시군통합 모형의 이론적 고찰을 통한 시군통합의 한계 탐색: 2단계 C3 모형과 제도적 집단행동모형을 중심으로
Exploring the limitations of city and county integration through theoretical examination of the city and county integration model: focusing on the two-stage C3 model and the institutional collective action model.
0
조회
0
다운로드
15
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Abstract
In Korea, there are many trying to consolidate between and among cities and counties, however, only two cases are success. Although most self organizing consolidation efforts failed, many local governments still have working for consolidation. The purpose of this paper to explore why does this idea of city-county consolidation persist on many local government decision agendas despite of high failure rate? and nevertheless, why numerous efforts of consolidation didn't accomplish the success. What factors influence the passage of referenda. For finding this questions,this papers examined the USA city-consolidation cases, and we focused on theoretical model and framework to understand of this real world situations. Leland and Thurmaier's two stage city-county consolidation model(C3 model) and institutional collective action framework suggest that there are too many veto point and high transaction cost to comprehensive consolidation. Therefore we can try to adopt alternative mechanism like as ILA and partnership instead of city-county consolidation which have high social conflict cost as well as high failure rate.
참고문헌 (82)
- 강용기, "자치구역 및 계층의 점진적 4단계 재편론", 한국자치행정학보, 22(1), pp.119~131 (2008), 한국자치행정학회
- 김대원, "통합시의 생산성 증대효과 분석-공공 산출물의 측정모형의 적용을 중심으로", 한국행정학, 33(3), pp.327~344 (1999)
- 김동훈, "도농통합형 행정구역개편의 효과분석 및 발전방향에 관한 연구", 사회과학논총, 7, pp.235~277 (1996)
- 김선기, "통합시의 배경과 과제", 도시문제, 3, pp.9~18 (1995)
- 김재홍, "정책연구논문", 도농통합 행정구역 개편이 지방정부의 효율성 변화에 미친 영향 연구, 2000, pp.9(2), 47~66[DOI]
- 박기관, "도농통합의 성과평가에 관한 연구: 원주시 10년의 통합효과를 중심으로", 지방행정연구, 20(3), pp.21~50 (2006), 한국지방행정연구원
- 박기관, "행정구역개편에 따른 도?농 통합의 성과와 결정요인 분석: DEA의 효율성 측정을 중심으로", 지방행정연구, 21(2), pp.65~93 (2007), 한국지방행정연구원
- 박종관, "시ㆍ군 통합에 의한 행정구역개편 정책의 성과평가에 관한 연구", 한국사회와 행정연구, 12(3), pp.57~77 (2001)
- 박지형, "시, 군 통합의 지역경제성장 효과", 16(1), pp.167~197, 한국정책학회
- 배득종, "행정구역 개편이 지방재정에 미치는 영향; 행정구역 개편이 지역발전에 미치는 영향", 지방재정과 지방세, 10, pp.31~42 (2008)
- 안성호, "한국의 지방자치체제 개편과 방향: 정치권 지방자치체제 개편안의 문제점과 과제", 지방정부연구, 14(1), pp.7~35 (2010), 한국지방정부학회
- 양고운, "지방정부 간 자율적 행정구역 통합의 성공요인 탐색:간 자율적 행정구역 통합의 성공요인 탐색:퍼지집합 질적비교분석(fsQCA)의 적용", 한국지방자치학회보, 25(1), pp.91~116 (2013), 한국지방자치학회
- 원윤희, "행정구역 개편이 지방재정에 미치는 영향; 행정구역 개편이 지방세출에 미치는 영향", 지방재정과 지방세, 10, pp.17~30 (2008)
- 유재원, "시군통합의 효과에 대한 경험적 분석: 단절적 시계열모형(ARIMA)의 적용", 한국행정학보, 43(4), pp.285~306 (2009), 한국행정학회
- 유재원, "시군통합의 추진동력과 정책대안", 한국행정학보, 44(1), pp.179~202 (2010), 한국행정학회
- 유재원, "대국민 인식조사를 토대로 한 지방분권 추진전략과 지방행정체제 개편" (2009), 전국시도지사협의회
- 이명석, "제도와 정부규모: 시정부를 중심으로", 한국행정학, 33(4), pp.211~224 (1999)
- 이성로, "도농통합이 주민의 정치적 행태에 미친 영향:공공선택이론의 시각에서", 한국행정학보, 37(1), pp.165~182 (2003), 한국행정학회
- 이시원, "시, 군 통합에 따른 행정구역 개편의 효율성 분석-DEA 분석 기법을 적용한 통합 전후의 비교를 중심으로", 한국사회와 행정연구, 12(3), pp.79~101 (2001)
- 이재기, "시, 군통합의 경제적 효과에 관한 연구-행정비용절감효과를 중심으로", 한국지방재정논집, 5(1), pp.113~141 (2000)
- 장덕희, "청주-청원 지방행정체제 개편의 정책효과 추정", 지방행정연구, 26(3), pp.59~88 (2012), 한국지방행정연구원
- 정순관, "지방행정구역개편 의제에 대한 비판적 논의", 12(1), pp.241~256 (2005), 한국거버넌스학회
- 정순관, "지방행정체제 개편논의: 주장의 혼재와 지역의 선택", 한국정책연구, 9(2), pp.1~19 (2009), 경인행정학회
- 최영출, "시군통합의 예산절감효과 추정 : 중복 공공시설의 절감효과", 도시행정학보, 18(3), pp.147~169 (2005), 한국도시행정학회
- 최흥석, "도농통합의 재정적 효과성에 관한 연구", 지방행정연구, 19(4), pp.145~172 (2005), 한국지방행정연구원
- 황수연, "지방자치하에서의 지대추구", 사회과학연구, 12, pp.27~45 (1996)
- 홍준현, "시ㆍ군통합에 의한 행정구역개편의 효과분석", 한국사회와 행정연구, 8(2), pp.59~90 (1997)
- Agranoff, Robert, "Inside the matrix: Integrating the paradigms of intergovernmental and network management", International Journal of Public Administration, 26(12), pp.1401~1422 (2003)
- Barnes, William R., "The new regional economics. The US Common", ~ (1998)
