Metathesis against the Projection Principle in GP
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The status of the Projection Principle, one major principle in Government Phonology (henceforth GP), has been brought into big arguments. This principle requires that government is defined in lexical representations and remains constant throughout a derivation. Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985, henceforth KLV) propose the Projection Principle to account for the apparent indifference of consonant sequences on government relations in Tigrinya. However, Park & Michaels (1997) argue that this principle should be excluded from GP, analyzing Korean consonant cluster phenomena such as tensing and neutralization where the Projection Principle cannot hold. By reanalyzing the case of Tigrinya which motivated the Projection Principle, they suggest that the Projection Principle should be replaced with a derivational account of government. Following their idea, this paper explores other crosslinguistic phenomena such as the stop/ fricative metathesis in Hebrew and the nasal/liquid metathesis in Old Spanish. Attempting to analyze the data in those languages without the Projection Principle, this paper shows that the Projection Principle does no work and can be abandoned in GP.
Abstract
The status of the Projection Principle, one major principle in Government Phonology (henceforth GP), has been brought into big arguments. This principle requires that government is defined in lexical representations and remains constant throughout a derivation. Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985, henceforth KLV) propose the Projection Principle to account for the apparent indifference of consonant sequences on government relations in Tigrinya. However, Park & Michaels (1997) argue that this principle should be excluded from GP, analyzing Korean consonant cluster phenomena such as tensing and neutralization where the Projection Principle cannot hold. By reanalyzing the case of Tigrinya which motivated the Projection Principle, they suggest that the Projection Principle should be replaced with a derivational account of government. Following their idea, this paper explores other crosslinguistic phenomena such as the stop/ fricative metathesis in Hebrew and the nasal/liquid metathesis in Old Spanish. Attempting to analyze the data in those languages without the Projection Principle, this paper shows that the Projection Principle does no work and can be abandoned in GP.
참고문헌 (26)
- Bat-El, O., "Phonology and Word Structure in Modern Hebrew", 박사, pp.1989
- Charette, M., "Some Constraints on Governing Relations in Phonology", 박사, pp.1988
- Charette, M., "Licence to Govern", Phonology, 7, pp.233~253 (1990)
- Chomsky, N, "The Sound Pattern English. Cambridge" (1968), MIT Press
- Kook Chung, "Neutralization in Korean : a functional view", 박사, pp.1980
- Harris, J., "A government-based analysis of lenition", Paper presented at Generative Phonology Workshop (1988), University of Leide
- Harris, J., "Segmental Complexity and Phonological Government", Phonology, 7, pp.255~300 (1990)
- Hume, E., "The Role of Perceptibility in Consonant", Consonant Metathesis, 1998, 293~307
- Janda, R. D., "Why Morphological metathesis rules are rare: On the Possibility of Historical Explanations in Linguistics", Proceedings of the 10th Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society, pp.87~103 (1984), Department of Linguistics, University of California
- Kaye, J., "Coda Licensing", Phonology, 7, pp.301~329 (1990)
- Kaye, J., "Government in Phonology : the Case of Moroccan Arabic", The Linguistic Review, 6, pp.131~159 (1990)
- Kaye, J., "On the Interaction of Theories of Lexical Phonology and Theories of Phonological Phenomena, In Phonologica 1988" (1992), Cambridge University Press
- Kaye, J., "The Internal Structure of Phonological elements : A Theory of Charm and Government", Phonology, 2, pp.305~328 (1985)
- Kaye, J., "Constituent Structure and Government in Phonology", Phonology, 7, pp.193~231 (1990)
- Kim, C. -B., "Tensification Revisited", Language Research, 10(2), pp.129~142 (1974)
- Kim, C. -W., "Neutralization in Korean Revisited", Studies in the Linguistic Sciences, 9, pp.147~155 (1979)
- Michaels, D., "Pro-segments and Syllable Structure", Rivista de Grammatica Generativa, 14, pp.55~77 (1989)
- Michaels, D., "Syllable Structure, Phonetics and Phonology", Revue de Phonetique Applique, 90, pp.63~67 (1989)
- Michaels, D., "Rules and Syllable Structure in Zoque", Paper read at the annual meeting LSA (1986)
- Park, H.-H., "Government Relations in Korean Phonology", 박사, pp.1996
- Park, H., "Government Switching in Phonology", Korean Journal of Linguistics, 22, pp.351~368 (1997)
- Silva, C. M., "Metathesis of Obstruent Clusters", Working Papers in Linguistics, 14, pp.77~84 (1973), Ohio State University
- Trubetzkoy, N. S., "Principles of Phonology (Translated by C. A. M. Baltaxe)" (1969), University of California Press
- Ultan, R., "A Typological View of Metathesis, In Universals of Human Language", pp.367~402, Stanford University
- Vennemann, T., "Preference Laws for Syllable Structure" (1988), Mouton de Gruyter
- Wanner, D., "On Metathesis in Diachrony, In Papers from the 25th Annual Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society" (1989)