지불거부응답의 판별
Detecting Protest Responses
0
조회
0
다운로드
4
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
조건부가치측정법(contingent valuation method)은 비시장재의 경제적 가치를 추정하는 방법의 하나로, 공공사업의 경제적 편익을 계산하는 데 이용되어 왔다. 지불거부응답(protest responses)은 본인의 선호와 상관없이 설문과정에서 공공사업에 대해 단 1원도 지불할 의사가 없다고 응답하는 행동으로, 전체 CVM 응답의 25% 정도를 차지한다. 본 연구는 평가 대상이 된 공공재의 가치 추정에 있어 지불거부응답 행동에 의한 편의(bias)를 최소화하기 위해, 자신의 선호에 의해 지불의사액이 ‘0’이라고 답한 응답으로부터 지불거부응답을 판별해 내는 문항(protest response filtering items)과 그 미시적 근거를 제시한다. 이를 위해 본 논문은 선호에 기반한 지불의사액을 ‘잠재적 지불의사액(implicit willingness-to-pay)’이라고 정의함으로써 설문과정에서 선호체계 이외에 다양한 요인이 작용하여 결정된 ‘구술된 지불의사액(stated willingness-to-pay)’과 구분하였다. 한편, 한국개발연구원(KDI)에서 주관한 20여 건의 CVM 데이터를 이용한 실증분석 결과에 의하면, 지불거부응답은 무작위가 아닌 응답자의 사회․경제적 특징에 의해 체계적으로 발생한다. 이는 지불거부응답을 공공재의 경제적 가치 추정에서 제외시킬 때 선택편의(selectivity bias)가 발생할 수 있음을 의미한다.
Abstract
This study analyzes ways to detect protest responses (hereafter, PR zero-bid) in the contingent valuation method (CVM). In order to distinguish PR zero-bids from true zero-bids (non-PR zero bids), this study adopts the concept of the implicit willingness to pay employing the Hicksian compensating surplus and the Taylor’s 1st order approximation. When a respondent proposes a zero-bid (i.e., WTP=0) and chooses a PR filtering item to indicate that her implicit WTP is not necessary zero, her response is identified as a PR zero bid. PR filtering items falling into the PR zero bids category include the uncertainty of information, distrust in the government and project achievement, disagreement to project plans, discontent with the fairness of public works and their payment method and animosity against the CVM itself. The empirical analysis shows that PR zero bids take place systematically in particular respondent groups: respondents who have never used similar facilities before nor plans to use the facility provided by the public project, the employed, and low income groups. In conclusion, the study suggests that a CVM questionnaire needs to be designed carefully to minimize problems associated with PR zero bids and the potential risks of having sample selection bias should be concerned.
참고문헌 (47)
- 예비타당성조사를 위한 CVM 분석지침 개선연구(KDI 중간보고): WTP 편익의 추정, "권오상", ~ (2011)
- 박용치, "가상상황 가치평가연구에서 출발점 편의의 검토", 조사연구, 3(2) (2002), 한국조사연구학회
- 예비타당성조사를 위한 CVM 분석지침 개선연구(KDI 중간보고): WTP 함수추정에서의 타당성 검토와 비모수적 추정, "신영철", ~ (2011)
- 엄영숙, "예비타당성조사 적용 CVM의 분석체계와 개선과제", 자원환경경제연구, 20(3), pp.595~628 (2011), 한국환경경제학회
- 엄영숙, "공공사업 타당성 분석을 위한 지불의사액 추정에 있어 지불거부 반응의 식별과 보정", 재정학연구, 2(4), pp.89~117 (2009), 한국재정학회
- 홍종호, "설문기법을 이용한 공공재의 수요 추정 : 주요 쟁점과 환경위성 탑재사업 가치평가에의 응용", 한국경제의 분석, 17(1), pp.1~72 (2011), 한국경제의 분석패널
- 예비타당성조사를 위한 CVM 분석지침 개선연구(KDI 중간보고): 시장영역설정과 조사 및 표본설계, "이주석", ~ (2011)
- 홍종호, "설문기법을 이용한 공공재의 수요 추정 : 주요 쟁점과 환경위성 탑재사업 가치평가에의 응용", 한국경제의 분석, 17(1), pp.1~72 (2011), 한국경제의 분석패널
- 홍종호, "다중이용시설 실내공기질 개선의 경제적 가치 추정: 서울시 지하역사를 중심으로", 한국경제연구, 17, pp.169~198 (2006), 한국경제연구학회
- 예비타당성조사 수행을 위한 일반지침 수정․보완 연구, "한국개발연구원", ~ (2008)
- 김일중, "환경정책의 비용", 편익분석 지침서, 2003
- Aprahamian, F., "Modeling Starting Point Bias as Unobserved Heterogeneity in Contingent Valuation Surveys: An Application to Air Pollution", American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 89(2), pp.533~547 (2007)
- Bateman I. J., "Economic Valuation with State Preference Techniques. a Manual Cheltenham" (2002), Edward Elgar
- Bergstrom, J. C., "Information Effects in Continent Markets", American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 71, pp.685~691 (1989)
- Blamey, R., "Contingent Valuation and the Activation of Environmental Norms", Ecological Economics, 24(1), pp.47~72 (1998)
- Bohara, A. K., "Addressing Negative Willingness to Pay in Dichotomous Choice Contingent Valuation: A Monte Carlo Simulation", Environmental and Resource Economics, 20, pp.173~195 (2001)
- Boyle, K. J, "Welfare Measurements Using Contingent Valuation: A Comparison of Techniques", American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 70(1), pp.20~28 (1988)
- Brouwer, R., "Public Attitudes to Contingent Valuation and Public Consultation", Environmental Values, 8, pp.325~347 (1999)
- Brown, T. C, "Does Better Information about the Good Avoid the Embedding Effect?", Journal of Environmental Management, 44, pp.1~10 (1995)
- Calia, P., "A Sample Selection Model for Protest Responses in Contingent Valuation Analyses", Statistica, 61(3), pp.473~485 (2001)
