본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

영국 노동당 정부(1964-70)의 이민-인종정책

The Development of the British Labour Government's Immigration-Race Policy, 1964-70

0

조회

0

다운로드

7

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류역사학

초록

1964-70년의 영국 노동당 정부는 오늘날까지 이어져 내려오는 영국 이민-인종정책의 큰 틀을 확립하였다. 그것은 바로 제한적인 이민정책과 통합적인 이민자정책을 하나의 정책 틀을 구성하는 두 부분으로 결합한 것이다. 이 시기의 영국 이민-인종정책에 대한 평가는 이민제한과 이민자통합의 어느 부분에 주목하느냐에 따라 학자들 사이에서 엇갈려왔다. 이민제한에 주목하는 학자들은 영국 정부의 이민-인종정책이 옛 영제국 및 신영연방 출신의 유색인 이민자들에 대한 인종차별적 성격을 내포하고 있음을 부각시키는 반면, 이민자통합에 주목하는 학자들은 노동당이 동등하고 조화로운 인종관계를 위한 원칙을 수립했다고 주장하였다. 본 논문은 1964-70년 노동당 정부가 확립한 이민-인종정책의 발달과정을 되짚고 그 성격이 어떠했는지를 검토하는 것을 목적으로 한다. 노동당은 집권 무렵부터 야당시절에 고수했던 이민제한에 대한 원칙적인 반대 입장을 포기하고 이전의 보수당 정부가 제정한 이민제한의 법적 틀을 더욱 강화해나가는 한편 국내에 정착한 유색인 이민자들을 통합하기 위한 인종관계법을 새롭게 구상하였다. 노동당 정부는 이민제한을 통하여 유권자들을 만족시키는 동시에, 이민자통합을 통하여 노동당이 야당 시절에 보여주었던 반인종차별적 태도를 지지했던 노동당의 지식인적 지지기반을 끌어안으려 하였다. 그러나 결국 제한과 통합이라는 이민-인종정책의 두 부분은 균형을 이루지 못한 것으로 드러났으며, 통합의 시도는 유색인 이민자들을 문젯거리로 간주하는 시선에 의해 상당부분 침식당할 수밖에 없었다.

Abstract

This thesis aims to study the development of British immigration-race policy established by Harold Wilson’s Labour government from 1964-70. Today, Britain is a multi-racial, multi-cultural society in which less than 10% of its residents have ancestors who immigrated to Britain from the British Empire and New Commonwealth after 1945. Facing the unwanted inflow of British subjects with darker skin and unfamiliar cultural backgrounds, British governments have introduced various legislative and administrative measures to stem the inflow of these people and to integrate already-settled immigrants into society. The 1964-70 Labour government period is especially critical in establishing the two-fold strategy of exclusive immigration policy on one side and inclusive immigrant policy on the other side, which has been passed down even until today. Scholars generally agree that the 1964-70 Labour government period is an important time in the development of British immigration-race policy, but the evaluation of this period among scholars has been significantly diverged. Scholarly opinions have differed due to varying emphasis on either immigration policy or immigrant policy. Scholars who emphasize restrictive immigration policy tend to criticize that the Labour government clearly intended to keep coloured immigrants out. On the other hand, other scholars who noticed that the first legislative measures to integrate immigrants first appeared in 1964-70 advocated the liberal feature of the Labour government’s years. It is important, however, not to consider immigration policy and immigrant policy separately. The two policies have been developed in the context of responding to the phenomenon of ‘coloured immigration,’ although the two were designed to fulfill different purposes. Around the time when Harold Wilson’s Labour government came to office in 1964, it abandoned its previous position of firm opposition toward the immigration restriction system adopted by the previous Conservative government. Furthermore, the Labour government even tightened immigration restrictions, at the same time designing the Race Relations Act to integrate already-settled immigrants. With this linkage of the exclusive measures at the border with the inclusive measures inside the border, the Labour government aimed not only to satisfy the public through the immigration restriction but also to maintain support of the intellectuals who had advocated Labour’s former anti-restriction stance. However, the two parts of the race-immigration policy, composed of restrictions on one side and integration on the other, proved to be exceedingly weighted toward the restriction side. Moreover, the attempt to integrate immigrants was significantly limited due to the perspective of coloured immigrants as ‘a problem.’

참고문헌 (33)

  1. "British Nationality Act", ~ (1948)
  2. "Race Relations Act", ~ (1965)
  3. "Commonwealth Immigrants Act", ~ (1968)
  4. "Race Relations Act", ~ (1968)
  5. "Cabinet: CAB 128, 129, 134", ~
  6. "Home Office: HO 376", ~
  7. "Prime Minister’s Office: PREM 13", ~
  8. "Volume 649, Nov. 1961", ~ (1961)
  9. "Volume 705, Feb. 1965", ~ (1965)
  10. "Volume 708, Mar. 1965", ~ (1965)
  11. "Volume 709, Mar. 1965", ~ (1965)
  12. "Volume 716, July. 1965", ~ (1965)
  13. "Volume 717, Aug. 1965", ~ (1965)
  14. "Volume 759, Feb. 1968", ~ (1968)
  15. "Volume 763, Apr. 1968", ~ (1968)
  16. Banton, Michael, "Promoting Racial Harmony" (1985), Cambridge University Press
  17. Bleich, Erik, "Race Politics in Britain and France: Ideas and Policymaking since the 1960s" (2003), Cambridge University Press
  18. Dorey, Peter, "The Labour Governments 1964-70" (2006), Routledge
  19. Hansen, Randall, "Citizenship and Immigration in Post-War Britain" (2000), Oxford University Press
  20. Joppke, Christian, "Immigration and the Nation-State: the United States, Germany, and Great Britain" (1999), Oxford University Press
  21. Lester, Anthony, "Race and Law" (1972), Penguin
  22. Miles, Robert, "White Man’s Country: Racism in British Politics" (1984), Pluto Press
  23. Paul, Kathleen, "Whitewashing Britain: Race and Citizenship in the Post Era" (1997), Cornell University Press
  24. Pimlott, Ben, "Harold Wilson" (1992), Harper Collins
  25. Rose, E. J. B., "Colour and Citizenship: A Report on British Race Relations" (1969), Oxford University Press
  26. Saggar, Shammit, "Race and Politics in Britain" (1992), Harvester Wheatsheaf
  27. Solomos, John, "Race and Racism in Britain" (1993), Macmillan
  28. Spencer, Ian R. G., "British Immigration Policy since 1939: The Making of Multi-Racial Britain" (1997), Routledge
  29. 박지향, "영국사: 보수와 개혁의 드라마" (2007), 까치
  30. Miles, Robert, "The Riots of 1958: Notes on the Ideological Construction of ‘Race Relations’ as a Political Issue in Britain", Immigrants and Minorities, 3, pp.252~275 (1984)
  31. Saggar, Shammit, "Re-examining the 1964-70 labour government’s race relations strategy", Contemporary British History, 7(2), pp.253~281 (1993)
  32. 정희라, "영국의 자유방임식 다문화주의 ― 영국적 전통과 이민자 통합 ―", 이화사학연구, (35), pp.1~27 (2007), 이화사학연구소
  33. 정희라, "‘자유방임 이민국’에서 ‘제로(Zero) 이민국’으로", 서양사론, (93), pp.247~270 (2007)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)