- Benton, J. Edwin, "City", County Consolidation and Economies of Scale: Evidence from a Time-Series Analysis in Jacksonville, Florida, 1984, pp.65(1), 190~198
- Bickers, Kenneth N., "The Microfoundations of the Tiebout Model", Urban Affairs Review, 34(1), pp.76~93 (1998)
- Birkland, Thomas A., "After Disaster: Agenda Setting, Public Policy, and Focusing Events" (1997), Georgetown University Press
- Blomquist, William, "Fiscal, service, and political impacts of Indianapolis-Marion County's Unigov", Publius: The Journal of Federalism, 25(4), pp.37~54 (1995)
- Bunch, Beverly S., "Municipal Consolidation An Analysis of the Financial Benefits for Fiscally Distressed Small Municipalities", Urban Affairs Review, 27(4), pp.615~629 (1992)
- Carr, Jered B., "Metropolitan Government and Economic Development", Urban Affairs Review, 34(3), pp.476~488 (1999)
- Carr, Jered B., "City-county Consolidation and its Alternatives:Reshaping the Local Government Landscape" (2004), ME Sharpe Inc
- Carr, Jered B., "Whose game do we play? Local Government Boundary Change and Metropolitan Governance, In Metropolitan governance: Conflict, competition, and cooperation", pp.212~239 (2004)
- Condrey, Stephen E., "Organizational And Personnel Impacts On Local Government Consolidation: Athens‐Clarke County, Georgia", Journal of Urban Affairs, 16(4), pp.371~383 (1994)
- Dodge, William R., "Regional Problem Solving in the 1990s: Experimentation with Local Governance for the 21st Century", National Civic Review, 79(4), pp.354~366 (1990)
- Downs, Anthony., "New visions for metropolitan America" (1994), Brookings Institution Press
- Durning, Dan., "The Effects of City-County Government Consolidation: The Perspectives of United Government Employees in Athens-Clarke County, Georgia", Public Administration Quarterly, pp.272~298 (1995)
- DeHoog, Ruth Hoogland, "Citizen Satisfaction with Local governance: A test of Individual, Jurisdictional, and City-Specific Explanations", Journal of Politics, 52(3), pp.807~837 (1990)
- Erie S.P, "The Study of Local Governance and Policymaking", Pubic Administration Review, 32(2), pp.172~183 (1972)
- Feiock, Richard C., "Private incentives and academic entrepreneurship:The promotion of city-county consolidation", Public Administration Quarterly, 24(2), pp.223~245 (2000)
- Feiock, Richard C., "A Quasi-Market Framework for Local Economic Development Competition", Journal of Urban Affairs, 24, pp.123~142 (2002)
- Feiock, Richard, "Institutional Collective Action and Joint Ventures for Economic Development", Public Administration Review (2007)
- City County Consolidation Efforts:Selective Incentives and Institutional Choice, "Feiock, Richard C.", Korea Research Institute for Local Administration, ~ (2006)
- Feiock, Richard C., "Is the World “Flat” or “Spiky”? Rethinking the Governance Implications of Globalization for Economic Development", Public Administration Review, 68(1), pp.24~35 (2008)
- Fleischmann, Arnold, "Regionalism and city-county consolidation in small metro areas", State & Local Government Review, 32(3), pp.213~226 (2000)
- Foster, Kathryn A., "Regional impulses", Journal of Urban Affairs, 19(4), pp.375~403 (1997)
- Gustely, Richard D., "The Allocational and Distributional Impacts of Governmental Consolidation The Dade County Experience", Urban Affairs Review, 12(3), pp.349~364 (1977)
- Grant, D., "Comparison of Predictions and Experience with Nashville ‘Metro’", Urban Affairs Quarterly, 1(1), pp.34~54 (1964)
- Heckathorn, Douglas D., "Bargaining and the Sources of Transaction Costs: The Case of Government Regulation", JL Econ. & Org, 3, pp.69~ (1987)
- Inman, Robert P., "Rethinking federalism", The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 11(4), pp.43~64 (1997)
- Johnson, Linda S, "Revolutionary Change in Local Governance:Revisiting the Rosenbaum and Kammerer Theory of Successful City-County Consolidation", Journal of Political Science, 27, pp.21~52 (1999)
