일본인의 조선민담 연구고찰 -일제 강점기 일본어로 쓰여진 설화집에 나타난 兄弟像을 중심으로-
日本人の朝鮮民譚研究考察 -日帝強占期に日本語で書かれた朝鮮の説話集における兄弟像を中心に-
0
조회
0
다운로드
24
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
本考は日常における様々な葛藤の中でも特に兄弟間における葛藤に注目し、それが日帝強占期に日本人によって日本語で書かれた朝鮮の説話集にはどのような現れ方をしているかを突き詰めたものである。 兄弟は世界の口承文学や記録文学にもよく登場するモチーフで、実に様々な理由で対立している。ところで、日帝強占期に日本人によって記述された朝鮮の説話集の兄弟譚は、すべて兄弟間の対立や葛藤を題材にしている説話のみである。説話集の中の兄弟像も‘悪兄善弟’, ‘富兄貧弟’, ‘愚兄賢弟’,‘怠兄勤弟’で形象化されるのが一般である。さらにその対立と葛藤の原因がすべて富(お金)にあるとの共通点を持つ。話の構造においても欲張りな兄が弟の成功譚をそのまままねて失敗し、懲罰を受ける形となっている。また、話の結末では兄弟間の葛藤が解消し、和解と友愛を回復してはいるものの、それも過酷な運命を克服しようとする主人公の意志や努力によるものではなく、与えられた運命に従順に耐え忍んだ報いとしての‘意外な幸運’によるものである。これらの説話集には現実に立ち向かって超克しようとする兄弟の姿は描かれていない。これこそ肯定的な日本の自画像を前に日本人学者が発見した、他国の説話には見られない‘あまりにも朝鮮的な’朝鮮の兄弟像であったのである。
Abstract
This thesis is to examine the conflicts between the brothers in everyday life mentioned in the legendry by Japanese scholars during Japanese colonial period. The brothers appearing too often worldwide as a motif in both oral literature and documentary literature are pitted against each other over the various things. However, the brothers described by Japanese scholars during its colonial period show only conflicts and confrontations. In general, the relations between the brothers in the stories are divided into two parts such as an evil brother and a good brother, a rich and a poor, a stupid and a wise or a lazy and a diligent. Wealth or money is only rationale why the conflicts and the confrontations are brought between them. The plot is organized in a way that the greedy brother follows his brother's success but fails to obtain it. At the end of the story, the conflicts between the brothers resolve to restore the peace and friendship, which is not the product of the hero's commitment and effort but an unexpected good fortune given by the obedience to the fate. The brothers in these folk tales also are not ones who overcome the difficulties they face. In this regard, the Japanese scholars' viewpoint shows that they discovered so Korean brotherhood that could not seen in the tales of other countries.
참고문헌 (18)
- 곽정식, "한국설화에 나타난 형제간 갈등의 양상과 의미", 문화전통논집, 4 (1996), 경성대학교, 향토문화연구소
- 권혁래, "근대 초기 설화, 고전소설집『조선물어집』의 성격과 문학사적 의의", 한국언어문학, 64 (2008)
- 조선총독부, "『조선동화집』(1924)의 성격과 의의", 동화와 번역, 5 (2003)
- 김영남, "동일성 상상의 계보:근대 일본의 설화 연구에 나타난 ‘민족’의 발견" (2006), 제이앤씨
- 김화경, "한국의 설화" (2002), 지식산업사
- 박미경, "다카하시 도루의 조선 속담집" (2006), 어문학사
- 염희경, "<해와 달이 된 오누이>에 나타난 호랑이상(설화와 전래동화 비교를 중심으로)", 동화와 번역, 5 (2003), 5권
- 오다케 기요미, "1920년대 일본의 아동총서와 <조선동화집>", 동화와 번역, 2 (2001), 2집
- "「조선동화」와 호랑이-근대 일본인의 「조선동화」인식」", 동화와 번역, 5 (2003), 5집
- 조춘호, "古小說에 나타난 兄弟 間의 葛藤 樣相과 意味", 국어교육연구, 18(1) (1986)
- 조춘호, "口碑 友愛說話의 樣相과 意味", 경산대학논문집, 11 (1993)
- 조희웅, "일본어로 쓰여진 한국설화", 한국설화론(1), 2005, pp.24, ~
- 최연숙, "민담 상징 무의식" (2006), 지앤지
- 최재율, "가족사회학" (1988), 전남대 출판부
- 中村亮平, "朝鮮童話集" (1926), 富山房
- 高橋享, "朝鮮の物語集附俚諺" (1910), 日韓書房
- 三輪環, "傳說の朝鮮" (1919), 博文舘
- 조선총독부, "조선민속자료 제2편 朝鮮童話集" (1924), 조선총독부
