내지덕(來知德) 『주역집주(周易集注)』의 판본 연구―장유임(張惟任)본과 고앵영(高奣映)본의 비교를 중심으로―

Abstract

Based on the previous studies, this paper is a comparative review of the editions of Lai Zhide’s Zhouyi Jizhu, Zhang Weiren’s (Zhang) and Gao Wengying’s (Gao), to clearly present the differences between the two branches, while revealing the origin of the diagrams that are only contained in Gao’s. According to the writer’s review, the difference between Zhang’s branch and Gao’s branch is appeared in three main aspects, other than their differences in printing. First difference is whether or not there exists a volume of sixteen. Zhang’s consists of sixteen volumes in total, however, Gao’s only has fifteen. The sixteenth volume of Zhang’s has two episodes, Kaoding Jicishangxiachuan (考定繫辭上下傳) and Buding Shuoguachuan (補定說卦傳), which Gao’s does not. Second difference is how the characters and phrases are differ from each other. Through the comparison of Volume one (Zhouyi Jizhu), we could confirm that the several of the paragraphs are omitted. Third difference is number of diagrams and descriptions. Gao’s has Juanmo (卷末), but has no volume sixteen. There are over a hundred diagrams and descriptions at the Futu (附圖) of Juanmo, as well as 19 of them in the Juanshou (卷首) under the name of Buyi (補遺); however, there is none in Zhang’s. Main question is, Gao’s diagrams and descriptions, 19 of Buyi and well over a hundred of them of Futu, are how related to Lai Zhide. According to the writer’s review, Buyi’s diagrams and descriptions originated from Rilu (日錄) written by Lai Zhide, but the diagrams and descriptions in Futu are mostly excerpts from the of Hu Juren (胡居 仁)’s Yixiangchao (易像抄) and Zhang Huang (章潢)’s Tushubian (圖書編), while some of them were works of Qu Jiusi (瞿九思) or Gao himself.