본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

China and Contemporary Korean Nationalism: Reflecting on China s NortheastProject

장동진|송경호|황민혁
한국학중앙연구원 (The Academy of Korean Studies)|2009.03|Korea Journal|제49권 제1호|pp. 120-153|DOI 10.25024/kj.2009.49.1.120

0

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

GoguryeoChinese nationalismNortheast Projectzhonghua minzuKorean nationalism
주제분류한국어와문학

초록

China’s Northeast Project (NEP), also known as the “Research Project of Northeastern China,” has unleashed national sentiment among many Korean people. Even if it originated in purely academic research, the NEP poses a grave political challenge to contemporary Korea. The Korean response to the NEP can be broadly categorized in two ways: The first is that while negative perceptions of these moves by the Chinese have prevailed in Korean society, the Korean government has been very cautious in expressing criticism of the NEP due to national interests with the Chinese government. The other point is that as time has progressed, a series of Korean self-reflections on the complex nature of nationalism in response to the NEP has emerged. With the analysis of these self-reflections, this paper attempts to address an inter-subjective nationalist perspective of history as a solution that recognizes “mutual recognition of national identity” in considering the prevailing reality of Northeastern Asian nationalism.

Abstract

China’s Northeast Project (NEP), also known as the “Research Project of Northeastern China,” has unleashed national sentiment among many Korean people. Even if it originated in purely academic research, the NEP poses a grave political challenge to contemporary Korea. The Korean response to the NEP can be broadly categorized in two ways: The first is that while negative perceptions of these moves by the Chinese have prevailed in Korean society, the Korean government has been very cautious in expressing criticism of the NEP due to national interests with the Chinese government. The other point is that as time has progressed, a series of Korean self-reflections on the complex nature of nationalism in response to the NEP has emerged. With the analysis of these self-reflections, this paper attempts to address an inter-subjective nationalist perspective of history as a solution that recognizes “mutual recognition of national identity” in considering the prevailing reality of Northeastern Asian nationalism.

참고문헌 (53)

