『史記』 「匈奴列傳」의 建國 前史 構成
Sima Qian’s Composition of the Pre-History of Xiongnu Empire
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Sima Qian admitted that he could not accurately understand the development of the northern history over a thousand years, but arranged the development of the pre-history by “from Rong-di to Rong, Rong, Hu, and to Xiongnu”. This is a new approach to existing research based on a biased understanding of the “Northern people(Bei-di) = Nomadic people = Xiongnu”. Through this, it is possible to organize the records of Sima Qian's pre-history of Xiongnu empire, which accurately identifies the characteristics of individual existence and systematically organizes them according to the changes of the times. Although the historical trends of Northern people, which have been closely related to the China, are weak in specificity, it is possible to give a general understanding of the Xiongnu history who emerged later. This fully reviewed Sima Qian's compositions willingness to provide accurate information about the Xiongnu, just as Confucius tried to write exactly the book of Chunqiu(春秋). This is because it is important for Sima Qian to provide accurate information to prepare countermeasures against the Xiongnu empire, who were then the targets of a strong threat to China. He recorded the history of the Xiongnu with this problematic consciousness and objectively summarized the situation before the foundation of state in B.C. 209. This is not an explanation of the Xiongnu's orgin, but the objective information about the situation in the North before their appearance. Therefore, new research and compilation of records of the Xiongnu can confirm the objective record of Sima Qian. It will be an opportunity to study the possibility of a new approach in the history of Xiongnu.
Abstract
Sima Qian admitted that he could not accurately understand the development of the northern history over a thousand years, but arranged the development of the pre-history by “from Rong-di to Rong, Rong, Hu, and to Xiongnu”. This is a new approach to existing research based on a biased understanding of the “Northern people(Bei-di) = Nomadic people = Xiongnu”. Through this, it is possible to organize the records of Sima Qian's pre-history of Xiongnu empire, which accurately identifies the characteristics of individual existence and systematically organizes them according to the changes of the times. Although the historical trends of Northern people, which have been closely related to the China, are weak in specificity, it is possible to give a general understanding of the Xiongnu history who emerged later. This fully reviewed Sima Qian's compositions willingness to provide accurate information about the Xiongnu, just as Confucius tried to write exactly the book of Chunqiu(春秋). This is because it is important for Sima Qian to provide accurate information to prepare countermeasures against the Xiongnu empire, who were then the targets of a strong threat to China. He recorded the history of the Xiongnu with this problematic consciousness and objectively summarized the situation before the foundation of state in B.C. 209. This is not an explanation of the Xiongnu's orgin, but the objective information about the situation in the North before their appearance. Therefore, new research and compilation of records of the Xiongnu can confirm the objective record of Sima Qian. It will be an opportunity to study the possibility of a new approach in the history of Xiongnu.
참고문헌 (29)
- "史記", ~
- "漢書", 中華書局 標點校勘本, ~
- Barfield, T. J, "Afghanistan: A Cultural and Political History" (2012), rinceton University Press
- Khazanov, A. M, "Nomads and the Outside World" (1994), Univ. of Wisconsin Press
- 니콜라 디 코스모, "오랑캐의 탄생" (2005), 황금가지
- 동북아역사재단, "譯註 中國 正史 外國傳 1 : 史記 外國傳 譯註" (2009), 동북아역사재단
- 사와다 이사오, "흉노: 지금은 사라진 고대 유목국가 이야기" (2007), 아이필드
- 왕밍거, "중국 화하 변경과 중화민족" (2008), 동북아역사재단
- 하자노프, "유목사회의 구조" (1990), 지식산업사
- 陶克濤, "毡鄕春秋 匈奴編" (1987), 人民出版社
- 蒙文通, "周秦少數民族硏究" (1958), 上海龍門聯合書局
- 王明珂, "遊牧者的選擇" (2008), 廣西師範大學出版部
- 陳序經, "匈奴通史" (2017), 新世界出版社
- 來村多加史, "萬里の長城 攻防三千年史" (2004), 講談社
- 林俊雄, "スキタイと匈奴遊牧の文明" (2007), 講談社
- 澤田勳, "冒頓單于 - 匈奴遊牧國家の創設者" (2015), 山川出版社
- Chin, T. T, "Defamiliarizing the Foreigner – Sima Qian’s Ethnography and Han-Xiongnu Marriage Diplomacy", Harvard Journal of Asian Studies, 70 (2010)
- Barfield, T. J, "The Hsiung-nu Imperial Confederacy: Organization and Foreign Policy", Journal of Asian Studies, 41(1) (1981)
- Barfield, T, "Empires" (2001), Cambridge University Press
- Hayashi Toshio, "The Beginning and the Maturity of Nomadic Powers in the Eurasian Steppes: Growing and Downsizing of Elite Tumuli", Ancient Civilizations from Scythia to Siberia, 19 (2013)
- Indrisano, G. G, "Empires and Diversity : On the Crossroads of Archaeology, Anthropology, and History" (2012), Press of University of California
- Scheidel, W, "XIONGNU ARCHAEOLOGY - Multidisciplinary Perspectives of the First Steppe Empire in Inner Asia, Vor-und Frühgeschichtliche Archäologie Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn" (2011), Press Uni-Bonn
- 김병준, "『사기』 흉노열전의 ‘흉노 前史’ 기록 검토", 중앙아시아연구, 21(1), pp.1~23 (2016), 중앙아시아학회[DOI]
- 이춘식, "흉노의 동아시아 패권 장악과 일극체제 수립", 정치와평론, 20 (2017)
- 정재훈, "司馬遷이 그린 匈奴의 ‘眞相’과 후대의 이해 ― 『史記』 「匈奴列傳」 冒頭의 先祖와 遊牧 관련 기록의 재검토 ―", 중앙아시아연구, 25(2), pp.179~201 (2020), 중앙아시아학회[DOI]
- 王國維, "觀堂集林 권13" (1984), 中華書局
- 姚大力, "追溯匈奴的前史―兼論司馬遷對“史道”的突破", 復旦學報, 2004(4) (2004)
- 岑仲勉, "伊朗之胡與匈奴之胡", 眞理雜志, 1(3) (1944)
- 黃文弼, "古代匈奴民族之硏究" (1983), 中華書局