본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

断られた際に取る韓日の言語行動および不愉快さの考察

거절당했을 때 취하는 한일의 언어행동 및 불쾌함에 대한 고찰 linguistic Behaviors and Feelings of Offendedness on Rejected Situations in Korean and Japanese

2

조회

0

다운로드

2

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류일본어와문학

초록

When a foreigner speaks in the second language, high tolerance for errors or mistakes in grammar and pronunciation is unexpectedly all too often shown. Misunderstanding or intolerance is, on the other hand, likely to occur in the case of sociocultural factors. There is no exception for Korean and Japanese even considering the fact that both linguistic systems are very much alike. Especially, we should take further and further caution concerning 「the refusal act」, given that this expression is against interlocutor's opinion. This paper, in which regards the case of one whose proposal is rejected as a part of refusal act, touches on speech acts brought about and feelings of offendedness when rejected through cross-linguistic comparisons and analyses between Korean and Japanese. The findings suggest that Koreans feel more offended when rejected than Japanese do. On top of that, Koreans as well as Japanese are more likely to feel offended when refused grounded on their own personal psychology and principle rather than lack of capability of accepting the proposals or offers. It, therefore, sheds the light on the implication that we should take more attention to the reasons of refusal. When it came to a majority of linguistic behaviors, both countries have shown much of resemblance, and yet the sharp contrast in the case of "refusal". It can be said that there may be considerably a fundamental discrepancy in the interpersonal relationship between two countries. This issue should be stretched in educational section, with the suggestion that teacher lead students to further enlightenment on the gap between both countries.

Abstract

When a foreigner speaks in the second language, high tolerance for errors or mistakes in grammar and pronunciation is unexpectedly all too often shown. Misunderstanding or intolerance is, on the other hand, likely to occur in the case of sociocultural factors. There is no exception for Korean and Japanese even considering the fact that both linguistic systems are very much alike. Especially, we should take further and further caution concerning 「the refusal act」, given that this expression is against interlocutor's opinion. This paper, in which regards the case of one whose proposal is rejected as a part of refusal act, touches on speech acts brought about and feelings of offendedness when rejected through cross-linguistic comparisons and analyses between Korean and Japanese. The findings suggest that Koreans feel more offended when rejected than Japanese do. On top of that, Koreans as well as Japanese are more likely to feel offended when refused grounded on their own personal psychology and principle rather than lack of capability of accepting the proposals or offers. It, therefore, sheds the light on the implication that we should take more attention to the reasons of refusal. When it came to a majority of linguistic behaviors, both countries have shown much of resemblance, and yet the sharp contrast in the case of "refusal". It can be said that there may be considerably a fundamental discrepancy in the interpersonal relationship between two countries. This issue should be stretched in educational section, with the suggestion that teacher lead students to further enlightenment on the gap between both countries.

참고문헌 (23)

  1. 荒巻朋子, "アメリカ人と日本人の断り表現の比較", 長崎大学留学生センター紀要, (7) (1999)
  2. 生駒知子, "英語から日本語へのプラグマティック⋅トランスファー:断りという発話行為について", 日本語教育, (79) (1993), 日本語教育学会
  3. 伊藤恵美子, "マレー語母語話者の語用的能力と滞日期間の関係について─勧誘に対する,断り,行為に見られる工学系ブミプトラのポライトネス", 日本語教育, (115) (2002), 日本語教育学会
  4. 李賢貞, "韓・日両言語における,断り,言語行動の対照─断りのプロセスを中心に─", 석사, 日本語教育, pp.2006
  5. 任榮哲, "あいづち行動における価値観の韓日比較", 世界の日本語教育, (5) (1995), 日本語教育論集,
  6. 大倉美和子, "語用論研究と日本語教育─メキシコ人と日本人の,誘いに断る発話,─,対照研究と日本語教育", 日本語と外国語との対照研究, 10 (2002), 国立国語研究所
  7. 吳俊雅, "拒絶表現의 日韓対照研究", 석사, pp.1996
  8. 柏崎秀子, "話しかけ行動の談話分析-依頼⋅要求表現の実際を中心に", 日本語教育, 79 (1993), 日本語教育学会
  9. カノックワン, "日本語における,断り ─日本語教科書 と実際の会話との分析", 日本語教育, (87) (1995), 日本語教育学会
  10. カノックワン, "日本語学習者に見られる,断り,の表現:日本語母語話者と比べて", 世界の日本語教育, (7) (1997), 国際交流基金日本語教育センター
  11. 熊谷浩子, "外国人待遇行動の分析(2)─断り表現を中心にして─", 静岡大学教養部研究報告 人文⋅社会言語学, 28(2) (1993)
  12. 鮫島重喜, "コミュニケーションタスクにおける日本語学習者の定型表現⋅文末表現の学習過程-中国語話者の,依頼,断り,謝罪,の場合", 日本語教育, (98) (1998), 日本語教育学会
  13. 서희정, "한국어 거절 화행 교육 연구-교재 분석을 중심으로", 석사, pp.2001
  14. 野村美穂子, "断りの表現─コミュニケーションと含意", 言語学論叢, (10) (1992), 筑波大学-般⋅応用言語学研究室,
  15. 藤森弘子, "日本語学習に見られる,辯明 意味公式の形式と使用─中国人、韓国人学習者の場合", 日本語教育, (87) (1995), 日本語教育学会
  16. 目黒秋子, "日本語の談話における間接的断り理解の過程─母語話者の認知の視点から─" (1996), 日本語学会論集 東北大学文学部
  17. 目黒秋子, "断り,のストラテジー分析─日本人、韓国語学習者、韓国人の比較─", 日本語文学, 5 (1998), 日本語文学会
  18. 森山卓郎, "断りの方略─対人関係調整とコミュニケーション", 言語, 19(8) (1990), 大修館書店
  19. 横山杉子, "日本語における,日本人の日本人に対する断りと,日本人のアメリカ人に対する断り", 日本語教育, (85) (1993), 日本語教育学会
  20. ルンティーラ ワンウィモン, "タイ人日本語学習者の,提案に対する断り,表現における語用論的転移─タイ語と日本語の発話パターンの比較から─", 日本語教育, (121) (2004), 日本語教育学会
  21. 元智恩, "意味公式で分析した日本語と韓国語の断り", 日本語文学 (2000), 일본어문학회
  22. 元智恩, "断りとして用いられた日韓の,言いさし文 についての語用論的分析", 日語日文学 (2000), 대한일어일문학회
  23. 元智恩, "日本語と韓国語の断り表現の構造─指導教官の依頼を断る場面を中心に", 言語学論叢, (21) (2002), 筑波大学 一般⋅応用言語学研究室

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (21건)