  1. Ahn,Byung Woo, "Jungguk-ui goguryeosa waegok-gwa dongbukgongjeong (Chinese Fabrication of Goguryeo History and the Northeast Project)", Gukje jeongchi yeongu (Youngnam Journal of International Relations), 7(2), pp.45~66 (2004)
  2. Anderson, Benedict, "Imagined Communities" (1991), Verso
  3. Baik, Young-seo, "Dongasia pyeonghwa guchuk-eul wihan yeoksa ilgi: myeotgaji jeeon(Interpretation of History for the Construction of Peace in East Asia: Some Suggestions)", Hwanghae munhwa (Hwanghae Review), 45 (2004)
  4. Mark E. Byington, "해결되지 않는 과거와 현대사의 딜레마", 고구려발해연구, (18), pp.373~400 (2004), 고구려발해학회
  5. Byington, Mike E., "Yeongto anbo-ui munje-ro boneun 20 segi jungguk-ui goguryeosa yeongu(China’s Studies on Goguryeo in 20th Century in View of Territorial Security) in: Minjokjuui-wa yeoksa gyogwaseo (Nationalism and History Textbooks in Asia and Europe)" (2006), The Academy of Korean Studies
  6. Carr, E. H., "What Is History?" (1961), Random House
  7. 최연식, "탈냉전기 중국의 민족주의와 동북아질서", 21세기정치학회보, 14(1), pp.245~267 (2004), 21세기정치학회
  8. Chung,Doo-Hee, "Jungguk-ui dongbukgongjeong-euro jegideon hanguk sahakgye-ui myeotgaji munje (A Critical Review on the Dispute of the History of Kingdom of Goguryeo between Korea and China)", Yeoksa hakbo (Korean Historical Review), 183, pp.457~476 (2004)
  9. Habermas, Jürgen, "The Postnational Constellation" (2001), MIT Press
  10. Habermas, Jürgen, "Der gespaltene Westen" (2004), Suhrkamp
  11. Han, Young-Woo, "Geundae hanguk sahak-ui baldal(The Development of Modern Korean Historical Studies) in: Hanguksa teukgang (Special Lecture for Korean History)" (1990), Seoul National University Press
  12. Hobsbawm. E. J., "Nations and Nationalism since 1780. 2nd ed", Cambridge University Press
  13. Jiang, Mengshan, "Goguryeosa-ui gwisok munje(On the Issue of Goguryeo History) in: Junggugindeul-ui goguryeo yeongu: dongbuk gongjeong-ui nolli (Chinese Studies on Goguryeo: The Logic of China’s Northeast Project)" (2005), The Academy of Korean Studies
  14. Jin, Yufu, "Kim Yukbul-ui dongguk tongsa (Comprehensive His-tory of China’s Northeast of Jin Yufu). Vols. 1-2" (2007), NAHF
  15. 전병곤, "중국 「동북공정」의 정치적 함의", 중국연구, 38(2006) (2006), 중국연구소
  16. Kang,Gwon-Chan, "Minjok jeongchaek-gwa jeongchi jeollyak-e uihan yeoksa waegok (Distortion of History Intended by National and Political Policies)", Minjok yeongu (Research on Ethnology), 14, pp.98~122 (2004)
  17. 강준영, "中國의 高句麗史 認識이 韓中關係에 미치는 影響*- “東北工程”을 둘러싼 양국의 歷史 認識을 중심으로 -", 중국연구, 36, pp.201~214 (2005), 중국연구소
  18. 강준영, "中國의 東北工程 再論", 중국연구, 38(2006) (2006), 중국연구소
  19. Kim, Gi-Bong, "Sidae chagojeok yeoksa haeseok-eseo talpihaja” (Let’s Break from the Anachronistic Interpretation of History). Gyosu sinmun (Newspaper for Scholars), December 18", ~ (2008)
  20. Kim, Han-gyu, "Yodongsa (History of Liaodong)" (2004), Munji Publishing
  21. Kim, Han-gyu, "Yeoksasang-ui jungguk-gwa jungguksa-ui beomju: hyeondae jungguk-ui minjokgwangyesa yeongu(China in History and the Scope of Chinese History: A Review of the Chinese Research on the History of Relations between Nations in the Boundary of Contemporary China) in: Dongasia minjokjuui-ui jangbyeok-eul neomeo (Beyond the Barrier of Nationalism in East Asia)", pp.87~123 (2005), Sungkyunkwan University Press
  22. Kim, In-Sung, "Yeoksajeok jinsil waegok-e daehan bipan-gwa banseong(A Critique and Reflection on the Distortion of Historical Facts)", Minjok yeongu, 32, pp.123~177 (2004)
  23. 김위현, "동북공정 이후 우리학계의 과제", 동양학, (42), pp.307~321 (2007), 동양학연구소
  24. 김우준, "중국의 대내외 전략과 동북공정: 현황과 우리의 대응", 세계지역연구논총, 22권(2호) (2004), 한국세계지역학회
  25. Koguryo Research Foundation, "2004 goguryeo yeongujaedan yeongu jaryo pyeollamjip (The Koguryo Research Foundation Collection of Research Materials)" (2007), Koguryo Research Foundation
  26. Lee, Da-Long, "Goguryeo-neun godae jungguk-ui ilgae jibang minjok jeonggwon(Goguryeo as a Local Nation’s Government of Ancient China)", Minjok yeongu, 14, pp.50~53 (2004)
  27. 이희옥, "China's Northeast Project and South Korean-Chinese Relations", Korea Journal, 45(2), pp.239~264 (2005), 유네스코한국위원회
  28. 이희옥, "동북공정의 정치적 논란에 비판적 해석", 동아연구, (53), pp.9~45 (2007), 동아연구소
  29. Lee, Jong-Wook, "Yeoksa chungdol (The Collision of History)" (2003), Gimm-Young
  30. 이순근, "On the Historical Succession of Goguryeo in Northeast Asia", Korea Journal, 45(1), pp.172~201 (2005), 유네스코한국위원회
  31. Li, Sheng, "Dongbukgongjeong-gwa goguryeo yeoksa yeongu-e daehan myeotgaji gyeonhae(Several Remarks on the Northeast Project and Historical Research of Goguryeo) in: Goguryeo yeoksa munjae yeongu nonmunjip (A Collection of Research Papers about the Issue of the History of Goguryeo)" (2005), Koguryo Research Foundation
  32. Lim, Hyung-Taek, "Dongasia minjokjuui-ui jangbyeok-eul neomeo (Beyond the Barrier of Nationalism in East Asia.)" (2005), Sungkyunkwan University Press
  33. Lim, Jie-Hyun, "Jeokdaejeok gongbeomjadeul (Antagonistic Accomplices)" (2005), Sonamu
  34. 임기환, "중국의 동북공정과 한국 역사학계의 대응: 고구려사 인식을 중심으로", 사림, (26), pp.1~22 (2006), 수선사학회
  35. Liu, Housheng, "Dongguk byeongyeongsa yeongu-ui ganghwa-rul gidae hamyeonseo(Expecting to Strengthen Northeastern Borderland History) in: Junggugindeul-ui goguryeo yeongu: dongbuk gongjeong-ui nolli (Chinese Studies on Goguryeo: The Logic of China’s Northeast Project)" (2005), The Academy of Korean Studies
  36. Nah, Youngju, "Dongbuk gongjeong-ui baljon gwajeong-gwa jeongchijeok seonggyeok (The Development and Political Characteristics of China’s Northeast Project)", njok yeongu, 32, pp.6~32 (2004)
  37. 남정휴, "중국 근대국가 형성과정을 통해서 본 중국의 민족주의", 한국동북아논총, 10(37), pp.79~102 (2005), 한국동북아학회
  38. Northeast Asian History Foundation, "2005 nyeondo jungguk-ui goguryeosa yeongu nonmunjip (A Collection of Chinese Papers on the History of Goguryeo in 2005)" (2005), Northeast Asian History Foundation
  39. Park, Jung-su, "Dongbuk gongjeong, hana-ui jungguk-inga, gyeongje baljeon-inga(The NEP, One China or Economic Development?)", Wolgan ataejiyeok donghyang (Asia-pacific Monthly Review), 153, pp.5~15 (2004)
  40. 박선영, "중국의 국가주권과 통일의 기억 만들기 ―동북프로젝트의 거시적 함의", 중국근현대사연구, (24), pp.91~110 (2004), 중국근현대사학회
  41. Piao, Wenyi, "Goguryeo yeoksa munjae yeongu nonmunjip (A Collection of Research Papers on the Issue of the History of Goguryeo)" (2005), Koguryo Research Foundation
  42. Piao, Wenyi, "Yeoksasang-eseo ‘jung’-gwa ‘wae’-ui hoekbun munje-e daehan chobojeogin gyeonhae(An Introductory Review on the Demarcation of the Center (Zhong) and the Outside (Wai) in Chinese History) in: Goguryeo yeoksa munje yeongu nonmunjip" (2005), Koguryo Research Foundation
  43. Piao, Zhenshi, "Jungguk gungnaeoe goseo-e gijaedeon go-guryeo-ui yeoksajeok jiwi-e gwanhan siron(An Attempting Analysis on the Historical Status of Goguryeo in Old Chinese Historical Records) in: Goguryeo yeoksa munje yeongu nonmunjip", pp.76~101 (2005), Koguryo Research Foundation
  44. 유용태, "중화민족론과 동북지정학― 논리근거", 동양사학연구, (93), pp.177~225 (2005), 동양사학회
  45. Shin, Jong-Won, "Junggugindeul-ui goguryeo yeongu: dongbuk gongjeong-ui nolli (Chinese Studies on Goguryeo: The Logic of China’s Northeast Project)" (2005), The Academy of Korean Studies
  46. So, Chi-hyeong, "Jungguk-ui dongbuk gongjeong-gwa jeongchijeok uido (China’s NEP and Its Political Intention)", Jungguk yeongu, 23, pp.47~68 (2004)
  47. Sun, Jinji, "Guksa-ui beomwi hwakjeong-e gwanhayeo(On the Scope of National History) in: 2005 nyeondo jungguk-ui goguryeosa yeongu nonmunjip" (2005), Northeast Asian History Foundation
  48. Tan, Qixiang, "Yeoksasang-ui jungguk-gwa jungguk-ui yeokdae gangyeok(China in History and Historical Realm of China) in: Junggugindeul-ui goguryeo yeongu: dongbuk gongjeong-ui nolli", pp.67~89 (2005), The Academy of Korean Studies
  49. Wang, Ke, "Minjok-gwa gukga: jungguk daminjok tongil gukga sasangui gyebo (Ethnicity and the State: Genealogy of China’s Theory of the Unified Multiethnic State)" (2005), Koguryo Research Foundation
  50. Yiwei Wang, "Seeking China’s New Identity : the Myth of Chinese Nationalism", 비교문화연구, 11(1), pp.79~106 (2007), 비교문화연구소
  51. 윤휘탁, "China's Northeast Project and Korean History", Korea Journal, 45(1), pp.142~171 (2005), 유네스코한국위원회
  52. 尹輝鐸, "中國의 東北邊疆政策 ―’을 중심으로", 중국근현대사연구, (27), pp.121~152 (2005), 중국근현대사학회
  53. Youn,Myung-chul, "Guguryeo-wa su dang jeonjaeng-ui seonggyeok-e gwanhan haeseok—dongbuk gongjeong-gwa gwallyeon-hayeo(On the Character of Wars between Koguryo and Sui-Tang)", Goguryeo yeongu (Goguryeo Studies), 18, pp.811~836 (2004)