- Leland, Suzanne M., "Case Studies of City-County Consolidation:Reshaping the Local Government Landscape" (2004)
- Leland, Suzanne M., "Lessons from 35 Years of City–County Consolidation Attempts" (2006), Municipal Yearbook
- Leland, Suzanne M., "City-county Consolidation: Promises Made, Promises Kept?" (2010), Georgetown University Press
- Lowery, David, "A Transactions Costs Model of Metropolitan Governance: Allocation versus Redistribution in Urban America", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 10(1), pp.49~78 (2000)
- Lowery, David, "Metropolitan Governance Structures from a Neoprogressive Perspective", Swiss Political Science Review, 7(3), pp.130~136 (2001)
- Lubell, M., "Watershed Partnerships and the Emergence of Collective Action Institutions", American Journal of Political Science, pp.148~163 (2002)
- Messinger, Boyd R., "Local Government Restructuring: A Test of the Rosenbaum-Kammerer Theory", 박사, pp.1989
- Miller, D., "The Fiscal Organization of Metropolitan Areas: The Allegheny County Case Reconsidered", Publius, 25(4), pp.19~35 (1995)
- Moore, Adrian, "Putting out the trash measuring municipal service efficiency in US cities", Urban Affairs Review, 41(2), pp.237~259 (2005)
- Oakerson, Ronald J., "Governing Local Public Economies: Creating the Civic Metropolis" (1999), ICS Press
- Olberding, Julie Cencula, "Diving into the “Third Waves” of Regional Governance and Economic Development Strategies: A Study of Regional Partnerships for Economic Development in US Metropolitan Areas", Economic Development Quarterly, 16(3), pp.251~272 (2002)
- Oliver, J. E., "Democracy in suburbia" (2001), Princeton University Press
- O'Looney, John, "GIS and Enlightened Location-Based Tourism: An Innovation Whose Time Has Come", The Twenty-Fourth Annual ESRI User Conference (2004)
- Ostrom, Elinor, "Governing the Commons: Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action" (1990), Cambridge University Press
- Park, Hyung Jun, "Collaborative Approach to Economic Development of Local Government and Institutional Collective Action", 박사, pp.2005
- Hyung Jun Park, "Institutional Collective Action, Social Capital and Regional Deveplopment Partnership", International Review of Public Administration, 11(2), pp.57~70 (2007), 한국행정학회
- Rusk, D., "Cities without suburbs" (1993), Woodrow Wilson Center Press
- Rogers, Bruce D., "Reform: Citizen Evaluations of Performances in Nashville-Davidson County, Tennessee", Publius, 4(4), pp.19~34 (1974)
- Rosenbaum, W.A., "Against Long Odds: The Theory and Practice of Successful Governmental Consolidation" (1974), Sage
- Savitch, Hank V., "Regional Patterns in a PostCity Age", Urban Affairs Annual Reviews, 45, pp.1~22 (1996)
- Savitch, Hank V., "Introduction: Paths to New Regionalism", State & Local Government Review, 32(3), pp.158~168 (2000)
- Schneider, Mark, "The Competitive City: The Political Economy of Suburbia" (1989), University of Pittsburgh Press
- Seamon, Fred, "Political Participation and City County Consolidation: Jacksonville-Duval County", International Journal of Public Administration, 18(11), pp.1741~1752 (1995)
- Selden, Sally Coleman, "The expenditure impacts of unification in a small Georgia county: A contingency perspective of city-county consolidation", Public Administration Quarterly, 24(2), pp.169~201 (2000)
- Stephens, G. Ross, "Metropolitan Government and Governance:Theoretical Perspectives, Empirical Analysis, and the Future" (2000), Oxford University Press
- Teske, Paul, "Establishing the Micro Foundations of a Macro Theory: Information, Movers, and the Competitive Local Market for Public Goods", American Political Science Review, 87, pp.702~713 (1993)
- Thurmaier, Kurt, "Interlocal Agreements as Overlapping Social Networks:Picket–Fence Regionalism in Metropolitan Kansas City", Public Administration Review, 62(5), pp.585~598 (2002)