- Chien, Y. L, "A General Model of Starting Point Bias in Double-bounded Dichotomous Contingent Valuation Surveys", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 50, pp.362~377 (2005)
- Cummings, R. G., "Substitution Effects in CVM Values", American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 76, pp.205~214 (1994)
- del Saz Salazar, S., "Estimating the Non-market Benefits of an Urban Park : Does Proximity Matter?", Land Use Policy, 24, pp.296~305 (2007)
- Diamond, P. A., "On Contingent Valuation Measurement of Nonuse Values, In Contingent Valuation: Critical Assessment" (1993), Elsevier
- DuVair, P., "Household’s Valuation of Alternative Levels of Hazardous Waste Risk Reductions: an Application of the Referendum Format Contingent Valuation Method", Journal of Environmental Management, 39, pp.143~155 (1993)
- Griffin, R. C, "Valuing Water Supply Reliability", American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 82, pp.414~426 (2000)
- Haab, T., "Referendum Models and Negative Willingness to Pay: Alternative Solutions", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 43(2), pp.251~270 (1997)
- Haab, T., "Referendum Models and Economic Values: Theoretical, Intuitive, and Practical Bounds on Willingness to Pay", Land Economics, 74(2), pp.216~229 (1998)
- Hoevenagel, R., "Effects of Different Descriptions of the Ecological Good on Willingness to Pay Values", Ecological Economics, 7, pp.223~238 (1993)
- Jakobsson, K. M., "The Worth of a Possum: Valuing Species with the Contingent Valuation Method", Environmental and Resource Economics, 19(3), pp.211~227 (2001)
- Johnson, L. T., "Distributional Preferences in Contingent Valuation Surveys", Ecological Economics, 56, pp.475~487 (2006)
- Jorgensen, B. S, "Protest Responses and Willingness to Pay: Attitude Toward Paying For Stormwater Pollution Abatement", Ecological Economics, 33, pp.251~265 (2000)
- Jorgensen, B. S., "The Role of Uncertainty in the Relationship Between Fairness Evaluations and Willingnes to Pay", Ecological Economics, 56, pp.104~124 (2006)
- Kahneman, D., "Comments, In Valuing Environmental Goods: A State of the Arts Assessment of the Contingent Method" (1986), eRowman and Allanheld, N. J
- Kriström, B., "Spike Models in Contingent Valuation", American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 79, pp.1013~1023 (1997)
- Loomis, J, "Alternative Approaches for Incorporating Respondent Uncertainty When Estimating Willingness to Pay: the Case of the Mexican Spotted Owl", Ecological Economics, 27, pp.29~42 (1998)
- McFadden, D, "Contingent Valuation and Social Choice", American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 76, pp.689~708 (1994)
- Meyerhoff, J., "Do Protest Responses to a Contingent Valuation Question and a Choice Experiment Differ?", Environmental and Resource Economics, 39, pp.433~446 (2008)
- Meyerhoff, J., "Determinants of Protest Responses in Environmental Valuation", Ecological Economics, 70, pp.366~374 (2010)
- Mitchell, R. C., "Using Survey to Value Public Goods: the Contingent Valuation Method" (1989), Resources for the Future
- Morrison, M. D., "Minimizing Payment Vehicle Bias in Contingent Valuation Studies", Environmental and Resorce Economics, 16(4), pp.407~422 (2000)
- Citizens’ Trust in Government and Their Willingness-To-Pay, "Oh, H", Economics Letters, forthcoming, ~ (2012)
- Ready, R. C., "Contingent Valuation When Respondents Are Ambivalent", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 29, pp.181~196 (1995)
- Schkade, D. A., "How People Respond to Contingent Valuation Questions: a Verbal Protocol Analysis of Willingness to Pay for an Environmental Regulation", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 26, pp.88~109 (1994)
- Schuman, H., "The Sensitivity of CV Outcomes to CV Survey Methods, In The Contingent Valuation of Environmental Resources: Methodological Issues and Research Needs" (1996), Edward Elgar
- Söderquist, T., "Why Give Up Money for the Baltic Sea? Movies for People’s Willingness (or Reluctance) to Pay", Environmental and Resource Economics, 12, pp.249~254 (1998)
- Strazzera, E., "Modelling Zero Values and Protest Responses in Contingent Valuation Surveys", Applied Economics, 35, pp.133~138 (2003)