관련 논문AI추천

Nationalism and State Interests: Seoul’s Restrained Rejoinder to China’s Northeast Project민인영, 조영철한국아시아학회 · 아시아연구2011 · 제14권 제1호Contending Perspectives on Koguryo: A Fresh Look at China’s Northeast Project판카즈 모한동국역사문화연구소 · 동국사학2011 · 제50호Different Historical Prisms and Regressive Political Reconciliation in Northeast Asia조영철, 천자현국제지역연구원 · 아태연구2016 · 제23권 제3호중국의 동북공정에 대한 한국 학계의 인식 분석: 정체성 정치를 중심으로차정미평화연구소 · 문화와 정치2019 · 제6권 제1호China's Northeast Project and Korean History윤휘탁한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2005 · 제45권 제1호Nationalism, Regionalism and Prospects for an East Asian Community김용민, 남종호, 이선필한국유럽학회 · 유럽연구2015 · 제33권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (4건)

Eochongye Social Capital in Jujeon-dong, Ulsan최종렬pp. 5-32Irw olhoe and the Introduction of Marxism into Korea in the 1920s박종린pp. 33-60Negotiating Identities and Re-acculturation of Second-Generation Korean Americans: The Role of Ethnic Media and Peer Group Dynamics박소라pp. 61-97Formation of the Minganhak and Modern Magazines in Colonial Korea: Focused on the Case of Gaebyeok한기형pp. 98-119
원문 보기