenance pursuant to section 2(ii) of the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act of 1939, the husband responds by bringing a suit for restitution of conjugal rights. In this paper, I evaluate the widespread belief that this period's legislation liberated women by analysing the pertinent legal framework of the time. It is demonstrated that although claiming responsibility for many of the laws, the colonial rulers did not always completely support them. The tireless efforts of Indian reformers and, increasingly, women's organizations led to the enactment of the new legislation on numerous occasions. Furthermore, it has been demonstrated in numerous instances that the British government had no real interest in putting the new legislation into effect. First it was researched about the inequalities of gender in British India than about the historical backdrop of KLRI Journal of Law and Legislation Volume 13 Number 1, 2023 205 legislations than the legislations were dealt in detail. Finally, the English notions like restitution of conjugal rights and equity, justice and good conscience were imposed by the colonist were analysed. It is true for lack of time I could not deal with the second notion but highlighted the first with case laws even going into courts for decisions which are not reported in the different law reports.
참고문헌 (99)
- Ahmad, K. N., "The Muslim Law of Divorce" (1984)
- Ali, Syed Ameer, "Islamic History and Culture" (1968)
- Ali, Syed Ameer, "Mohammedan Law, Vol. I, Vol. II" (1985)
- Almenas-Lipowsky, Angeles J., "The Position of Indian Women in the Light of Legal Reform" (1975)
- Altekar, A. S., "The Position of Women in Hindu Civilization", ~ (1938)
- Anderson, Norman, "Law Reform in the Muslim World" (1976)
- Baillie, Neil B.E., "A Right of Muhammadan Law" (1887)
- Baillie, Neil B. E., "A Digest of Mohummudan Law" (1875)
- Bhattacharjee, A. M., "Muslim Law and the Constitution" (1985)
- Billington, Mary Francis, "Women in India" (1985)
- Coulson N. J., "A History of Islamic Law" (1964)
- Cousins, E. Margaret, "Indian Womanhood Today" (1941)
- Das, F. Hauswirth, "Purdah: The Status of Indian Women" (1932)
- Esposito, John L., "Women in Muslim Family Law" (1982)
- Farroqi, Vimla, "Muslim Women: Problems and Prospects" (1993)
- Fyzee, A.A. Asaf, "Socio-cultural Impact of Islam on India" (1976)
- Fyzee, A.A. Asaf, "Outlines of Mohammadan Law" (1974)
- Fyzee, A.A. Asaf, "Outlines of Muhammadan Law" (1949)
- Gilani, Rizul Hasan, "Islamic Family Law" (1990)
- Gledhill, Alan, "The Republic of India" (1970)
- Gupta, A. R., "Women in Hindu Society" (1982)
- Hamilton, Charles, "The Hedaya" (1975)
- Haq, Mushirul, "Islam in Secular India" (1972)
- Hodkinson, Keith, "‘Muslim Family Law’, a Source Book" (1984)
- Hossain, Rokeya Shakwat, "Rokeya Rachanabali" (1973)
- Jain, M. P., "Outlines of Indian Legal History" (1966)
- Jung, Ibn. S. Mohamedullah, "A Dissertation on the Administration of Justice of Muslim Law" (1926)
- Khawar, Mumtaz, "Women of Pakistan: Two Steps Forward and One Step Backward?" (1987)
- Lateef, Shahida, "Muslim Women in India" (1990)
- Latifi, Daniel, "Justice and Social Order in India" (1984)
- Layish, Aharon, "Law in Multicultural Societies" (1985)
- Liddle, Joanna, "Daughters of Independence-Gender. Caste and Class in India" (1986)
- Macpherson, W., "Procedure of the Civil Courts 1793 of the East India Company" (1850)
- Mahmood, Tahir, "Social Legislation in India, Vol.2" (1978)
- Mahmood, Tahir, "Muslim Personal Law-Role of the State in the Indian Subcontinent" (1983)
- Mahmood, Tahir, "Personal Laws in Crisis" (1986)
- Mahmood, Tahir, "The Muslim Law of India" (1987)
- Mainul, Md, "Jamaiat-al-ulama a Hay" (1946)
- Malik, Vijay, "Muslim Law of Marriage, Divorce and Maintenance" (1988)
- Mayo, Katherine, "Mother India" (1927)
- Mayo, Katherine, "Slave of the Gods" (1933)
- McNaughten, W. H., "Principles and Precedents of Muhummuden Law" (1825)
- Mitre, Trailokyanath, "The Law Relating to Hindu Widow" (1881)
- Mitter, Dwarkanath, "The Position of Women in Hindu Law" (1984)
- Monsoor, Taslima, "From Patriarchy to Gender Equity: Family Law and its Impact on Women in Bangladesh" (1999)
- Mujeeb, M., "Islamic Influence of Indian Society" (1972)
- Mullah, Farduji Dinshad, "Principles of Mahomedan Law" (1933)
- Nasir, Jamal J., "The Islamic Law of Personal Status" (1986)
- O'Malley, L.S.S., "Modern India and the West-a Study of the Interaction of their Civilization" (1968)
- Pearl, David, "A Textbook on Muslim Law" (1987)
- Qadri, Ahmad, "Commentaries on the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939" (1961)
- Rahman, Tanzil-ur, "A Code of Muslim Personal Law, Vol. I" (1978)
- Ramadan, Said, "Islamic Law and its Scope and Equity" (1961)
- Ramusack, Barbara N., "Women and World Change: Equity Issues in Development" (1981)
