조약의 언어와 해석 그리고 번역 - 수호통상조약을 중심으로
Language of Treaty, interpretation and translation
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Joseon Dynasty begin its first official contact with western powers in the 1800s, and was almost forced to become included into the world order centered around the western nations. Joseon faced open without any preparations, which was different from Japan and western powers that had made detailed preparation for a long time for the purpose of invasion into Joseon. With the friendship and trade treaty between Joseon and Japan in 1876 as the start, Joseon entered into friendship and trade treaty with western powers, such as the U.S.A., England, France, Germany and Russia. All the commercial treaties not only with western powers but also with Japan and China were unequal. In fact, Japan and China, which had opened their doors to foreign countries before Joseon did, also signed unequal treaties with the western nations. Joseon concluded more unequal treaties than Japan and China because of its lack of understanding of foreign languages as well as of modern western laws. In addition,it made a language-decisive mistake in that treaties written in foreign languages became the standard of interpretation when misunderstandings related to law clauses arose. It showed how poor the understanding of the importance of languages and translation was in those days. This attitude ended up incurring an economic loss in reality
Abstract
Joseon Dynasty begin its first official contact with western powers in the 1800s, and was almost forced to become included into the world order centered around the western nations. Joseon faced open without any preparations, which was different from Japan and western powers that had made detailed preparation for a long time for the purpose of invasion into Joseon. With the friendship and trade treaty between Joseon and Japan in 1876 as the start, Joseon entered into friendship and trade treaty with western powers, such as the U.S.A., England, France, Germany and Russia. All the commercial treaties not only with western powers but also with Japan and China were unequal. In fact, Japan and China, which had opened their doors to foreign countries before Joseon did, also signed unequal treaties with the western nations. Joseon concluded more unequal treaties than Japan and China because of its lack of understanding of foreign languages as well as of modern western laws. In addition,it made a language-decisive mistake in that treaties written in foreign languages became the standard of interpretation when misunderstandings related to law clauses arose. It showed how poor the understanding of the importance of languages and translation was in those days. This attitude ended up incurring an economic loss in reality
참고문헌 (14)
- Massini, F, "근대중국의 언어와 역사" (2006), 소명출판
- 김영수, "1884년 한러조약, 언어와 해석의 차이", 사림, (38), pp.141~167 (2011), 수선사학회
- 김정건, "국제조약집" (1986), 연세대학교출판부
- 박찬호, "국제해양법" (2009), 지인북스
- 박한민, "1878년 두모진 수세를 둘러싼 조일 양국의 인식과 대응", 한일관계사연구, 39(39), pp.369~421 (2011), 한일관계사학회
- 외교통상부 조약국, "알기쉬운 조약업무", 외교통상부 조약국, ~ (2006)
- 이건상, "가이세이조(開成所)의 개혁(改革)과 제학제술(諸學諸術) ―교육적 개혁의 실시와 이에 대한 의미를 중심으로―", 日本語敎育, (44), pp.261~277 (2008), 한국일본어교육학회
- 이진구, "조불조약이 초기 개신교의 선교활동에 미친 영향", 교회사연구, (27), pp.33~57 (2006), (재)한국교회사연구소
- 장복희, "조약의 해석 및 적용:유럽인권협약을 중심으로", 법학연구, 19(2), pp.365~386 (2011), 법학연구소
- 최덕수, "조약으로 본 한국 근대사" (2010), 열린책들
- 최종고, "한독수호통상조약의 체결과정", 한독법학, 3, pp.21~43 (1982)
- "한겨레신문 2011년 3월 9일자 기사", ~ (2011)
- "뉴욕타임즈 1885년 7월 19일자", ~ (1885)
- "한국일보 2010년 6월 20일 기사", ~ (2010)