- Rankin, George Clause, "Background to Indian Law" (1946)
- Saksena, Kali Prasad, "Muslim Law as Administered in India and Pakistan" (1949)
- Sastri, L. S., "The Child Marriage Restraint Act, 1929" (1988)
- Schacht, Joseph, "An Introduction to Islamic Law" (1964)
- Setalvad, M. C., "The Role of English Law in India" (1966)
- Shabbir, Mohammad, "Muslim Personal Law and Judiciary" (1988)
- Shelat, J. M., "Secularism: Principles and Application" (1972)
- Siddique, Muhammed Mazheruddin, "Women in Islam" (1952)
- Thanvi, Ashraf Ali, "Al- Hilat Al-Najija Lil Halilal Al-Ajiza" (1932), Arabic and Urdu in Delhi
- Tyabji, Faiz Badruddin, "Muslim Law" (1968)
- Upreti, H.C., "The Myth of Sati" (1991)
- Wilson, Roland Knyvet, "A Digest of Anglo-Muhammadan Law" (1895)
- Wilson, Roland Knyvet, "Anglo-Muhâmmadan Law" (1930)
- Ahmad, Furqan, "The Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application (Amendment) Bill 1986", Islamic Comparative Law Quarterly, 4 (1986)
- Carroll, Lucy, "Muslim Women and Judicial Divorce: An Apparently Misunderstood Aspect of Muslim Law", Islamic and Comparative Law Quarterly, 5 (1985)
- Carroll, Lucy, "The Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961: Provisions and Procedures-A Reference Paper for Current Research", Contributions to Indian Sociology (NS), 13 (1979)
- Chatterjee, Ramananda, "Indian Social Reformers", Modern Review (1927)
- Derrett, J. Duncan, "Justice, Equity and Good Conscience in India", Classical and Modern Hindu Law, 4 (1978)
- Derrett, J. Duncan, "The Role of Roman Law and Continental Laws in India", Classical and Modern Hindu Law, 3 (1977)
- Dhavan, Rajeev, "Borrowed Ideas: On the Impact of American Scholarship on Indian Law", American Journal of Comparative Law, 33 (1985)
- El Arousi, M., "Judicial Dissolution of Marriage", Journal of Islamic and Comparative Law, 7 (1977)
- Engels, Dagmar, "The Age of Consent Act of 1891: Colonial Ideology in Bengal", South Asia Research, 3 (1983)
- Fawcett, Millicent Garrett, "Infant Marriage in India", Contemporary Review (1890)
- Fyzee, A.A. Asaf, "Muslim Wife's Right of Dissolving her Marriage", Bombay Law Journal, 38 (1936)
- Haq, Mohammed Nurul, "The Effects of Legislation and Judicial Decision on the Muslim Law of Dower", Dhaka University Studies Part A, 45 (1988)
- Hinchcliffe, Doreen, "Divorce in Pakistan: Judicial Reform", Journal of Islamic and Comparative Law, 2 (1968)
- Hossain, Yasmin, "The Begum's Dream: Rokeya Shakwat Hossain and Broadening of Muslim Women's Aspirations in Bengal", South Asia Research, 12 (1992)
- Hussain, Syed Jaffer, "Legal Modernism in Islam: Polygamy and Repudiation", Journal of the Indian Law Institute, 7 (1965)
- Khambafta, K. J., "Dissolution of Muslim Marriage at the Instance of the Wife", Bombay Law Journal, 11 (1934)
- Liddle, Joanna, "Gender and Imperialism in British India", South Asia Research, 5 (1985)
- Mahmood, Tahir, "Personal Laws in Bangladesh-A Comparative Perspective", Journal of Indian Law Institute, 14 (1972)
- Malik, Shahdeen, "Saga of Divorce Women: Once again Shah Banu, Maintenance and Scope for Marriage Contracts", DLR, 42 (1990)
- Mannan, A. M., "The Development of the Islamic Law of Divorce in Pakistan", Journal of Islamic and Comparative Law, 5 (1974)
- Pearl, David, "Modernising Personal Laws in India", South Asia Research, 5 (1972)
- Rashid, G. Khalid, "Impact of Colonialism on the Sharia in India", Islamic and Comparative Law Quarterly, 3 (1983)
- Sen, A, "Hindu Revivalism in Action-The Age of Consent Bill Agitation in Bengal", The Indian Historical Review, 7 (1980)
- Sengupta, Indira Chowdhury, "Mother India and Mother Victoria: Motherhood and Nationalism in Nineteenth Century Bengal", South Asia Research, 12 (1992)
- Siddiqi, Dina M., "The Articulation of Gender Ideology and Nationalism among Muslims in Nineteenth Century India", Journal of Social Studies, 57 (1992)
- Singh, Sukhdev, "Development of the Concept of Divorce in Muslim Law", Allahabad Law Review, 5 (1973)
- Srivastava, D. K., "Personal Laws and Religious Freedom", Journal of the Indian Law Institute, 18 (1976)
- Sudhir, Chandra, "Whose laws? Notes on a Legitimising Myth of the Colonial Indian State", Studies in History New Series, 8 (1992)
- Tinker, Catherine, "Human Rights for Women, The U.N. Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women", Human Rights Quarterly, 3 (1991)
- Engels, Dagmar A. E., "The Changing Role of Women in Bengal 1890-1930 with Special Reference to British and Bengali Discourse on Tender", Ph.D., pp.1987
- Esposito, John L., "Muslim Family Law in Egypt and Pakistan: A Critical Analysis of Legal Reform. Its Sources and Methodological Problems", Ph.D., pp.1974
- Rashid, Abdur, "The Islamization of Laws in Pakistan-with Special Reference to the Status of Women", Ph.D., pp.1987